1,080 karma · joined April 4, 2018
As a pilot, I am surprised by how important audio communication is for retention and awareness. Given that my visual senses are (nearly) overwhelmed with information, I think there is a risk that moving ATC from audio to visual would simply saturate the "visual channel" of pilots.
In terms of automating coordination, it's obviously possible but it would take decades to prove its relative safety. (Aviation is extremely safe.) The system would be very fragile, unless you had 24/7 fully staffed backup human ATC, which rather defeats the purpose. Practically speaking too, planes take a long time to build, and the current system allows planes built 80 years ago to fly alongside brand new ones. The cost of abolishing the 'legacy fleet' (i.e. all current passenger aircraft) is pretty high!
In some jurisdiction, yes, legally, such evidence might not be probative, but you might still convicted because of it.
I also think that your using the example of submarines -- notoriously an onerous lifestyle that very few are capable of living -- pretty much torpedoes your implicit suggestion that this would not be too much of a change.
https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/01/18/why-car-i...
https://www.afr.com/companies/energy/humelink-budget-trimmed...
https://www.pv-magazine-australia.com/2024/03/21/community-c...
It's safety-critical for aviation, because if all GPS fails, then the additional workload across the system means that a crash is likely.