HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hynek

819 karma · joined March 26, 2009

I’m a software engineer at an ISP and spend too much time on FOSS.

aspe:keyoxide.org:5KLULPTEPFVHZUBX2QRS4XM2M4

submissionscomments
hynek··on Don’t mock what you don’t own
Hey, I’m the author and happy to engage in constructive exchange with everyone who read the article and has thoughts or questions

(NB the full title is ‘“Don’t Mock What a You Don’t Own” in 5 Minutes’ the principle is super old and this article is just an explanation why it makes more sense than it sounds.)

hynek··on Don’t mock what you don’t own
Which is…precisely what the article is saying!?
hynek··on Don’t mock what you don’t own
So you haven’t made it past the second heading and already felt compelled to “disagree wholeheartedly”? The article is _precisely_ about the knee-jerk reaction you’re exhibiting and trying to explain why that decades old principles makes more sense than it seems.

Please search for “If you’re anything like me, that makes no sense! What else am I supposed to mock?” and read with an open mind.

hynek··on Which is not Posix
I'm super confused by the hostility of this comment. The TIL post was just a summary of a drama that almost removed which from debian and the lessons learned from it about the guarantees and portability of which (none), and how to prevent problems in the future.

You can freely choose that the problems don't apply to you, and you can be angry at POSIX and/or Debian for whatever happened or not as many others in this comment section. But I don't understand why you chose to write a belligerent comment as if any of it is the author's (yes me, but I didn't submit it to HN) fault or as if he is arguing in front of a committee to take it away from you.

As for Carlo Wood: https://savannah.gnu.org/projects/which links to http://www.gnu.org/software/which/ that in turn links to https://carlowood.github.io/which/. Maybe do your research if you want to be a pedant?

hynek··on Subclassing in Python Redux
I’m not 100% sure (and on my phone) but I think the idiomatic way would be to subclass https://docs.python.org/3/library/collections.abc.html#colle...
hynek··on Subclassing in Python Redux
I thought that from context it was clear that it means “Code sharing _via subclassing_ is a bad idea.” which the whole previous section tried to establish. I have clarified the sentence.
hynek··on Semantic Versioning Will Not Save You
That's not part of the article, but I indeed think that a process that (almost) nobody applies correctly, is not a good process. Telling people to just try harder is never the solution to anything.

I acknowledge the value of SemVer both here and in the article, but in the practical world it simply does not deliver the value that its proponents claim and users have to deal with it. The article is supposed to help with that.

hynek··on Semantic Versioning Will Not Save You
You lead with dunking on the author (yes, me) for describing a reality that you later acknowledge yourself. The article only says that SemVer in practice cannot be relied upon and describes ways how to deal with that fact of life. Nothing else.
hynek··on Waiting in Asyncio
https://glyph.twistedmatrix.com/2014/02/unyielding.html
hynek··on Waiting in Asyncio
A more charitable view is that they signify an API that evolved from callback-based APIs like Twisted over many years and made nicer APIs like curio or trio only possible (whose features/insights slowly feed back into asyncio but backward compat keeps the warts around).
hynek··on Pipenv: promises a lot, delivers very little
Yes, that’s why there’s multiple hashes per package.
hynek··on Python 3.7: Introducing Data Classes
It does: http://www.attrs.org/en/stable/examples.html#types
hynek··on On Conference Speaking
Only if they explicitly offer that. I've never got compensation for anything unless I got invited. And you only get invited if you've built a name for yourself.

Bigger conferences also usually offer financial aid that is always worth trying.

hynek··on On Conference Speaking
[author of the linked article here]

It’s obviously a matter of style, however I’d like to point out, that it’s not about extra work for me at all.

I probably spend as much time on my slides as you do (if not more), I just have a very different goal in mind and optimize for it relentlessly.

hynek··on On Conference Speaking
Kind of depends on how you define a “good speaker”, right? Your style and mine style are obviously very different (lots of it is also due to English being my third language of course) but people still have expressed that they consider me a good speaker.

It’s like with everything: talent or grind. Or both if you want to be an amazing speaker. :)

hynek··on On Conference Speaking
Eliud Kipchoge ran a marathon in 2:00:25. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
hynek··on On Conference Speaking
[author of the linked article here]

In peak irony, I’m actually considering to make it my next year’s talk. It’s too long for lots of people to read, but I think I could make an entertaining talk out of it.

hynek··on On Conference Speaking
[author of the linked article here]

I get bored while practicing (and it’s getting worse as I get better) but the audience changes everything for me. In the absence of special talents, plowing through boredom and practice anyway is what separates good talks from mediocre ones.

hynek··on On Conference Speaking
[author of the linked article here]

I’ll have to disagree here. Using PyCon US as an example since it ended recently:

1. My talk video has already been watched more than 650 times. I don’t think I had that many people in the room.

2. I rarely go to actual talks because as a European, being able to meet my American friends and being able to discuss things IRL is sadly a once-per-year issue. Open Spaces/BoFs are also more valuable IMHO by being present. IOW: now I’m back I’ve started to catch up by watching conf videos. :) As a speaker, I’d prefer people going to talks too of course. Last year I spoke to a 1/3 filled room and it sucked so hard I wasn’t sure I’ll submit another talk.

3. PyCon sells out. Always. It would be a pity to limit all the work to a small minority. Some great talk videos end up iconic too.

4. Plenty people can’t afford conferences at all. Be it money, job, or family responsibilities. Talk videos are a great way to democratize knowledge.

hynek··on On Conference Speaking
[author of linked article here]

Depends!

At PyCon US/EuroPython everybody pays by default and the money goes towards financial aid so as many people as possible can attend. As a speaker, you can also apply for finaid of course.

The bet is basically that people that are able to attend today are the speakers of tomorrow. And anecdotally, it’s working out quite fine!

I let my employer pay my way to PyCon US and EuroPython because I’d attend anyway. PyCon ZA is special, because it’s in Cape Town and I like to surf so I pay myself. :)

Other than that, if a conference wants me as a speaker, they have to pay for my travels and accommodation. I’m also a diva and ask for SkyTeam flights which at least gives me indirect benefits (status miles + segments towards my status).

I don’t have to take personal holidays because I work at a small company and being able to exchange myself professionally with other peers is critical to my growth as an employee.

All that said, you speak because you enjoy the experience. I also got to see Japan, Russia, Ukraine, … all places I wouldn’t have gotten to see! To make a living with it you’ve got to be famous/influential already.

hynek··on Using attrs for everything in Python
Hello, thank you for the rare nice words in this thread!

I got a bit hit by surprise by the submission of this article to HN (it’s like two weeks old now) so it caught me a bit off guard close before a new release and there’s some inconsistency between the GitHub README and the docs on RTD.

The version that’s on PyPI now <https://pypi.org/project/attrs/> has it as the first sentence after the first code sample anyone ever sees (and people still complained because the just don’t read :() and the new version <https://attrs.readthedocs.io/en/latest/> has a whole section around the example explaining attrs’ scope and ib/s: <https://attrs.readthedocs.io/en/latest/overview.html> (the new version also adds and promotes aliases that make more sense but that’s beyond the point).

I feel like I’ve really done my due here and I’ll have to accept that I can’t make everyone happy. :|

hynek··on Using attrs for everything in Python
http://attrs.readthedocs.io/en/latest/overview.html#on-the-a...
hynek··on Using attrs for everything in Python
http://attrs.readthedocs.io/en/latest/overview.html#on-the-a...
hynek··on Please fix your Python decorators
"Slow" is not what I read from the benchmarks tho. :) I prefer to avoid edge cases by default and optimize hotspots if necessary. Especially for stuff I publish on PyPI. Likewise I don't care what people do in internal projects. :) It's just frustrating if you install a lib and stuff blows up. :|
hynek··on Python 3 in 2016
The newer a pip, the more likely it is that it caches things for example. There a more things, I had long discussions with dstufft about it in the past.
hynek··on Python 3 in 2016
But you have to build those with its dependencies. And the best thing Go came up with is vendorizing.
hynek··on Python 3 in 2016
ATM it takes work to create a deployable artifact.

We package virtualenvs using fpm, others use Docker. But Go just spits out a single binary you can scp anywhere (the build process OTOH is more painful IMHO).

That’s why I’m highly curious about https://us.pycon.org/2016/schedule/presentation/2122/ .

hynek··on Python 3 in 2016
I would recommend to even use pyenv (https://github.com/yyuu/pyenv) that will allow you to install any Python version in your home directory (i.e. not fucking up your system installation).

If you maintain many FOSS libs like I do, together with tox it's priceless.

hynek··on Python 3 in 2016
That’s only true for people who are part of the community for a long time. Newcomers don’t understand what the fuss is about and why anyone would want to use Python 2.

My own Python bubble is more like what you described (although the mood is improving IMHO) but talking to newcomers is eye opening.

hynek··on Python 3 in 2016
Hm that’s unfortunate that it comes out that way. I thought I’m just acknowledging that people are agonizing over them and then explain why’s not a good metric.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →