HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

icehawk219

655 karma · joined November 3, 2013

submissionscomments
icehawk219··on Google's fact-checking bots build vast knowledge bank
It most certainly is not your data. It's on their servers, in their apps, and running through their network. They decide what they do it with, how long they keep it, and whether or not you even have access to it. Comparing them to the post office doesn't really make sense either considering that's a public service, and one a depressingly large number of people want to get rid of. Google is a for profit company and their data is how they make money.

If you don't like that reality then don't use their service. It really is that simple.

icehawk219··on Why Can't the United States Build a High-Speed Rail System?
Agreed, and combined with NIMBY it'll be damn near impossible to build in densely populated areas. NJ Transit has been dealing with this for decades as people keep claiming they want more rail lines but don't want them in their own towns, they want them in the next town over so they don't have to hear the train. There's no reason to believe that trying to build a high speed line wouldn't face the exact same complaints.
icehawk219··on Why Can't the United States Build a High-Speed Rail System?
I completely agree with you but also feel like the big problem is people tend to state it as a case of "why the country, as a whole, needs high speed rail" and as you point out the vast majority of country really doesn't. Or at least doesn't think they do. We'd benefit greatly if we instead looked at it as a case of "why [state/city] should have high speed rail".

High speed rail from NYC to LA, while it may be cool and might be a nice big engineering challenge, really just doesn't appeal to most people. But if I, in central NJ, could take a train into Manhattan in under 2 hours, that would actually be incredibly useful and I'd love to be able to. Right now the time and cost of me taking a train from here to DC is prohibitively high compared to driving or taking a flight. These regional cases are where high speed (or at least higher speed) rail would really shine in my opinion.

icehawk219··on Obama presses to end corporate trick for evading taxes
Maybe I've just become jaded about American politics but every time a politician says something like this I tend to just assume that they're doing it to gain favor with the public while knowing there's nearly a 0% chance it will actually happen.
icehawk219··on Net neutrality
Well the idea is that anyone can run for election and in order to afford to do so people can pool their resources and help out. So if I want to run for mayor and you really like me a lot better than the other person you can pitch in in different ways. You can help me reach out to voters, you can make calls for me, you can help me with social media, or you can donate money to me so I can pay people to do those things. This by itself really isn't a problem especially when there are caps on how much money people can donate, which there are. But if you donate as much money to my campaign as you are allowed what's to stop you from calling up the local TV station and paying them directly to run an ad for me? I might not even necessarily be involved at any point.

The big problems come when we do things like decide a multinational corporation qualifies as a person and therefor the rules around how much money a company can donate don't apply to them. And we do things like change the rules around what the limits are. And then people do things like fund PACs where they pool their resources and promote a candidate on their own without actually donating to the campaign itself directly. Some of these are just outright stupid decisions that never should have happened in the first place and others are loopholes. Campaign finance reform in the US doesn't have a single silver bullet that's going to fix everything. There's a lot of things that are wrong with it. Citizens United (the corporate personhood ruling) is probably the biggest but it's still just one problem among many.

icehawk219··on Net neutrality
Lobbying in its purest form is supposed to be a way for people to have a voice in their government. Anyone in this country can ring up, or write, or email, their representative and push for an issue they feel strongly about. Likewise they can also make campaign contributions to the representatives, or candidates, they like and want to see in office. And the two can very easily be tied together: "I'm donating to your campaign because ...". If you keep it that simple it's a pretty good idea and is one that I think most people can get behind.

However in our modern world it really is just blatant bribery. Because corporations and rich individuals are able to donate such vast amounts that they are the only ones people care about. Take a look at how much money is spent during election cycles and it's obscene how many millions are poured into running for office. All that money has to come from somewhere. Say, for arguments sake, you must raise at least $5m to have a chance of winning an election but you think you can only raise about $2m from small donations (individuals) and then a few companies come along offering you nice big money bags if you agree to support their causes. Who do you care most about?

icehawk219··on Introducing a simpler, faster GitHub for Mac
I use this but I use it primarily as a diff'ing tool. It's very convenient for that and is also handy on the occasions I'm working on something and then look and realize I have several commits worth of uncommitted changes. Where the UI excels for this is easily just unchecking a couple files or highlighting a few lines from one file to commit only exactly what I want to and then quickly re-checking and committing the rest. This doesn't happen all that much but when it does it's great having a tool that makes it easy to deal with.

Other then that I just find the command line to be quicker for most things.

icehawk219··on Tor exit node operator prosecuted in Austria

  It has really put me off, and probably many others, from ever hosting a TOR node
The cynic in me can't help but assume that that's the entire point.
icehawk219··on Understanding web pages better
This is a worrying trend I've been noticing as well. The last couple of years especially I've noticed a very large increase in people just not caring about graceful downgrading as well as people just not even testing in other browsers. I've had many conversations with people that are huge fans of Angular and Backbone and similar frameworks and when I mention people without Javascript I just get the canned "but everyone has Javascript turned on anyway and if they don't, too bad" response. Interestingly enough every one of them were also people who developed and tested only against Chrome and never even bothered to acknowledge other browsers. I know someone who is a developer who actually likes IE and uses it as their main browser and for years they've dealt with breaking bugs on sites like Github and other popular tech sites because people just don't even test in other browsers any more.

The cynic in me wants to say that this mentality is pushed for by companies like Google because no Javascript means no spying. But honestly I think it really just comes down to laziness. So few people truly care about their craft.

icehawk219··on YouTube to Acquire Videogame-Streaming Service Twitch for $1 Billion?
I think it's important to take notice that Twitch's recent problems (the buffering problem, chat problems, the delay in general) are problems with their ability to cater to the big tournaments which causes me to really not be all that surprised if this turns out to be true.

The ways they've handled the tournaments have really disillusioned many streamers. I don't know if there's any better way for them to have dealt with the scaling problems they faced as I can only imagine the work that must go into supporting a live stream, with real time chat, that has 100k+ viewers (and for some of the bigger tournaments that's a small number). Something like a 30s+ delay in the stream makes it very difficult to have real interactions between the streamer and the viewers which is particularly bad for smaller streams. For the big guys it doesn't matter as much since their interaction is less back-and-forth and more broadcaster in style and there's absolutely no interaction with the tournaments.

The point is that if this is true it really doesn't surprise me at all. And whether or not it is I think there's definitely an opening for some serious competition to Twitch by making a service that is essentially an exact copy but from a business focus standpoint caters more towards the small-to-medium sized streamer and their audience.

icehawk219··on How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds
That's the general idea. Show them what life will be like if you're on the internet slow lane in the hopes they'll wake up and realize what it really means. Especially since the branding has become that they really want to create a "fast lane" which actually doesn't sound like such a bad idea until you realize the reality is the exact opposite.
icehawk219··on We are throttling the FCC to dialup modem speeds until they pay us for bandwidth
The problem with this plan is that Bombcast couldn't care less. They have a monopoly so what are their customers going to do? Switch to a non-existent ISP? And thanks to the death of Net Neutrality Bombcast can even go as far as to say "Hey Netflix, see this competitor of ours? Your rate just went up 250% if their customers are allowed on your site." (and for those thinking this would run afoul of anti-trust regulations you are 100% correct and I would LOVE to live in a universe where the government cared enough to do something about it, but I just can't believe that that would actually happen).

ISPs have proven time and time again that they can't be bothered to care about their customers. So while I would like to see your idea come to fruition the only people who really lose are the customers. The ISP doesn't care, the FCC doesn't care, the rest of the government doesn't care, even the people don't care enough to do anything substantial.

icehawk219··on My Experiment Opting Out of Big Data Made Me Look Like a Criminal
> What concrete things do I gain from opting out? What do I lose? How does it actually affect my life?

These are for profit businesses and both are ultimately controlled by investors. What's to stop Google or Facebook from giving that data to your insurance company so they can increase your premiums? Or what about the case a few years ago where a girl was pregnant and her father found out when Target started sending them targeted ads and spam?

And keep in mind not only do they collect and use this data but they NEVER delete it. It's their data an it's their data for as long as they decide to keep it. What you gain is the ability to say or do something without being forced to think "in 25 years will this be used against me?"

icehawk219··on PHP – a look back, a look forward
> No one here suggested you should be writing PHP daemons.

I agree with everything you've said and this statement isn't false in the scope of this thread. But I can't count how many times fellow PHP developers have suggested using PHP to write daemons and scripts that would be running on servers for weeks or months (or presumably even years) without restart or how much push back I received when I suggested using something better suited for it. But to your point none were proficient in other languages so it's only natural they'd try to figure out how to do it in the one they knew best.

icehawk219··on PHP – a look back, a look forward
"I've really squeezed everything out of this shitty little language"

Whenever PHP is mentioned people always jump to talking about the limits of the language and I'm curious what those limits were? I've worked on big and small code bases, large scale and small, and everything in between and haven't hit anything I'd call a "limit of the language" that we didn't just go right past without missing a beat. I do agree there are much better options out there now but based on a very different criteria which is why I'm doing what I can to learn many of them and move on from PHP.

icehawk219··on The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering city street driving
Along the same lines another thing that I think most of us in the US this winter (or least parts of it) had to deal with are potholes. I've gotten quite good at avoiding the potholes around me by preparing for their presence well ahead of where they actually are. In one case there's one right at the top of a hill near me and right under the passenger side tires if you don't move slightly to either side. But because of the incline of the hill you can't even see it until it's less than a few feet in front of you. I'd hope they figure out how to detect these but it seems like a pretty difficult problem.
icehawk219··on Lessons learned from a cancelled project
I had the same exact problem with a side project that spiraled out of control and was eventually cancelled in favor of a new job. What I had just started at the end, and what friends have done, that seems to work really well is to use something like Trello or Asana (which is a semi-ironic recommendation since my project would've been a competitor to these two) and lay out your immediate goal right now. Don't write any more code until you have that figured out. Then start entering tasks/ideas/features/bugs/etc that get you from wherever you currently are to that point.

I know someone who did this and has become disciplined about going back to that list whenever he starts working on the project to make sure the idea he's working on is on that list. If it isn't it's added to the "maybe one day" list on Trello and he switches gears over to some other task. Keeping in mind that tasks could be writing code but they could also be market validation as well. Of course he still has the issue of re-writing half of it every couple of weeks when he thinks the "old" code is now crap and needs to be refactored to perfection. That's a slightly more difficult hurdle to over come in my opinion.

icehawk219··on Stop commenting your code just to say you did
One of my guiding principles for code comments has always been "say why not what". If I can't figure out that what on my own then something is probably very wrong with the code. What I want to know is why you used a for() instead of a while() to iterate over an array or things like that. Comments that explain what you're doing I find to be cruft. I don't necessarily hate on them but I do find them unnecessary and unhelpful.
icehawk219··on Popcorn Time And Tech's Duty To Do The Right Thing
Every time this topic comes up I'm reminded of The Pirate's Dilemma [0], which is a great read that I recommend. The way the author presents the problem, using history as a reference, is that when "pirates" come to play and achieve acceptance by the masses (basically everyone "pirates" sometime at this point because people like what they're offering) you basically have two options. You can compete with them and potentially win big like Netflix or iTunes. Or you can fight against the change to the bitter end. History would suggest that the first option is always the better one yet the second option seems to be what the incumbents almost always choose.

[0] http://www.amazon.com/Pirates-Dilemma-Culture-Reinventing-Ca...

icehawk219··on Papers, Please: The 'boring' game that became a smash hit
Zero Punctuation did a good review of this game [0] (starts at 3:20) and sums up the attraction to it pretty well in my opinion. "It presents constant moral choices but makes it really hard to be a good person."

[0] http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/zero-punctuation... (probably not SWF)

icehawk219··on The Meteoric Rise of DigitalOcean
Something I noticed when taking a new job at a startup recently is that people seem to latch onto the idea of a USP being some fancy bell or whistle. The idea that "everything else in the market is terrible, we're making it easier" can set you apart seems to be lost on a surprisingly large number of people.
icehawk219··on LIVE: Twitter IPO
I feel like there's probably plenty of people outside of tech that fall within the "normals" bucket you're referring to that get value out of Twitter. I think their real problem (besides is it sustainable) is that it's not vital or irreplaceable. If Twitter went away tomorrow the people who would be hurt the most are the ones communicating out with it, not the ones consuming from it. And those are the people they are trying to monetize.

Think of how most of us here who work on SaaS platforms would try to monetize something like Twitter if we just thought it up today and Twitter had never existed. We'd probably put a pricing structure in place along the lines of "$x/mo per million followers" or "$x/mo per $y tweets".

I know plenty of people who like Twitter and use it regularly but it's something they check now and then and if they forget to or miss something it's not a big deal to them.

icehawk219··on How much money are you earning from your software products?
So far $0/mo off Neutrino (https://getneutrino.com) as I'm still getting up and going. I built it for myself to help keep track of my own side projects and then decided to embrace the idea of "sell your by-products". I'm now getting a crash course on marketing and sales.
← PreviousPage 4 of 4