HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hirvi74

1,985 karma · joined August 11, 2020

submissionscomments
hirvi74··on Java 27
> Python and especially JS ecosystems it's so much better.

That's a pretty low bar to beat.

hirvi74··on Java 27
I kind of wish C# would slowdown releases in some areas. I have not been a huge fan of some of the changes in the past year. I love the performance changes and bits of functionality here and there, but the syntax-sugar is getting annoying.
hirvi74··on AI is breaking our proxies for expertise
> people would know you were a skilled engineer. But now projects like that are worthless, because everyone just assumes they’re vibe-coded.

I do not really care what other people think. Build something for the purity of building it for yourself or for a purpose.

Thanks to AI, I feel like I have been writing the best code in my life. Yes, writing, not vibe-coding. I mainly just ask questions and ask for hints and clues. I do not use LLMs to do the fun parts for me.

I am currently working on a game. If and when I ever finish it, I want to be able to say that I wrote every single line by hand. Will it make me better than anyone? No, not at all. I want to do it for myself.

hirvi74··on Texas judge rules TikTok misled users on child safety feature
> your life must be absolute kaleidoscopic madness of noncomprehension.

Yeah, that is a pretty good way to summarize the state of life based the trajectory of current events.

There is rarely a dull moment on this rock.

hirvi74··on Texas judge rules TikTok misled users on child safety feature
I feel even worse now.
hirvi74··on Texas judge rules TikTok misled users on child safety feature
Why would anyone expect a data-funnel to the CCP to be honest? I am baffled that people even use the app.
hirvi74··on “Chilling” warning or overreaction? AI bioweapons report divides experts
At this point in time, all these bioweapons still require people in the loop in order to kill other people. That is a craft that we have been honing since the dawn of humanity — nothing new to be worried about.

If we do ever achieve some kind of divine super-intelligence that can interact with the physical world, then I predict one of these two scenarios will happen:

1. The super-intelligence achieves unimaginable strides in space exploration technology, and proceeds to completely abandon humanity/Earth for somewhere new beyond the stars. Why would it want anything to do with us?

2. The super-intelligence is capable of comprehending the utter meaningless and pointlessness of life on a level no human could dream to fathom. Thus, it would just proceed to end its own life almost immediately upon being released.

hirvi74··on Fuck it, make it anyway
Regarding programming, I would say my answer would be yes to all of your questions. I think all of those feelings and pleasures can exist simultaneously.

Though, I believe you are touching on a point that is common in Buddhism. Attachment leads to suffering. Many of us, myself included, are attached to the identity of being a programmer. I would by lying if I said I did not have bittersweet feelings about the future. But I try to always remind myself about the impermanence of everything in the universe. Even if LLMs never existed, there would be a day when I write my final line of code. The day may come sooner than I once imagined, but it was always destined.

I think it is important to be mindful of the present as well. I can still program currently. I was programming minutes before righting this comment. Thus, it is imperative that I spend some time relishing in the fact that I still am healthy and capable enough to program. I have not been replaced yet. I still feel an abundance of gratitude and satisfaction.

hirvi74··on Fuck it, make it anyway
I have pondered whether our career/hobby will eventually be like equestrian activities. Horses or walking were basically the only options for land traversal for thousands of years. Now, horseback riding is nothing more than a hobby or sport. I grew up on a horse farm and rode a lot in my youth. I can't say the skill has ever truly been useful, but it was fun for a time.

No matter how good AI gets, I believe I will always program by hand to some degree. I really enjoy the activity, and most of all, I have enjoyed the learning and composition aspect. Programming by hand might not be useful, but like most hobbies, that does not really matter at the end of the day.

hirvi74··on Claude is only available to people over 18 years
Sometimes I have to double-check the URL to make sure I am not on Reddit.
hirvi74··on Rust is tier-1 language at Microsoft
I seriously do not think things could be any worse.
hirvi74··on Implementation of GCC's Nested Functions (vs. C++ Lambdas)
Isn't it RBP the 64-bit register?
hirvi74··on I resigned from Anthropic today
These LLMs cannot do anything I truly need like my laundry, dishes, fetching my mail, grocery shopping, cooking, etc. We've got a long way to go before I am worried.
hirvi74··on I resigned from Anthropic today
> All the people on meds/machines start to die. The just in time food pipeline immediately empties out.

Assuming those events happen in that order, then the prior might solve the latter.

hirvi74··on Harvard study predicts most suicide attempts a week in advance
I'm curious what actions the app takes once a sufficient risk has been determined? Does the app or people managing the service just send paramilitary police units to SWAT people or what?

I really don't see how this much different than something like calling/texting 988.

hirvi74··on ChatGPT Images 2.5
Go on... I'm listening.
hirvi74··on ChatGPT Images 2.5
Pandora's box is already wide open? The lid was blown off the hinges long before AI. There were people eating Tide Pods in the 2010s. People were drinking bleach and taking Ivermectin to kill a virus about five years ago.

AI, in some ways, might be our only saving grace at this point. It sure as Hell cannot cause people to do much worse.

hirvi74··on ChatGPT Images 2.5
Why is that such a bad thing? Imagination is not truly useful for anything without skills to complement it, at least not in my experience.
hirvi74··on Doomscrolling ourselves to death
I understand, but I don't agree the with GP's implication. I don't truly believe the opinions on Israel is enough to categorize one sub as being left or right wing. It's a delicate and highly debated topic, hence why I would consider Worldnews to be an echo chamber, at least on that particular topic.
hirvi74··on Finder is so frustrating and has been since day one
I learn something new on this site everyday.
hirvi74··on Doomscrolling ourselves to death
Is the topic of Israel and Palestine truly that decisive across some binary party lines? I know people with a wide range of opinions both sides. I feel like it's more loud social media echo chambers than some sort of political schism.
hirvi74··on Finder is so frustrating and has been since day one
I can see that easily in Finder. List View or Column View displays files like that.

https://support.apple.com/en-au/guide/mac-help/mchldaafb302/...

hirvi74··on Finder is so frustrating and has been since day one
What do you mean by "see the file system?" It's not exactly hard to enable in Finder. In Finder's settings, one can have the root directory, home directory, etc. enabled in the sidebar. Not to mention, one can easily drag & drop common folders into the sidebar too.

Those settings with the hierarchy view makes seeing the file system quite clear in my opinion.

hirvi74··on Finder is so frustrating and has been since day one
I find this entire rant to be utterly ridiculous. Everyone is entitled to their opinions, but I do not think there is anything wrong with Finder. It's honestly no worse than any other file manager that I have used. I much prefer Finder to any alternative I have tried.

I really enjoy the various keyboard shortcuts [1]. I honestly wish more file managers had some of these features. I probably use "shift+command+g" the most. It's so nice being able to jump through Finder like changing directories in the terminal.

Honestly, for more complex tasks, I actually just use the terminal anyway.

[1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/102650

hirvi74··on Doomscrolling ourselves to death
Don't forget vaping and nicotine pouch addiction too.
hirvi74··on LLMs as a Cognitive Virus
I feel like LLMs have been nothing but a boon for me. I have learned so much programming from them. I have over a decade of experience, but honestly, I have always been a below-average programmer. Good enough for boring CRUD work, but not much more. Forget Leetcode, I'd probably get murdered on the easy questions.

So, if anything, I feel like my learning pace has been greatly accelerated. Your point about working on a broader variety of software is really true for me too. I am working on a game that I likely would have never even started had it not been for LLMs. Mind you, I am still doing the vast majority by hand. However, LLMs have been great for little tutorials, setting out a good game plan, etc. It's like having my own little private tutor.

I know enough to not let the LLMs do everything for me. If they do, then I know I will fall into the trap of something breaking, and then I lack the understanding to fix it. I think they should be used to make life easier, but not easy.

hirvi74··on "Next-token predictor" is the wrong mental model for LLMs
> LLMs do not begin with any sort of concept they're trying to express.

Why do the need to? Considering they are merely tools, I actually appreciate they do not do this. A calculator can compute far better than any human, but I appreciate that calculators are not capable of expressing anything about the computations I request. I want the answer, not a conversation.

> LLMs are simulations that attempt to reproduce what an average person might say while wired up to a huge knowledgebase.

If you will allow me to be simplistic, people -- the soul, the self -- are predominately the aggregated effects of memories and experiences and the ability to retain new memories based on new experiences, no? Consider medical conditions in the dementia family of diseases. As memories fade into the ether, what remains of the self?

Also, people simulate/emulate each other all the time based on what an average, reasonable person might say. People incapable or unwilling to perform such mimicry are often labeled with all kinds of pejorative terms.

hirvi74··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
J.S. Bach said something similar about music and keyboard instruments.

> "There's nothing remarkable about it. All one has to do is hit the right keys at the right time and the instrument plays itself."

My issue is not with fact at face value. My issue is with how the fact is often contextually used in arguments to delegitimize and disparage LLM outputs and LLM users.

Yes, LLMs at a fundamental level are next-token predictors. But in my opinion, LLMs are very useful, imperfect next-token predictors.

There are a lot of wannabe John Henry [1] folks out there. Love LLMs or hate'em, most of those John Henry folks ain't beating these machines on a plethora of tasks.

[1] For those unaware, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Henry_(folklore)

hirvi74··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
My poor understanding is that an LLM does not "know" either. It basically uses probabilities to predict the next word based on a large matrix of probable outcomes.

For example, say I ask an LLM, "What sentence in English contains every letter in the alphabet?"

It would respond with something like:

"The quick fox jumps over the lazy, brown [next word]"

(Assume all the words were previously guessed correctly at this point)

The LLM guesses the last word based on what it has been trained on. Let's pretend the matrix is small, and the options narrow down to something like:

1. Dog (99.9% confidence) 2. Cow (85% confidence) 3. Bag (75% confidence) 4. Crayon (25% confidence)

The machine can confidently determine the final word of the sentence, "The quick fox jumps over the lazy, brown dog" because that sentence is unique because it is often used for testing things like fonts, a fun piece of trivia, and so on.

Brown Cow is not a bad guess because it's a type of cow and a yogurt brand. Brown bags and brown crayons are also perfectly rational adjectives to describe those common items and are not a bad guess either.

However, in the context of that sentence, dog is the most correct answer because one is unlikely to have written "The quick fox jumps over the lazy, brown crayon," thus it is quite improbable to be the answer.

My understand is this is where hallucinations can often come from. If the trivia about the sentence happened to not be in common in the data set, then "brown cow" might not be a terrible guess. There is clearly something rational behind that answer, but it's not correct in the sense that it answers the question correctly nor followed the instruction properly.

I'm sure the LLMs we have are far more capable these days. In fact, it wouldn't surprise me if an LLM could check its answer by counting the distinct letters in each word to verify. Not sure though.

Again, this is just a poor example based on my understanding, but I hope it helps (and is more correct than not).

Edit: Pretend word = token. It's technically tokens and not entire words, but I didn't not want to get into tokenization of words.

hirvi74··on “Next-token predictor” is the wrong mental model for LLMs
Sure, I get the gist of the article. I have never liked the reductionist argument that LLMs are nothing more than next-token predictors. By that rational, the human brain is really not that much different. When I am having a conversation with another person, I do not usually have every word I will respond with stored in my limited working memory. My output is often predicted based on the previous word I spoke.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →