HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hotdogscout

268 karma · joined July 7, 2023

I'm tall
submissionscomments
hotdogscout··on I now lack the juice to fuel the bluster to conceal that I am a simpleton
It's easy to be confused when you keep changing your definitions when they're not consistent!

"is that "white" isn't an ethnic group with an actual cultural or racial lineage".

"The reason this group is unique as an ethnicity w.r.t. recategorization is because the structure and violence of slavery isolated them from historic ethnicities and forcefully regrouped them under a new one."

Conflicting statements.

According to you white people don't have historic ethnicities but black people also don't because of slavery and that is why they deserve capitalization?

hotdogscout··on I now lack the juice to fuel the bluster to conceal that I am a simpleton
The shift in labels and categories applies to all ethnicities, not just whites, even in the US.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-drop_rule

All of the definitions are contested and subject to localities, not just whiteness.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/263722423_Not_black...

>is that "white" isn't an ethnic group with an actual cultural or racial lineage.

None of them are. There's more genetic diversity in sub Saharan Africa than in any other place on earth. People from Asia and people from Africa don't identify as black or asian as a consistent racial lineage.They're also a western ad hoc hodge podge just as much as whiteness is.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_people

None of your explanations single out white people as an especially fake identity inconsistent with asian or black.

hotdogscout··on I now lack the juice to fuel the bluster to conceal that I am a simpleton
Leftist activists circles have grievances with white people and this is a small token of revenge. Depersonifying white people. Asians don't get internally consistent treatment because of intersectionality.

Are we really pretending it's a coincidence all the time?

This naivety is rightfully never applied to right wing bigotry.

I'm not white myself but I'm genuinely confused as to why this kind of blatant ethnic antagonization is so normalized in western elites and extremely taboo to point out.

hotdogscout··on One man's artistic wonderland, created in rental, gets protected status
>When you say "move on" it seems like you don't think it's wonderful. When you say "deviant nature" it also sounds like you don't think it's wonderful.

This post was full of comments deriding the people appreciating the apartment, that's who I was speaking to with the "move on". Deviancy is how we have everything, every evolution came from deviancy, being different is ok.

>justice is bullshit, it's nobody's fault anyway but that doesn't mean I'm going to try to push back: I'm powerless and it would be futile but we need these things to prevent total chaos is that right?

Yes!

>But a definition of narcissism is: selfishness, involving a sense of entitlement, a lack of empathy, and a need for admiration, as characterizing a personality type -- you think that's good???

Yes!!! Collectivist "empathy" or slave morality has a lot of caveats that I don't like (revenge, envy, resentment). Like kindness, selfishness is also beautiful and defiant. Empathy is only supported as long as the social contract implies reciprocity, it is also selfish behaviour, let people be free of it as much as possible.

>The picture I get from your comments is: you're being raw, expressing directly out of a deep well of your being and experience in an unfiltered way, you've been really hurt and betrayed and have found your peace about it, in part by acceptance with thinking 'nobody has responsibility' anyway, and you don't feel you can do anything about it so you just have to accept it.

I don't think my comment expressed that. The justice/free-will was an example of how you can know truth (there is no free will) while also appreciating punishments. I can see art as a narcissistic expression while also appreciating narcissistic expressions.

Art is like religion, to those who believe in it it's everything, to those who don't it's just a pile of BS.

I don't like the ressignification people do of words to frame their beliefs in a flattering light in order to win people over.

"I am pro abortion, yes it is murder, I am pro murder."

hotdogscout··on A Visual Guide to Vision Transformers
You mean 3b1b (three blue one brown)?
hotdogscout··on One man's artistic wonderland, created in rental, gets protected status
>Tell me what gives your life meaning and I can be similarly scornful

Art.

Just because I describe something without emotional involvement doesn't mean I'm against it. I love art.

Most leftist movements are coalitions based on envy and revenge. Justice is delayed vindictiveness. Doesn't mean I don't vote for leftists.

People have no free will. Doesn't mean I think it's unfair to arrest a murderer.

You can be honest about what things are.

Narcissism is fine, envy is fine, the constant sublimation of these impulses as something other than what they are is tiring.

Eating meat is extremely immoral, I still do!

My comment was a vague response to a lot of people here berating the appreciation of that apartment. Yes it's narcissism, all art is narcissism, move on, this is ok!

hotdogscout··on One man's artistic wonderland, created in rental, gets protected status
I am not anti-art though, just like I'm not anti-narcissism.

I think narcissism is a wonderful trait. I think art is a wonderful thing.

Justice is frustrated vindictiveness and people have no free will but that doesn't mean I rage against the western judicial system.

hotdogscout··on Reading more Ursula Le Guin (2019)
The credentialism that permeates discussion in Bolshevik adjacent circles annoys me deeply.

Famous political authors that sold a lot of books don't bring any more credentials to an idea than if I said something in a 4chan post. Argue with the ideas you got from the author, don't keep using them like a religious figure!

So many comments here are just quoting things without pondering if it's bullshit. Sometimes it is!

For irony and fun here's a quote from PhD dropout Natalie Wynn:

There’s also a certain amount of genuine leftist bullshit passing itself off as scholarship. I was once in a comparative literature seminar that I foolishly took in the hopes of getting to read something written with a decent prose style, or at least something by an emotionally competent human being. Boy was I disappointed when on the first day the professor made two allusions to “my good friend Derrida.” Those are quotation marks around “my good friend” because he mentioned that Derrida was his friend every time it came up. Pass the cyanide, honey.

Anyway, the low point of this guy’s endless, beginningless, argument-free impromptu lectures came when he baldly asserted that the poetry of Milton had a direct influence on the workings of ISIS. Yes, this would be John Milton, the 17th century English poet, and ISIS, the contemporary Syrian terrorist organization. And what evidence did the professor adduce in support of this outrageous claim? None whatso-fucking-ever. And the other grad students in the room just sat there nodding knowingly, taking notes like a bunch of sycophants. No one raised their hand, no one said, “Excuse me professor, but what in Jesus’ name are you fucking talking about?” I didn’t even say anything. I had no spine!

The only explanation I can think of for this was that the professor had this reflexive hatred of himself, of English literature, of basically all of Western culture, and so he had to hallucinate that Islamic terrorism is in some way the outcome of over-zealously reading Paradise Lost.

I guess this is what being good friends with Derrida does to you.

hotdogscout··on How to graduate your PhD when you have no hope
Mediocre probably. I don't think biology is the bottleneck of great ideas.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_family

hotdogscout··on Smart devices are turning out to be a poor investment
What product or service do people expect from a smart speaker?

Mobile phones can be an investment if you don't have one but smart devices are for comfort and entertainment, not production.

hotdogscout··on How to graduate your PhD when you have no hope
Newton died a virgin, averages are defined by average people, don't stress on their anecdote and don't put your value in what women think of you.
hotdogscout··on A Nigerian woman reviewed some tomato puree online. Now she faces jail
>The heyday of the upper middle class Maoist was probably forty years ago.

Going by social media/academia/big tech I'd say they're making a comeback.

hotdogscout··on A Nigerian woman reviewed some tomato puree online. Now she faces jail
No. Distilling societies to material conflicts between anarchist actors for their own good is how Marxism as a school of thought (historical materialism) distills colonialism, which is really close to realism.

https://content.csbs.utah.edu/~ehrbar/valmat.pdf

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marxist_schools_of_thought

I said Marxist and not Realist because most people know about Marx and people confuse realism in political development with the common definition of realism.

>Claiming something is "Marxist" because you disagree with it

Strawmanning.

hotdogscout··on A Nigerian woman reviewed some tomato puree online. Now she faces jail
That is my point. Violent colonization can have wildly different outcomes and there's a lot more to the success of a society than predation.

That is a simplification that's often resting on emotional resentment to injustice but doesn't really define or predict how a country develops.

hotdogscout··on A Nigerian woman reviewed some tomato puree online. Now she faces jail
>A big part of what is perceived as "backwards" are long term effects of British colonial rule, from which they are still recovering. There's a lot of ink spilt studying how the systems which colonial powers set up get left behind, which keeps in place a stratified society with the goal of enriching all the people in positions of power (read: corruption). That takes time to overcome. This is as true for Latin America as it is for Nigeria, India and all the rest.

This is very debatable. Ethiopia and Liberia were never colonized. So wasn't Japan.

Places where the institutions of colonization were toppled like Haiti did not fare well, neither did Nepal. This is a Marxist reading of History that imo is way too simple and results in a lot of inconsistencies, but it's in tune with feelings of justice (or revenge if you like Nietzsche).

hotdogscout··on A Nigerian woman reviewed some tomato puree online. Now she faces jail
Really poor countries will probably not have strong liberal institutions needed for free speech, just like they won't have the best pride parades or provocative comedians.

But there's not much in the way of an authoritarian place producing a lot. The left doesn't bat an eye on how unionizing is illegal in China.

hotdogscout··on How To Choose A Romantic Partner: What psychology tells us
The same way you choose friends.
hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
I like unions. I don't like socialism. Socialist countries ban unions, which I like. Unions need freedoms to operate, which need to be respected too. Unions have a lot of ideological affinity with socialist movements, usually downright indistinguishable, I think this is not good.
hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
I know there's collusion between some police departments and far right protestors in the US, this is obvious. I say some because there are exceptions.

But your point was "there's no problem [protesting for the right]" and there is, there obviously is. They range from death at the hands of far left killers, persecution at work/academia, unemployment.

It's absurd to pretend the right has no stake when protesting as you implied.

>individual incidents of violence

So it's a coincidence the killers were ideologically opposed to the victims? I don't get how "individual" these deaths are when there's a clear political motivation.

Death of ideological enemies by "civilians" is how fascism in Italy began. Civilian political violence is not irrelevant.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
>racism is illogical and dependent on cognitive fallacy to be maintained.

Can you explain why it's illogical and what fallacy it's maintained on?

I don't think I can logically claim torturing babies is wrong without some arbitrary axioms but you must have some killer logic I don't.

>Double standard: you picked apart my post and didn't acknowledge a thing about the tweet I quoted.

I did though (?). She said something that almost nobody denies, that BLM is associated more with the left, and you went on about what that entails but I see nothing untrue about what she said about that correlation.

I think you confuse logic with morality.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Duncan_Lemp

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killings_of_Aaron_Danielson_...

https://amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/jun/14/virginia-sho...

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/14/us/steve-scalise-congress...

https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/capitol-breached-protesters/...

I ask for minimal perspective towards people you feel contempt. I'd say the same to someone claiming left wing protests are easy and leftists have "no problem" participating in them. It's just not true.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
"\1 komali2 asserting that Yu Jie @yujie89 has conflated leftist ideology with BLM

is not equivilant to

\2 komali2 conflating BLM with the Republican Party."

I'm aware, I don't think komali2 thinks the Republican Party supports BLM. (?)

"Anyone claiming..." Should be relevant when someone claims that I suppose.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
>Conflating leftist ideology with BLM when BLM is explicitly a movement against excessive police violence against black people is funny - kinda says the quiet part out loud about what conservatives represent.

Would you conflate BLM with the Republican Party? This is a quiet part?

>You can't "win in the marketplace of ideals" against these people with rigorous logic and spirited debate, if you could, they wouldn't exist, because their entire belief system depends on cognitive fallacy.

I think you don't understand how inherently axiomatic the logic of political positions are.

Just for fun: I counted four cognitive fallacies in your post.

Sweeping generalizations (conservatives ...),

ad hominem attacks (by labeling the author as a "typical American right-wing talk show political grifter" without addressing the substance of her arguments),

false dichotomies (by implying that engaging with her viewpoints through "rigorous logic and spirited debate" is ineffective and that protest is the only viable response)

and confirmation bias (dismissing the possibility of engaging with the her arguments in good faith and assuming that the only reason for their presence is to engage in divisive tactics).

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
>Shove fetus pictures into people's faces? No problem! Strap on swastikas and March through town? Police escort!

If it's really no problem try doing it. You're not being realistic about the consequences of being disruptive.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
Iran's current government is socialist though.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_Socialist_Ba%27ath_Part...

It's the most deadly conflict of the region and it's brushed off because it's the fault of a socialist dictator.

I am not right wing. Last election I voted for a socialist union leader despite not being socialist. As someone in academia I'm frustrated with so much corruption and harassment and bullshit passing off as science by leftists. This is where I come from.

>I love how Americans are so brainwashed about "the communist threat". I'm sure there are sometimes political games from China, sometimes linked to ideology (and maybe the example you gave it's indeed one of them, big deal, there are plenty of fraud done by right-wing academics), but in the majority of the cases, China involvement in frauds is just because China is a big country with an emergent economy, with a lax regulation to fraud supported by a corrupted dictatorship.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Document_Number_Nine

Their intention is ideological, the goal is to destroy liberal democracy, this is documented. Yes the far right would do the same. I argue they are the same movement.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
I'm well aware there's nuance but it's still a problem.

A country club is extremely biased towards conservatism even if there isn't an all encompassing authoritarian mind control scheme for it.

Leftism is popular in Academia because of selection bias and not some huge conspiracy, I'm aware, but that is still a problem if it lets so much misbehaviour pass and keeps gaslighting critics.

>being left-wing does not mean a scientist will accept to reject the truth

I agree but it's been known to happen and it's been known to be brushed under the carpet. Although there has been recent cases of literal socialist conspiracies in Ivy League universities.

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/harvard-university-professor-...

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
I'm not American and I wasn't thinking of the US exclusively. I think it's a problem of democratic western academia, but there's no data outside the US as far as I know. If academic institutions of rich reputation champion, for example, denial of the Cambodian genocide, is the harm undone if another institution admits it happened?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#:~....

>Things are more complicated: some people get more fame and more founding that their work would normally require because they present themselves as cancelled. There are even "anti-leftist-dogma university" initiatives coming out, which means that right-wing academic will have an easy position available there while left-wing academics don't have any such advantage

I think the worst of the deplatformed people enjoy this fame, which is not great. I'm a lot less concerned about Milo's exclusion than I am of Xi Van Fleet's. Drawing the ~line of acceptability~ at human rights is fine but academia is drawing it at leftist interest.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
I wouldn't say unions are socialist at all. In fact unions are the first thing to go out the window under socialist governments.

(The relevant part of the Wiki article is highlighted) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_relations_in_China#:~:....

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
"I think it's sociologically healthy for our species that people with ugly, hateful ideologies face as much resistance as possible, in many forms, all the time."

I really don't think I'm being unfair in saying that comment implies the deplatformed people are vile.

Given the context of the article what other group could be the "people with ugly, hateful ideologies" if not the deplatformed speakers?

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
If you look at any right leaning pundit online you'd see substantial instances of violence against the right. Look at Andy Ngo's Feed.

1924 preceded McCarthyism by 3 decades.

I conceded that the stonings did happen against Black people and I didn't know.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →