HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hwbehrens

1,437 karma · joined October 10, 2019

https://behrens.dev

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/hwbehrens; my proof: https://keybase.io/hwbehrens/sigs/dLHJ81Px5e89QVjFDYNRo6_ogUJozHWtgGR9MK3AYQQ ]

submissionscomments
hwbehrens··on Copilot is closing
I typically open the comments first before I read the article, so that I can more easily preserve the link between content and discussion by opening the article from the comments page.

Thank you for limiting my "Nooooo..." to only 5 'o's.

hwbehrens··on America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
In case you are wondering what this does (like I was), Wikipedia states "This bill is designed to solve [American dependence on China] by reducing reliance on Chinese manufacturing of semiconductors and increasing America's scientific and technological achievements."

Basically, it allocates a bunch of money for supply chain and production improvements.

hwbehrens··on GitHub incident: 2022/03/24
My meter was working perfectly until I read the parent comment, at which point it measured off the scale and promptly broke.
hwbehrens··on Show HN: Lunar XDR Brightness control
Here is a nice little discussion about this exact topic:

http://talkingplants.blogspot.com/2019/09/botanic-or-botanic...

It seems to be a historical and cultural artifact?

hwbehrens··on Zotero 6
By default, you can use Zotero without logging in, which will cause it to keep everything locally. It's not obvious how you might go about partially syncing to the cloud, however.

In practice, though you shouldn't store the SQLite in a cloud sync service, setting up a symbolic link for the backing PDFs in e.g. Dropbox works quite well and gives you more control over your data syncing. Then, you only need to rely on their cloud for the paper titles and metadata.

hwbehrens··on Show HN: Just Launched an App for Dads
I like the idea, and it's definitely an under-served market. One comment off the bat: it's not at all clear to me what is the division between the free version and the "Grow" tier. I might be in the minority on this, but the conspicuous absence left me with a feeling of "What's the catch?"

I won't start using an app that doesn't let me do anything useful without paying, and I'm not going to sign up for a service if I don't know what I'm paying for, so I always look for that information up front before I even install.

hwbehrens··on Moderna’s HIV vaccine has officially begun human trials
I am only moderately not a biologist, but this seems essentially correct -- vaccines are trying to address false negatives, but allergies are (in theory) caused by false positives. The mechanics of T cell training in the thymus for self/nonself discrimination are only partially understood, but any approach to rewrite antigen recognition would be (A) extremely risky, by potentially inducing massive autoimmune effects if anything went wrong, and (B) much more impactful for e.g. organ transplantation than allergic response.
hwbehrens··on Music subscriber market shares Q2 2021
My wife and I share a single Spotify account, so when she's listening, I switch to the free tier of Amazon Music. I wonder if that counts toward that 13%?
hwbehrens··on I automated my job over a year ago and haven't told anyone
> People need work to feel fulfilled.

While you're likely to get skewered for this line, I think it's because of a mismatch in vocabulary that is being ignored. The "work" in antiwork is usually referring to paid employment, but it seems that you're using it more akin to fulfilling accomplishment. I agree with you on the whole that people need to feel that they are making a positive impact on their surroundings to feel satisfaction.

Maybe that comes from paid employment, or volunteer work, or hobbies, or social interactions. A street preacher, a stay at home parent, an ancient cave painter, a bricklayer, and a software architect might all feel equally satisfied by their work, irrespective of the value placed on that work by their society.

In fact, I would argue that the (professed) goals of antiwork are aligned with your view -- people should be free to pursue the work they personally find the most fulfilling, rather than the most profitable.

hwbehrens··on B-CORE slab. Honeycomb like construction panel
Moisture interactions are usually a key consideration for nearly all building materials, but it doesn't seem to be considered here at all. They mentioned space a lot, but there's not a lot of water in space...

What structural component is this meant to replace? It's called a "slab" but I can't see it being used to replace a concrete slab; even if it were stainless, I recall from that 1000-year house discussion that ground contact corrodes metal quite quickly.

hwbehrens··on Cost of Attrition
The parent's loyalty isn't to the company, it's to their direct reports (I assume). After you've been shielding people from the shitstorm for long enough, it can feel very difficult to fold up your umbrella and leave. Even if it's strictly better for you, it might violate your utilitarian instincts or personal ethics.

Of course, companies know this and use it as one of the many tools to suppress wages.

hwbehrens··on World ocean temperatures in 2021 were the hottest ever recorded
I downvoted your parent comment not because I didn't catch your meaning, but because I didn't think it contributed meaningfully to the conversation (basically, a throw-away 'ha ha' comment).

Elaborating on your perspective on the situation, sharing how it's affected your behavior or though processes, or engaging others in discussion would have produced a more substantive contribution.

I am very sensitive to HN sliding into a 'Reddit, but for nerds' situation where facile comments dominate the conversation and the signal-to-noise ratio is unbearably low.

Looking at your other comments, in general you do a pretty good job of holding back the tide -- please don't take this as a general comment against you, but more as a signpost for others.

hwbehrens··on U.S. surgeons transplant pig heart into human patient
If pigs (or any animal) broaden the compatibility to other organs, what are the ethical implications for raising them with the intention to harvest their organs, if any?

On one hand, we already raise pigs to kill and eat routinely, and (mostly) people don't care - is this any different than say, buying a pig heart at the market to eat?

On the other hand, it does somehow feel different to me, perhaps because sharing organs somehow humanizes the pigs by emphasizing our similarity? I'm not entirely sure from where my hesitation stems.

I'm curious if anyone else read this story with mixed reactions.

hwbehrens··on Make the internet yours again with an instant mesh network
> they're impossible to shut down

They're impossible to shut down without (potentially) affecting innocent bystanders. If they don't care, they absolutely can and do shut down towers.

In this case, if they judge anyone broadcasting or using this network as subversive, then there are no bystanders, only accomplices. And, thanks to the tyranny of the inverse square law, it becomes much easier to sniff out broadcasters/uplinks as well.

The easiest way to mitigate this is to do both -- rebroadcast a cell connection over WiFi, and do so intermittently and in varying locations to complicate triangulation.

hwbehrens··on How to read research paper, textbook, long text content?
As a counterexample, this [0] was a paper that I read and summarized for some colleagues a while back. It's fairly related to my area of expertise, so I didn't find it too bad -- maybe a couple of hours to grok it and do a write-up.

However, among my colleagues (all very talented in their own unrelated areas) it generated a fair amount of consternation, because although they had a week to read it, none of them felt like they had a good grasp of it until after I had presented it. The key takeaways that had jumped out at me immediately were lost in the noise.

Whether or not a week is the right time, I can definitely empathize with taking more than a day to evaluate a paper, particularly in an area not very near to your own as there might be a lot of missing background to fill in. In contrast, my PhD advisor could flip through a paper in 30 seconds and pick up the key points it took me an hour to extract. In that sense, I really think that reading papers is a skill that can be trained.

[0]: https://drops.dagstuhl.de/opus/volltexte/2020/13109/pdf/LIPI...

hwbehrens··on Autistic people challenge preconceived ideas about rationality
It also ignores that if you booked a trip to a place, you likely did so because you want to go to that place. Thus, if you were forced to cancel your trip due to a conflict, it is implicitly more likely that you would book a trip there again in the future - a rain check, essentially.

If the question was "Which of these trips would you like to pay for twice?", then it's immediately obvious that the cheaper trip should be cancelled.

hwbehrens··on Kinesis Advantage 360
You might also check out the Dygma Raise, which follows a similar vein as the Moonlander but keeps the staggered layout.
hwbehrens··on SARS-CoV-2 infects human adipose tissue and elicits an inflammatory response
> probably the same thing

These things, which are usually things like diabetes, blood sugar problems, high blood pressure, elevated cortisol and so on, do correlate with poorer COVID outcomes.

My understanding is that, even when you control for these factors, outcomes for obese patients are still below what we would expect to see. This means that there is still a contributing factor that we haven't considered yet, and the parent study hypothesizes one possible reason.

hwbehrens··on Do you ever avoid submitting something on HN so devs won't ruin it?
> I thought we were supposed to have each other's back,

There are 3 to 4 million devs in the US alone -- with a sample of that size, you'll get the full spectrum of people. Heck, you'd probably find some that like that the dislikes were removed. From their perspective, by blocking your extension they're actually making the world a better place.

It's shades of grey all the way down.

hwbehrens··on This shouldn't have happened: A vulnerability postmortem
> It is also hard to convince people to do a ground up rewrite of code that is seemingly working fine.

I think this is an understatement, considering that it's a core cryptographic library. It appears to have gone through at least five audits (though none since 2010), and includes integration with hardware cryptographic accelerators.

Suggesting a tabula rasa rewrite of NSS would more likely be met with genuine concern for your mental well-being, than by incredulity or skepticism.

hwbehrens··on Ask HN: Are Indeed, LinkedIn the go-to places for exploring new jobs?
> On the resume part, fill up your resume/LinkedIn profile.

I've been told the opposite -- in the recruiter view on LinkedIn, they can only see your 3 most-recent positions, and they almost never expand the fold to see the rest. Thus, it's critical to curate those.

For example, let's say you previously worked at BigCorp, but left to pursue your startup idea (Startup A). In the meantime, you've consulted at another startup (Startup B), and you're working at SmallCorp to make the ends meet until your idea takes off.

You'd be better off listing StartupA, SmallCorp, and BigCorp (or StartupA, StartupB, and BigCorp) as compared with StartupA, StartupB, and SmallCorp, since only the most recent three jobs will be shown, and recruiters tend to more heavily weight BigCorp signals.

hwbehrens··on How death rates from Covid-19 differ between vaccinated and unvaccinated
The denominator of the death rate is not COVID cases, it is total population. If the number of COVID cases drops, even if mortality remains constant, then the death rate will also see a concomitant drop. When compared to a graph of the daily cases, the pattern in the parent post essentially matches.
hwbehrens··on How not to sort by average rating (2009)
While I agree with the author in principle, I think there is an implicit criteria they ignore, which is the intuitive correctness from the perspective of the user.

Imagine a user chooses "Sort by rating", and they subsequently observe an item with an average 4.5 ranking above a score of 5.0 because it has a higher Wilson score. Some portion of users will think "Ah, yes, this makes sense because the 4.5 rating is based on many more reviews, therefore its Wilson score is higher." and the vast, vast majority of users will think "What the heck? This site is rigging the system! How come this one is ranked higher than that one?" and erode confidence in the rankings.

In fact, these kinds of black-box rankings* frequently land sites like Yelp into trouble, because it is natural to assume that the company has a finger on the scale so to speak when it is in their financial interests to do so. In particular, entries with a higher Wilson score are likely to be more expensive because their ostensibly-superior quality commands (or depends upon) their higher cost, exacerbating this effect due to perceived-higher margins.

So the next logical step is to present the Wilson score directly, but this merely shifts the confusion elsewhere -- the user may find an item they're interested in buying, find it has one 5-star review, and yet its Wilson score is << 5, producing at least the same perception and possibly a worse one.

Instead, providing the statistically-sound score but de-emphasizing or hiding it, such as by making it accessible in the DOM but not visible, allows for the creation of alternative sorting mechanisms via e.g. browser extensions for the statistically-minded, without sacrificing the intuition of the top-line score.

* I assume that most companies would choose not to explain the statistical foundations of their ranking algorithm.

hwbehrens··on Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood
> Owning the name of a common adjective seems dubious to me. It's like naming your company "big."

Or "Uber"?

hwbehrens··on The untold story of the world’s biggest nuclear bomb
Actually, one recent work on n-body gravitational methods found that "nuclear explosives remain an indispensable element of the planetary defense portfolio." [0]

In particular, although these dispersion methods (as you pointed out) don't typically reduce the impact energy to zero, they offer a roughly 2 order-of-magnitude decrease in impact energy while requiring only month-scale warning.

In contrast, diversion techniques which can reduce the impact energy to 0 (e.g. by shifting the impactor to 'miss' our planet) can require decade-scale to accomplish their goal.

[0]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009457652...

hwbehrens··on New MacBook Pro has first ‘DIY-friendly’ battery replacement design since 2012
Wow, I totally forgot about that period. I recall that I used to plug in my laptop when I arrived at my desk, then remove the battery to ensure that it was running exclusively on wall power in an effort to improve battery health. I never did have to replace that battery...
hwbehrens··on Python 3.10
I'm personally most interested in the typing and debugging improvements, but I imagine most people will be looking forward to the pattern matching (case statements).
hwbehrens··on Pay Transparency Is Coming
> Why is transparency a problem here?

> The person doing orders of magnitude more work is probably only getting paid 10% more.

You've answered your own question. Transparency is undesirable from an employer's perspective because it encourages a closer alignment between compensation and productivity, and the mismatch between these currently serves as a significant profit advantage to the employer.

If I can get 1000% more work from someone, and pay them 10% or 100% more, I am highly incentivized to prevent them from becoming aware of the value of their efforts, because they might realize their (relative) exploitation.

At the same time, the less-productive worker also benefits from this lack of transparency because they get ~90% of the pay for 10% of the work. Disrupting the status quo would not be economically rational for them either.

Thus, only the small fraction of underpaid, overworked people benefit from increased transparency, and it is not surprising to find that the majority would resist its implementation.

hwbehrens··on China plans to break up Ant's Alipay and force creation of separate loans app
> The fact that even Beijing isn't taking that path should show how extreme it is.

I think they absolutely are taking that path with their recent push towards the eYuan. If they want to replace Alipay with their nationalized, centralized system, I imagine the steps would look roughly like:

1. Create eYuan (Done)

2. Disrupt other solutions (We are here)

3. Disallow other solutions

4. Done

hwbehrens··on Court issues permanent injunction in Epic vs. Apple case
> Apple could decide they don't give a shit about native Mac games

I think it's possible to make persuasive argument that this already took place around the time that they killed OpenGL support and/or refused to allow Vulkan support. Requiring a proprietary API that only works on a tiny subset of gaming devices* seems like they've already made their position on this topic very clear.

* I'm excluding mobile devices here since mobile games were called out as a different market in the parent comment.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →