How do you reconcile that with incompleteness and undecidability results?
274 karma · joined August 25, 2026
How do you reconcile that with incompleteness and undecidability results?
Where is the net benefit people keep talking about when they claim productivity gains are obvious because "more code faster, can't you see?"
The original sales pitch from the major player in this technology hype cycle is "cure cancer, fix global warming, take over the economy". Not "more LOC".
What do you mean by oversell? And why do you think the general public would be more apt to understand "distinct embryonic progenitor lineages" than "two organs"?
What exactly is the problem here? You think medical researcher are using medial nomenclature wrong?
Honestly write a paper about it then.
https://faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzPapers/USAconscious...
You ought to learn some advanced mathematics to avoid making such absurd claims as "mathematics is too simple to model complex physics"
Pray tell what parts of physics are too complicated for mathematics
Language is fun!
EU:
1.1 million homeless people https://www.feantsa.org/files/Themes/Overview/2025/ex_summar...
Divided by a population of 451,990,314 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_European_U...
= 0.00243
US:
745,652 homeless people https://www.huduser.gov/portal/sites/default/files/pdf/2025-...
Divided by a population of 341,784,857 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta...
= 0.00218
It's all vibes, and the numbers contradict the vibes. There's 30 years of literature trying to explain the "productivity paradox" where we can't see any excess productivity driven by computer technology. Lots of FOMO, no hard data. For an entire generation. And people come here every day and say stuff like you just said and they really seem to think that "this time is different".
Turns out productivity growth stalled after the 1960s and has been very low ever since. No one can properly explain why. One thing stands out: investment in compute drives economic growth, but crucially doesn't demonstrably increase productivity either of labor or capital, or total factor productivity.
What I suspect is happening is: computers and software drive wealth concentration. 60 years on from the first general commercial computer, IBM 360, the entire industry has been driven by redistributing wealth towards an ever diminishing number of public companies.
With that perspective, what is happening with LLMs seems to fall right into the 6 decade pattern. I'm still in the middle of reading the 2 dozen papers or so I found about it so far but it has been fascinating.
They are trying to reframe the fact that their software doesn't do what they promised in the sales pitch as the proverbial "feature, not a bug".
It's usually the first step I take when writing research. I don't even read the analysis, just go straight for the papers.
They usually provide me with very relevant seminal papers and I can then easily expand from the bibliography in those papers.
It basically solves discoverability, whereas in the past I would spend days and would need to ask colleagues and librarians for help, to achieve what I can get in minutes now.
But again, I value the actual output of the LLMs at bellow zero factually wise because I need to check everything they say if I want to internalize it and use it for any end. Pointing me to sources is the perfect use case. Really, I cannot emphasize enough how little I trust the text LLMs produce, I actively avoid reading it because I really don't want to risk ingesting spurious information that I might later repeat or rely on for any reason.
Also, the SPR is a complex system made up of several locations where salt massifs have been drilled and hollowed out in the shape of highly specified storage caves.
There are requirements for pumping throughput for example, and some of the concerns regarding operational life and the dozens of partial drawdowns these caves have been subjected to, relate to them loosing the ability to quickly discharge oil.
In a word: it's complicated. I encourage looking up technical documentation online, super easy to find using 'filetype:pdf'. There are a lot of details involved in building, running, and assurances required from the SPR storage system.
From what I found out, turns out the question of SPR design and operational limits is a complex issue to say the least. The SPR is a big system composed of many sub-systems and there are entangled legal, policy, technical issues at play. Interesting stuff!
It is quantifiable: several mathematical objects and categories people invented to do symbolic computation in letters and published papers are somehow very useful to model and understand data from physical measurements of reality.
I highly recommend reading the "Unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics" essay by Wigner:
https://www.hep.upenn.edu/~johnda/Papers/wignerUnreasonableE...
I think you might have meant hermeneutics, in the sociological sense of 'subjective interpretation'?
I'd like to add: we can't know a priori what will be needed to be known and what can safely remain behind an abstraction you just use.
That is revealed when our mental models grind against reality. Avoiding that friction at all costs is a problem because it will happen and you'll be unprepared when it becomes unavoidable.
Trusting some abstractions that have earned it but not all is how we deal with it. Limit your focus, and adapt. If you just trust all abstractions thrown in front of you until something breaks irreparably, you will be (person or organization) between a rock and a hard place and without any knowledge or skill on how to get out of that predicament.
That to me is the biggest risk in accepting the fallacy of general automation.
Software could be so much simpler and more reliable. There's so much bloat that is necessary to solve problems created by bloat. I hope we find our way out of this mess sooner rather than later. I'd hate for entire generations to suffer the current state of software whereas the theoretical understanding necessary to make things better was produced very early in the history of programmable computers.
Analysis and any artifacts are all handcrafted by me. I mean, that is the work. I have never seen papers or code as an outcome. What I want is to learn and enable other to learn. That I can only get from doing the work myself.
Also, (2011)
Besides the circularity in saying that a cultural shift happened because something changed, Investment Banking is a thing since at least 1932 when the Glass-Steagall act was passed to enforce separation of concerns between "commercial banks" and "investment banks".
Venture capital dates from at least the 1950s:
The Venture Capital Revolution https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.15.2.145
"The first true venture capital firm was American Research and Development (ARD), established in 1946 by MIT President Karl Compton, General Georges F. Doriot"
As for Leveraged Buyouts, I highly recommend this analysis of 2000 cases done in 1993 which is far from any categorical conclusions on LBOs being a straightforward phenomenon that can be explained away in four sentences.
The Determinants of Leveraged Buyout Activity: Free Cash Flow vs. Financial Distress Costs https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1993.tb05138.x
It explicitly asks:
1. Do LBOs create wealth, or do they merely redistribute wealth?
2. Does the debt taken on in LBOs cause problems in periods of economic distress?
My point being essentially: don't hand wave historical analysis away. Get into it, read the papers, and the primary sources. History is fascinating and full of interesting questions about why things have come to be how they are in society. Whenever I feel intrigued by some historical question, and I decide to question the facile explanations that come to mind, I am endlessly fascinated by how complex and nuanced things are, and by how much analysis has been published starting out with the same questions as I asked myself.
What is the actual point then? The whole thing feels very out of touch with any underlying reality. The only thing the author reports to doing is downloading, installing and running some code? I agree with the criticism. It is a self congratulatory exercise that has no utility value whatsoever, a point driven home by the solicitation at the end. Like we should be dazzled by the analytic skills of someone who can't understand how his tooling knowledge should be congruent to a real domain to be at all relevant, let alone useful.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/02/how-mckins...
History shows profit maximizing behavior in letters dating to 1900 BCE Egypt and 1800 BCE Anatolia by Assyrian merchant houses.
I appreciate the analysis you're making, again, but it is low resolution. There's a lot more nuance to what you're saying and it definitely doesn't come down to MBA graduates in the past few decades.
The consultancy-private equity complex for example is a big part of the shift in American culture after "Greed is Good" was said out loud in the 1980s. Why this cultural shift happened? "Because MBAs" is not as much of an answer as it is bar talk simplistic hand waving to end a conversation and change subject.