HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hxa7241

932 karma · joined November 25, 2008

random DNA unit, human, XY configuration -- http://www.hxa.name/notes/
submissionscomments
hxa7241··on Reasonable Anger In Europe Over Ridiculous Copyright Extension
Well, yes, disavowal is too strong: the USA will just try to reduce (international) IP. The main point is the turnaround.
hxa7241··on Reasonable Anger In Europe Over Ridiculous Copyright Extension
The USA will find the weapon of IP law etc. it has been building all over the world turned against it.

One would expect China and India to follow USA commercial practice and use the established structures of IP. But USA-IP is not intended to be good economics in the real sense, it is supposed to benefit the USA. When the USA is a net importer, it will be the loser. It will start to disavow international IP.

But IP is fairly dumb in an information economy so it must die out in the not too distant future anyway.

hxa7241··on Idea Dump | willgrant.org
Calling it a 'dump' seems rather downbeat (a dump is "a site for depositing garbage"). Something like idea corner' would be more encouraging.
hxa7241··on Clojure vs Scala - Anecdote
I have a comparison too: a rather different kind, but no less reasonable for this sort of game, and with all source available -- http://www.hxa.name/minilight/#comparison

It says that languages do not vary by factors of 10. Considered as pure 'lexical structure' the range is about 2 or 3 between small and large. Anything more than that must have some reason -- most probably library support.

Of course, library support is important, and quite fair to be compared in lines -- it represents real work that has to be done. But it seems worth trying to distinguish it as a library matter -- or whatever else.

hxa7241··on Programming is just like writing
As for philosophy, the pedigree is certainly there. Philosophy gave rise to, and helped develop, logic, and logic, in the early 20th century did rather give rise to programming. You could easily make an unbroken line of thought. So there certainly is something significant in common. But software is essentially about practical application.

Programmers seem to have difficulty in simply saying that programming is most like engineering design. It is probably because most people are unfamiliar with what engineering design is -- they perhaps think it only about material, or about absolute control. Engineering is at root logical and creative -- in a particular kind of combination, and for practical purpose. That is just like software.

hxa7241··on Programming is just like writing
They want to emphasise a point. But think of what is indispensible. If the program was unreadable -- maybe the source is lost -- you still have a running, useful, device. But if you do not have execution, you do not really have software anymore.

Software as function -- for execution -- and software as representation -- for humans -- must be pretty much equally important, in the end. But surely the key constraint, the definitive matter is what software does, what it is as an artifact. We can communicate about anything, but software is software because it performs some action.

hxa7241··on Programming is just like writing
No, it is not really. To adapt a related note http://www.hxa.name/notes/note-hxa7241-20101218T2158Z.html from a while ago:

What makes writing writing is what it is used for. Writing is used for communicating between humans. It only works the way it does because of what is on the other end of it -- another person.

And that is why software must be different. Software is different from writing because its (ultimate, essential) purpose is different (and particular): it is not communication, it is (engineering) design. It works the way it does because it is for constructing an artifact.

When you look at software, what you see is not language, it is a machine.

To represent a machine requires a particular kind of structure. A machine has a particular form, and a description or notation that captures it must reflect that form. That form seems to be a recursive, hierarchical regularity -- a nestable scaffolding. And a machine has a core of objective logical rigidity.

Writing lacks this hierarchical logical structure. It communicates illogically, by allusion, impression, etc. Its use meant it never evolved any other way.

Instead, software must have this logical structure. The term 'programming language' is perhaps a source of the confusion, now unfortunately established. Software does not communicate to a machine, it embodies the machine.

hxa7241··on How to Design Classes (in Ruby, Python, Java or any OOP)
No, this is quite right. Classical music is as bloated, heavy-handed, and decadent as Java. Good music is found in the 16th century and earlier, and in the 20th century and later. We can see this maps to software: good ideas are to be found in the 70s and earlier, and in some hoped-for new era yet to come . . .
hxa7241··on Why To Write Tests For Your Code
> In a way, using tests to check code is like designing two trucks and having them pull against each other; if nothing breaks, you know they both work.

('bad metaphorical thinking' Dijkstra alert)

This is wrong. If the tests pass, it is entirely possible that both the original code and the tests are faulty.

hxa7241··on Copyright Infringement and Theft – The Difference
> Humans didn't evolve with 'information' in the sense that we're using it now. What information we did have (e.g. where the enemy is, how to cut stone and build bridges) was guarded either by force or by complexity of replication.

That seems to be an anachronistic view through the eyes of a modern myth of commerce. One would expect information was shared. Proto-humans who could not or would not share information -- hence crippling co-operation -- would have been out-competed by those that did, so de-selected by evolution.

What is more central to being human than language, that is, communication of information? It did not evolve by guarding it and restricting it.

> we've created the Intellectual Property construct in an effort to apply what we think of as 'natural' rules to intangible things.

That is really quite distant from fact or sense. IP was created as a means of censorship and/or monopoly. And the idea that IP is somehow 'natural' is completely upside-down. Intangible/abstract objects are quite natural on their own: they have their own natural qualities distinct from material objects -- it is being freely and infinitely communicable and copyable that makes them exactly what they naturally are.

hxa7241··on Copyright Infringement and Theft – The Difference
How about educating these corporations about changing business models to suit changed circumstances?

The economic -- i.e. overall -- effects of piracy are quite likely good for the public.

hxa7241··on Copyright Infringement and Theft – The Difference
You are not thinking of the harmful effects of copyright. The mechanism of copyright, by definition, is to restrict the flow of information. This is exactly what you do not want in an information economy.

First, because the cost of that restriction is effectively magnified. When information was in paper books, it was difficult to copy. Copyright restricted copies, but since people could not make copies it did not make much difference. But now information is digital the cost of copying is practically zero. That means the restrictions of copyright stops people realising a large benefit that would otherwise be available.

Second, the most vital ingredient in production of new information seems most likely not extra monetary incentive, but other information. And the fact that information is infinitely copyable amplifies its value. A single amount of money can pay for only one piece of information production. But a single amount of information can contribute, through copies, to an unlimited number of pieces of information production.

This is the funny thing. Copyright really only works with products that are substantially non-abstract, non-informational. When you have an economy that really is all informational, copyright does not actually make sense: its intrinsic contradiction just becomes too self-destructive.

hxa7241··on What Your Old Graphing Calculator Says About Technology
There is a feedback aspect that this article does not seem to get.

> After all, the material hasn't changed (much), so if the calculators were good enough for us 10 or 15 years ago, they are still good enough to solve the math problems.

Technology changes the material: it changes what you think you need or want. You could almost say dialup internet was fine for viewing text web-pages -- why does it need to be faster? Broadband enabled web video -- which in turn spurred the need for broadband.

The calculator example looks a bit like a phone. If you took a phone from 2000 and one from 2007, they would look pretty similar. It is still a phone, is it not? We do not need something more, do we? And then the iPhone appeared.

> Here's the thing. Some technologies don't change all that quickly because we don't need them to. . . . Look at cars or power plants

Crikey! If you wanted to hit on two of the things we do most need to change, and have for decades, it might well be just those.

The whole article disturbs me a bit, actually, because it seems dangerously full of the anti/un-creative mindset. You will never invent anything if you just look at what you have and think of justifications for why everything is pretty much fine. You create by finding faults and imagining what you do not have. Look at those two calculator pics, and think of them as representing some part of the web now and in 2021. Scary? Well that is what it will be unless you get irritated and make some weird unexpected new stuff!

hxa7241··on Fastest sort of fixed length 6 int array
To be a little more speculative . . . if it is on GPU, is there some way of using rendering operations? The 'hidden-surface problem' in graphics has been described as basically a sorting problem: so represent each number as a triangle Z . . . well, maybe it would not be very fast, but you could do a few million at once!
hxa7241··on If Software Is Eating The World, Why Don't Coders Get Any Respect?
There is a big confusion here between personal credit and objective physical properties.

Software is 'eating the world' because it is the most super-efficient building material ever invented.

You could say the wheel 'ate the world', but not because each person making each wheel is a genius, but because of the general physical properties and value of roundness. The overall benefit is not a matter of individual credit or respect, it is a matter of physics.

We should be paying the total programming workforce for the total (personal) effort required, not the absolute (objective) 'value' returned. The excess of value is gain: you do not need to pay anyone, it is a free gift from physical reality.

Now, whether programmers' pay compares 'fairly' with anyone else is still an open question, but the physical facts of software being great stuff does not (or should not) seem to justify one side or the other.

hxa7241··on How to Never Miss Writing a Blog Post
I would think you need some kind of content strategy, more than tricks.

Get stimulus from various or particular kinds of things and respond to it. That is probably the best source I can think of.

Maybe keep notes of many/any ideas and add to them and rethink them over an indefinite period.

I have posted something every week for about 8 months now (missing only one week). They are idiosyncratic, but some are probably quite interesting -- two or three have appeared on HN.

hxa7241··on The patent system isn’t broken — we are
> [disclosure is] an important way the patent system encourages innovation, actually: it forces inventors to build alternative ways to do things

Are you sure it is not just a way of forcing people to waste effort making something different when there is a perfectly good solution ready to use? Is it not better to be building on things rather than around them? and having invention driven primarily by demand not by obstacles?

> Stop offering patent protection and there’s no more required disclosure -- all this stuff stays locked up as trade secrets

Are you sure it is not the likeliness of keeping the secret that dominates here? That is, if you think you can keep an invention secret for longer than a patent term, you will choose that instead of a patent -- since it will give you a longer monopoly. And if you think you cannot keep the secret, patent disclosure does not help anyone else that much, since the secret was going to leak anyway.

The supposed rational is one thing. Whether it actually works that way is another -- and there is no clear proof that it does work.

hxa7241··on Why software patents are not fixable
> Patents are a good idea.

That is overstating it. They are a reasonable idea, but it does not seem at all clear that anyone has ever proven them to be actually a good idea -- i.e. that they have a net benefit, even if they were properly realised and enforced.

hxa7241··on MoonScript - A programmer friendly language that compiles to Lua.
'Lua bytecode' does not really exist -- i.e. it has no public definition -- the developers can change it in any way at any time -- only the Lua language itself is 'defined'.
hxa7241··on Martin Fowler on Software Patents
It is not entirely clear that patents would help much in that.

If it is not possible to keep something secret, patents would only help if people otherwise really would keep inventions secret. But there are ways to gain even without secrecy -- first-mover advantage, etc. -- and inventors would be attracted to those rather than nothing at all.

If it is possible to keep something secret, then those motivated by the gains from patents would choose secrecy in preference, since secrecy is an even stronger monopoly.

hxa7241··on "We Really Don't Know How To Compute" - Sussman keynote at Strange Loop
It is, I believe, fairly well compressible: down to about 200MB (from about 800MB).

(I think I got this from the book 'Genomes' by Brown, 2002.)

hxa7241··on Do You Live In A Protected Freedom Zone?
This is a way of expressing what Kant said about lying and morality. A liar presumes the existence and practice of a moral rule against lying, but makes an exception of themself -- that is the only way their action makes sense and is profitable.

IP is a priori immoral because it fails moral universalisation. If we all shared what we produced freely, we would all gain (a thousandfold, a millionfold ...), and at no cost to each other. If we all had to be equally bound by restrictions and payments and legal action, we would all lose.

The only way IP, as a principle rather than pragmatically, can make sense is as an immoral intention.

(This is the funny thing about 'natural rights' arguments for IP: they all fail universalisation, trivially and obviously. It is odd they get much respect at all.)

And the actual practice does seem to follow the morality. Just as the article describes, where groups have power to choose, they tend to waive the rules for themselves, and just enforce them for everyone else.

hxa7241··on Intellectual Property Rights Same Advantages As Barbed Wire?
Here is a good quote for you:

"Economic analysis has come up short of providing either theoretical or empirical grounds for assessing the overall effect of intellectual property law on economic welfare." -- 'The economic structure of intellectual property law'; Landes, Posner; 2003. (Conclusion, p422, s3.)

Landes and Posner are the accepted orthodox authority on the subject, and even they are telling us that we do not even know if copyright is doing any good.

hxa7241··on Intellectual Property Rights Same Advantages As Barbed Wire?
Yes, but let's face the hard questions, but right questions, in favour of doing the obviously wrong thing just because it looks easy.
hxa7241··on Intellectual Property Rights Same Advantages As Barbed Wire?
Here is the ideal: we pay people for the time/effort/resources to create, then we all copy and use that product freely and unrestrictedly. Everyone gets compensated for any loss, and everyone has freedom to access all gain.

The idea of property really does not apply. It is the wrong way to think about the problem. We want new and better systems of organisation, but the restrictions of property are what we want to avoid if at all possible.

> You have no fundamental right to enjoy the innovations produced by others without compensating them.

That seems quite wrong; in fact the opposite is more like the truth. The form of a moral obligation is to put the interests of others before yourself. That is, to put it simply, you have a duty to help others. If others enjoy your products without compensating you, that is good -- it is pretty much what a moral act means.

Now, you might object that someone has sacrificed effort to produce, they must deserve something. But that adds something else: the idea of loss or harm, and this is precisely where IP/abstract-goods and property fundamentally diverge. Abstract goods can be used by any number of people without reducing anyone else's use or causing loss.

If you want to solve the problem you must see that thinking in terms of property is to make a mistake right at the beginning.

hxa7241··on Who holds the copyright to a picture taken by a monkey?
It is not about 'nature' as some mystical attribute. It is about the basic physical limitations of reality.

The restrictions instituted by normal property are grounded in the actual restrictions of physical reality. The restrictions instituted by 'intellectual property' have no such grounding.

> If I tell a guy my idea, and he implements it trivially with huge profit, then the loss is very real to me.

It is not real at all, and it justifies nothing.

If something is physically taken from you, you lose it -- whether there is any law or not. If someone else makes money, you lose nothing -- the idea of loss you present is entirely dependent on assuming there is a law supporting it. A law cannot be justified by itself; that is circular.

hxa7241··on Thomas Jefferson on Patents
The point is not quite that.

The point is not: they are not natural therefore they are wrong. It is: they are not natural, therefore they are not simply, automatically right -- they can have only a practical justification.

hxa7241··on Developer Lorem Ipsum
Surely something more like:

   int lorem( char* ipsum, int  dolor )
   {
      float amet = 0.0;

      for( int i = 0;  i < eiusmod;  ++i )
      {
         int consectetur = adipisicing( amet );
         tempor[ i ] += elit;
      }

      return sed * eiusmod;
   }
(-- variable names in latin: there's something to win friends and influence people.)
hxa7241··on The 'intellectual property' oxymoron
> Technically, "monopoly" is a misnomer when applied to IP

Whatever the technical rectitude of non-monopoly assertions, they really ought to sound fairly shady when one considers the very intent and mechanism of IP: to increase profits of the producer, by raising prices through restricting supply. IP is certainly supposed to quack like a duck.

hxa7241··on The 'intellectual property' oxymoron
Yes, that is wrong -- it seems covered by the ethics of lying/truth-telling (from Kant, it is contradictory: if lying were a universal rule, it would destroy the possibility of communication in general).

But IP is about more than just clear attribution. And clear attribution is not dependent on IP -- we can have it without the other IP features. So a justification of attribution is not sufficient to support IP too.

← PreviousPage 5 of 12Next →