HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hnbad

3,172 karma · joined March 31, 2021

Isn't this ironic.

(he/they)

submissionscomments
hnbad··on Dark web agent spotted bedroom wall clue to rescue girl from abuse
The tell-tale phrase of a soon-to-be victim in a relationship with an abuser is "he's not like that when we're alone", not "I can fix him".

There's a difference between confidence and dominance. It's difficult to grasp given how much our culture tends to conflate them as desirable traits in men but the main distinction is that one is about resilience and the other is about abuse.

Confidence is attractive. Unless you're deeply insecure (and abusers often are insecure even if they try to mask it in displays of dominance) you're likely attracted to confidence in potential partners - yes, even as a straight guy. Just like an insecure person can use dominance to mask their insecurity, a confident person can also act submissively. This isn't just true in BDSM, it's actually a social dynamic many people engage in completely naturally.

An abuser (or I guess the pop-psych term is usually "narcissist" but let's not open the can of worms on whether that is ever applied "correctly") will often seek out a confident partner they can manipulate into a position of vulnerability they can take advantage of to control them.

The problem with power is that it is nearly inseparable from abuse. Abuse will inevitable arise from any power imbalance because the mere circumstance of being in a position of power can easily lead to absuses of power unless you're extremely diligent about your use of it. A healthy social dynamic always requires a balance of power - even if there may be a local imbalance in any one-on-one dynamic it can be offset by the wider network if it is stable and strong enough. If you look at powerful men in modern society almost none of them are actually confident. The few who are tend to paradoxically stand out for their humility and deference (i.e. taking credit for their losses and sharing credit for their accomplishments). But this is of course much more difficult than starting out from a position of power and fearfully lashing out at any potential rival.

hnbad··on Dark web agent spotted bedroom wall clue to rescue girl from abuse
Sure, and so is Stockholm Syndrome - except in that case we know the concept was made up by a criminologist working with the local police to help them come up with a psychological explanation for why the hostages stopped trusting them after they had horribly mishandled the hostage crisis and endangered their lives.

Note that most "well-known" examples of "hybristophilia" are parasocial or only exist as distance relationships, especially when the subject of attraction is incarcerated. Being incarcerated literally limits the potential for abuse and especially violent abuse which further contributes to an illusion of safety and control which the abuser can take advantage of by engaging in psychological manipulation tactics like lovebombing.

You don't have to subscribe to pseudoscientific explanations like evopsych or some inherent trait in women making them naturally predisposed to seeking out people who harm them in order to figure out what can cause these phenomena. In fact, I find just-so "explanations" (like you seem to imply by pointing at a term like this as if it in itself holds explanatory power) extremely unsatisfying because they're little more than thought-terminating clichés.

It's also worth pointing out the term was coined by the guy who is best known for promoting chemical castration (which aside from having motivated Alan Turing to take his own life is still a contested issue in the scientific community due to studies showing serious side-effects and the efficacy being questionable as it may heavily suffer from selection bias) and the one time he forced sexual reassignment surgery on a male infant (David Reimer) after a botched circumcision. Reimer later "detransitioned" upon learning of what had been done to him. Incidentally Reimer also accused him of having forced him - when Reimer was a child - to engage in pretend sexual activity with his brother and to watch pornography. Oh, and the guy also considered relationships between children and full adults morally defensible in principle, while also dismissing critics as "right-wing" despite much of the criticism coming from intersex and transgender people.

hnbad··on "Token anxiety", a slot machine by any other name
> The current trend in all major providers seem to be: get you to spin up as many agents as possible so that you can get billed more and their number of requests goes up.

I was surprised when I saw that Cursor added a feature to set the number of agents for a given prompt. I figured it might be a performance thing - fan out complex tasks across multiple agents that can work on the problem in parallel and get a combined solution. I was extremely disappointed when I realized it's just "repeat the same prompt to N separate agents, let each one take a shot and then pick a winner". Especially when some tasks can run for several minutes, rapidly burning through millions of tokens per agent.

At that point it's just rolling dice. If an agent goes so far off-script that its result is trash, I would expect that to mean I need to rework the instructions and context I gave it, not that I should try the same thing again and hope that entropy fixes it. But editing your prompt offline doesn't burn tokens, so it's not what makes them money.

hnbad··on Evaluating AGENTS.md: are they helpful for coding agents?
I recall that early LLMs had the problem of not understanding the word "not", which became especially evident and problematic when tasked with summarizing text because the summary would then sometimes directly contradict the original text.

It seems that that problem hasn't really been "fixed", it's just been paved over. But I guess that's the ugly truth most people tend to forget/deny about LLMs: you can't "fix" them because there's not a line of code you can point to that causes a "bug", you can only retrain them and hope the problem goes away. In LLMs, every bug is a "heisenbug" (or should that be "murphybug", as in Murphy's Law?).

hnbad··on Evaluating AGENTS.md: are they helpful for coding agents?
LLMs are basically improv theater. If the agent starts out with a wildly wrong assumption it will try to stick to it and adapt it rather than starting over. It can only do "yes and", never "actually nevermind, let me try something else".

I once had an agent come up with what seemed like a pointlessly convoluted solution as it tried to fit its initial approach (likely sourced from framework documentation overemphasizing the importance of doing it "the <framework> way" when possible) to a problem for which it to me didn't really seem like a good fit. It kept reassuring me that this was the way to go and my concerns were invalid.

When I described the solution and the original problem to another agent running the same model, it would instantly dismiss it and point out the same concerns I had raised - and it would insist on those being deal breakers the same way the other agent had dimissed them as invalid.

In the past I've often found LLMs to be extremely opinionated while also flipping their positions on a dime once met with any doubt or resistance. It feels like I'm now seeing the opposite: the LLM just running with whatever it picked up first from the initial prompt and then being extremely stubborn and insisting on rationalizing its choice no matter how much time it wastes trying to make it work. It's sometimes better to start a conversation over than to try and steer it in the right direction at that point.

hnbad··on TikTok's 'addictive design' found to be illegal in Europe
Let me rephrase your question: "But if it's illegal for TikTok to do this, shouldn't Meta also be sued over it?"

The answer is "Yes".

hnbad··on Listen to Understand
> Humans are wired to be egocentric. When we hear something related to a past experience, it triggers memories and associations — which we then want to talk about. Shifting the attention from her to me. This is my default state when I'm not focused. I'm not really listening. I'm just waiting for my turn to speak.

On a completely unrelated note, many autistic people express compassion by sharing similar experiences to communicate "I understand how you feel because I can relate to your experience".

I guess the author is a good example for why this tends to upset people (and especially allistic/non-autistic people).

On an also completely unrelated note, the example phrases/questions the author gives at the end read like having a conversation with ELIZA.

hnbad··on Dead Internet Theory
I think most people only recall becoming aware of Facebook when it was already so widespread that people talked about it as "the site you go to to find out what extended family members and people you haven't spoken to in years are up to".

Let's remember that the original idea was to connect with people in your college/university. I faintly recall this time period because I tried to sign up for it only to find out that while there had been an announcement that it was opened up internationally, it still only let you sign up with a dot EDU email address, which none of the universities in my country had.

In the early years "social media" was a lot more about having a place to express yourself or share your ideas and opinions so other people you know could check up on them. Many remember the GIF anarchy and crimes against HTML of Geocities but that aesthetic also carried over to MySpace while sites like Live Journal or Tumblr more heavily emphasized prose. This was all also in the context of a more open "blogosphere" where (mostly) tech nerds would run their own blogs and connect intentionally much like "webrings" did in the earlier days for private homepages and such before search engine indexing mostly obliterated their main use.

Facebook pretty much created modern "social media" by creating the global "timeline", forcing users to compete with each other (and corporate brands) for each other's attention while also focusing the experience more on consumption and "reaction" than creation and self-expression. This in turn resulted in more "engagement" which eventually led to algorithmic timelines trying to optimize for engagement and ad placement / "suggested content".

HN actually follows the "link aggregator" or "news aggregator" lineage of sites like Reddit, Digg, Fark, etc (there were also "bookmark aggregators" like stumbleupon but most of those died out to). In terms of social interactions it's more like e.g. the Slashdot comment section even though the "feed" is somewhat "engagement driven" like on social media sites. But as you said, it lacks all the features that would normally be expected like the ability to "curate" your timeline (or in fact, having a personalized view of the timeline at all) or being able to "follow" specific people. You can't even block people.

hnbad··on ‘ELITE’: The Palantir app ICE uses to find neighborhoods to raid
Of course it's Palantir.
hnbad··on Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups
Being an asshole is incentivized by the system. If you don't want companies to behave like assholes, change the system to one that punishes that.
hnbad··on Stardew Valley developer made a $125k donation to the FOSS C# framework MonoGame
Not under capitalism, sure. But traditionally gift economies worked exactly because people understood that gifts also imbue a burden of responsibility. Not necessarily in repayment but to honor the gift and pay the good deed forward instead of simply enriching yourself.
hnbad··on There's no such thing as a fake feather [video]
Given the incredible number of chickens that are processed every single minute across the world, this shouldn't be surprising but it's easy to see why you might be surprised if you never considered where all the stuff that isn't meat goes.
hnbad··on Italian Competition Authority Fines Apple $115M for Abusing Dominant Position
You must believe that US companies are trying to enter and stay in hostile markets out of the sheer kindness of their hearts. Have you considered that not being present in the second biggest market by GDP may actually be a massive liability by creating a massive opportunity for competitors that will be far better adapted to stricter regulatory conditions? You could just as well advise US car manufacturers to stick to building cars like the Cybertruck and ignore markets that consider it unsafe.
hnbad··on Italian Competition Authority Fines Apple $115M for Abusing Dominant Position
The US is in the middle of a recession if you exclude the AI bubble. Even if you include the AI bubble it's barely avoiding stagflation. I'm not sure "growth and innovation" accurately serves as a contrast between the US and EU tech companies right now.
hnbad··on Italian Competition Authority Fines Apple $115M for Abusing Dominant Position
> They want the data just as bad as everybody else.

Sure. Let's look at the main site: https://european-union.europa.eu/index_en

Big cookie banner. Wait. What's that. It's not a modal? And a big "Accept only essential cookies" button with the same visual weight as the "Accept all cookies" button? Surely everybody does it this way because it's literally what EU law requires - surely nobody would try to trick people into clicking "accept all" by hiding the alternative behind multiple layers of opaque options and checkboxes.

So let's look at what data they are harvesting: https://european-union.europa.eu/cookies_en

Technical cookies... functional cookies... boring - most of these are just for handling logins and preferences. Ooh, analytics! But what's Europa Analytics? Let's check: https://european-union.europa.eu/europa-analytics_en

Oh, they are not only opt-in, they even respect DNT headers. And they're masking the IP addresses before processing them further. Damn, they must really want that data just as bad as "everybody else".

hnbad··on 8M users' AI conversations sold for profit by "privacy" extensions
They say they remove information from the collected data. They aren't very explicit about what information they remove or not. They also seem to be feeding the data they collect right into the affiliated data broker company.

There are two different markets for this kind of complex data:

- Aggregate (demographic) data is useful for targeting, not just regular ads but also in-person outreach or even just identifying areas with a high density of potential customers; you can also use these insights to then categorize people in your own data set (e.g. when onboarding a new user you might cross-reference their details and find out they're high value just based on the "non-personal" data from the data broker that matches their profile).

- Specific (personal) data is useful for companies like insurances to flag you for risks you wouldn't otherwise have to disclose or they might not be able to request disclosure of; because direct transfer of personal data is the most likely kind to run into privacy law issues this is now often obfuscated by feeding it into AI models (i.e. the AI learns to match the collected data at the data broker to the input data it receives from the data broker's customer but there is never an explicit connection between the two data sets so the data broker can claim it is anonymized/aggregated when in practice it's still granular enough for the AI model to be able to categorize you based on seemingly spurious associations).

Note that the fist case overlaps with the second because "aggregate" usually still means that when looking at a new dataset (i.e. data collected from one person) you can say with some confidence which pile of aggregated data it fits in even if that pile doesn't contain an exact match due to anonymization/pseudonymization. Also note that this means there isn't really any feasible way to "aggregate" data in such a way it can no longer be argued to be subject to the data subject rights of the GDPR unless the data is fully isolated (e.g. total number of monthly visitors of an entire website by year).

hnbad··on 8M users' AI conversations sold for profit by "privacy" extensions
It would have been no less suprising to me had it been a US company but it certainly fits the cultural stereotype of callousness that particular country has been openly displaying in recent years.
hnbad··on 8M users' AI conversations sold for profit by "privacy" extensions
This might be a case of app permissions just being poorly delineated. E.g. I've seen Android apps require "location data" access just because they want to connect over bluetooth or manage WiFi or something (not entirely sure which one it was specifically) because that is actually the same permission and the wording in the permission modal is misleading.
hnbad··on 8M users' AI conversations sold for profit by "privacy" extensions
A big problem is also that you can pretty much only grant permission for one specific site or all sites and this very much depends on which of those two options the extension uses.

For example there's no need for the "inject custom JS or CSS into websites" extensions to need permission to read and write data on every single website you visit. If you only want to use them to make a few specific sites more accessible to you that doesn't mean you're okay with them touching your online banking. Especially when most of these already let you define specific URLs or patterns each rule/script should apply to.

I understand that there are still vectors for data exfiltration when the same extension has permissions on two different sites and that "code injection as a service" is inherently risky (although cross-origin policies can already lock this down somewhat) but in 2025 I'd hope we could have a more granular permission model for browser extensions that actually supports sandboxing.

hnbad··on 8M users' AI conversations sold for profit by "privacy" extensions
Israel is the new Russia, I guess.
hnbad··on 8M users' AI conversations sold for profit by "privacy" extensions
Note that this is a pretty blatant GDPR violation and you should report this to the local data protection agency if you are a EU resident and care about this (especially if you've used this extension). Their privacy policy claims the data collection is consent-based and that the app settings also let you revoke this consent. According to the article, the latter isn't the case and the user is never informed of the extent of the collection and the risk of sensitive or specially protected personal information (e.g. sexual orientation) being part of the data they're collecting. Their privacy policy states the collected data is filtered to remove this kind of information but that's irrelevant because processing necessarily happens after collection and the GDPR already applies at the start of that pipeline.

If Urban VPN is indeed closely affiliated with the data broker, a GDPR fine might also affect that company too given how these fines work. There is a high bar for the kind of misconduct that would result in a fine but it seems plausible that they're being knowingly and deliberately deceptive and engaging in widespread data collection that is intentionally invasive and covert. That would be a textbook example for the kind of behavior the GDPR is meant to target with fines.

The same likely applies to the other extensions mentioned in the article. Yes, "if the product is free, you are the product" but that is exactly why the GDPR exists. The problem isn't that they're harvesting user data but that they're being intentionally deceptive and misleading in their statements about this, claim they are using consent as the legal basis without having obtained it[0], and they're explicitly contradicting themselves in their claims ("we're not collecting sensitive information that would need special consideration but if we do we make sure to find it and remove it before sharing your information but don't worry because it's mostly used in aggregate except when it isn't"). Just because you except some bruising when picking up martial arts as a hobby doesn't mean your sparring partner gets to pummel your face in when you're already knocked out.

[0]: Because "consent" seems to be a hard concept for some people to grasp: it's literally analogous to what you'd want to establish before having sex with someone (though to be fair: the laws are much more lenient about unclear consent for sex because it's less reasonable to expect it to be documented with a paper trail like you can easily do for software). I'll try to keep it SFW but my place of work is not your place of work so think carefully if you want to copy this into your next Powerpoint presentation.

Does your prospective sexual partner have any reason to strongly believe that they can't refuse your advances because doing so would limit their access to something else (e.g. you took them on a date in your car and they can't afford a taxi/uber and public transport isn't available so they rely on you to get back home, aka "the implication")? Then they can't give you voluntary consent because you're (intentionally or not) pressuring them into it. The same goes if you make it much harder for them to refuse than to agree (I can't think of a sex analogy for this because this seems obvious in direct human interactions but somehow some people still think hiding "reject all non-essential" is an option you are allowed to hide between two more steps when the "accept all" button is right there even if the law explicitly prohibits these shenanigans).

Is your prospective sexual partner underage or do they appear extremely naive (e.g. you suspect they've never had any sex ed and don't know what having sex might entail or the risks involved like pregnancy, STIs or, depending on the acts, potential injuries)? Then they probably can't give you informed consent because they don't fully understand what they're consenting to. For data processing this would be failure to disclose the nature of the collection/processing/storage that's about to happen. And no, throwing the entire 100 page privacy policy at them with a consent dialog at the start hardly counts the same way throwing a biology textbook at a minor doesn't make them able to consent.

Is your prospective sexual partner giving you mixed signals but seems to be generally okay with the idea of "taking things further"? Then you're still missing specific consent and better take things one step at a time checking in on them if they're still comfortable with the direction you're taking things before you decide to raw dog their butt (even if they might turn out to be into that). Or in software terms, it's probably better to limit the things you seek consent for to what's currently happening for the user (e.g. a checkbox on a contact form that informs them what you actually intend to do with that data specifically) rather than try to get it all in one big consent modal at the start - this also comes with the advantage that you can directly demonstrate when and how the specific consent relevant to that data was obtained when later having to justify how that data was used in case something goes wrong.

Is your now-active sexual partner in a position where they can no longer tell you to stop (e.g. because they're tied up and ball-gagged)? Then the consent you did obtain isn't revokable (and thus again invalid) because they need to be able to opt out (this is what "safe words" are for and why your dentist tells you to raise your hand where they can see it if you need them to stop during a procedure - given that it's hard to talk with someone's hands in your mouth). In software this means withdrawing consent (or "opting out") should be as easy as it was to give it in the first place - an easy solution is having a "privacy settings" screen easily accessible in the same place as the privacy policy and other mandatory information that at the very least covers everything you stuffed in that consent dialog I told you not to use, as well as anything you tucked away in other forms downstream. This also gives you a nice place to link to at every opportunity to keep your user at ease and relaxed to make the journey more enjoyable for both of you.

hnbad··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
It's funny that the President of the United States literally stated that the European Union's raison d'etre is inherently hostile to the US - pretty much as close as you can get to calling us an enemy - and yet EU politicians still desperately cling to holding the doors open for US corporations which continue flaunting our laws and are inherently incapable of abiding by them because of the US's publicly stated and demonstrated intent to commit warrantless surveillance under the use of gag orders.

Given how much Russian political influence tanked after the economic ties were forcibly severed (or at least had to become more discreet and indirect as in the case of Russian gas imports - though those will allegedly further decrease in the near future) it seems reasonable to assume that a lot of these weirdly pro-US anti-EU stances held by European politicians are linked to the economic ties to the US. But of course I'd never dare to accuse any EU politicians of taking bribes - us Westerners have far more sophisticated methods of giving politicians money to do what benefits us than the profane bribery of Russian cops being handed money to look the other way.

hnbad··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
> What matters is can your decisions be defended in front of a judge. I am not qualified to figure that out, and unless you're a lawyer, neither are you.

It's not a lawyer's job to answer that question because the answer is necessarily "yes" unless you intentionally did the illegal thing (i.e. intentionally did what the law explicitly tells you not to do) - and even then you might be able to defend it somehow.

The question is whether you have a good enough case for a ruling in your favor. And again, lawyers can't answer that because the question is always "it depends" - they're not in the business of fortune telling.

If you ask a lawyer for legal advice, it's their job to give you sufficiently good and accurate enough advice that if you tried to sue them over giving you bad or inaccurate advice they'd have a good enough chance of winning that lawsuit. How much they're willing to speculate about things like what's good enough for you and how high they'll set the bar depends on a variety of factors again.

There's literally no guarantee you can successfully defend something in front of a judge. The law is the law and the facts are the facts. If you end up in court, it helps if you have solid paperwork and a solid papertrail you can use to demonstrate you did everything correctly and in good faith - this is about creating facts that can be used to your advantage.

But the amount of expense required to do literally everything perfectly to the letter of the law and reliably document that you did so would make running a profitable operation impossible regardless of what laws we're talking about, so you necessarily have to strike a balance. And where you strike that balance is a business decision because it's about managing the risk of doing business. And that's not something your lawyer can decide for you - that's something you have to decide for yourself if you run the business. Because at the end of the day it's about your personal liability - whether through financial risk if your business is held liable or direct liability if you get personally held liable for your actions.

But this is not legal advice, I'm not a lawyer. I just know enough about (EU privacy and general German) law to be dangerous and accidentally trick actual lawyers into thinking I have a law degree.

By the way, that's also where that line comes from: it's saying "you can't hold me liable for decisions you make based on what I told you" - even when what a lawyer says is perfectly reasonable and sound to them they'll likely tell you it's "not legal advice" unless you are willing to pay the price tag of being able to hold them liable for what they said.

hnbad··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
DNT headers are not by themselves legally binding. However they can rightfully be considered an indication of a user's preferences (kind like how the OS language settings can be an indication of what language a user wants a website to use).

What most people miss about the GDPR is that most of it (as well as the ePrivacy Directive covering more technical aspects like cookies) really only exists because of the one big thing at its core most people are either not aware of or intentionally omitting:

The GDPR establishes a user's right to ownership and control of their personally identifiable information as an inalienable and irrevocable fundamental human right. This is what makes all the rest of it necessary: it's not about "cookie banners", it's about requiring others to obtain consent for what they want to do with that information; it's not about writing "privacy policies", it's about explaining what you do with that information and how you guarantee their rights are respected by you and disclosing who you're passing it on to and how you're ensuring they too respect those rights.

The alternative to consent dialogs (whether as "pop-ups" or via confirmations when prompting for relevant information) would be requiring every website to have a written contract with each user. Consent is only valid if it is demonstrably informed (and non-coerced but that's a different story) and it must be specific and revocable. You can't have users blanket opt-in to everything you'd like - they wouldn't even know what consent they'd need to withdraw later if they reconsider.

By the way, courts recently seem to have started ruling that the way many AIs work the companies training them are in violation of copyright laws by using intellectual property as training data without permission and in order for contracts to be legally binding, anything given by one party has to be given consideration by the other (i.e. anything of value given by one party has to be balanced out with something of value given by the other party) - so I wouldn't be too quick to ridicule the idea that using Facebook means Facebook can do with your data whatever its terms of service say they can do, even if posting on Facebook can probably not be considered an effective way of informing Meta about your disagreement.

hnbad··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
I'm sorry but the word is "consent" not "intent" and that's literally how consent works.

If I (a complete stranger to you) walk up to you and kiss you on the lips, it doesn't make a difference whether you're wearing a t-shirt informing everyone you don't want strangers to kiss you on the lips or not - I don't have any basis on which I can presume to have obtained your consent so I'd still be violating your rights.

This is very much a "tech bros don't understand consent" case: if you do something without consent, you better have a damn good reason other than "but it's good for meeee" (or "good for my bottom line"). "My business model depends on it" also isn't a good justification - there are plenty of business models that depend on things that are unquestionably illegal, we just refer to them as "criminal enterprises" rather than "disruptive startups".

hnbad··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
This sounds interesting and all but I'd like a more technically informed source than The Verge to judge whether the headline is accurate:

> One change that’s likely to please almost everyone is a reduction in Europe’s ubiquitous cookie banners and pop-ups. Under the new proposal, some “non-risk” cookies won’t trigger pop-ups at all, and users would be able to control others from central browser controls that apply to websites broadly.

That's nonsensical. The GDPR doesn't require "cookie banners and pop-ups". Obtaining consent for things you can't do without consent does - if you insist on handling it that way. And "'non-risk' cookies", i.e. technical cookies required to fulfil the functionality requested by the user (e.g. maintain a login session) definitionally don't require consent and thus no "pop-up" or "banner". So what is the actual change here?

hnbad··on Interactive World History Atlas Since 3000 BC
That wouldn't be the foundation of Facebook, that would be Facebook introducing the algorithmic timeline. Remember that Facebook explicitly considered it a success because it increased "engagement" while the vast majority of its users reacted negatively to it and when commenting on it indicated that it made them feel worse, that it negatively transformed the kind of social interactions they had on the platform and that it was detrimental to their mental health (because previously Facebook had been centered on 1-to-1 and many-to-1 interactions between peers and now was about 1-to-many interactions with an audience - something I guess Google tried to mitigate in its own social media experiment somewhat unsuccessfully by letting you group your "friends" into "circles").

The revolutionary change that made Facebook uniquely successful wasn't being a social media platform, it was forcing its users (who were so far treating it as a way to keep in touch with acquaintances, old friends and distant family) to compete for each other's attention and offering corporations the opportunity to join that competition - all the while retaining the messaging that the platform is about "social" interactions between peers. And of course mining the everliving #### out of their users' data while non-consensually tracking them across the entire web without their knowledge.

But the "attention is the currency in the marketplace of ideas" concept they launched pretty much defined all "social media" companies from that point on, which is why we nowadays often forget the term used to be much more appropriate in the past (although often constrained to a crowd of very technical nerds).

Oh, and of course they very successfully killed much of the tradition of the Open Web by encouraging a walled garden approach even when it required them to actively defraud their advertisers by lying about the performance of video content. But I think the trophy for launching that extinction event belongs to Apple when they pivoted away from the original web-first concept for the iPhone to the proprietary App Store.

hnbad··on Uncle Sam wants to scan your iris and collect your DNA, citizen or not
Sure but that's somewhat tautological and not very helpful if you seek an empirical or predictive understanding of it. The question really is what complexity of the system (meaning: all of it) is irreducible and what can at least be approximated with simplified models.

You may balk at this as being ultimately futile but our entire existence is built on trying to break apart and simplify the world we exist in, starting with the first cut between self/inside and other/outside (i.e. "this is me" vs "this is where I am" - a distinction that becomes immensely relevant after the moment of birth). Language itself only functions because we can create categories it can operate on - regardless of whether those categories consistenly map to reality itself.

hnbad··on Uncle Sam wants to scan your iris and collect your DNA, citizen or not
You don't leave iris prints everywhere you go. Even most fingerprints you leave are unusable for identification. Contrary to what CSI may have taught most Americans, even usable DNA samples aren't a given.

Biometrics aren't "publicly available" let alone "easily obtainable". They're easy to extract from you but this is why extraction and retention of this kind of data should be considered extremely invasive and sensitive. That wallet in your pocket may be "publicly available and easily obtainable" but that doesn't mean we should treat it as such - rather we should make sure it's actually illegal to do so without your consent: that's why theft is a crime.

hnbad··on Uncle Sam wants to scan your iris and collect your DNA, citizen or not
Because the US has laughably weak privacy laws and most Americans snicker at the EU GDPR because of "cookie banners" (which btw isn't a thing - most consent dialogs are non-compliant as they shouldn't serve to just inform you but to actually obtain voluntary, revokable and specific informed consent) instead of thinking about what it means to actually have a fundamental human right to privacy and ownership of your own data or not.

They keep the samples for the same reason US tech startups keep deleted data and track seemingly useless behavior. Because they might find a use for it someday and there's literally no law preventing them from doing it.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →