HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hither_shores

249 karma · joined February 21, 2022

submissionscomments
hither_shores··on Physicists rewrite the fundamental law that leads to disorder
> I simply observe that the SR by itself does not describe the outcomes of experiments.

No formalism describes the outcome of experiments by itself. There always needs to be an interpretation attached, and our choice of interpretation is always underdetermined by observation.

> The problem with this is that it is violently at odds with observations that every human makes every moment of their lives

Like all other interpretations of all other physical theories, MWI isn't and can't be at odds with our observations alone, because our observations alone aren't enough to imply any particular relationship between observations in general. And like all other interpretations, it is and must be at odds with competing interpretations, and in particular with the folk-physics model we're naturally inclined to use. But this means very little, because folk-physics is wrong, and this far from the paleolithic savanna, it's wrong in ways that matter. Intuition is evidence, but it's not particularly strong evidence, and it's certainly not proof.

> and it does not account for the Born rule.

Sure, it still needs a separate account of subjective probability. But so does everything else: it's just a little harder to notice in the classical regime, since the relevant probabilities are always either 1 or 0.

hither_shores··on Physicists rewrite the fundamental law that leads to disorder
> The wave function is not a description of anything physical. The domain of the wave function is not physical space, it is configuration space. This is the reason entanglement seems weird to us, because we live in physical space and the wave function does not.

This is circular: you're assuming that realism about the wave function is incorrect to argue against the (tragically misnamed) many-worlds interpretation, but the only substantive claim the MWI makes is that realism about the wave function is true.

hither_shores··on Ask HN: Serious mathematics books that can replace a good teacher?
Introductory model theory has no particular prerequisites beyond elementary set theory and logic, but it does demand a fair amount of mathematical maturity. If this is your first exposure to higher math, you're probably better off starting with another topic. Real analysis or group theory would be the traditional choices.
hither_shores··on Ask HN: Serious mathematics books that can replace a good teacher?
No, they're fairly niche topics as far as the rest of mathematics is concerned. You'll see much more emphasis on them, and especially on statistics, in an applied math curriculum.
hither_shores··on Ask HN: Serious mathematics books that can replace a good teacher?
The Elements is of course historically significant, but it would be a horrible introductory textbook.
hither_shores··on Singapore Government Tech Stack
The first Korean Republic (1948-1960) was vastly more repressive than the PAP at its worst, let alone today. Mass arrests of political opponents, reeducation camps, massacres: you name it, Rhee did it. The second republic (1960 to 1961) was theoretically a liberal democracy, but got couped almost immediately. After that, South Korea remained a somewhat milder developmental dictatorship, ala Singapore, until 1987.
hither_shores··on An update on the campaign to defend serious math education in California
A magnet high school in northern Virginia.
hither_shores··on An update on the campaign to defend serious math education in California
An introductory math class is supposed to

- get you used to the general feel of the topic

- make you practice proving things

The specific theorems students prove are not really the point.

hither_shores··on Now I’m calculating with constructive reals
Which is exactly why nonstandard analysis is way more complicated: the usual construction of the hyperreals involves some somewhat technical set theory, and even a relatively fast and loose version is going to require at least a first course in abstract algebra to be intelligible.
hither_shores··on Functional programming with bananas, lenses, envelopes and barbed wire [pdf] (1991)
Explicit getter-setter lenses and profunctor lenses are not quite the same thing, although they happen to be equivalent in Haskell. For example: the getter-setter encoding only works when you have diagonals (~ copying data).
hither_shores··on I stopped working on black hole information loss
You're double-counting. Starting from Newtonian mechanics, gravitational waves are indeed a huge, incredibly novel prediction. So is gravitational lensing. So is any other consequence of a coupling between the metric and the stress-energy tensor - because that's the real novel prediction.

Once you grant that the metric varies smoothly over space and time, gravitational waves are pretty mundane.

hither_shores··on I stopped working on black hole information loss
Bostrom is a full professor of philosophy at Oxford. Whatever you think of his arguments (or more likely, whatever mangled summary of them you ended up getting after the internet played a multi-year game of telephone with them first), he's as actual a philosopher as any living person can be.
hither_shores··on I stopped working on black hole information loss
This is too strong. There are important fields whose points are not tensors (e.g. spinor fields) and treating them like tensor fields risks introducing all sorts of subtle confusions.
hither_shores··on I stopped working on black hole information loss
They also involve addition, but that doesn't make them arithmetic. Knowing linear algebra gets you perhaps 10% of the way to having the math background for a first course in GR.
hither_shores··on I stopped working on black hole information loss
Numerical relativity is not just or even mostly linear algebra. Even in the weak-field limit, where linearized GR is qualitatively correct, you still have to actually solve the resulting PDE.
hither_shores··on TypeScript and Set Theory
"+" is probably a bad choice: sum types are a separate thing. In TypeScript, they can be implemented as

     Sum<X, Y> = { tag: "left", data: X } | { tag: "right", data: Y }
Generally higher order types are named according to what they do to types, not terms. `x: ICat & IDog` means "x is in the intersection of ICat and IDog", not "x is the intersection of an ICat and an IDog". (The latter interpretation only even makes sense for record types and a few other special cases: what's the intersection of an integer and a string supposed to be?)
hither_shores··on There’s more to mathematics than rigour and proofs (2007)
That is not at all what the incompleteness theorems say.

The first incompleteness theorem says that for any consistent formal system T (with a recursively enumerable set of axioms) capable expressing of elementary arithmetic, T can express a statement which it can neither prove nor disprove.

The second incompleteness theorem says that T can't prove the statement "T is consistent". (I've still glossed over a number of technical details here; pick up a book on model theory if you want all the messy internals.)

First order logic is notably not capable of expressing elementary arithmetic. And observers aren't involved in any way.

hither_shores··on As inflation soars, how is Arizona iced tea still 99 cents?
You're not wrong, but GP's error is much more object level than that. The neoclassical paradigm has flaws; claiming that all markets are perfectly competitive is not one of them. Sweet tea is a textbook case of monopolistic competition, and short run inelasticity is to be expected.
hither_shores··on Logarithms yearning to be free
This is the starting point of "tropical" analysis
hither_shores··on Logarithms yearning to be free
> So the type of the return value changes at asymptotes/limits (already) and thus that's not a pure function in terms of math.

Plenty of functions are discontinuous. Almost all of them, in fact. (This isn't true constructively, but GP is clearly doing classical analysis.)

> If a [math] function returns a more complex type signature instead of throwing a ZeroDivisionError (as Python core does) what is that then called? Is it differentiable or no, etc?

Depends on the smooth structures you've imposed on the domain and codomain, which requires much more powerful types to represent than are available in any mainstream language I'm aware of. (You might be able to contort Haskell into something sort of close, but it wouldn't be simple.)

hither_shores··on What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physicists (2016)
> Back to the divergence theorem, physics wants to have a 2 dimensional measure they write as dA and a three dimensional measure they write as dV, but there is a gap in their argument: They are necessarily working with what measure theory calls product measure and in particular Fubini's theorem, and there needs to be some orthogonality that is not made clear, in either math or physics.

Those are differential forms, defined explicitly in terms of submanifolds of euclidean space. Turning them into measures on the corresponding manifolds requires picking an arbitrary "unit speed" parameterization (or equivalent data) to absorb the equally arbitrary (from the intrinsic perspective) choice of embedding.

Sticking with differential forms and letting smoothness assumptions handle all the measure-theoretic difficulties for you is the principled choice and also the easy choice, so it should come as no surprise when physicists choose it.

> Physics in quantum mechanics keeps talking about superposition and linearity. Us math people know in fine detail just what linearity is -- it's central to linear algebra, Banach space, Hilbert space, integration, differentiation, and more. I have to question if the physics people have a clear understanding of linearity. Then there is superposition -- tough even to make a mathematically credible guess just what physics means by superposition.

obeys the superposition principle = has dynamics given by a linear operator. Or sometimes a bounded linear operator, continuous linear operator, etc. depending on context. Physics is no different from math in this respect.

> I'm tired of screaming myself to a sore throat over the claims that the wave functions of quantum mechanics form a Hilbert space. Hilbert space is a math idea, and in math departments we know quite well what a Hilbert space is, a complete inner product space. The "complete" part is in the sense of Cauchy, that every Cauchy convergent sequence converges. Well, the wave functions fail that completeness assumption.

State spaces in finite dimensional QM are projective Hilbert spaces, in a perfectly literal sense, with all the completeness properties you expect. You're right that intro QM mischaracterizes it though: the position (wlog momentum) "basis" is actually defined with respect to a rigged Hilbert space structure Psi \subset H \subset Psi^*. This is also the appropriate approach for the infinite dimensional case ... and a completely inappropriate approach for teaching freshmen.

> The last time I was reading from Feynman's Lectures on Physics I recall, before I wanted to get my money back, that he claimed that a particle of unknown position had probability distribution uniform over all of space. WRONG! It's a trivial argument, maybe even at the middle school level, to show that no such distribution can exist.

Again, he's teaching freshmen: don't confuse lies-to-children with genuine misunderstanding. Physicists are well aware that plane waves are not actual states.

hither_shores··on Life’s preference for symmetry is like ‘a new law of nature’
Noether's theorem gives you conservation laws from continuous global symmetries, like those you've noted. Under certain conditions this can be extended to discretized global symmetries (as in, for instance, a crystal lattice) but there's no analogue for the true discrete symmetries exhibited by most body plans.
hither_shores··on Amazon workers on Staten Island vote to unionize
Employers have a legal obligation to negotiate in good faith with unions which are the exclusive representatives of an entire bargaining unit. They have no such obligation to members-only unions. This is what the "right to collectively bargain" refers to in the context of US labor law. If you don't like the terminology, you can try to take it up with the NLRB, but it doesn't change the facts on the ground.
hither_shores··on Two Vexing Problems in Functional Programming
No, that's not accurate. The final form of your Haskell program before it's compiled down to some assembly language (currently C-- or LLVM) is a graph reduction problem. The partially imperative part is the runtime system, which actually reduces the graph (= runs your program), but this is significantly more complicated than the sort of high level loop transformations you're talking about. Search "spineless tagless G-machine" for a (somewhat idealized) description of the core architecture of GHC.
hither_shores··on Two Vexing Problems in Functional Programming
The category with linear circuits as its morphisms, labelled sets of electronic terminals as its objects, and laying circuits in parallel as the monoidal product (which is the usual notion of the category of circuits; perhaps you have something more sophisticated in mind, but if so you should specify that) is not cartesian closed.

One of the many ways to demonstrate this: all linear circuits have duals (voltage <-> current, series <-> parallel, and so on), but in a cartesian closed category only the terminal object is dualizable.

What you're probably thinking of is the fact that this category is compact closed. The corresponding internal language is going to be some sort of process calculus (I think the pi calculus is too strong, but not sure), not the lambda calculus.

hither_shores··on Amazon workers on Staten Island vote to unionize
The NLRA has historically been interpreted in a way that denies bargaining rights to members-only unions. It hasn't been tested in a while, and it's possible that the current NLRB would view the issue differently, but unless and until that happens minority unionism is not a viable strategy in the US.
hither_shores··on The singularity is close?
> Where are all the AI/ML practitioners, i.e. people who don't make a living out of predicting The End of the World, and with actual subject-matter achievements, predicting the Singularity and the Robot Apocalypse?

The answer is in the question: they're spending most of their time doing AI research or ML work, whereas the internet celebrities who write most of what you read spend most of their time getting you to read what they write.

hither_shores··on With Category Theory, Mathematics Escapes from Equality (2019)
Doing everything in terms of explicit equivalence relations is perfectly rigorous, but it results in a combinatorial explosion of bookkeeping tasks for anything other than set theory, and so no one actually does it. We want foundations that allow us to engage in idiomatic mathematical reasoning and be perfectly rigorous at the same time.

> For instance, seeing that a situation might be described/given by several equivalence relations, we'd probably want to have equivalences between equivalence relations, and then work based on "quotient sets of equivalence relations"

That's the general idea, yeah.

hither_shores··on With Category Theory, Mathematics Escapes from Equality (2019)
That's the "infinity": ordinary (1-)categories have (1-)arrows between objects, 2-categories have 2-arrows between 1-arrows, 3-categories have 3-arrows between 2-arrows, and so on. Infinity-categories have (k+1)-arrows between k-arrows all the way up. (And a 0-category is just a set: objects, but no arrows)

> Is (1+(1+1)) the same amount of equivalence to 3 as 1+2 is? I'd much prefer a notion that could look at how 'equivalent' terms are opposed to just looking at equality after β-reduction.

"Amounts" of equivalence between terms isn't really the right notion here: there's not much you can do with "an equivalence exists", which is all that "X and Y are equivalent" really means. A 2-equivalence (which in this context I think is going to end up being something like a rewrite rule?) should be an equivalence between particular programs, not the whole space of programs implementing a given function.

hither_shores··on The Feynman Lectures on Physics (1964)
Linear algebra and multivariable calculus
← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →