HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hp50g

414 karma · joined March 14, 2013

submissionscomments
hp50g··on Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
It's not Ada or Pascal-like :)
hp50g··on Liberation fonts causing Windows 7 SP1 to BSOD
Google windows SDK. Download, install. Sorted. What's hard about that?
hp50g··on Liberation fonts causing Windows 7 SP1 to BSOD
TBH win32 was pretty good and well thought out. How it was plugged into NT and how it evolved wasn't.
hp50g··on Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
dynamic loading, arbitrary casts (it is what I tell you it is) etc etc.
hp50g··on Liberation fonts causing Windows 7 SP1 to BSOD
This is win32 and does not represent the NT kernel in any way. There is a load of stuff they had to port from win16 which was shit and have been stuck with it ever since that effectively compromises NT's architecture. GDI in kernel space was a pragmatic choice considering the other competitors on the workstation market were basically HP, Sun and SGI and they all had nearly graphics acceleration.

NT itself is flipping marvellous :)

hp50g··on NetBSD turns 20
Definitely. I had a dialup SLIP server running on NetBSD on an old Compaq desktop for nearly 10 years and it didn't get a single update. It died when the case filled up with dust to the point the CPU fan stopped going round and it blew up.
hp50g··on Windows Blue under the hood: MinKernel and BaseFS
That's still NTFS territory. ReFS seems more appropriate for large scale file serving and/or volume flexibility.

As for all the symbolic links, they all still work. They're only there for compatibility reasons and will disappear at some point (WinSxS is a worry though).

hp50g··on Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
Agree here. My statement perhaps could be better written. I'm saying not that idiots write C, but idiots can write C badly and often do. Much as anyone can cross a road, idiots can do it and reliably get squashed every time.

I disagree about sendmail though - that was a stinking turd and I have been ever grateful since postfix arrived on the scene :)

hp50g··on Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
This sort of stuff works until you need to poke some registers in a graphics card or the language's MM has a bug or you need C's dynamic nature.
hp50g··on Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
You are wrong: I'm calling them idiots because they use C in a dumb way and don't stick it through valgrind etc.
hp50g··on Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
C also makes memory access and device driver code very easy. The mechanical issues are a side effect of that.

As for design errors, they are hard to prevent anywhere.

hp50g··on Windows Blue under the hood: MinKernel and BaseFS
It doesn't ship with half the dependencies that were tangled up which is why minwin exists. Minwin has a GUI too (apparently you can trigger it during boot on win phone 8 :) )
hp50g··on Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
I'd actually blame it on idiots writing C myself.

You can't really have a totally safe systems programming language (correct me if I'm wrong here).

hp50g··on Windows Blue under the hood: MinKernel and BaseFS
Better x86/x64 support I'd imagine. Despite being a rabid Linux fanboy, I've had way more driver availability issues with Linux over the years than windows.

To be honest, windows just pretty much works these days.

hp50g··on Windows Blue under the hood: MinKernel and BaseFS
Most of these aren't used frequently. I imagine they will make a reappearance in ReFS2 if required
hp50g··on Windows Blue under the hood: MinKernel and BaseFS
It almost is. Windows 2008 Server Core was a result of this. It doesn't have a GUI. Ita also what they run Azure on.
hp50g··on Windows Blue under the hood: MinKernel and BaseFS
NT has had VFS from day one (volume manager). You just don't get to see it from the UI and win32 abstraction. In fact NT has mounts, a single tree, case sensitivity and no concept of drive letters. sounds a bit unixy doesn't it?

I have no idea why they came to these conclusions.

hp50g··on Windows Blue under the hood: MinKernel and BaseFS
To be honest, windows NT is a whole load more complicated than Linux variants at every level. It's almost a framework for building operating systems upon. NT architecture is actually really super nice - shame about win32 being thrown on top.

20MiB is impressive.

hp50g··on North Korea declares war on South Korea - full declaration
I don't know why they even think they'd get away with this. All strategic targets will be flattened in 30 minutes flat and the rest of the country will just starve to death or die from the fallout. I assume they know this will happen?

I genuinely feel sorry for the people on both sides Of this conflict as they're all going to suffer if it kicks off.

If the international community gets involved as well, its going to drag out even longer than Afghanistan or Iraq.

Its ugly whatever happens.

hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
We have to use iSCSI. Not all our kit talks NFS plus we use SAN block replication between DCs which really doesn't play nice with NFS (we did test it and discovered that not all NFS implementations are good).

This whole thing has to play nice with a windows DFS cluster as well.

hp50g··on Frustrated with iCloud, Apple’s developer community speaks up
Apple's dalek lawyers will emerge chanting litigate! Litigate! Litigate!

Serious Apple have always done a crappy job of online services - why would you expect any more.

hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
2TiB per LUN on ESX until recently actually. We have a single filesystem that is 19TiB.
hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
AWS is a prime example. EC2 unreliable, doesn't perform well and is expensive (and fairly weather dependent by the looks too). If you want anything that can actually shift anything, dedicated servers are cheaper (but you might actually have to commit - oh dear if your margin is that tight, you don't have a product worth it).

The only use case I can see for it really is rapid scaling but that seems only viable for content delivery as your data back end architecture is way harder to scale than click the magic cloud button. Back in the old days we used to do content via CDN (Akamai etc) which actually works out cheaper per GiB.

Then we approach things like S3 which is terribly unreliable (some of our clients use it for storage as it's cheaper than a SAN but they suffer for that). Drop outs, unreliable network requests, latency, rubbish throughput and buggy as fuck SDK.

Its like consuming value line products from a supermarket. Sure there's quantity but its lacking in quality.

hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
2008. TBH not sure what CPUs we had in there. Kit has been scrapped now. I wouldn't bother going through it again. We now have a standard half and full rack which we can purchase and deploy quickly for an installation so there are no plans to piss any more time and cost up the wall.

We did have a testing period which was unfortunately run by a Muppet who decided the loss was acceptable. Muppet now no longer works for organisation.

hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
We run our software (and other "enterprise" software) multiple instances per node and they are fully isolated. Most is in JVMs but we have C++ stuff with no problems.
hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
Unless you are doing really heavy IO or CPU across multiple VMs on the same host which is likely if you have any load worth mentioning. There is a 20% to 30% difference if you run one process per VM or 8 processes on bare metal in an 8 core machine. We benchmarked it on known good configs optimised to bits.

Either the hypervisor scheduler is shit or the abstraction is costly. I reckon its down to the reduction in CPU cache availability and the IO mux.

This was HP kit end to end, VMware certified, debian stable on and off ESX 4.

hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
Processes are a form of virtualisation are they not?

That's enough abstraction.

hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
Its a shit tool that creates issues and costs fuckwads of cash. That is it.

We understand it. The numbers sold are not the numbers gained.

The entire infrastructure deployment was planned around virtualization, DC failover and resilience using VMware's guidelines and solutions (VMware were even paid to consult on this). It never delivered and doubled our administrative and licensing overhead.

hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
Its definitely 20-30% for realistic workloads using VM based tech on top I.e. CLR/JVM or a database engine which is realistic. This is on top of VMware. I can't speak for Xen.

The outcome is pretty grim.

hp50g··on Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It With OpenStack
I think this only solves the cost problem. VMware is damn expensive for what it is.

I'm not really a fan of virtualization myself. We canned it at our organisation a couple of years ago. We had 30 ESX/vSphere managed hosts across 3 data centers which hosted app servers, web front end servers, virtual load balancers and some other minor infrastructure. The final straw was the upgrade costs. Not only that we had problems with volume size limits on our SAN which would require more expense and hackery to work around. Also, we couldn't host our database servers on top of it due to performance problems so we had to have dedicated machines there anyway.

The whole thing at the end of the day just added complexity, expense and didn't improve reliability, security or load distribution as our architecture was sound on that front already.

We've gone back to the original virtualization system: processes and sensible distribution of them across multiple machines. Performance, cost and sanity have improved.

I can understand that virtualization is useful when your resource requirement is less than one machine but above that, I doubt there are any real benefits. It's snake oil.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →