351 karma · joined November 7, 2011
Your boast about your Lisp credentials is exactly the kind of things I caution against in the article. Your pride has prevented you from properly learning Clojure, which has a very different programming style from other Lisps.
You are basically illustrating my point live, again.
On the other hand, nowadays you probably can get away with not knowing Java when doing Clojure. There are also Clojures that are not on the JVM. For example, if you do Clojurescript, then you probably need to know some Javascript. There are also natively compiled Clojures for shell scripting, e.g. babashka, etc.
You are basically illustrating my point about "You probably cannot learn Clojure all by yourself". You need a mentor to show you how to do Clojure correctly, or you have the humility to learn the proper Clojure way. Sadly, most people would rather just try something and jump onto conclusions immediately.
So I agree that it is harder for experienced people than for young kids fresh from school.
In my startup, our onboarding time is two weeks. I would say nine out of ten fresh graduates we hired picked up Clojure and were able to do something useful after two weeks. But we did have one or two persons who were not able to and they ended up in one of FAAG (yes, we did do leetcode style interviews, but only asked medium level questions).
From my personal experience, before I become a Clojure user, I wouldn't dare to write "hard" software such as compiler, database, and such, all by myself. Now I have done all that, I would credit part of that to the productivity of the language. That's why with such a small community, Clojure ecosystem has produced so many first of its kind innovative systems, e.g. Storm, Datomic, etc.
If anything, as someone who has a Ph.D. and a career spanning both academia and industry, I can assure you that functional programming languages like Clojure is much more productive than the mainstream languages, even for implementing cutting edge CS research.
My experience of implementing algorithms from papers is that, in Clojure, the implementation is much more straightforward, always almost a direct translation from pseudo code in the paper to actual working code, even the pseudo code is inevitably written in an imperative style. However, the original author's code implemented in c/c++/java is always much more convoluted and bears no resemblance to their pseudo code in the paper. That should tell you one thing: that is functional languages often capture the bare essence of computer science, whereas mainstream language often have too much incidental complexity imposed by the languages themselves.
If you ask me, java.util.concurrent is a much better and battle tested concurrent infrastructure than the simplistic implementation in go, because java.util.concurrent is actually written by the world's foremost concurrency expert, Doug Lee. I will take that over someone else's hand rolling concurrent runtime any day. God knows how many bugs there are in your home grown concurrency code.
In a nutshell, if you can mathematically prove a certain degree of soundness of your code, you have not done anything to show your code does what it is supposed to do.
Basically, you could be doing wasted work to satisfy your compiler, and have made zero progress in solving your problem, because that's not what the type system does.
Dynamical languages focuses on solving problems of human beings. The human beings' requirements are often inherently arbitrary, logically unsound, or even self-contradictory. Shoehorning a type system in there often serves to make solving human's problem harder. Consequently, in practice, most popular programming languages are dynamic. The current craze with types is just a fad, in my opinion.
It's impossible to be productive in a large Java code base within a month even if you joined as a seasoned Java developer. But it is routine for a programmer who has not even heard of Clojure before to become productive in a production Clojure code base in two weeks. We do this all the time with our interns.
Basically, after that dinner in Argentina, one of them is dead, another is arrested.
Juji develops a state of art AI chatbot creation platform. We work with companies such as Google, Robinhood, Barnes and Noble, and universities such as UIUC, Arburn, and Air Force Academy. See https://venturebeat.com/2018/10/18/juji-is-an-empathetic-ai-... for a general description.
We are a Clojure shop. The backend is in Clojure and the frontend is in Clojurescript, with Re-frame and Rum on top of ReactJS. We also leverage python for machine learning and tensorflow for deep learning. Watch https://youtu.be/phA4bMjKvCY for our recent talk in the main Clojure conference.
For details of the position, see https://juji.io/careers#frontend
We are building an advanced artificial intelligence platform that aims to understanding individuals. Funded by the US government and VC, we aims to democratize marketing research.
We are looking for talented front end developers who are passionate about usability and user interfaces. You should have great sense of aesthetics and attention to details.
We use ClojureScript at the frontend and talk to our Clojure based APIs in GraphQL. If you love learning new technology, we are the right company for you.
To apply, email jobs@juji-inc.com with your resume and links to your portfolio.
Juji is building an AI platform at focus on understanding individuals. We are funded by both US government and VC. We have repeating paying customers who rave about our product.
We are looking for talented individuals to join us. Our technology stack consists of Clojure/Clojurescript, Datomic, Postgresql, Kafka, Docker, AWS. Send your resume to jobs@juji-inc.com to apply.
We are building a platform to power next generation of AI. VC and US government funded. Have paying customers. Looking for brilliant developers to change the technology landscape of the world. We love Clojure and do everything with the language. New graduates and seasoned professionals are both welcome.
Juji, Inc. is building an AI platform that focuses on understanding and helping individuals. We are funded by both US government and VC, with repeating paying customers. We are looking for talented software engineers to join our engineering team. Our stack includes Clojure/Clojurescript, Datomic, Postgres, Kafka, Docker, AWS.
Juji builds advanced AI platform to help people. We are funded both by VC and US government, and have paying customers. Join our growing small team to change the world with world class computer scientists, experienced clojure hackers, and brilliant colleagues graduated from top universities.