HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hinkley

48,108 karma · joined December 14, 2014

submissionscomments
hinkley··on SpaceX catches the Starship to end Flight 15
The silver lining is that if Elon had continued pushing for Mars, to not let it happen organically, Mars would become a company town, with all the bad connotations that ever had, with paying for air added on top of it.
hinkley··on SpaceX catches the Starship to end Flight 15
The Internet was built to be literally bomb-proof rather than figuratively. The utility of that has been self evident and “five nines” thinking continues this tradition. AWS AZs are meant to partially survive floods and wildfires. A super volcano would take out an entire region but people would have other problems at that point (the exception being if emergency services were on those machines, but disaster teams have been learning to bring emergency infrastructure with them ever since New Orleans).

As a UIUC student used to be fond of reminding me, part of the University of Illinois’ contribution to the old Internet was in a building that, if it were to collapse, would fall outward and not crush the basement. Officially that building was designed so every office has natural light, like a collapsible water cup, but it’s a very interesting coincidence that it (the basement) is bomb proof.

hinkley··on SpaceX catches the Starship to end Flight 15
Every product has the same adoption curve. Early customers pay a premium which pays for building the factories, not just the product. By the time everyone is using them the prices have gotten low enough that the price is informed by supply rather than demand.

SpaceX being their own customer, and a lower priority one, lets them levellize their revenue, which also helps retain staff. And if anyone commoditizes launch systems, they have a hedge against that. However if demand for starlink ever does exceed capacity, the launch side could find their schedules being much more variable.

In software, you see this with priority queues all the time if you know where to look. Someone makes a “low priority” system that soaks up spare capacity. Internal customers become dependent on these systems and then become delay-averse. Meanwhile, other teams also start soaking up that spare capacity, by improved design or feature creep or both. That low priority system becomes starved of resources, and the internal customers start saber rattling. That system gets its own dedicated resources, and now stranded resources climb back to the original levels, if not worse.

Starlink will eventually become the same thing. And I wonder if they will spin it off when that situation arises.

hinkley··on SpaceX catches the Starship to end Flight 15
The problem with space planes is they are terrible planes, terrible rockets, and feed the egos of pilots.

To be fair to NASA and the astronauts, NASA needed humans who behave like military test pilots. In physiology, in reaction time, in crisis management, in following chain of command. And the armed forces were willing to give them access to known quantities.

We didn’t know how control systems would evolve over the next three decades, but the pilots wanted to pilot, and did not trust the control systems. And the irony of it all is that the Space Race was a proxy war for nuclear armament, so control systems needed to be made autonomous anyway.

Better control systems, wider telemetry, and not worrying about incinerating employees let current generation rocketry iterate faster, and do more fucking around and finding out. We found out twice with the shuttle and it killed the program.

It’s curious how much the upper stage now resembles a space shuttle on a ballistic trajectory instead of a glide angle. Very different landing strategies for those two modes of descent…

hinkley··on SpaceX catches the Starship to end Flight 15
I know engineering is about expediency, and price, but I’m still bummed that we aren’t getting ships with landing gear in this or likely the next generation of rockets either.

Seems that the heavier the rocket the more ground clearance to need to self-land, and so you can’t scale up the dragon’s landing system. I don’t think there’s anywhere near enough weight to shave off of the next rocket or enough specific impulse to add to bring the size back down.

hinkley··on Seagate's new hybrid drive raises some old questions
I will never buy electronics off of Amazon ever again. Whether they’ve fixed their mingling or not, they did it for years with no regrets. That level of contempt for customers deserves to be boycotted in perpetuity.
hinkley··on FAA issues national ground stop – lifted 4.5 hours later
And then there’s the Tower of Hanoi of breaking major changes into tiny pieces that can increment without making rollbacks impossible. Always two more steps than you would think you need and requires patience that management often doesn’t possess.

Example, got a feature with a new required field? Add empty field, synthesize a default value for existing rows, start accepting data, validate that data, require the data, use the data.

If you’re doing deployments once a week, you end up juggling two stories so you’re not sitting on your hands the whole time, and two stories divided your attention, so the odds of fucking it up go up anyway even though you’re being careful on paper.

Meanwhile one of your coworkers is doing the same dance on another feature, so you start tripping over each other as team size increases.

hinkley··on FAA issues national ground stop – lifted 4.5 hours later
Scrum originally recommended people run sprints from Wednesday to Wednesday so you were doing deployments in the middle of the week. I’ve never worked anywhere that did a Scrum right, and I don’t mean that in the “well then you’re doing it wrong” sense. I used Kanban before Scrum and man is that a downgrade.
hinkley··on FAA issues national ground stop – lifted 4.5 hours later
Several hours. That number goes up quickly when the bus number for something that broke unexpectedly is unavailable. While your coworker who actually knows what that error means is at the zoo with his girlfriend or with his kids.

The whole point of WLB is that we don’t live like monks.

hinkley··on FAA issues national ground stop – lifted 4.5 hours later
Assuming they don’t have an actual life and aren’t somewhere touching grass.

I’ve worked with several people who either confessed to or were accused of having taken up pastimes that would guarantee they weren’t available during times they shouldn’t be expected to be available.

Management gets rewarded for getting more work out of us and there’s always someone pushing boundaries trying to leach a little more work out of the staff they have. These same people seem to think burnout is a big mystery, because to admit they caused the problem would be to admit they did something wrong.

hinkley··on FAA issues national ground stop – lifted 4.5 hours later
We did Monday morning IST, on a build we declared valid on Friday afternoon - no pressure to declare premature victory there. The cherry on top was sprint demos first thing in the morning PST so when I first joined the project the demos got interrupted on a regular basis.

I don’t think most people fully appreciated how much work a handful of us did to make sign off faster and deployment less error prone.

hinkley··on FAA issues national ground stop – lifted 4.5 hours later
> Friday evening maximizes that window.

For the FAA it sure as fuck doesn’t.

hinkley··on Service degradation on Microsoft 365
Remember when Teams ate cellphone batteries like candy? Pepperidge Farms remembers.
hinkley··on Writing correct software is hard and math alone won’t help us (2016)
There’s something I used to say that I haven’t repeated in a while and I’m not sure why since I still believe it:

Software is effectively contract law, and if one were solvable the other would be too. The fact that we have so many lawyers, and loopholes are a constant issue is the same reason we have so many programmers and so many bugs.

We cannot nail down what is and isn’t acceptable input, acceptable output, and acceptable intermediate states all at the same time. And that’s what you need for correct software.

hinkley··on Anthropic IPO
If you need 10x the available compute you’re not going to get it for 10x what you already paid. You’re talking about potentially destroying all of your vendors.

If you’ve ever don’t consulting work, you know how dangerous it is when the majority of your revenue comes from a single customer. You stop being independent, you stop having your own set of values, and if anything happens to that company, you’ve already proven you lack the ability to court as large a contract from other customers.

It always ends in a loss of identity and huge layoffs.

Making vendors product triple their current production rate for the next five years isn’t even possible to start this year, because they have to build facilities and train employees. Nobody runs businesses at 50% capacity anymore. That’s considered wasteful, even stealing profits from your shareholders.

They can’t even get memory chip companies on board with their koolaid.

hinkley··on Anthropic IPO
So the same as the last two AI fads. Error rate being halved by each generation results in smaller and smaller increments.
hinkley··on A false smoke alarm almost drowned Jane Street's only NYC datacenter
We had a discussion about this at my last job. The War rooms were a three ring circus that my team stayed out of 4 times out of 5, substantially by actually planning ahead. Though as time went on we started doing a lot more to protect the services behind us instead of just ourselves, and then the total war room count dropped like a rock.

Someone hit on the notion that it’s Stockholm Syndrome. You bond with people you go through shit with. You don’t bond with people who prevent the shit. That was a super awkward conversation. The asshole in charge quit shortly after it, but 2 years later we still occasionally called each other out for making plans that accounted for a toxic chain of command that was no longer toxic.

hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
The silver lining is that if world population really has peaked and we are on the decline, we can follow the model of Christchurch and The Netherlands and refuse to let people rebuild in the most vulnerable areas. We can return those areas to nature and in some cases, like the Netherlands, use those areas to also improve the chances to survive the next extreme weather event. Every time the a Netherlands declares a moratorium after a flood, their ability to avoid flooding in population centers improves a little bit. And the reforest land which helps a bit with the drawdown (asterisk for methane production, which may represent less carbon in the atmosphere but a greater greenhouse effect)
hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
It’s too late for the pebbles to vote. It’ll take as long as it takes. And it will seem like it will take even longer because we will need to find new physics, chemistry, biology, and manufacturing to solve it.
hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
Carbon free energy is not free energy. Store where? For how long?
hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
You buy groceries don’t you? You use 911? You get visited by relatives? You need roads and traffic control even if you stay entirely in the crosswalks. And critically, you need the worst sort of traffic on those roads. Tractor trailers, fire trucks, construction equipment.
hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
I'm sure you're trying to be clever but you've succeeded in communicating nothing.
hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
I'm not talking about putting gas into holes in the ground and then expecting it to not bubble back out and/or kill us. I'm talking about recarbonizing farm land, which we will need anyway to deal with climate change, aforestation, and probably accelerated rock weathering.

It took us 200 years to break it, we'll probably be 300 years fixing it, at which point the ocean will have likely absorbed all it can and started giving it back to us.

hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
If we reach net 0 carbon, which we won't, we still have the extra carbon we already added. That doesn't just go away. We will have to get to net negative to fix most of this.

Particularly because all the CO2 we dump into the ocean will return to the surface in ocean upwellings once the currents have run a full cycle.

hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
Someone has to be the example they want to see emulated. Expecting the hoi polloi to have as much imagination as you, when you’re doing nothing with that imagination except complain, is foolishness.

Be the change.

hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
The number of people in my personal and professional life who are willing to make sacrifices as long as they cost them absolutely nothing is simply astounding.

That’s not how sacrifice works.

If you want to stop rewarding bad actors you often have to give up something in return. Such as Amazon Prime. Or McDonald’s French fries.

hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
And the heat island effect making heat pumps less efficient, increasing the heat island effect.
hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
The damage to roads by heavy vehicles is the fifth power of the weight. So it’s trucks that are subsidizing your driving an EV and that’s perfectly fine.
hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
And when your house burns down and the insurance company finds out why, you’re going to be homeless.
hinkley··on Fossil CO2 emissions decrease in 2026
Recarbonizing the soil will also help make us more resilient to drought.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →