HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hunterpayne

474 karma · joined September 14, 2025

submissionscomments
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Also, I don't want a different article, I want one informed by someone who has a real understanding of these topics. For example, if a datacenter is in Washington state, fresh water (and its fresh water we care about here) isn't consumed. In Ireland, probably some is consumed. This is because of wind patterns and where water vapor will be carried to from the datacenter. If its carried over land, fresh water isn't consumed. If its carried over ocean, then it is. Stuff like this is why you actually need knowledge of the issue, and not just an understanding of datacenter cooling systems.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
"Many people with a STEM background understand these things .. they are not generally called "scientists" in Commonwealth English."

Sure, but none of them work at the institution referenced by the article. That isn't what they do.

hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Your post doesn't have a reply link for some reasons but here is my response. What they need is expertise in energy generation. They need to understand concepts like a duck curve, power storage and its material requirements, relative EROEI of various power generation sources and a basic understanding of when newer forms of generation are likely to be ready. For instance, they should understand that renewables need to be well sited. They need to understand that the solar albino of Ireland is (far) too low for solar PV to be effective. Things of this nature. Engineering things around energy generation and the physics of how a grid works. If you don't understand these things, you are throwing darts at a dart board when you try to provide analysis of various types of industrial infrastructure.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Do you honestly think that the very detailed understanding of cooling systems that you have has anything in common with the popular opinion that datacenters use lots of water?

Also, you are arguing jargon...and data centers use completely closed loop designs where it makes sense (very cheap power) and use what you describe where it makes sense (with more expensive power and cheaper water). Finally, nothing you said disproves that there is a significant propaganda effort to demonize datacenters by a foreign power.

hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Those are not scientists. They also compute GDP.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
That's the thing, the popular impression is that this is the case. But if you read what scientists actually wrote/said you would realize that what science says and what activists and journalists claim science says are quite different. That's why its almost impossible for a journalist to get a quote from a scientists on this topic anymore. Its also why there are almost no scientists who are members of "green" political entities (eg Sierra Club) anymore. Did you see a quote from a scientist in this article? When was the last time you saw one?
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Near Vancouver.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Which is most of Ireland's economy. I am fine with pulling the plug on them. They are not. I mean, who wants to lose 2/3rd of their GDP overnight?
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Objectively no, 23% of nothing is nothing. Ireland has no industry. Their grid is smaller than a major city's grid. That this is 23% says a lot more about the size of the Irish grid and their lack of industry than it does about how much energy a datacenter uses.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
The vast majority of the anti-datacenter movement is funded by the CCP. That's why it is so lacking in facts. Most datacenters use closed loop cooling. That means it doesn't consume water for anything more than the toilets and water fountains. Yet this talking point pops up in almost every article on the topic. Part of the reason you are seeing closed door meetings now is because leaders know that the public is profoundly misinformed on this topic. It doesn't help when AOC is waving a jar of dirty water as if it is proof of something.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
That opinion should be informed by facts and data. This opinion isn't really informed by anything except scientifically illiterate propaganda. That's the problem. Journalists larping as experts in something that they have absolutely no expertise or even the basic scientific background to understand. The amount of misinformation on topics surrounding energy generation is absolutely criminal and journalists are far and away the biggest spreaders of misinformation on this topic. If I could, I would make a journalist without scientific or engineering credentials talking about this topic a felony on par with murder. After all, they are causing significant amounts of misery in the 3rd world with their lies.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Credibility is a thing. Articles like this burn it quite quickly. It really is past time that the scientific community needs to make a public statement rejecting these types of "journalists".
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
Sure, $1B for the plant and $19B for the lawyers. Korea and China build them in 4 years for about $1B each. This is entirely self-inflicted by people who are completely scientifically illiterate.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
The rest of Europe sued Ireland to get them to stop being a tax haven. Ireland basically refuses to do so. If they did, most of their economy evaporates overnight (and the US government gets a lot more tax revenue). Ireland's economy is basically 2 tax shelters in a trench coat.
hunterpayne··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
That's 7x the cost that I pay in the Pacific NW. Where are you?
hunterpayne··on After 7 years in production, Scarf has reluctantly moved away from Haskell
"If there were a super-efficient hammering machine, it could be better to figure out ways to use nails to replace screws in designs than to hold onto screws just for nostalgia's sake."

How about for the sake of the bridge continuing to stand? Or is that not a good enough reason for the accountants?

hunterpayne··on After 7 years in production, Scarf has reluctantly moved away from Haskell
I can't even describe how much I dislike SBT.
hunterpayne··on After 7 years in production, Scarf has reluctantly moved away from Haskell
Just to put it in perspective, most Scala programmers rejected Scala3 before it was even written. The Scala team, in their infinite wisdom with a collective 2 years of professional programming under their belt knew better. Nobody switched and Scala2 has been slowly dying with their neglect ever since.

PS The Scala team should have been fixing their type inference engine which lacked some important features and needed a better (Horn clause based) architecture. They did a complete rewrite instead.

hunterpayne··on After 7 years in production, Scarf has reluctantly moved away from Haskell
Python is preferred because Python programmers are cheaper than other languages. Not because of any sort of technical advantages. Its literally the worse performing programming language in popular use. And it uses invisible characters in its syntax. Truly, it is the VHS of our industry.
hunterpayne··on After 7 years in production, Scarf has reluctantly moved away from Haskell
javac doesn't really do a whole lot. Consequently, whatever compile time you are complaining about would be worse with any other compiled language. Most optimization work in Java happens at runtime.
hunterpayne··on After 7 years in production, Scarf has reluctantly moved away from Haskell
"proving code correct has been a research topic at some point."

It has been an area of active research for 40 years. But almost all the research returned the null result, meaning that the program proving didn't improve code quality (basically it didn't work). Yet somehow a group of programmers, usually fresh out of academia falls for program proving each generation. Strong types do really help but you need a good compiler which is sometimes lacking in the real work cough Scala cough. The problem with strong types and program proving is that the juice just isn't worth the squeeze meaning the extra time taken doesn't result in reduced debugging time or improved code quality. I don't think that changes with LLMs. It just exposes the flaws more quickly.

hunterpayne··on Successful companies go blind
Yes, take a look at the idea of "luxury political beliefs" for depth into this idea.
hunterpayne··on Successful companies go blind
They were trained on the output of Reddit mostly. Its a miracle they even work at all given that.
hunterpayne··on War Atlas: An interactive cartography of every named war in human history
Again, you are confusing causalities (wounded and dead) with KIA (just the dead). That's why you are getting such different numbers. Its a pretty easy mistake to make and there are lots of media reports that make the same mistakes.

PS Also, some numbers count civilians and others just count military. And usually civilian dead > military dead in most wars.

hunterpayne··on War Atlas: An interactive cartography of every named war in human history
You are counting wounded (as in missing limbs). The map is only counting deaths.
hunterpayne··on War Atlas: An interactive cartography of every named war in human history
Sigh, because certain civilizations wrote things down more than others. Also, some environments don't lend themselves to preserving things, others are. These will naturally create biases because if you are studying somewhere wet, almost nothing not made of stone will survive, even and especially things that are written upon. In the desert, things will be preserved for centuries, including things made of clay, leather or paper.
hunterpayne··on War Atlas: An interactive cartography of every named war in human history
China is the one exception actually. India, Africa and the New World civilizations didn't really like focusing on the past and didn't record it. Europe and China did. In China that's probably about the strength of the bureaucracy. In Europe its probably more about kings establishing legitimacy.
hunterpayne··on Why skilled workers come to Germany and then leave again
You probably have a different definition of programmer than me. Yours seem to be someone who uses a computer.
hunterpayne··on Why skilled workers come to Germany and then leave again
Dude, software itself is written in English, not just English but it is most often (but not always) encoded in a character set that is English specific (can't even do French). The docs for every single platform, API and language are in English. You can get translations for some stuff and auto-translate the rest. But you can't even file a bug without English. The people you know probably don't write software, they are probably using computers to scam people and deploy software written by others to aid in that.
hunterpayne··on Why skilled workers come to Germany and then leave again
Wow, what a take...that says a lot about you and nothing at all about the US. I would guess that you are actually your own worst enemy.
← PreviousPage 8 of 33Next →