HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hugoroy

1,160 karma · joined August 22, 2010

IAAL BNYL https://hroy.eu
submissionscomments
hugoroy··on VMWare Taken to Court Over GPL Violation
There is a huge difference: in this case the Vmware product does include linux kernel code. So there's definitely some reproduction and distribution of copyrighted parts even excluding the use of APIs.
hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
Your comment is unclear. Your main argument is that you don’t care, but why don’t you care?

I see two hypotheses.

1. Because you don’t care about your rights at all > Then this project is not for you, move on.

2. Because you think the terms and privacy policies of services you use online are not “binding”? > Then you’re very naive and a bit ignorant about the law.

It’s alright to not know how the law and how contract works exactly, that’s why you need this project even more; because that’s what it does: it makes things simpler to understand for you.

hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
Hello, hugo from tosdr.org here!

Just wanted to point out that everything is on https://github.com/tosdr and there are easy stuff to work on to help us: https://github.com/tosdr/tosdr-build/labels/LowHangingFruit

Everything we make is Free Software (and open data) and we’re a not-for-profit.

We recently put online: https://tosdr.org/submit-point.html which is supposed to help increase contributions to the site so that we have more data and more relevant information. Please help us test, debug and contribute :-)

One last thing, we’re also running https://tosback.org/ -- all of this is a lot of work, and we definitely need more contributors :-) (opened another discussion about Tosback: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8396361)

hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
If there’s something you think is wrong, you can discuss and participate. Can you point specific examples which you think are "subjective"?
hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
Yes but it’s not open source. Ours is: https://tosback.org -- https://github.com/tosdr/tosback2 and tosback3
hugoroy··on TldrLegal – Software Licenses Explained in Plain English
(ToS;DR project lead here)

We’re a not-for-profit. And all our code is at https://github.com/tosdr/

I’m all fine to see other projects tackling the issue. But I’m not a big fan of closed-source services that exploit people’s participation.

(Or maybe I completely miss the source code to tldrlegal.com, in such case I apologize! But then, don’t hide it ;-))

hugoroy··on Yale censored a student's course catalog site. I made an unblockable replacement
Defamation is illegal, so obviously freedom of speech isn't the highest priority in the US.

(I'm just trying to show you that there are limits on what you can say without legal trouble and what you cannot say without legal trouble: it all depends on where you put the cursor and how the limits are enforced. But to point out the existence of limits in order to demonstrate the absence of something is flawed.)

BTW, one comment: Holocaust denial is illegal in France. But to be clear, holocaust denial means refuting the facts established by the international Nuremberg tribunal. So it's not like a completely open category. Now, whether it's efficient is another matter…

"If there be time to expose through discussion the falsehood and fallacies, to avert the evil by the processes of education, the remedy to be applied is more speech, not enforced silence."

-- US Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis

hugoroy··on France's Data Protection agency issues their maximum monetary penalty to Google
Just a note: 150,000€ is indeed the maximum penaltly allowed by law for this, see http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexteArticle.do;jsession...
hugoroy··on France's Data Protection agency issues their maximum monetary penalty to Google
says the guys who surely have read all the privacy policies he supposedly agreed to… right?
hugoroy··on Free vector icons
You misread the license: http://ikons.piotrkwiatkowski.co.uk/license.html

> Making modifications or alterations to any of the icons does not free you to then sell, license or distribute them to anyone else.

If you’re looking for something really permissive: http://fortawesome.github.io/Font-Awesome/icons/

hugoroy··on Show HN: I'm working on an open-source Gmail replacement
> It's free and open source, although

There's also kolab.org which is completely free software (uses Roundcube for web interface since 3.1).

hugoroy··on Just Delete Me
and http://www.accountkiller.com/
hugoroy··on Just Delete Me
Hm. Do you really want to do that on your own? You'd have to find the ToS, document ToS changes, analyse the ToS, etc.

We're trying to do that already at http://tosdr.org, please join in (http://github.com/tosdr) and http://tosback.org

Edit: Hm I thought 5apps supported https already, i guess i was wrong

hugoroy··on OpenMailBox: An alternative to Gmail based on free software
I'm not basing my judgement on where it comes from. I read the ToS and, since they're in French, I'm sharing two observations:

- there are typos there

- they don't say much

It's not good quality per se, that's it. I don't care where it's coming form.

hugoroy··on OpenMailBox: An alternative to Gmail based on free software
Good. The text I'm referring to is in French. Can I expect him to write perfect French on a legal document?
hugoroy··on OpenMailBox: An alternative to Gmail based on free software
The terms of service are here: https://openmailbox.org/cgu.php

There are some typos there and they don't say much. Do I need to say more about the quality of this?

hugoroy··on Shooting the messenger (Secunia and VLC)
VideoLan is a non for profit association, and VLC is Free Software (GPL).

I wouldn't qualify their incentives as being the same (and VideoLan has no commercial incentive at all by definition).

hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
Funny. You should have read the Y Combinator Hacker News Guidelines:

"Be civil."

http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
You're using our API? Please get in touch with us. We're a very small team and the project is very young. You can't really expect to use it like that without telling us and expect it to work well! (It's open data and free software, you don't legally have to tell us, but please do so).

http://tosdr.org/about.html#contact

hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
"Laws may put more requirements than pressing a button." Are you sure?

There are many kinds of contracts, not all of them have the same form requirements.

I am sure you haven't read most of the contracts you are bound to, yet, you are bound to them.

hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
Hi. Exactly, we're trying to fix this with http://github.com/tosdr/ToSBack3 but this is not ready unfortunately :-(
hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
There are other solutions to fix this, http://tieguy.org/blog/2012/08/19/a-quick-note-on-conspicuou...

However, if you think this is really the problem about ToS, I think you're missing the bigger picture: http://tosdr.org/blog/tosdr-in-action-i-have-read-and-agree....

hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
"a large step of trust by installing executable code into my browser."

Have you read the page where you get the extension? http://tosdr.org/downloads.html : you can get the source code on http://github.com/tosdr

hugoroy··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
http://tosdr.org/legal.html (linked from the bottom)

But there are no specific terms around the service we provide to you. The only thing is a disclaimer: "this is not legal advice" this is just our opinions.

It's like reading an article or a book. You don't need to accept ToS to do that ;-)

One other example would be to use Free Software. If you download and use, e.g. GNU/Linux, you are not accepting any ToS. (For instance, only modification and distribution of copies is regulated by the GNU GPL. Merely using the program is not).

hugoroy··on EFF Makes Formal Objection to DRM in HTML5
The spec without CDM does not do anything at all. This spec goes hand-in-hand with having a proprietary CDM. So ultimately, standardising this at the W3C means having all open web users install a proprietary CDM.

Again, if this whole debate was outside discussing open web standards, this would be valid. But what we're discussing here is inclusion or not in open web standards.

hugoroy··on EFF Makes Formal Objection to DRM in HTML5
> For whatever reason Big Media aren't going to allow you access to their content without the DRM

What is "Big Media"? This is just pure speculation not based on facts.

There is plenty of high quality, paid-for content on the web already which does not require DRM.

IIRC, there are no more DRM on music on iTunes either.

It's just a matter of negotiating. If a company's better at negotiationg DRM-free content than Netflix, then too bad for Netflix. There's no reason why web users should support these costs.

hugoroy··on EFF Makes Formal Objection to DRM in HTML5
> Hollywood doesn't need nor care about the web or the w3c apart from as a marketing avenue. They would be just as happy delivering all content through a standalone application, as they are doing currently.

If they do not care, why are they pushing for getting a W3C stamp on their DRM system?

> There are no "CDMs in HTML5" , this is a nonesense statement.

To accept EME because proprietary CDM are outside of the spec is pure hypocrisy. To say that EME is okay because it would be working with clear-key systems too is complete BS, because such systems already exist and do not need EME. Hence the EME spec is only here to get standardised API for proprietary CDMs, which is why no one else but Hollywood, Netflix and Google & al. are pushing for this.

I would not care about EME, if they were not trying to integrate that into the W3C, which should stand for an open web, where free technologies are on equal footing with proprietary ones. EME would de facto force web users to have proprietary software installed in the form of CDM (which is DRM). Unacceptable.

hugoroy··on Google ToS rated: “keeps your searches and logs for an undefined period of time”
We will do this when we have a solid way of archiving the terms (see http://github.com/tosdr/tosback3). So yes, it's planned.
hugoroy··on Google ToS rated: “keeps your searches and logs for an undefined period of time”
Oops. I didn't see the points for Spotify were already published. These are drafts for most of them!
hugoroy··on Google ToS rated: “keeps your searches and logs for an undefined period of time”
We don't consider their opaque deletion policy transparent. We only consider that they are transparent about some of their security (compared to most equivalents i'd say). See the whole thing (click "Expand"):

> + Transparent security practices Discussion

> GitHub gives a detailed overview of their own security practices and their service providers' practices and obligations.

https://groups.google.com/d/topic/tosdr/2vIh4l7sTnk/discussi...

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →