HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

iamawacko

59 karma · joined June 8, 2023

submissionscomments
iamawacko··on Predictive policing software terrible at predicting crimes
This ignores two things, first of which is "Empirical research on the relationship between length of incarceration and recidivism is limited and insufficient for developing federal sentencing policy" [1]. There is no guarantee that any sentence that would at all be reasonable for the crime would reduce the rate, and in fact that study I cited did not find any deterrent effect for sentences less than 5 years.

The second part I feel you miss are the as many as 14,000 other people arrested for shoplifting. If 6,000 is less than 1/3, than there were about 20,000 arrests. Your "Criminals commit crimes, a lot" seems to ignore all the other people. Extending incarceration wouldn't just affect the repeat offenders, but would also lock a massive number of poor people. You say class is just a distraction, but the very articles you cite bring up poverty as a factor.

Bringing up the decrease in robbery rate in Ireland is also a bit misleading, as they had a much lower number of robberies per 100,000 people (about half the rate)[2][3] to begin with, as compared to the US (the subject of this article). That means fewer people are responsible for a higher percentage of the crime.

[1]https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-pu... [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/191235/reported-robbery-... [3] https://www.statista.com/statistics/191235/reported-robbery-...

iamawacko··on Moneyball Military: An Affordable, Achievable, and Capable Way to Deter China
I initially wrote a fairly long piece about why this particular article is wrong, but then I went and looked into who the Hoover Institute is. Its a conservative think tank that has Kissinger as a fellow, so the hawkish attitude, anti-socialism, and mildly misleading statements of political nature all make sense.

The assumption that the US will end up in direct conflict with China is, in my opinion, contradicted by the the Chinese tendency to stay away from wars and focus on economics. They have had only minor border skirmishes and small roles in counterinsurgency in their past 50 years of existence.

I also think that we are too far in for economic warfare to be effective. Any attempt to cut off China from the US will harm the US more than China. The Hoover Institute is partially responsible for the position we are in now, as many of the US politicians that acted to encourage manufacturing abroad were fellows. They are big on free markets, and the hands of the free market determined that low cost manufacturing abroad is of greater importance than US unipolarity.

I think another major point that the article ignores is that the transition towards a market economy from a planned economy was disastrous for the USSR. The Era of Stagnation came right after market reforms, and all of the ex-Soviet countries economies tanked after the fall of the USSR

iamawacko··on ‘World of Warcraft’ players trick AI-scraping website into publishing nonsense
I'd be interested in something like a blog post about this
iamawacko··on Apollo will close down on June 30th
I've found Lemmy to be a good reddit alternative. https://join-lemmy.org/
iamawacko··on Reddit is Fun will shut down on June 30th in response to Reddit API changes
I'm moving to Lemmy thanks to all this.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2