HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hn_throwaway_99

78,715 karma · joined February 20, 2017

submissionscomments
hn_throwaway_99··on Your Big Mac might cost more if McDonald's AI thinks people nearby can afford it
Those prices are very good and in fact lower than any McDonald's I've seen in the US. I just checked the price of a McDouble at my nearest McDonald's and the sandwich alone (no fries or drink) is $4.50.
hn_throwaway_99··on Your Big Mac might cost more if McDonald's AI thinks people nearby can afford it
Agreed, and the use of "AI" in the headline is basically just ragebait. There were companies in the late 90s and I'm sure earlier that sold "pricing optimization software" - that's literally what capitalism is built on: charging a price that optimizes profits. And of course many companies have used things like coupons as a tool for price discrimination for decades.

There are parts further down in the article that are more concerning because they're using what should really be more private data in their pricing algorithms, like your geolocation, personal history or even the type of phone you have. But "store location" has been an aspect in pricing algorithms since basically the dawn of capitalism.

hn_throwaway_99··on Your Big Mac might cost more if McDonald's AI thinks people nearby can afford it
What does Walmart have to do with it? Walmart sells products that people need at affordable prices. For McDonald's (and a lot of fast food generally these days) the prices have gone up so much that the value isn't there anymore. Sure, McDonald's food was never healthy and it wasn't exactly haute cuisine, but it was convenient and a guilty pleasure for lots. Now it's cheaper, healthier and hardly much more time consuming to make better food at home. Plus, the indoor dining experience is virtually dead at any fast food restaurant I've been to since Covid - it's nearly all drive through and takeout now. Nearly all the value prop for most fast food is gone or going away.
hn_throwaway_99··on The AI Race Just Got Awkward
> I think it's critical that AI be democratized and not isolated in the hands of a few private companies.

While I'd like to agree with this, the fact is that pushing the frontier out has always taken (and folks expect to continue to take) hundreds of millions/billions of dollars. Open source and distilled models can follow on for much cheaper, but it's hard to imagine the frontier ever being "democratized" given the huge sums of money required. It was this realization that forced OpenAI to take tons of private investment in the first place.

hn_throwaway_99··on The AI Race Just Got Awkward
> They probably all think about Mash and a vodka still, and a completely unrelated association.

I don't know anyone with even a passing understanding of how LLM training works that thinks that is the appropriate analogy.

hn_throwaway_99··on California farmers are struggling to sell grapes as demand for wine drops
It's amazing to me how everyone is so sure of their pet theories. Young people are socializing less! It's GLP-1s! Pot is pushing out wine! Or is it craft beer! Or liquor! Or Covid made us all drink less!

How hard is it to say you just don't know? The reason we have researchers and sociologists examine this stuff is to look at actual data and come to a better conclusion than rando Internet person that pulled it out of their ass.

hn_throwaway_99··on The great crime decline is happening all across the country
But that environment also largely doesn't exist anymore that made that upbringing possible. Heck, parents are getting arrested and having CPS show up at their door for having their kids walk alone less than half a mile to the store.
hn_throwaway_99··on The great crime decline is happening all across the country
I think we know the answer to that one...

Besides, GP is flat out wrong - not prosecuting crime does not result in reduced crime stats. The crime decline is led be a relatively huge 15% reduction in homicides. Even if those homicides remain unsolved or are not prosecuted, they still end up in crime stats. And unlike other crimes where you may argue they go unreported, when someone ends up dead (by usually violent means in a homicide) it rarely goes unnoticed.

hn_throwaway_99··on My Recent Woodworking Projects
> Don't get sucked into the mindset of, I want to build a few projects, therefore I need $2000 worth of new power tools.

I can't recommend maker spaces enough. Of course each space is different, and some are incredible and some are lacking, but in general the ones I've visited (or been a member of) are awesome, filled with a diverse group of people who are usually excited to share their knowledge. Definitely look to see if there is a good maker space where you live!

hn_throwaway_99··on I'm the mom in that viral Giants clip. Let me tell you about my husband
I honestly do not understand this at all. I never use AI to edit my writing, nor do I want to. To me that defeats the entire fucking point of writing.

It's like learning to play an instrument, and then using AI to make you sound better. Why bother to learn at all then??

I get I may be very much in the minority here, but I still hate it.

hn_throwaway_99··on Automattic has a new board after failed attempt to put CEO on leave
Can you tell me where you see Matt has 84% voting control?

I thought the reporting on this (at least in TechCrunch) was downright bizarre. The only thing that ever mattered was who had voting control, and I couldn't see anywhere that this was reported in TechCrunch. I can't even fathom how the other board members thought they could oust Matt if he had majority control. None of this makes any sense to me.

Edit: I see the 84% number further down in the article. Still, that makes this make even less sense to me. How could the other board members vote out Matt as CEO with only a minority vote?

hn_throwaway_99··on Chinese authorities reportedly in possession of F-35 components in Hong Kong
Not gonna lie, kinda surprised that shipping top secret military parts sounds like folks go to a Mailbox Express drop to get a UPS tracking number.
hn_throwaway_99··on Where's the Beef?: The lab-grown-meat revolution that wasn't
There is some confusion I think in what this article is about. It's specifically about lab grown animal cells, which was always crazy expensive and never produced a good tasting meat due to the lack of integrated fat.

That is very different from stuff like Beyond and Impossible Burgers which aim to mimic the taste of meat with plant ingredients. If anything, lab grown meat cells were at a huge disadvantage to the Beyond/Impossible crew, who could make a better meat for cheaper and was more appealing to customers (if I'm going to forego an animal product, I'd rather have a plant version than a frankenmeat version).

But to your point, I really liked Impossible Burgers specifically because they were the only plant-based alternative that really satisfied a craving for meat. There were veggie burgers for years prior, and they were "its own thing", but I'd always feel hungry after eating one. I like Impossible Burgers because it satisfies all my hunger for meat but I'm not killing an animal in the process.

hn_throwaway_99··on Claude discovers a novel enzyme system with CRISPR-like repeats
Just going to post this. And I think it's safe to say that no, they didn't read it.
hn_throwaway_99··on People hooked on vapes try a new way to quit: cigarettes
That was hilarious but I hate how hard The Onion has to compete with reality now.
hn_throwaway_99··on Did OpenAI solve the wrong Navier-Stokes problem?
Totally agree. I wouldn't quite call it clickbait, but the article does this thing I find annoying where it puts the "sensationalist" framing at the beginning (the "loophole" quote you put), but then closer to the end fully admits that it wasn't really a loophole in any case:

> It did, however, unambiguously solve the problem according to the Clay Institute’s original formulation. The official problem statement, penned in 2000 by mathematician Charles Fefferman, offers an option called “C,” in which solutions are allowed to use an external force like OpenAI’s.

hn_throwaway_99··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
> I doubt those panels will ever harvest enough energy to offset the energy use to produce both the cells and supports.

While I agree those steel supports are large, that seems insanely wrong to me, but not an expert so curious if someone with more info could comment.

hn_throwaway_99··on Robin Williams' Daughter to Fans Creating AI Videos: 'Have Some Shame'
> you're free to downvote me if you disagree, because either way, in this case both up and down votes prove me right.

incants magical spell so that I'm always right!

Checkmate atheists, or something.

hn_throwaway_99··on Nobody pays for FOSS, we can force them to
Is there any well known, successful FOSS that isn't also free as in gratis?

I understand the distinction but have literally never encountered it in practice.

hn_throwaway_99··on Can you tell which images are AI-generated?
I thought that at first, but a comment below enlightened me. These types of games are a great way to get free training data.
hn_throwaway_99··on Can you tell which images are AI-generated?
There are tons of real stock photos with that type of mundane content.
hn_throwaway_99··on How Hacker News ranking works: scoring, controversy, and penalties (2013)
More powerful bots and more incentives to game the system.
hn_throwaway_99··on How Hacker News ranking works: scoring, controversy, and penalties (2013)
It's not just "lots of comments" though. It's more comments than upvotes. You may disagree, and it may not be a perfect metric, but in reality I think it's works very well. 90+% of the time when I look at a post with tons of comments and a relatively small number of upvotes, it's flamewar central.
hn_throwaway_99··on AI safety is mostly a sex cult
The other thing that annoys me is that there are plenty of folks in the AI safety space who do not think very highly (at least now) of Yudkowsky. One of the comments I saw recently on a Substack article talked about how Yudkowsky has "beclowned" himself by not updating some of his earlier theories given how LLMs function.

So it's pretty annoying that this article is trying to paint everyone who cares about AI safety is in a "sex cult". There are lots of folks who are genuinely concerned about risks. If anything I discounted a lot of the AI safety folks because I thought they were not seeing the underlying limitations in LLMs. That may still be the case, but agents keep breaking through what I thought were limits on their behavior.

If anything, I don't understand at all the folks who think ASI is on the horizon (< 10 years) but think everything will be hunky dory and easy to control once we actually do build superintelligence.

hn_throwaway_99··on Microsoft exec called AI scraping 'the largest theft of labor in human history'
> How do people not understand that some laws only make sense at a certain scale?

100% agree, and the problem is that technology moves a lot faster than law can keep up. Just look at the Flock brouhaha. Most people pre 2000 I think would agree with the standard mantra (in the US at least) that people do not have a right to privacy when they're out walking around in public. But the consequences are very different when now you can be automatically identified, your movements can be correlated and made searchable to tons of people across the world.

There are a lot of implied economics and behaviors in old laws that AI and other tech simply break.

hn_throwaway_99··on Y Combinator's PAC is throwing money at Republicans across the country
While I agree, I still think it sucks that we are essentially now in a "pay-to-play" political environment. Any rich person who may be highly affected by government regulations (which is basically all of them) now is expected to donate a huge chunk of money if they even want to be listened to. This is why most of the money is going to incumbents (i.e. the people most likely to actually be in office in Jan). I'm not saying there haven't always been aspects of this but Citizens United really let this money explode exponentially. I really hope we can get a constitutional amendment overturning Citizens United once we return to sanity.

Also, the rationale behind CU looks woefully stupid and weak now. I honestly believe it is the Dred Scott of our day. The USSC has always interpreted "free speech" with an eye to potential unfair harms (i.e. yelling fire in a crowded theater and all that), and the idea that rich people should be allowed to donate unlimited amounts of money to their preferred candidates certainly hits that level IMO.

hn_throwaway_99··on Two parallel neural ectoderm progenitors contribute to the developing brain
Uh, no.

The premise (and this is how the GP comment put it) was that humans around Homer's time had fundamentally different brain structures, and that differences in poetry and thinking processes could be explained by looking at how brains changed over the last few thousand years.

That's not "overzealous comment section policing". It's rejecting a premise that is completely infeasible with everything we know about human evolution (or relative lack thereof) during that timespan.

hn_throwaway_99··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
Yeah, I agree that the "Blue Zone" theory is mostly explained by bad record keeping. Okinawa is one of the poorest areas of Japan, but was deemed a Blue Zone, despite that wealth is nearly always positively correlated with longevity within similar cultures. Low and behold Okinawa had shitty record keeping and tons of incentives for relatives to commit pension fraud.
hn_throwaway_99··on Sex, AI, and the Apocalypse
Ironically, I think "normal" people are more concerned about P(utopia) OR P(doom) than any folks in the groupthink bubble you are referring to.

That is, I hear lots of techies talk about us living in an "age of boundless abundance" if we can just manage to not kill ourselves (e.g. Thiel seems to consider anyone worried about the pace of technological process as the antichrist). Normal people are extremely concerned that this abundance will be hoarded and leave most of them without a job (and they generally like having money to eat stuff and live in a house/apartment). And who can blame them, we basically live in an age of abundance now but one that has resulted in extreme wealth inequality where some are living another gilded age and others are watching their towns decay. The techies always seem to handwave that we'll just have UBI or whatever without putting forth a plausible scenario as to how we'll wrest power from our future trillionaire overlords.

When someone threw a Molotov cocktail at Altman's house, I remember seeing a post online that tons of people were cheering on this act of violence, and there was a post by an SF techie saying she was floored people were willing to put their face to comments supporting this vigilantism. The top response to that was "If you don't realize that everyone outside SF hates your fucking guts, you don't get out enough."

I hope it can go without saying that I don't support this violence, but if folks think it's only "SF group thinkers" who are deeply angry about the current and future impacts of AI on society, you're frankly clueless.

hn_throwaway_99··on Economic policy for AGI
BS. While I agree the cutoffs are arbitrary, marking a cohort by, say, "people who graduated highschool before the advent of smart phones" or "people who went through childhood in the early years of social media" are valid groupings.

As a Gen Xer my childhood was soooo different from what kids today experience. And literally every single Gen Xer I know is glad and feels relief (sometimes mixed in with remorse) that our childhood was before the consumer Internet took off.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →