HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hugoroy

1,160 karma · joined August 22, 2010

IAAL BNYL https://hroy.eu
submissionscomments
hugoroy··on Google ToS rated: “keeps your searches and logs for an undefined period of time”
Hi, thanks for your comment.

For reference, here's what we're showing on tosdr.org:

> Google can share your personal information with other parties

> Google will share your personal information with other parties. For sensitive information (medical, racial, ethnic, political, religious or sexuality) Google requires “opt-in”. Google can also share or publish aggregated data that does not identify a person

Now, what I am writing in the "discussion" forum is not on tosdr.org exactly because it is all difficult to interpret. My conclusion, is what is on tosdr.org -- if you think the current statement written there is wrong, please submit a patch :)

Now about what I wrote under "discussion" (which is as it suggests, all here to be discussed:) Yes, it does not sound legal in the EU. That's actually the whole problem and why Google is currently under scrutiny by European Data protection agencies. http://www.cnil.fr/english/news-and-events/news/article/goog...

I'm welcoming your opinion (and anybody's) about this in reply to what I wrote https://groups.google.com/d/msg/tosdr/QZgR8faRWDU/PatkxP2G-B... :)

About the EFF, we're working with them on ToSback (http://github.com/tosdr/tosback2 and http://github.com/tosdr/tosback3). I actually also believe that ToS;DR should have more resources and more contributions from orgs like the EFF ;)

Edit: fixed the github links

hugoroy··on Instagram's official response
Well, I'm sorry that this guy can't read. I have read many different copyright licenses, and this copyright license is not "boilerplate". You can have very different copyright licenses for such web services. You can get an overview at http://tos-dr.info/topics.html#copyright-scope

As you can see, the new Instagram © license is like Facebook's or Twitter's. But very different from others. (Actually, the current Instagram © license is okay)

hugoroy··on Instagram's official response
No they're not. This article from the Verge is weird. The important changes are in the copyright license. The instagram blog post is lying by omission.

Look at the former section "Proprietary Rights in Content on Instagram"

> Instagram does NOT claim ANY ownership rights in the text, files, images, photos, video, sounds, musical works, works of authorship, applications, or any other materials (collectively, "Content") that you post on or through the Instagram Services. By displaying or publishing ("posting") any Content on or through the Instagram Services, you hereby grant to Instagram a non-exclusive, fully paid and royalty-free, worldwide, limited license to use, modify, delete from, add to, publicly perform, publicly display, reproduce and translate such Content, including without limitation distributing part or all of the Site in any media formats through any media channels, except Content not shared publicly ("private") will not be distributed outside the Instagram Services.

This section about copyright has turned into something pretty much like Facebook's:

> Instagram does not claim ownership of any Content that you post on or through the Service. Instead, you hereby grant to Instagram a non-exclusive, fully paid and royalty-free, transferable, sub-licensable, worldwide license to use the Content that you post on or through the Service, except that you can control who can view certain of your Content and activities on the Service as described in the Service's Privacy Policy, available here:http://instagram.com/legal/privacy/.

hugoroy··on Dear Internet: please move the share buttons from the web page to the browser
Huh? The share button in your desktop or your phone is not making requests to Facebook or Twitter, thus it's not tracking you. For instance, when you integrate twitter's buttons on your website, you must opt-in the "do not track" which means that otherwise, anyone visiting the website will be tracked by twitter and the data is kept for some days. Unless of course if that person has an extension like disconnect.me
hugoroy··on Dear Internet: please move the share buttons from the web page to the browser
These buttons are sources of data for Facebook, Twitter etc. That's how they track their user over the Web. So no incentive for them to remove them
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Not at all ;) thanks (not a native English speaker)
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
What do you mean?
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
You're right. I was actually unsure at the time. The data comes from the EFF.
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
thank you very much for reporting this. As we're all working on non-windows systems, we would not have found out by ourselves!
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Thanks for your feedback. The whole explanation can be found about cookies can be found here. Tell us what you think!

http://tos-dr.info/topics.html#cookies

> 5 GitHub requires cookies

5: means it's a low score. So it's considered bad, but it doesn't influence very much the whole class of GitHub.

> GitHub requires cookies to work and misleads you to

> believe that you remain anonymous while cookies contain

> “unique identifiers”. However, only session cookies are

> used, not persistant cookies.

The whole discussion is here https://groups.google.com/d/topic/tosdr/gyMiAkV5ZG0/discussi...

Do you agree/disagree? We welcome contributions!

hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Not necessary (see SoundCloud for instance). The whole problem is that the copyright license is just overbroad and not limited at all.
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
tosback.org is no longer updated.

Yes, the facebook TOS are difficult to archive: http://wayback.archive.org/web/*/http://www.facebook.com/leg... issue on GH if you have a solution: https://github.com/pde/tosback2-data/issues/1

hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
That's a fair point. You can discuss this at https://groups.google.com/d/topic/tosdr/hI5Too_uDVk/discussi...

I'll be happy to reply over there :) (if we spread the discussion too much, it will be lost)

hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
I agree. But sometimes the copyright license conceded by the user goes way beyond what's needed for the service. Why do you give rights to sublicense and to transfer to Facebook or Twitter?

Details: http://tos-dr.info/topics.html#copyright-scope

hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
check out commonterms.net ;)
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
You're welcome to discuss this specific point at https://groups.google.com/d/topic/tosdr/b6ryqY9NdMw/discussi...

Since all Twitpic does is hosting public pictures for Tweets, I would assume as a user that if I click "Delete" then the pictures would be… well. Deleted. Having a short period to rescue the picture from a back up would be acceptable.

I don't understand your example with the "high profile blogger".

hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Yes. Differences between legislations is one thing that's making the task harder. I think it's better to focus to what the terms actually state. But I always keep in mind the jurisdiction under which the company operates as it can influence the meaning of the terms.

However I'd fear to get to the other extreme and to end up making a rating system saying which legislation is better than the other. It's not the scope.

One other thing: we think the terms should be self-explanatory. I don't think services should expect their users to know the EU data protection law. So it would seem smart for me that the services makes a statement about them in their terms (just like they state details about their security practices for instance).

hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
actually the original inspiration was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_energy_label
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
For the moment: Anyone who can push to the 5apps.com git master branch. That is people at http://unhosted.org

We would be happy to get th umbrella of a non profit org like Mozilla or the EFF.

Any way, if you don't like our decision: you can get involved. Or you can fork it.

hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Yes. https://github.com/flamsmark/privacy-policy-template & http://blog.docracy.com/post/27931026976/an-open-source-priv...
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Yes. Which is a bit silly, I haven't really understood their justification for it. But if they want to clear that up, it would be a good idea.
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Yes. I have been in touch with the author and invited to cooperate. But... where is the code? how does it work exactly? How can it interoperate with other projects trying to back up archives of terms? etc. etc.
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
The category is explained http://tos-dr.info/topics.html#ownership also, see http://tos-dr.info/topics.html#copyright-scope
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
AGPL is our JS+HTML+CSS code. The data itself (JSON) is CC-BY-SA.
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
I also think it's a poor choice. What do you suggest?
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Yeah "Ownership" is meant as a category rather than a title. I guess I forgot to give this one a proper title. Will fix this soon.
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
The plan is to work with the EFF's tosback https://github.com/pde/tosback2 (they need contributors too BTW) and track changes over time so we can notify people when something wrong is going on (they'd be able to subscribe to a list of services' ToS;DR)
hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Yes, trust is one problem. I think we're being objective (at least we are trying, with building a scoring system that's automatic). But for sure, we are not being neutral. We do think that tracking should always be opt-in, not opt-out.

At least, we're working in total transparency and it's an open process. I hope that helps.

hugoroy··on ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
There's an issue for that. https://github.com/unhosted/ToS-DR/issues/11
hugoroy··on Frank Zappa Explains the Decline of the Music Industry
In the last paragraph, that sentence isn't in the book I have: "We require a LARGE quantity of money and the services of a team of mega-hackers to write the software for this system"
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →