HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hn_decay

197 karma · joined June 27, 2011

Fuck off and die you moronic halfwits. Hacker News continues its descent to shittitude.
submissionscomments
hn_decay··on Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation
>Can you name a case where Microsoft has tried to screw some fairly small developer by using a patent lawsuit?

Why does it have to be a "fairly small developer"? Microsoft has a legacy of a lot of broad patents owing to the fact that they've been rolling in billions for decades (and hence can stomach having a lot of people filing trivial patents). With that they try to either run competitors out of business, FUD users into avoiding alternatives, or outright demand some extortion fees (see every Android maker and Microsoft's current patent shakedown).

"Obvious infrginements" is loaded and has little meaning given the incredibly broad patents allowed by the patent system.

>would we be better off without patents altogether, or are we grumbling about minor annoyances compared to what we'd be dealing with without patents (e.g. lots of obfuscation)?

We would be far better off without software patents. There is absolutely no doubt about that. I neither encourages innovation (it more likely discourages innovation), and it only helps to entrench the most successful.

hn_decay··on Why Google cares if you use your real name
* Superficial isn't a synonym of "wrong". *

It is a synonym for "barely worthy of anyone's time.

And yes, of course Google wants Google+ to make them money. But saying "they want a healthy, vibrant, non-threatening community...thus allowing them more page visits and thus ad impressions, thus allowing them to make lots of money" has a completely different synergy than "they want your name so they can sell it".

hn_decay··on Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation
http://www.google.com/patents/about/7620565_Customer_based_p...
hn_decay··on Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation
Why should they have shame? This is exactly how the system works. They are abusing the system in the same way that companies like Apple and Microsoft have been, the latter just seem to have a soft spot in some people's hearts.

We need a patent nuclear war. This needs to end. BRING IT ON LODSYS. May every patent holder in every nook and cranny start cashing in.

hn_decay··on Why Google cares if you use your real name
Google knows who you are. Google knows where you've been on the web, and what you're doing. They long have. Google told me on my own + page several of the pseudonyms I've used across the web.

The "Google wants to sell you" bit is not insightful. It's not a unique perspective. It's the same superficial analysis we see with every single thing Google does.

Google wants an online community of real people, with what that entails. There is a long and documented trail of discussions on this topic regarding the downsides of anonymity. Yet there are also upsides, and if someone wants an anonymous discussion forum that supports that, there are plenty of options for that.

But it is wholly inconsistent with the goals of Google+.

Alas. Whatever Google does, just say it's because they want to sell you out. It's a clean, pat answer.

hn_decay··on Be Handsome, Be Attractive, Don't Be Unattractive
By your posting history, I highly suspect that Hacker News isn't the right site for you. Digg, perhaps?
hn_decay··on Be Handsome, Be Attractive, Don't Be Unattractive
I think the whole of Hacker News thanks you for this generous service you provide for them. You are, truly, a hero.
hn_decay··on Be Handsome, Be Attractive, Don't Be Unattractive
Thank you for your thoughts. I am curious, though: What is "click karma"? I'm not quite seeing how a humorous response post that puts into context a previous front-pager here on HN is for "click karma".

In fact I see that the only two comments are by, and I apologize, bores. I assume that you have another post nearby in the new, under a different account of course, that you are hoping to elevate by trying to urinate on this submission? For the life of me I can't understand why two people would leave such boorish comments when they could have just moved on.

hn_decay··on Google Deletes Last 7 Years Of User's Digital Life, Shrugs
So if we discard the polarizing language about customers and products, we get to your point being that the more profitable you are as a customer, the more attention you get?

I don't think that is terribly challenging viewpoint.

hn_decay··on Google Deletes Last 7 Years Of User's Digital Life, Shrugs
Sophistry : "a subtle, tricky, superficially plausible, but generally fallacious method of reasoning."

Google makes money because they have users, in the same way that a television network makes money because they have viewers. Both are entirely reliant upon their user base, and will desperately trying to optimize and maximize that user base.

If the GP's point was "there is a very low profit / user, and a limited impact by irate customers (at least those who don't shout from the rooftops)" then they are making an accurate statement, and it's actually what I supported -- Google doesn't care whether you're on a "free" or pay program, they'll still try to avoid talking to you.

The bit about products and customers is just completely unnecessary, again, sophistry. Google's product is a mail system and a search engine and a social product, and sometimes users pay for it (I use Apps for Domains), and sometimes advertisers pay for it. Cutifying that into comforting slogans isn't helpful.

hn_decay··on Google Deletes Last 7 Years Of User's Digital Life, Shrugs
"But, see, the trouble here is that these users aren't customers. They're product sold to advertisers."

The whole product/customer thing is a boring bit of sophistry usually used to slander Google.

Google's profitability secret is a very high revenue to employee ratio. When I bought a $600 Nexus One from Google and discovered a problem with fulfilment, the grand total of support Google supplied to me was an automated email response (that itself was a dead end -- no recourse or escalation), and a link to an FAQ.

That's just how Google operates. If they can make a cron job that eliminates the need to supply support for most customers, that's what they do. It is this way whether they benefit from you via your eyeballs, or from your wallet.

hn_decay··on Google+ Now The Top Free App In The Apple App Store
"Duncan Stewart's retweet of"...

I am honestly curious -- why wouldn't you just say "Andy Levy said it best"? Is there some onus of attribution regarding retweets? (Not snarky -- seriously curious. My personal opinion is that you blog about or retweet or share something because you think it's notable, deserving no attribution unless you've actually added something interesting to it)

Twitter celebrities will have a natural aversion to any medium that essentially puts them at ground zero, and they're going to look for reasons not to like it. For the overwhelming majority of ordinary people, however, it does fill a need. The first-class nature of circles and the privacy controls have completely changed social networks for me, making intermixing classes of relationships much more relaxing.

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
"Getting geeks to dislike patents is easy."

Isn't that kind of strange? Aren't we the ones who most benefit from patents?

"Do you really think that the opinion of people on HN has a measurable impact on our patent system?"

Yes I absolutely do. In fact I think the next 24 months will see a lot of debate and eventually significant change to software patents in the US. All I care about are defusing those who attempt to make everyone feel too ignorant to have an opinion about patents (such attempts appear in every discussion about patents. Lots of hand waving about how we all just don't get it, leave it for the big boys, etc)

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
There is no hindsight effect about the notion of identifying classes of text in a string of text. I fully and completely anticipate that patent being invalidated.

"If something is blindingly obvious at the time, it probably won't get a patent. The USPTO and other such agencies are not perfect but they are not total imbeciles."

The USPTO has shown, time and time again, to be willing imebeciles. They have habitually approved virtually all patents, opening them for review only when contested. I have zero expectation that they are doing any serious review of these patents, and they most certainly are not consulting any industry experts to gauge the true novelty of a patent.

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
Aside from what azakai mentioned (it tends to be large companies that are the biggest culrpits for laying patent minefields), I have no doubt that a lot of people are doing exactly that. The now obvious value of software patents -- artifacts that for decades were literally little more than harmless curiousity -- has led to an explosion in filings.
hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
No he was not right. The comment he replied to quoted an example of an infringing implementation based up all claims and dependencies in the patent. It was 100% correct, and remains 100% correct. Someone didn't cherry pick one elemtn of a claim and that was it, they found a specific infrginging activity, and having read the patent in detail, they are dead on.

More handwaving, however. This is why we can't have nice things.

You are wrong. Ptacek is wrong. AND APPLE AGREES. How is this nonsensical side discussion still occurring? The specific example is one that Apple used, so...what is going on here?

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
His very first message in this discussion!

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2777338

That _IS_ essentially what the patent claims. Ptacek tried to add specificity by pointing out that Apple essentially added the disclaimer "on a computer", which is of marginal usefulness.

His original response was wrong, and was the classic alluding to some deeper (but never stated) meaning to the patent. There is no deeper meaning. That is it.

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
Where he suggested that people who were accurately describing the patent were wrong because they were...you know....missing a claim or something. Yet those interpretations were entirely right, and are mirrored by Apple's own interpretation of their patent.

Simply responding to every patent comment with vagaries and innuendo is not enlightened or helpful. It's unhelpful noise meant to short-circuit discussions about the very, very broken patent system.

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
"either people were doing it before the patent was written, in which case it's obvious and deserves to die, or it was never done before, in which case it doesn't matter how obvious it seems in retrospect."

This isn't necessarily true.

There is also a general concept that if something is obvious to a general practictioner, then it should not be patentable. Does anyone believe that minus the iPhone or that 1996 patent submission that someone else in the computer field wouldn't have "invented" the concept of linking distinct types of text? Now I know that there is plenty of prior art, and this patent will be invalidated, however just discussing the concept that it really was the very first implementation.

Remember the idea of a patent is that you are granted a government monopoly in return for revealing, essentially, your secrets. Who thinks this is a secret? Or the vast majority of patents, for that sake. The current situation is not one where people are actively stealing techniques, but instead it's one where many independent teams of developers inevitably end up at exactly the same end result. That is clear evidence of the farcical, not-as-intended patent system.

Stop and brainstorm for a couple of days about every nuance and variation of wearable or implanted computer. File patents in the hundreds. In a few years you will be a trillionaire.

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
Good fight? I'm fairly sure at this point Ptacek realizes that he was wrong. So wrong that Apple's own self-serving explanation of the patent is identical to the root explanation that caused so much of this discussion.

You insult this community while offering absolutely nothing to counter any complaints about this patent except for, as others have tried, vagaries. Patents are public, so if you've actually got something, let's see it. Otherwise it's just noise.

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
This is exactly the impression I took from Ptacek's post. It is condescending and remarkably offers no counterpoint but instead deals in vagaries and innuendo.

If someone wants to discount an opinion about a patent, they have the patent at the ready for their arsenal. Copy pasting the long-form version of "on a computer" is not a response.

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
To a degree, yes absolutely. The overwhelming majority of software developers, I suspect (invented stat), are against software patents, and the few who aren't suffer the illusion that deep in the obtuse language of patents there really is something novel...because they've been told such in so many internet discussions (that usually follow exactly the course of this one). I don't think that is true, and the illusion that there is something deeper is purely because we seldom talk about the specifics because patents are so horrendously worded, with so much boilerplate.

Thankfully Apple itself has provided such an interpretation, and their interpretation, worded to best be in their favor, is exactly as trivial as many have suspected.

This is a critically important discussion for this industry.

hn_decay··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
Could you please explain what this patent entails then?

Too many times discussions on here have been shortcircuited by claims that the complainant just doesn't understand patents. The discussion fizzles and the absurdist situation with software patents continues.

I've read this patent in detail, as gruelling a task as that is, and it does seem to be as trivial as others are suggesting (as is the case for most trivial patents that get criticized on here). The claims that detail, essentially, a computer are boilerplate in 99% of software patents. They are not particularly relevant and add little specificity.

EDIT: Another submitter has posted a listing of Apple's specific complaints, and it is exactly as others are suggesting -- Regex'ing input and identifying types of text.

hn_decay··on TripAdvisor Architecture - 40M Visitors, 200M Dynamic Page Views, 30TB Data
I was replying to the context of the post, and specifically spoke to horizontal scalability so I am confused that you felt it appropriate to "correct" that.

Having said that, hundreds of millions of records equals a small dataset. I still don't understand when that's held as some sort of edge case when it's easily accommodated on commodity low-end hardware.

hn_decay··on TripAdvisor Architecture - 40M Visitors, 200M Dynamic Page Views, 30TB Data
If they are joining across partitions, then perhaps. If they are forced to localize data to make it joinable, whereas doing the "join" at the app level makes it more horizontally scalable, then that might be an impact.

However against a single instance if you can join in your app faster than on the database for a trivial join, something is seriously wrong with your implementation. I have never, ever seen such a case where it wasn't a scenario where they should have analyzed their plan, to discover a monstrous issue they need to resolve.

In many high performance database systems the IPC to the database level is actually the most expensive operation. Doing two calls instead of one is always a net negative unless you're doing something wrong or fit isolated horizonal scaling scenarios.

hn_decay··on Testing Benford's Law
Benford Law applies to anything where values appreciate or depreciate exponentially. Kind of weird to see it relate to passcodes (where it isn't really Benford's Law at all, but instead is simply numeric proximity), but for monetary values, forces of nature, population counts, etc, Benford's Law will always apply to a large enough set, for reasons that become very evident once you understand the reasoning.

http://blog.yafla.com/Demystifying_Benfords_Law

Best page I've seen on it.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2