Recently they had a database outage. After that they decided to archive unread items after 60 days. If you're like me and have a lot of feeds, this really doesn't work. I've decided I won't renew my subscription next year.
I was using the hosted Miniflux instance, until their database went out, and they decided that archiving unread items would be fun. Now I'm using what I've used for like the last 3-4 years now. simplerssreader.com
Maybe they forgot RSs, or maybe not. I used to get Google alerts as feeds, until they stopped capturing most things. RSS alerts like Google alerts, when they used to work would be pretty cool.
Here's what Feedly could do better. It could strip down. When I look for an RSS reader, I don't look for something that looks like the front page of HN.
I do look for a simple list of feeds, with folders. That's it, nothing more. That's all I need. When I open a single feed, the articles display.
Of course having filtering is nice, but not necessary. There are plenty of services out there that will do that for me. I don't read feeds based on anyone's curation, including Feedly's. I read them based on whatever I'm interested in reading that day.
My thing with self hosting is that I'm using a shared plan. I currently have over 500 feeds, and I don't think they'd be all that happy about it if well... um... I decided to use RSS on their servers.
I have an accessibility issue with The Old Reader, I contacted them about it and they never fixed it. In list view, there are no links to articles at all, if you're using a screen reader like I am. That makes me have to use the reader in expanded view. While I love the use of headings, it's one of the features on my wishlist for my absolute most epic RSS reader ever, (and it was a design feature of Google Reader,) I don't want to navigate passed the heading with the title, and 15 additional headings, because people seem to think that using headings is good for SEO.
Also, limiting the amount of feeds is a big nono in my book!! IF they didn't do that, and charged $10 monthly, I'd pay.
Google reader used to do the recommendations thing. I loved that!! Also not having to scroll through everything at once is the beauty of the feeds list format. In other words, you have a list of feeds, that should be the only thing on the page. When you open a single feed, the content is displayed.
I won't use a reader that doesn't do things that way. They might have articles on the bottom, after the list of feeds OK fine I guess. I never use that part of the page willingly. The problem is that too many feed readers are being developed to look like HN. No, that isn't how readers should be.
For me personally, I always click the link to read any articles I'm interested in. If there are comments, and I'm really interested in what you said, I'll probably post one.
Twitter got rid of RSS years ago, I use a service for that. I did the Tumblr thing for a while as well, and the hole reblogging thing was extremely annoying. It's a blogging platform, which is exactly how I used it.
Oh, I have to disagree, I think high volume sites are a great thing for RSS. In fact, I tend to think the more items in a feed, the better. No, I usually don't go through all of them at once, I'll go through several hundred at a time.
When I look for an RSS feed, it's usually to see if it's updating, not because of any accessibility concerns. A lot of times, I'll find broken feeds. However, if a site is really giving me trouble with navigation, I'll rely on the RSS feed for reading purposes.