HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hirsin

2,342 karma · joined October 14, 2014

Identity product manager at GitHub - @hpsin. I own the Apps and Authorization platforms. Previously Microsoft Identity protocols PM for Entra and the Microsoft Account systems.

Views my own.

submissionscomments
hirsin··on How to get stuff repaired when the manufacturer don't wanna: take 'em to court
They go broke or rely on an ever growing market, ie housing is always being built (most of your examples).

But Instant Pot is the classic example of going broke because everyone bought exactly one of their products and never needed another (ignoring the three we have...)

hirsin··on API Shouldn't Redirect HTTP to HTTPS
This is only enabled for a small percent of people at random, otherwise just folks in the advanced protection program.
hirsin··on Big data is dead (2023)
Trick questions (although not known as such at the time) are the basis of most of the work we do? XY problem is a thing for a reason, and I cannot count the number of times my teams and I have ratholed on something complex only to realize we were solving for the wrong problem, i.e. A trick question.

As a sibling puts it though, it's a matter of level. Senior/staff and above? Yeah, that's mostly what you do. Lower than that, then you should be able to mostly trust those upper folks to have seen through the trick.

hirsin··on ICC prosecutor seeks arrest warrants against Sinwar and Netanyahu for war crimes
I don't think the US govt gives a hoot for the common soldier except where their warrant would provide precedence for a senator or president to also be arrested.
hirsin··on First proof that "plunging regions" exist around black holes in space
This may be hopelessly naive but isn't the idea of GR that with sufficient fuel (and I suppose breaking some laws of physics) I can effectively postpone my experiencing next Thursday (here on earth) by moving away from earth at one lightsecond/second?
hirsin··on Urban renewal left the U.S. too scared to build
I mean, the same classes and groups instituting redlining were the ones picking where the infrastructure went.

I don't think anyone is blaming the existence of infrastructure as the causative factor.

hirsin··on US drug control agency will move to reclassify marijuana
Business 2 owns the building and the atm, renting it to business 1, the dispensary. B1 pays the cash as rent to b2 who puts it into the ATM again. A SWAG but it's common enough in other business setups to alter costs as I understand it.
hirsin··on 'Catastrophic grid failure' a possibility for Texas solar/wind/battery storage
For some reason grid storage reporting always seems to use a power metric instead of storage metric, which makes no sense to me. I've seen this in a half dozen stories, and found that even the government reports do this. I think it stems from someone reusing a column to represent both storage and power across generators and batteries.
hirsin··on What contributing to Open-source is, and what it isn't
What does it mean to judge a contributor? They're a faceless account, maybe a dog on the internet. Isn't the contribution the defining piece of work?

Maybe for growing your maintainer collection, with privileged access, but not contributions?

hirsin··on Simon Tatham's Portable Puzzle Collection
There's an excellent Android version of Slitherlink with multiple variants, well worth the couple bucks to unlock unlimited games beyond the initial couple hundred.
hirsin··on This is a teenager
This is fairly literally how people watch a homeless guy get choked to death in the New-York subway. "Someone will call the cops eventually".

No, you can't be a bystander, even if it might be dangerous.

hirsin··on The Papa Johns closest to The Pentagon is far busier than usual
Nothing about the last several months implies surgical strikes or key infra being targeted, and heavily leans towards glassing the enemy territory.

Certainly they have that capability, and there's plenty of evidence that they do targeted killings, but that doesn't appear to be their MO when invading someone.

hirsin··on The U.S. government may finally mandate safer table saws
And they're pointing out it's not just those two replaceable components - it's the _entire saw_ that they're risking destroying off a false positive that some woodworkers will hit frequently.
hirsin··on Tips for linking shell companies to their secret owners
I felt it quite underwhelming, until I realized it only looked at a handful of companies. Somehow only three of Microsoft board are on other boards? Wow, how puritan of them! Ah, not quite...
hirsin··on 'Lavender': The AI machine directing Israel's bombing in Gaza
This assumes that AI based weaponry provides value. The case in point here is showing that the only value it provides is a flimsy justification for civilian casualties. We... Don't need more of that in the US, nor would it provide a "good guy" any legitimate value.
hirsin··on It's time to stop using SMS (2021)
Passphrases and a browser extension, basically. The Passphrase can still be stripped off the wire and used later while passkeys are phishproof and single use.
hirsin··on It's time to stop using SMS (2021)
How many sites actually do that? Microsoft does it for the device compliance/SSO/push notification stuff. Heck even we (GitHub) don't push the app and require TOTP or SMS first if you want to use the app.
hirsin··on It's time to stop using SMS (2021)
Did you happen to transfer that phone number from a land-line to a mobile? Sort of like geo-ip systems, the SMS providers like twilio track blocks of numbers and label them as land-line or not, and refuse to send SMS to landlines. Unfortunately they're quite stale and don't account for the possibility that users could switch their number. They have ways for the user to reach out individually and fix their number, which is... Dumb.
hirsin··on It's time to stop using SMS (2021)
You've basically backed into the logic of passkeys as well. It's all about _provably_ having the thing you have. Basically everyone is storing their passwords on their computer anyway, if at all, so the computer is the thing they have. Why not make that the factor instead of a string?
hirsin··on You can't leak users' data if you don't hold it
It's not a server-side component but something integral to the passkey itself. Everything is on the key and there's no third party - just the key, and the site you're authing to. So when you auth with a passkey, it includes some details around "this came from a Feitian model x or yubico model y or bitwarden or...". That's blank, IIRC, if it's Apple.

And then if a corporate type has said "well we only gave our employees Yubikey 3s", they can instruct their idp to only accept passkeys for Yubikey 3s.

This is a tradeoff - their employees can't register legitimate, useful personal passkeys like their phone, but an arbitrary (not dedicated nationstate) attacker is a bit less likely to somehow takeover the account and add a Feitian key. That mismatch is a nice signal to block the user.

But in general, outside of corporate identities, no one has any interest in caring what kind of passkey you use. GitHub doesn't, certainly, outside of resident key requirements, a different bundle of fish.

(and yes, Dan is definitely great at this stuff, read his blog on this stuff).

hirsin··on Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions into public housing
Which is why if you've ever lived far outside the city, you're tired of people from the city coming out to visit you to buy all the stuff they can't get in the city.

Oh, no, it's the other way round, mostly. It's easier to deliver a quantity and variety of goods to a dense area than the sticks. Which is why "go shopping" is a suggestion for people going to NYC, not Tucson.

hirsin··on Two-Thirds of U.S. Adults Would Rather Wait to Watch Movies on Streaming
Basically. We all had a pair of shots I'd say. Easy even for strongly concerned folks to have six feet separation between bubbles.
hirsin··on Two-Thirds of U.S. Adults Would Rather Wait to Watch Movies on Streaming
It's relatively affordable, or was during the late pandemic, to simply book a theater. They charge about the same as twentyfive tickets and it's for you and up to twenty friends. Was great to add an intermission to the middle of James Bond to go hit the restroom and get drinks.
hirsin··on CEO of data privacy company Onerep.com founded dozens of people-search firms
And when they autofill that value with 1, because they obviously got all of that data legitimately? Will consumers be asked to prove a negative?

Even test cases will run into data sharing issues.

hirsin··on Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable
Ice only melts under pressure right around the freezing point - it's that weird overhang on the phase diagram, maybe to around minus fifty C. But by -180C it's always solid.
hirsin··on Testing how hard it is to cheat with ChatGPT in interviews
Indeed - with 3.5 at least it does fail the easy mode riddle https://chat.openai.com/share/b3761807-551d-4cfc-b291-6d37ee...
hirsin··on The man who coined the word "robot" defends himself
Interestingly, the Chernobyl liquidators forced to clean the roof were referred to as robots. I think the TV series expanded that to "bio robots", but books about the incident from tbe nineties simply used robot.
hirsin··on Nightshade: An offensive tool for artists against AI art generators
Artists pay those people and make their jobs needed. Same as the person above claiming Duchamp didn't negotiate with the ceramics makers - yes, they absolutely did and do pay their suppliers. Artists aren't smash and grabbing their local Blick.

AI pays no artist.

hirsin··on Google shares update on next step toward phasing out third-party cookies
Wild, I sat in meetings for months with JohnW and the Chrome team to discuss exactly these things but go off.
hirsin··on [dead]
> à new test to assess the constitutionality of gun laws by holding they must be "consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation."

This is the piece I find disconcerting. It effectively bans any legislation short of a constitutional amendment, as roughly tautologically any law that changes firearm regulation is not in keeping with existing regulations.

I wonder if this could be used later to find expansions of gun rights unconstitutional because they're not in keeping with existing regulations?

← PreviousPage 5 of 22Next →