249 karma · joined February 21, 2022
Hamiltonian mechanics faces more serious obstacles, though if you really want to you can engineer a noncanonical symplectic structure to capture the dissipation. Wouldn't recommend it though.
Some monad transformers, like `MaybeT m a`, are just wrappers around a composed `m (Maybe a)`, but others, like the continuation passing transformer `ContT r m a = (a -> m r) -> m r`, are very much not.
This is true, it's just not why magnets can lift things.
Trying to teach yourself physics by reading wikipedia is like trying to learn how to program by reading the C++ standard. It's a fine resource, but not for that. You need an introductory physics textbook, not an encyclopedia. Griffith's Introduction to Electrodynamics is a classic choice.
> those iron filings are pulled by virtual photons created by the magnet
No. Virtual particles are part of a notational scheme for carrying out certain computations in quantum field theory. They're not particles, and they're definitely not involved in classical electromagnetism.
> I've concluded that magnetism is an unexplained phenomenon, just like gravity: we have accurate formulas, but nobody knows what those formulas describe.
The formulas, ultimately, describe the relationship between our observations. This is the only sense in which we ever explain anything, and a sense in which magnetism and gravity are both very well-explained.
> For intuitive understanding, I see a magnet as a well, except that this well can be moved around and has two poles.
You should not try to understand electromagnetism intuitively yet. You haven't built the right intuitions, and to do that you first need to tear down your wrong ones.
Regularization techniques take effective field theories like the Standard Model, which are known to be inaccurate at high enough energies, and isolate their low-energy behavior.
For example: classical electrodynamics, interpreted naively, says that the total energy stored in an electron's electric field is infinite, since the field strength blows up to infinity at the position of the electron itself. As this isn't actually true, we know there must be physics going on very close to the electron that our theory doesn't account for. But even if our theory isn't the Final Truth, it's still capable of making perfectly good predictions far away from the electron, and we can't just sit around waiting for quantum mechanics to be discovered.
So we make the structure of the electron a parameter of our theory: it can't tell you what the force between two electrons is, but if you posit that the electron's charge is distributed like so, it can tell you what the force between two electrons would be.
We then use empirical data to reabsorb our new degree of freedom: this is renormalization. Instead of trying to predict the force between two electrons, we measure it, and then work backwards to figure out what the electron's charge distribution would have to look like to produce that force. In this particular case: the electron behaves as if it were a sphere about 10^-15 meters across. This is of course not the actual structure of the electron, but it reproduces the same low-energy classical physics.
I went to Caltech and would definitely not do this. The CS faculty was fantastic, but the undergraduate option has some problems:
- a wildly disproportionate share of cheating cases came from CS undergrads
- CS graduation requirements are very flexible, which is a mixed blessing. On the one hand, giving students more freedom is broadly a good thing, and many of them use that freedom to double major or go deep into specialized grad level work. On the other hand, some of them use it to construct schedules much easier than most other options would allow. Not all of them, but enough that "B's in caltech CS" is not as strong a signal as you might think.
Some signals I would consider stronger for Caltech students:
- CS/Math double majors. Or CS/[Any technical subject], for that matter.
- Summer research: someone paying five figures of opportunity cost to do something they think is interesting is probably not a $/effort optimizer.
- Grad-level CS coursework. CS 139 (Design and Analysis of Algorithms) in particular pulls no punches.