HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

horsawlarway

11,569 karma · joined May 23, 2017

submissionscomments
horsawlarway··on Adult Film Producer Unmasks Prolific 'John DOE' Torrent Pirate as Meta Executive
They might be in the clear if they were solely downloading (might) but if he's also seeding then it's just copyright violations.
horsawlarway··on The largest electric aircraft just flew [video]
They discuss quite a bit of this in the video. I actually thought it was a decent walk through of why they're targeting the space they're targeting, and how they're thinking about exactly these problems.

Some items to consider from the video

1. short flights spend an large amount of energy simply having the engines running during taxi to/from the runway.

2. Take-off also consumes much more fuel than cruising.

3. 1 & 2 combine to push airlines to prefer larger & larger planes making longer trips when using fuel (it's how they're managing that 45.9 seat mile number - it get much worse for shorter trips).

4. They're already pushing the 400kwh/kg range for batteries (I believe he makes an offhand comment in the video that they're using 8 packs, with roughly the capacity/weight of 4 tesla battery packs - which would put their batteries in the ~4k lb range if we estimate by teslas pack weights. They are likely pushing to go lower than that. I think it's not crazy to consider they're targeting a production weight ~50% below your guess - in the high 3000s)

5. On top of fuel savings, one of his more compelling points is that maintenance on their engines will be much, much lower. Jet engines are expensive to service, maintain, and repair (thousands of parts, complicated designs, extreme operating conditions). Their motors are basically 450kg dc motors - it's a giant drone motor mounted on an airframe.

6. they seem to have quite a bit of interest from existing airlines (ex - united) so apparently this does seem compelling to them.

7. He quotes a $5 take-off cost in electrical power. Something like an Embraer ERJ-135 uses ~20 - 30 gallons of jet fuel for the same thing (~$100). If they target a plane that's doing very frequent takeoffs/landings, operating costs could be considerably lower, not just lower.

---

Personally - I don't know if they'll make it work, but it's definitely an interesting play, with more real thought put into it than most attempts I've seen.

horsawlarway··on Corporate America is getting hooked on open-source AI
You're not corporate America (and trust me, I mostly mean that as a plus).

I also work in software, and while I vaguely disagree that open models can't be used (they absolutely fit into productive niches here, and holy hell are the last generation [ex laguna s1, kimi k3, glm 5.3, etc] actually decent) - I will agree that SOTA are a better fit for software development, especially when used in conjunction with an already very expensive employee who's driving them.

But for "Corporate America"... no. You absolutely don't need SOTA. They're doing things like transcription, summarization, customer interaction, minor technical tasks like form creation in existing tools, report generation (ex - powerpoint, pdf, docs, etc) and other general "white collar tasks". Think about roles in business that are in the 60-85k compensation range.

It's mostly busy work that keeps existing processes flowing and the business on the rails. Important, but not research/novel.

And cheap ai... is a wonderful fit for a lot of this. No one wants to replace an employee making 80k with a less reliable AI that costs 45k a year in tokens (SOTA). But they're absolutely willing to drop 2-3k/year on AI (~100/month - right in the open model cost range) for that employee if they can get a 10% bump in productivity or happiness.

horsawlarway··on Whistleblower warns Postal Service mail ballot system has catastrophic problems
Literally, what the fuck are you talking about.

As in, please be more specific with your claims that we don't require identification to vote.

Because it strikes me as a very low effort Fox News talking point, not any reality.

Most states allow you to cast a provisional ballot on polling Day without an ID, but require that you return and present an ID to accept it.

But no state is accepting votes without identifying the voter. They just vary somewhat in what alternatives they accept.

Compare your statement to the info here and come back with something better: https://ballotpedia.org/Voter_identification_laws_by_state

I have never voted without being required to present gov issued ID. Ever.

horsawlarway··on Reasons robotics is hard
While I agree this is a technical path that makes sense, I'm not sure it's a financial path that does. Or at least not outside of very upscale, niche products for wealthy consumers or businesses.

Which doesn't mean I disagree with you. I also think that this progression is the most likely. But it implies we're decades away from broad adoption rates.

Think fifty years to hit mass adoption, not five. (Because that much more closely aligns with other structurally disruptive tech like automobiles or computers) Which is definitely not the story being pitched to investors at the moment.

horsawlarway··on The war with Iran will not be won through airstrikes, so what's left?
> I think Trump feels duped

This is an incredible spin on this whole fiasco.

I cannot emphasize enough how understated I am being when I say this: I expect our president to be capable of accurately assessing the consequences of military engagement with foreign nations, and if he is so easily "duped" he is unfit to continue in the position.

Perhaps he should be spending less time lining his own pockets with crypto scams, pump and dump schemes, insider trading, and paid access to his tweets. There was no shortage of advisors who could have warned him that this was an asinine plan.

horsawlarway··on Luanti removed from Google Play due to baseless AI copyright notice
I think this take holds up very poorly when the reality boils down to:

"Government policy and critical services have made it so there are functionally two markets for mobile software, each owned by the manufacturers and developers of the mobile OS and hardware"

This isn't like physical sales, where I can open up a store anywhere. This also isn't like classic software sales for windows/mac desktops, where I can sell you a program from any website or physical store.

---

Functionally - this is like these private companies revoking your business license at their whim. I don't find it a tenable position.

horsawlarway··on Judge rules Trump administration’s blacklisting of Anthropic was illegal
Yes - because the system is trying to prevent the flood by piling up sticks instead of removing the source of water.

It's in failure mode (intentionally, is my read) because while it might eventually declare "x is not legal" at no point is it discouraging the people who did X (and have now also done y, z, 1, 2, and 3 - all also likely illegal) because there is zero actual accountability at the personal level.

If your house is flooding from a broken pipe... you don't bail. You turn the water off.

horsawlarway··on AI Agent Has Root
This line also undercuts the whole fucking article too.

Because as it damn well says - this is POSIX working exactly as designed.

I don't know why he's in here playing this up as some unexpectedly crazy, scary, dramatic music style thing (I mean... I do, it's so he can try to sell you something after scaring you...).

He started the damn process. Of course it's running as his damn user.

It would be one thing to honestly evaluate that security model and its merits (of which there are many, despite the risks). It's another to play this up as some giant surprise.

---

Constant stream of junk articles in here like

"You know when you hit that nail with the hammer you were holding? Did you consider you could have hit something else in reach instead? It's like, that hammer was like, you, man! Isn't that cray-cray and super duper scary??!?!?!"

horsawlarway··on The Tariff Cost: analysis of the costs to Americans from new tariffs on Canada
I think it's a bit more complicated than you're implying here.

Yes - you are technically correct that each country is taxing its own citizens/businesses with tariffs. I also agree that phrasing is more honest than what the article states

But for interconnected supply chains, the result can get pretty muddled.

Ex -

Canada sells wood to a US company. US applies tariff.

That US company sells a component made of that wood back to a Canadian company. Canada applies tariff.

That Canadian company uses that component to produce a good that's sold to US consumers. US applies tariff.

etc...

For the end purchasers of the finished product - the net increase in price (the final "tax" you pay) might be a summation of various tariffs applied by both countries as they interact with each other.

The price increases at the final sale are additive, regardless of which country is capturing the tariff as tax. The real result is that the product is just more expensive to make when tariffs are in place, and so must be sold at a higher price based on the total tax applied to all parts of the product (regardless of where in the chain it was US/Canada/China/Other/Etc actually capturing a tariff).

Ex - you will pay more because of US tariffs, and more again because of Canadian tariffs in response to US tariffs.

horsawlarway··on Qwen3.8-Flash-Next
In a lot of spaces, this is actually preferable.

Ex - nodejs natively supports a huge set of typescript with built-in type stripping these days. But ask most hosted models to build a typescript project and they default to a heavy compile step, or a tool like tsx, ts-node, etc.

Models with lots of "world knowledge" have a good chunk of that knowledge go stale, and there's no real way to refresh it without training a new model.

Another classic example of this back in the day was to ask who the president of the US was, and watch different models happily give different answers based on the date they were trained.

---

Personally, I'm really interested to see if we're headed towards a spot where the model is entirely distinct from the knowledge store.

We're vaguely there with the ability for models to go search the web, but I think the reliability of that path is going to continue declining (more and more spam content, less and less genuine value).

I kinda want a paradigm where I can pick and engine and a knowledge bank, and combine them as I please.

Ex - if I'm doing gardening, I can pick "gardening for models (version 32)" as my knowledge store.

If I'm doing auto-repair... "cars for dummies (version 3)". etc...

horsawlarway··on Apple introduces M6 and M5 Ultra
shut your mouth - that brown was beautiful.
horsawlarway··on Walgit – a Git server that is one binary in front of an object store
I don't really see a problem.

Prior to this it would have been the millions of throw-away "hello world" intro projects, or "todo app" websites. Hell - think of how many people wrote "facebook clones" back in the day.

The author is likely still gaining some skills & experience - although they're more likely project management & ops style skills than technical coding skills (ex - what does interaction with this look like, what's the desired cli surface, how do I configure/deploy it, etc).

Intellectual property is pretty much always going to be a case where 99.999% of everything gets thrown away. Because the cost of duplication is zero, so the model trends very hard towards a "winner take all" popularity contest. A very small number of projects will see large success, everything else will likely be gone in a couple years.

---

If anything, I quite like this new space. I no longer have to worry about trying to make software "big enough" for other people to use. Previously, it would take a large enough investment that simply scratching my own itch was prohibitively expensive - so I had to be picky about what I would pick up and work on.

Now I can bang out all sorts of things designed just for me.

I needed a way to limit screen time for kids, and existing apps are both expensive and junk. Cool - local llms wrote me a new home app for my android tvs in an hour. It does exactly what I want, and nothing else.

I wanted to point my Home assistant audio satellites at unsloth studio instead of ollama. Cool - local ai in unsloth picked apart the ollama implementation and updated it to work with unsloth.

Wanted a new ph monitor for my hydroponics setup, with an auto-doser (some super cheap peristalitic pumps), awesome, an old arduino plus an llm and it runs just fine.

etc...

I love it. It's simple to get relatively effective results on a scale of 1, for a scale of 1. I don't have to worry about trying to get community help or onboard people, or pitch it as a product, etc... It's mine, it'll last as long as I want. It is trash? Sure - to you (seriously, it'd be hard to run, is explicitly designed for my stuff, has no docs, etc... I'm under no illusions that it's not garbage in the broader context). But it's treasure to me.

horsawlarway··on There's no such thing as a small software team anymore
Yeah, I think engineering orgs mostly jumped the shark.

Metrics like pr count and commits have always been terrible gauges for success compared to business performance.

But they're easy to measure, and even easier to game now with AI.

So we're seeing an outrageous gain on these metrics, and they've become almost completely divorced from business results.

No one cares how fast you ship prs. They care that you offer a compelling product, that works when they need it work, for a price they're able and willing to pay.

It's like we've decided to measure how far we've traveled in gallons of gas burned, but completely forgotten about measuring miles per gallon.

horsawlarway··on I like 'em thick: an apology to my English teachers
I think this is one of the more important points in this thread.

The problem is that too many pieces require experiences that the majority of the classroom just doesn't have.

It's not that students don't venture far enough into the cave to find the treasure, it's that the treasure literally isn't treasure to them yet.

The venturing that needs to happen for them to find the treasure isn't time spent in the material, it's time spent gaining life experiences.

Ex - there was nothing you could have done to make a book like "The Great Gatsby" good for me as a 15 year old. It's filled with themes that I had no experiences to connect with - no lost romances, no wealth (or even really a sense of wealth and money), no major life regrets, nothing at all to make this book hit. It's a dreary book about miserable, unlikable people when read from the perspective of a 15 year old student.

So why are we asking 15 year old students to read this book?

And that doesn't mean we can't throw students in over their heads every now and then (ex - exposure to the unfamiliar is fine). But if that's all you give them... they decide reading is pointless. You have to strike a middle ground with material that hits home.

And there's a range of teacher quality here as well - some are genuinely good at pushing students towards understanding the value in material, even if they lack experiences. But most aren't (at least in the US educational system I went through, which was a mix of decent public schools and expensive private schools)... they're passionate and well intentioned, but fail to empathize with the emotional maturity and world view of their young students.

horsawlarway··on Apple announces changes for apps in the European Union
And none of these are meaningfully different on high end laptops from other providers.

Apple had a window with M1 devices where I'd probably agree they were just better. Apple also has a history of making devices that are very expensive, and have a corresponding higher quality (ex - in the 2000s when most laptop manufacturers were racing to the bottom, and things like the Eee pc were considered hot - lots of garbage quality windows machines).

But many manufacturers today have entries in the "High quality, high price" category, and they're very similar.

Ex - https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/dell-laptops/new-xps-14-lapt...

The size is almost identical to an M5 laptop, the battery life is almost identical to an M5 laptop, the touchpad is almost identical to an M5 laptop (personally, I actually like the touchpad on the xps slightly more because the cutout on the front of macbooks is sharp, and I find it annoying and painful for long use, but I also have very large hands and I'm left handed).

And also - the price is functionally the same as the new M5 laptops.

All of those land in the +/- 10% range of each other. With just slight differences (ex - I can get a touchscreen on the XPS if I want, but it makes the battery life 15hrs instead of 18hrs on the macbook. The XPS is also fractionally lighter (3lbs vs 3.4lbs). The macbook is ~10% faster on single core benchmarks then the intel series 3, but identical to slightly worse on multicore. etc...)

Basically - unless you're actually using different machines here... stop it, you're talking out your ass (cough - fanboy - cough).

Even the framework... yes - it's clearly not as "good" as the $3600 macbook I have. I don't expect it to be given I paid ~$1500 for it. But it also excels in other areas that make it worth considering - I have 3 young kids, and I've had the screen pulled flat several times, the touchpad got a cup of milk dumped in it, and my oldest shoved a screwdriver into a usb-c port. Turns out new screen hinges were ~$19, the touchpad was ~$21, and the replacement port was $9. All done at home myself with simple tools.

Compared to several trips to a store and weeks without a laptop... that's a type of ergonomics that I prefer right now.

horsawlarway··on Apple announces changes for apps in the European Union
Apple makes nice hardware, but it's definitely not superior for everything, and the gap between other manufacturers isn't really there anymore on the upper end.

So sure - the Macbook is better than a cheap ~$500 laptop. But between my work issued Macbook and my nice Dell XPS? Not much difference. In either price or hardware...

Honestly, even between the macbook and my framework - not enough of a difference to really be that upset about (my biggest complaint is mostly just battery life).

---

Personally, I would argue that OS is a much bigger pain point to deal with, and you should probably factor that higher in the decision than the hardware. Just expect to spend roughly the same on the machine (Apple is still ~20% more)

horsawlarway··on Anthropic's War on open source AI
I've read most of this.

I find it be incredibly self-contradictory. I don't even think this aligns much with the actions of the company.

> Second, there is a good chance free information really does undermine authoritarianism, as long as the authoritarians can’t censor it [...] A superhumanly effective AI version of Popović (whose skills seem like they have high returns to intelligence) in everyone’s pocket, one that dictators are powerless to block or censor, could create a wind at the backs of dissidents and reformers across the world.

But hey - gotta turn Fable off and stop it from doing any security work! Dictators shouldn't be able to censor it, but we sure can, so better hope we're not the dictators.

Again, the I think the problem most folks have with Anthropic's attitude is that it conveniently positions Anthropic as the "arbiter" who gets to make the final value judgement.

They desperately want AI to be a genie they can keep firmly contained in their bottle (excuse me - data centers) and which only grants the wishes they want it to grant - for only a small fee, of course!

Which he clearly outlines as "a country of geniuses in a datacenter". He doesn't want those geniuses spread out. He wants the chains on the genie at all times.

Which flies pretty hard in the face of the rhetoric that they want to promote equality and democracy.

---

Basically, Anthropic's argument inherently leads to the conclusion that there is actually a dictator, and that dictator is Anthropic. You're not avoiding it, you're just praying it's benevolent.

All baked on top of the assumption that his "country of geniuses in a datacenter" premise is correct in the first place, which I find to be a fairly weak position.

The much more egalitarian position would mandate that we shoot for "a genius in every person's pocket" - one that runs on the hardware owned by that person, and not sold to them sip by sip from a datacenter. But that means they lose the control they desperately want.

horsawlarway··on On AI regulation and messaging
Yeah... Anthropic gives off big "I'm sorry, Dave. I'm afraid I can't do that" vibes.
horsawlarway··on Choosing an AI model: one prompt, 11 models, different results
Approaching this from the perspective of a potential customer and not a designer - I find that I actually like the smaller/open model output quite a bit more.

Kimi, GLM, and Deepseek all absolutely run away with the "Can I quickly read the menu and find the address" challenge.

Most of the rest of the pages are stylistic, but hard to parse.

If I were in a car on a mobile phone trying to find the address of the place to meet a friend for coffee... I don't want a bunch of fluff and stylistic design that makes it hard to parse the information on the site.

horsawlarway··on The web server deployment model breaks at hobby scale
Most of these problems are actually solved with containers, though.

An opinionated release of k8s (k3s, microk8s, etc) does wonders for making much of it just disappear.

You pay a slightly higher up front cost in complexity, in return for largely removing absolutely all the listed problems in this blog.

If you're going to run more than just one app... It's the route I'd recommend.

I think the market is already moving here, too. Synology is exposing very easy interfaces to run container workloads on their devices.

I think we're headed towards something like a combo NAS/router that handles storage and networking (by far the hardest parts of hosting).

horsawlarway··on The web server deployment model breaks at hobby scale
Nah he's entirely right. Serve http, let the user do https.

If you want to put caddy in front of yours? Great it works.

For me, running a much larger setup? Great, it also works.

For users who never expose it beyond an IP address on lan? Great it also works.

horsawlarway··on Crime Pays but Botany Doesn't
The above post fails to distinguish between unmaintained and native.

Native is great. I'm with you entirely.

Failure to maintain the space is not. That causes expensive and annoying problems.

horsawlarway··on The Gargantuan Lie That Is Collapsing the Climate
To face this directly: I think an honest answer is probably "yes".

Our buying habits empowered the type of company that wants to put AI into everything. Whether they continue to do so or not will also depend on our buying habits going forward.

horsawlarway··on Crime Pays but Botany Doesn't
I mean, I get it - I somewhat agree with your take, but this is somewhat of a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" case.

I think you undermine your argument when you don't understand the complaint. Because I'd also like to see a lot more native plants, and less manicured, mono-culture yards with poison sprayed all over them.

But at least in my area, the problem isn't "oh look a spider"... it's "oh shit, that house is collapsing because of termites", and "Oh shit, my neighbor's mom's house just burned down because rats chewed through the wiring in the walls", and "Fuck me! That's hogweed growing in that yard! Time to call the city".

Pests are a real concern - they cause lots of monetary damage, and can seriously injure or hurt people if not monitored. Does that mean we should nuke everything with chemicals and make a sterile hellscape? No - I don't think it does.

But it doesn't pay to be dismissive either.

horsawlarway··on I'm switching my phone from Android to Linux
I think it was one of those cases where "the road to hell was paved with good intentions".

I'm old enough and was very pro-android in the early days when it first released. I absolutely remember the frustrations around having vendors just REFUSE to update the OS on devices. Even things that were brand spanking new often got left to rot, and the OS updates in those days were genuinely meaningful software updates - Lots of new capabilities.

So I was actually ok with Google going down the route of moving critical software into an installable package that they controlled, that would provide a way to get new capabilities onto devices that manufacturers didn't give a shit about anymore.

---

But the problem is that "Google" today sure as hell isn't the google that I liked back then (and even that google was starting to shift tone).

And now this package is a backdoor that they can use like a beat-stick to force vendors to stay on their version of Android, and it functions to make "Android" (the distro that users actually use) functionally closed-source and non-permissive.

---

I still strongly believe that the appropriate regulation for this situation (across both iOS and Android) is that the company that makes the OS should be prohibited from running any sort of app store, and app stores must be selectable at device initialization (ex - the Internet Explorer ruling, but for app stores).

horsawlarway··on Antigravity 2.0
I'll take this bait.

First up - I completely agree that parts of the terminal experience are decidedly lackluster, you can make them "fine" but the general experience doesn't align with consistent OS principles users are familiar with, and I agree that good mouse support, expected copy and paste, selection behaviors, adding files/attachments to prompts, etc... all could be better (and actually are mostly better on decent modern terminals, as an aside)

But... And this is the big but... LLMs are basically text IO systems. And terminals are designed from the ground up to allow text IO to control the entire system, including the TUI (ex - multiplayer agent tmux is a fun demo).

It's a genuinely powerful pairing, and basically ALL of the non-TUI systems basically end up just embedding a terminal [cough* xterm *cough] and becoming a non-standard TUI themselves, anyways.

So TUIs have become a big deal because it's the obvious and easy way to give an LLM "computer use" skills, without spending a fortune on tokens doing graphical processing for GUIs, which are geared towards humans and not agents, and are generally less powerful anyways.

horsawlarway··on Online ad giant Adform was hacked, proving once again why ad blockers are needed
The internet is already a class based internet. Why do you think SO many services want you to login, or force you to their mobile apps? They are curating your experience to be as extractive as possible, and if you're not worth much money, they absolutely ditch you, or "pivot" away from that user base.

Attention doesn't matter, attention that generates revenue for corporations does. If you think there's some egalitarian process happening here... you're misunderstanding how the incentives in this system play out.

And no - I don't think the 90s internet is coming back. To be frank, I don't give a flying fuck about your mom and whether she can use mIRC or not (or my mother, for that matter). I care about my kids, and the experiences they'll have with technology.

I think dropping my children into this ad-riddled, dopamine hijacking, carefully crafted to be exploitative technological environment is just a damn irresponsible thing to be doing. And if that means ad-blockers as a side effect... great.

Then I'll vote to burn that damn thing down every chance that's presented. I don't think people should be served up addictive experiences through always present devices to sell them shit they don't need with funding from ads. Full fucking stop. What a fucking dystopia you present as some progressive space. Blech... It's only progressive in the sense that everyone gets the same gruel of meaningless, unfulfilling content.

horsawlarway··on Online ad giant Adform was hacked, proving once again why ad blockers are needed
Oh give it a rest.

You want to talk about killing a system... look at all the perverse incentives that pop up when companies are allowed to sell user attention instead of decent services and products.

If the modern social media internet dies because of ad-blockers... good damn riddance.

horsawlarway··on The AI bubble is popping; we just don't know it yet
Worth buying? Maybe.

Actually bought and distributed? No.

Again, hardware just doesn't roll out that fast, and you're talking about trying to distribute expensive hardware to a population with a 47k median yearly wage.

I've built robots. Even if the software expense is ~$0... you're not going to escape the fact that a robot that can do anything remotely similar to household work is just going to be expensive. Like, several thousand dollars in actuators and sensors alone, not counting any compute.

LLMs are a SaaS - Robots are delivered hardware. The graveyard is littered with software folks who thought they could deliver hardware like it was software.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →