HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

iamdamian

1,140 karma · joined June 23, 2019

I want to make the web better.
submissionscomments
iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
> Gas heating is easily replaced by heat pumps, even in cold climates

This claim has been contested a few times in this thread below.

> Building and maintaining natural gas infrastructure to homes is expensive

Can you quantify this? How does this compare with the cost of replacing it all and powering it all with zero emissions power sources?

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
The issue is that I’ve been unable to find any convincing data showing that this will have meaningful impact relative to its cost.

This thread has a relevant discussion and citations: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35758192

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
That's a fine strategy, but practically speaking, if you're looking for a foot in the door, I'd start with something that doesn't anger more than half of your constituency.
iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
I'm not sure, but yes I could imagine the larger buildings being targeted by more regulations.
iamdamian··on Why did Google Brain exist?
Excellent, thank you.
iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
Based on the information you've provided, I don't think we can get rid of a whole percent, since that would require the entire country to completely get rid of gas stoves and also for their new electric stoves to be powered by something that does not produce emissions.

I know you'll disagree, but my take is that the upside (<1% savings over the course of, say, 30 years) is outweighed by the downside (lack of ability to cook or boil water during a power outage, far worse cooking experience).

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
I'm a little confused by this take.

Anyway, yes I'm a New Yorker and also rent.

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
These are common in New York and may even be required by residential building code: https://up.codes/viewer/new_york/irc-2018/chapter/15/exhaust...

(Note: I'm a New Yorker but not an expert in building code.)

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
I appreciate you digging up this information, this is exactly what's been lacking in press coverage of the issue.

If you're telling me that fully eliminating gas stoves in the U.S. (something that will not happen in our lifetimes and will come at great political and personal cost) is going to reduce U.S.-specific emissions by just 1%, I think I'm even more convinced that this regulation should not have been passed.

What am I missing?

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
Yes, but this regulation targets everyone in the state of New York, not just renters, and the research I've read seems to indicate that fume hoods protect against this indoor pollution.
iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
> but you don't really have an option if the only thing installed is a gas stove to heat your tea water or saute your onions...

A cheap electric kettle or standalone burner is an option, isn't it?

And doesn't the research indicate that fume hoods help regardless?

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
This regulation unfortunately targets the entire state of New York and includes not just NYC renters but also home owners.
iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
> Are you saying that if we got rid of all gas burning appliances in homes, that would not have much effect on climate change?

Yes. (Also, I welcome strong evidence to the contrary.)

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
I haven't seen evidence that this regulation will prevent the planet from being destroyed.

Also, personal health is not something that's generally regulated by the government, despite the potential to cause additional state spending.

iamdamian··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
This regulation feels quite frustrating to me, and several comments in this thread illustrate why.

This change is being promoted as a critical step in the fight against climate change. (See most news articles over the past two years covering this.)

But when you dig into the details, it seems like the regulation may not have much effect on climate change at all.

When you point this out to advocates, you'll get an entirely different argument, this time about personal health. I don't think the personal health justification stands up to scrutiny, for two reasons:

1. If you buy a home and want it to have a gas stove, why is it the state government's place to say that you can't do so, for your own health?

2. According to research I've seen, vented fume hoods seem to mitigate any health effects; if that's true and a state government really wants to intervene, why not spread awareness or perhaps mandate that newly constructed buildings with gas lines also have venting for fume hoods? (Incidentally, requiring venting for fume hoods would be a nice baseline for New York.)

I haven't seen any well-reasoned debate on this topic, possibly because the rationale for the regulation is, in fact, incoherent.

iamdamian··on Why did Google Brain exist?
Now you have me curious. Which laws, specifically?
iamdamian··on Borrowers with High Credit Scores Penalized Under New Federal Mortgage Fee Plan
You seem to be comparing apples and oranges.

Credit scores are a reflection of your likelihood of defaulting on a loan, and in debt financing, a fundamental truth is that higher risk = higher reward (in this case, higher fees).

That said, I don't have a dog in this fight.

iamdamian··on Ask HN: Why don't smartphones encourage programming like early 80s computers?
> Only for a small part of the population is programming in itself an end.

What about in absolute terms? How many millions of developers would write or run code on their phone / tablet if they could?

iamdamian··on The Dangerous Rise of Front Yard Polticics
Check out the Black Mirror episode called ‘Nosedive’.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nosedive_(Black_Mirror)

iamdamian··on AI clones teen girl’s voice in $1M kidnapping scam: ‘I’ve got your daughter’
Can you clone ChatGPT's weights off of GitHub?
iamdamian··on AI clones teen girl’s voice in $1M kidnapping scam: ‘I’ve got your daughter’
Couldn't you say this about nuclear research or bioweapons as well? Yet those are highly (and, seemingly effectively) regulated.
iamdamian··on U.S. bank lending slumps by most on record in final weeks of March
Are there still fractional reserve requirements in the U.S.?
iamdamian··on Launch HN: Type (YC W23) – AI-powered document editor
This hypothetical incentive structure seems tenuous at best and not the open and shut case it sounded like in your original comment. I’m sorry but I don’t buy it.
iamdamian··on Launch HN: Type (YC W23) – AI-powered document editor
Incentivized how, specifically?
iamdamian··on A different tipping culture compared to a few years ago
It's encouraging to read that people are reacting like I am to this increased pressure to tip—namely, by tipping less.

Hopefully this customer behavior will make its way back to management (and maybe even lawmakers) so that we get to a more reasonable system (i.e., no drip pricing, employers pay a fare wage, tip screens for random purchases go away).

iamdamian··on The GitHub 1000 year archive may be the last code dataset uncontaminated by AI
I understand there is some sort of insinuation here, but without understanding the terms, it's hard to say whether it's actually true.
iamdamian··on The GitHub 1000 year archive may be the last code dataset uncontaminated by AI
What is a code dataset? And what is AI contamination? Are you saying it's impossible to create a collection of hand-written code from here on out and know that none of it was generated by an LLM?
iamdamian··on California AG and state senators introduce bill to ban hidden fees
Not to mention the cleaning fee that's only disclosed when you make it to the purchase page, with the additional "House Rules" that you are required to take out the trash, strip the beds, and run the dishwasher before you leave.

All the while, you don't get daily cleaning like you would in a hotel.

It's pretty bad, and I'm gradually moving back to hotels, which are a known quantity.

iamdamian··on California AG and state senators introduce bill to ban hidden fees
This is welcome news.

An egregious example of what they are (hopefully) aiming to stop: https://passingtime.substack.com/p/perfidious-pricing

Also, a 2021 story from the Times about how drip pricing is getting out of control: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/02/opinion/consumers-drip-pr...

iamdamian··on Gitlab’s Startup Acquisition Process
It seems that Amazon did something similar under the guise of becoming an investor: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23929044
← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →