HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ilayn

186 karma · joined September 6, 2018

submissionscomments
ilayn··on Aro – Zig's new C compiler
I hope Zig adds complex numbers before it is too late. It's a pity that they did not steal array syntax and slices from Fortran/Numpy.
ilayn··on My Windows Computer Just Doesn't Feel Like Mine Anymore
Nope same for me with intel drivers. Intel update utility recommends one, installs it.

Leave computer idle windows rolls it back in the night to a driver from 2021.

ilayn··on New algorithm discovers language just by watching videos
Noone knows what babies do. Anything else is speculation.
ilayn··on The Mythical Non-Roboticist: Wouldn't it be great if everyone could do robotics?
I am in that group you mentioned and this is not even a bad take. They might have been trying to imply ROS but that's also a very much not a well-targeted criticism either. Robotics is not bunch of humanoids moving their attached manipulators.

Next; this article appears in IEEE spectrum not Quanta. I want higher quality from IEEE as was the case for decades and it is not a pop science avenue. Good pop science is hard and other places do it much better.

This is just a mediocre blog article found somehow its way into IEEE which is very concerning about the quality of IEEE spectrum.

ilayn··on The Mythical Non-Roboticist: Wouldn't it be great if everyone could do robotics?
Did you pay attention to what IEEE stands for?
ilayn··on The Mythical Non-Roboticist: Wouldn't it be great if everyone could do robotics?
It is sad to see that IEEE is becoming the discovery channel of engineering.
ilayn··on PyPy has been working for me for several years now
Scipy maintainer here. Numpy has no fortran code on itself and uses lapack lite written in C. Scipy has 10% of its codebase with very old F77 libraries that we are removing slowly. Nothing against fortran but this is slowly turning into a urban legend.

The main reason fortran is still used around is fundamentally LAPACK. BLAS has long been converted to C/Assembly, openblas mkl or others. But Lapack is a lot of code to translate not because fortran is better but the original authors wrote it in F77

ilayn··on Why Rust cannot replace C++
I am also a very avid C++ avoider but if I am in a meeting with this author and they tell me we need to use C++ for something, I'll take it.

Because I trust pain more than smarts. And I do agree that we are coming to a point there will be a better compiled language. Rust actually broke the untouchable status of C/C++. In my opinion the final popularity blow will come from something else. I wish I knew what it was.

ilayn··on Interview with Yanis Varoufakis on Technofeudalism
I would argue otherwise. I have absolutely zero negotiation power. In the past there was more. See Apple-Epic saga or multiple reports that show Amazon manufacture popular products clones and pushing the original manufacturer down in the search results. These are impossible moves with Walmart. You need to physically erase products to outcompete your competitor.

Secondly, in Walmart we are all physically seeing the same product on the same shelf. With online "markets", I don't even know if I am seeing the stuff I wanted because there is an algorithm that hides certain things from me but shows it to you. These are exceptionally intrusive moves by the mall itself. Walmart could only dream about such manipulations. In the old model, I can still stand side-by-side with my competitor as product options.

In that sense, it is fundamentally malicious and a very new economic model.

ilayn··on Interview with Yanis Varoufakis on Technofeudalism
You can switch to a different location and continue business, should a conflict arises with a landlord in a mall.

With Amazon, if you have a conflict, you are done. You cannot come back to the mall. And there is a single (or very few malls).

In other words, it is not a market, where people come together for business) anymore it is being bound to a higher power to grant you rights of doing business.

ilayn··on Interview with Yanis Varoufakis on Technofeudalism
Your contribution is not the storage of your tweets. You can delete them one by one or with API but it won't make any difference at this point. And you need to repost it somewhere. You have contributed to keep the platform relevant. So no you can't take them anywhere else.
ilayn··on Interview with Yanis Varoufakis on Technofeudalism
Whatever you get out for your own self is a secondary by-product. You are bounded to that platform to get what you get and cannot leave by taking what you already contributed.

While you are benefiting from certain social returns, you are also the reason why someone else's brand is growing by the same argument. Hence the platform is doing nothing but increasing its importance for its matchmaking value. That is the premise. At some critical threshold, the platform achieves the "I'm too big to bother with individual users" and declares the feudal lordship (remember similar Stackoverflow and Reddit dramas with "We do as we please" attitude and nothing happened to the platforms because users could not give up - the following mod saga for reddit and so on and accepted their fate). It already happened with social media platforms long time ago.

ilayn··on PID Controller Explainer (2022)
PID success does not relate to time delay except the additional phase.
ilayn··on 20 Years of Gmail
Still unapologetically using rocketmail address as my burner email.

After gmail, proton, fastmail nothing beats the nostalgia and the let down I felt when yahoo bought and destroyed it.

ilayn··on Statistical Process Control: A Practitioner's Guide (2022)
Another post to drive a control theory person up the wall.
ilayn··on What Is a Schur Decomposition? (2022)
Basically lack of expertise among maintainers, f77 codebase, and neverending packaging/distribution problems.
ilayn··on What Is a Schur Decomposition? (2022)
I guess it is a rite of passage to rewrite it. I'm doing it for SciPy too together with Propack in [1]. Somebody already mentioned your repo. Thank you for your efforts.

[1]: https://github.com/scipy/scipy/issues/18566

ilayn··on I designed a cube that balances itself on a corner
Multimeter and basic input output testing is your underappreciated friend.
ilayn··on How I'm able to take notes in mathematics lectures using LaTeX and Vim (2019)
TikZ and pgfplots
ilayn··on PIDs: Creating Stable Control in Games
How about you don't kick off with a lol then? Maybe you set the tone of engagement.
ilayn··on PIDs: Creating Stable Control in Games
> the error depends on the goal you need to reach, and if the goal constantly changes, I and D are kinda useless...

Why do you think that? the error is the difference between actual and desired at every instant. If you move the desired then you enlarge the error term and PID reacts to close that gap, it might never reach if you are changing the goal too fast but that's something related to the concept of "bandwidth". OTherwise you are quite right and all is OK.

If you have multiple axes then the typical solution is to have n PID loops for n axes. This assumes that the dynamics of the system is decoupled. In english, if I do something in one axis it will not affect the other axes. Then you can tune the PID loops independently. Otherwise, dry math.

ilayn··on PIDs: Creating Stable Control in Games
Control theorist here. The articles are pretty good. There is nothing wrong with them.

What you are insinuating is not always correct that if you model stuff you'll get a better result. Sometimes PID is more then enough and in fact better since your model can get arbitrarily complex and you don't have any tools to deal with that behavior. It's a bit snobbish that you need to have math and all the shenanigans. The rest of the manufacturing world disagrees with your premise that is very common in academic circles.

ilayn··on Ask HN: Why are mathematical standards so low? (And what should they be?)
I have rather unorthodox view on this subject, I would already concede defeat if you object to it. However, to criminally box my view into a few sentences, we should start cleaning up our undergrad curriculum from root loci, routh hurwitz, Laplace transform etc. and put industrially relevant things like PID and all kinds of heuristics. We also need to fire anyone who says yes but "that's trial and error" as if engineering is not 90% that.

This is not an easy task by any means, it would require a lot of expertise. However we have to get back to being related to the field and not hijack control engineering to do applied math. A mech/electrical engineering curriculum, with all their flaws, will leave you around the neighborhood of a working engineer. You will not be ready for the production-grade however you would be a cadet.

With control engineering, you don't learn anything about the field but learn bunch of haphazardly put together half-assed math concepts. When you get out not only you don't know anything, you also have this elite view that "oh they are just doing PID, peasants!". In other words, control design is 5% of the whole process. Understanding the system is the crucial part. Anyone can tune something that barely works. Not everyone understands the system. Strogatz' nonlinear book should be more important then Ogata.

Let me give one example; Laplace transforms or all integral transforms with different kernels are extremely hard topics at undergrad level and confuse the hell out of students. To the point that when you present them the intricacies of analytical continuation and other necessary things to treat the subject you lose them. Hence we should not pretend to teach these things. Hence "oh replace dots with powers of s and then replace s with iw" is not helping anyone.

Apologies for cutting it short but I have to get shit-faced with my guests soon :) Hence I wish all a happy new year!

ilayn··on Ask HN: Why are mathematical standards so low? (And what should they be?)
I have worked heavily on SOS and LMI based methods in general, IQCs to be precise. Sum-of-squares are so stupidly explosive in the size of required conditions, (pretty much impossible to do anything more than 5-6 parameters), you can play around with it theoretically. You might feel good about it.

If you call yourself an applied mathematician and keep working on these things, I will be the last person to object. But if you say Sigma* algebra or Sobolev spaces, or infinite dimensional systems, or this or that is required to understand dynamical systems that means you are not really getting the central ideas in control and confusing the methods with the problems we are trying to solve. That is my premise.

ilayn··on Ask HN: Why are mathematical standards so low? (And what should they be?)
By funeral I mean, academia completely killed the applicability of this rich branch of engineering and left it as "exercise to the reader". Take MPC control, it originated from the industry and academia did not care for very long time until it has been realized that you can play around with optimization problems and now being put forth as the one of the jewels that rigorous mathematical gave birth to.

Industry, exceptions notwithstanding, pretty much got used to ignoring the the theoretical advances. Hence control theory became this testeless pages long article sillyness where you get 9 pages of integral inequalities to tune 2 parameters and call it adaptive control success.

ilayn··on Ask HN: Why are mathematical standards so low? (And what should they be?)
Another control theorist here. I strongly disagree with your premise of rigor in control. The whole field is ripe with math snobbery and virtually plotted its own funeral to the point of absurdity.

The field's key contribution is in the ideas and the insights it can provide otherwise extremely laborious to obtain. Definitely not in senseless dry exposition of unnecessarily general theorem proof parroting.

ilayn··on Firefox Sync actually works
When does it do that? I mean during doing what?
ilayn··on Firefox Sync actually works
Why would anyone need a reason? I mean it seriously. Chrome users on this platform really baffling for me. They know what the consequences are, they know quite well what the icon with their picture on the corner does. Still being OK with this is super interesting.

Most products are often get grilled here for having closed code parts or similar concerns but when it comes to giving complete audit of their online existence, "meh...". Same folks who criticize canonical (which I disagree strongly with their late practices) only to install chrome as their browser on their systems.

Insert "statistically speaking" wherever needed.

ilayn··on Progress toward a GCC-based Rust compiler
That's only true if you are not distributing your code. If you want to kill portability just involve MSVC in anything.
ilayn··on Fortran 2023
Other than the original reference implementation, you would not find any other fortran version of BLAS anymore. And nobody links to the reference for performance code. All written in either close to metal C with SIMD etc. or straight in assembly altogether. LAPACK is mostly fortran but there are also libraries slowly rewriting those in Rust/Julia and C.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →