HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ijpoijpoihpiuoh

389 karma · joined September 24, 2018

submissionscomments
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Tree planting: Where can I do it and which type is best?
Planting that many trees is not what's required. What's required is growing and maintaining them. If they burn in a fire, you need to start over. If they get cut down, you need to start over. If the land they're on gets sold and redeveloped, you need to start over. Etc. I think this seems a lot easier than it is because the wrong language is being used to describe what is actually required. You need to bring into existence and perpetually maintain (even after your death) 172-572 trees. That is not easy.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Tree planting: Where can I do it and which type is best?
Where do you go to plant trees such that you can be certain the trees won't just be cut down in a few years, and also don't simply displace other trees that would otherwise grow?

Also, do you keep track of the trees to make sure they actually grow? Just planting the seed or even a sapling is far from sufficient to ensure that carbon sequestration occurs. Young trees are food for a variety of animals and insects. Do you know what fraction of the trees you plant actually reach maturity? I've seen estimates that far fewer than one in five do.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on U.S. to set up plan aimed at allowing prescription drugs from Canada
I don't fundamentally mind the policy decision. It's bad for Canadians and good for Americans, although we give up some agency in the determination of our own prices by making this play. I just wish the messaging around this didn't have to be so disingenuous.

Also, if I were Canada, I would ban the export of drugs to the United States if the US domestic price for the drug is higher than the Canadian price for the same drug. Because otherwise the effect would be that a single market would exist for the drug, and the average price in Canada would face upward pressure as a result. Although if they did this, an American administration bent on getting the same effect could cap all domestic drug prices to the prices paid by Canadians and skip the pointless importing step. I wonder how Canada would react to that? I guess if I were Canada at that point I would make drug price negotiations secret.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on U.S. to set up plan aimed at allowing prescription drugs from Canada
You're missing the fact that one big reason the prices are so low in Canada is regulation.

https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/full/10.1377/hlthaff.20.3....

What the administration is proposing is effectively to regulate drug prices, but outsource that work to Canada, since it's politically unpalatable to their base here in the US.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on A Programmer’s Regret: Neglecting Math at University
To each their own, but a lack of math skills has rarely hurt me in my career. I guess I could be getting paid even more money as an ML specialist if I had more math knowledge. But you can make absurd amounts of money as a skilled generalist, so that only hurts you if you really find meaning in that type of work above what you'd do as a generalist programmer. And if that's where you're at, you can always study the math now.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Google reveals fistful of flaws in Apple's iMessage app
Project Zero was not the group that discovered the G+ vulnerability, though. Project Zero's terms do not bind other teams within the company who have not agreed to them.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Approaching Peak Housing Dysfunction in California
Personally, I'd rather live in NYC or Tokyo than the Bay, and indeed that is the choice I eventually made.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on I thought I was being ‘blacklisted’, so I demanded to see colleagues’ emails
Ok, but who do you treat well in this situation? The unpleasant student, or the person who is asking for information about them? If you remain silent about your honest opinion of the student, you are potentially foisting this unpleasantness on your colleague who might hire her.

For me, the takeaway here is to be honest and to not exaggerate, especially in matters of import. You can't always do the best thing for everyone, so when that's impossible, let the truth be your guide. The other thing is that the adviser should have brought these concerns to the student while she was still under his tutelage.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on I thought I was being ‘blacklisted’, so I demanded to see colleagues’ emails
It seems like the reform act of 2013 might make these comments in-bounds:

Honest opinion: It is a defence for defamation, to show the statement complained of was a statement of opinion; that it indicated, in general or specific terms, the basis of the opinion; that an honest person could have held the opinion on any fact which existed when the statement was published, including any fact in a privileged statement that was pre-published. The defence is defeated if the claimant shows the defendant did not hold the opinion.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Why We Can’t Figure Out Why Infrastructure Is So Expensive
Since the figure quoted is "X deaths per year", that that would be a large exaggeration, as I said, right?
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Why We Can’t Figure Out Why Infrastructure Is So Expensive
No pedestrians or bikes on the interstate. It's likely the figure is just a large exaggeration.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Why We Can’t Figure Out Why Infrastructure Is So Expensive
> And this is not just a cost issue. Its estimated that failure to adhere to known safer pavement designs is resulting in 10,000 - 15,000 unnecessary deaths a year.

That seems unlikely, if this was in a single state, considering only about 35k people die each year on the roads in the entire country.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on FTC Imposes $5B Penalty and Sweeping New Privacy Restrictions on Facebook
It's 1/4 of their annual net income. It's far from a joke, but it is true that it isn't ruinous.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Detecting Chrome headless, the game goes on
You've made an unfounded assumption -- that is, that the person you're responding to is scraping irresponsibly. If they are, as they say, simply replacing human researchers with the equivalent bots, then the net load change from automation is zero, or possibly even negative.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Detecting Chrome headless, the game goes on
Often what the municipalities are doing for public records is harder and more expensive than just publishing an API. So The funding excuse doesn't really cut muster with me.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Have We Hit Peak Podcast?
Does it matter at all that people start and end low quality podcasts? Nobody listens to them, nobody spends money on them, and the producers lose little by trying something and stopping.

What I care about is the availability of high quality talk and news available on Podcasts. There seems to be plenty, and even if the ecosystem contracts by 50-75% there will still be far more good content than I have time to listen.

Also, considering "podcast" just means "digitally delivered serial mostly-spoken audio," it's hard to imagine it going away permanently. We have five senses, only two of which are typically used for informal communication. We have a few communication modalities for vision: video, graphics, text. And we have two that I'm aware of for listening: music and speaking (podcasts).

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on U.S. tech giants collaborate with Chinese surveillance company
It seems representative of a certain class of article lately that is willing to bend the truth to the point of breaking in order to say something bad about any of the large American tech companies.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on U.S. tech giants collaborate with Chinese surveillance company
I responded to you in the other thread.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on U.S. tech giants collaborate with Chinese surveillance company
It's a rehash of an article in the Intercept. And it is indeed about the OpenPower foundation, which you can see if you click through the link in the first sentence. The fact that the editorial doesn't even mention the name of the foundation stands as a comment about its quality, not about the facts of the story.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on U.S. tech giants collaborate with Chinese surveillance company
The click-bait is strong with this storyline. It's also been posted and upvoted here a number of times over the past week, despite it being a non-story. Presumably people are seeing the title and upvoting without reading or understanding what's actually happening. Especially since this is just an editorial that regurgitates the high level points of The Intercept's story with little further thought or analysis.

I've flagged it. IMO, the mods should change the title to something more honest like, "Chinese Microchip Company Participates in OpenPower Foundation."

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
IMO people should have a right to sell things they've made. I get that that is inconvenient to open source folks. And most of the time it will be fine. But, IMO, if this is a concern, someone should make it worth it to this owner not to sell it to a bad organization. It is just not good enough to say, "You can't sell this thing because it is inconvenient to me, someone with whom you have no contract and to whom you owe no duties."
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
> The only obligation any maintainer has is to abide by whatever terms they release their code under.

That's not actually true, right? The obligation flows the other direction. People who receive the code are obligated to abide by the terms. The author does not have to do anything except follow the law. They are not bound by the terms under which they are distributing their code.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Issue: find a new home for repos including Requests
So it seems. Would that be a problem for some reason?
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on American kids would much rather be YouTubers than astronauts
There are ~12k YouTubers with >1M subs, though, so the math is a little more generous than those with 10M subs. Also, remember that this couple has more sources of income than just YouTube revenue. There are surely some YouTube engineers making >$1M/y, but not very many. And none of them have a job called "living on a boat and doing fun boat things," nor can most of them boast a basic cost of living south of $40k.

NOW, none of this should be taken as an endorsement of YouTuber as a viable career path for most people. You are, I think, correct that your expected value is much better if you pursue software engineering. Especially if you're not extremely attractive, multi-talented, adventurous, and highly risk-tolerant. It is also a lot of work to make these videos -- SLV had one video where they went over the actual process of making their videos, and it is a six day a week job. But I want to make sure we're being fair to the YouTuber lifestyle here. For the ones that make it, very decent or even insanely good money is possible -- more than most people realize.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on American kids would much rather be YouTubers than astronauts
The number of active astronauts though is a lot lower than the number of active YouTubers with a lot of subscribers. Also, 10M subscribers is a lot. One of my favorite YouTube channels has about 1M subscribers.

https://socialblade.com/youtube/channel/UCZdQjaSoLjIzFnWsDQO...

SocialBlade estimates their earnings as being at a minimum $4k per month. But the range is up to $56k per month. They also have a patreon where they have almost 4k people donating at least $1 per video, although when they last had their donation amounts public the average was substantially higher. IIRC that was was close to $10k per video. At four videos a month, that's $40k per month. They also were basically given a $1M boat by a luxury boating company, and many of their videos are sponsored by Audible or Squarespace.

So, at least for this channel, $500k/y in revenue is a pretty conservative estimate, although I'd bet even money they make more than $1M per year. I think setting the bar of "famous and successful" at 10M subs is too high.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on American kids would much rather be YouTubers than astronauts
I dunno. Being an astronaut doesn't sound much better when you put it reductively.

"Astronaut" doesn't mean "space adventurer" at all. Most of the time is spent in training and classes on the ground. Moreover, once you go out to space -- supposing you ever get to go, not likely -- you find that there's nothing there (that's what "space" means), most notably, no bars, movie theaters, or hot young people of your preferred gender. And the whole deal might be scrapped if the wrong political party gains power and slashes NASA's budget by 50%.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform
Interestingly enough, Google responded to that with a product offering: https://www.google.com/search?q=google+certified+locksmith

Not sure how well it works, as I haven't needed a locksmith in a long time. But for what it's worth, there is that.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform
Some of the accusations are pretty thin too, this one included. Last I checked, Google doesn't make money off of organic Google Maps results, except inasmuch as Maps acts as a halo product.

What exactly is Google supposed to do here? Are they to require a validated business license to update one's listing on Google Maps? Besides the non-trivial expense associated with that, it would act as a barrier to entry for smaller businesses that don't have one, and you can bet there'd be articles on here hating that too (just like there have been about the GMail API changes).

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on U.S. Tech Giants Are Helping to Build China’s Surveillance State
This raised the question in my mind: is the author being dishonest, or does he just have a different perspective and different values than me? Or alternately, have I not thought through my own values sufficiently to see that I should expect the same outcome as he does?

If I assume the author is being honest, the rationale must be something like this. The Chinese government is a serial human-rights violator. Most recently, it has been known to put people into reeducation camps on the basis of having a minority religious affiliation, but that's just one of many examples. Companies ought not sell to or provide services for human rights violators. This restriction should apply transitively as much as is reasonably possible.

Now, given that there is a company in this foundation that is working with the Chinese government, it is reasonable to anticipate that the efforts of the foundation would benefit the Chinese government. Therefore, all of the other companies that are participating in the foundation are tainted by transitivity. They should either oust the one company working with China, or else themselves leave the foundation.

I'm not sure where my agreement with this author breaks down, but it is somewhere before his conclusion. For me, the big question is how open standards and software jive with this transitive interpretation of moral responsibility. Anyone working on OpenCV or TensorFlow is working on something that could reasonably be anticipated to assist the Chinese government in the repression of its citizens. Same goes for anyone who publishes in the ML space. But I think the idea that one should not do these things is absurd, so I think a line needs to be drawn somewhere, and that line is far short of Google's or IBM's participation in this foundation.

That said, I think I could be convinced that companies working mainly with the Chinese government should not be allowed to sit on the foundation. But I'm not sure even of that.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Anomalous CPU utilization on Windows build node caused by ads
I don't see any ads on my W10 machine and I haven't done anything to disable them. Where are you seeing this?
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →