HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

iliis

692 karma · joined January 24, 2011

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/iliis; my proof: https://keybase.io/iliis/sigs/mtvGemD8-YZxsqy-tL5zo7-_fVd844s0KJ9ajcvOknc ]
submissionscomments
iliis··on OSIRIS spots Philae drifting across the comet
You can treat anything as a point mass as long as you're far away enough ;) And even with point masses only, orbital mechanics can get quite complex.

When you are close enough that a significant portion of the comet's mass is "besides" yourself (somewhere off to the side) it will pull you to the side.

This even holds true for spherical objects (say, you standing on earth), where you get gravitational pull not only towards the center but also towards the sides. For a perfectly symmetrical sphere, these sideway forces cancel each other out tough.

But earth isn't a perfect sphere, so even on our own planet you get (very small) variations in gravitational pull (stronger pull at the poles or near mountains (where the crust is thicker)): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_of_Earth

iliis··on OSIRIS spots Philae drifting across the comet
Indeed, KSP gives a good intuition about orbital mechanics and space travel. It makes you appreciate the skills of NASA/ESA/... engineers even more!

Also, KSP now has 'real' asteroids! http://wiki.kerbalspaceprogram.com/wiki/Asteroid

iliis··on OSIRIS spots Philae drifting across the comet
You can always reenact it in Kerbal Space Program ;)
iliis··on The Tyranny of the Rocket Equation (2012)
You might be interested in Copenhagen Suborbitals (copsub.com): A danish group trying to reach space in a DIY fashion financed by donations. It's quite impressive what they've already achieved with not that much more than duct tape!
iliis··on Cursors
There's an end? Aw, man! I tought it was just big bunch of randomly chosen levels. How about a counter? Something like 'this is level 123 from 444'?

Surprisingly awesome game tough!

iliis··on Oculus Connect 2014
Yeah. I'm watching the keynote right now, and Carmack talks quite extensively about the display problems they're facing and in no way indicates the use of multiple displays.

Also, the demo video of Lanman and company mentions 'calibration issues' they have on the outer parts of the display where you can cleary see alignment issues.

I still think it's a very clever idea of getting better resolutions with reasonable effort tough ;)

iliis··on Oculus Connect 2014
For those of you wondering about the higher resolution: A reddit user made the suggestion¹ that they are using two displays on top of each other and some clever signal processing to (almost) double the spatial (and temporal!) resolution.

See http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XwaARRMbSA for a demonstration of this technique and note that one of the guys from this project was hired by Oculus.

--

1. https://www.reddit.com/r/oculus/comments/2gytxj/i_just_did_t...

iliis··on I was asked to crack a program in a job interview
We did that in our second year and it was awesome. I don't know if it was the same binary but it was well made. The first password was very easy (just a constant string) and it got progressively harder from there. At the end we had to step through some recursive algorithm and you learned to read assembly almost as well as normal code. And the server for submitting the passwords didn't filter the username so you could enter arbitrary HTML into the high-score...
iliis··on New dual carbon battery charges 20x faster than lithium ion batteries
Good point! Altough bad example with the CPU: I do want a 20 GHz one and so do a lot of others. But I can see if it works as advertised very quickly whereas you cannot really absolutely with ultimate certainty prove that this bracelet doesn't work...
iliis··on What If the Moon Orbited at the Same Height as the ISS?
For a real example see Pluto and its largest moon Charon. And as you probably already know, our moon IS tidally locked to us ;)

Then, there's the question "What if the earth was a torus?": http://www.aleph.se/andart/archives/2014/02/torusearth.html

iliis··on Why Nerds are Unpopular (2003)
How much of our skills are learned and how much is genetic ability is an old debate ("nature vs. nurture"). I come down quite hevily on the learning side: You can remove half the brain of a person and if you do it slowly or early enough he will grow up into a quite normal human. I mean, even walking is mainly a learnt skill!
iliis··on Why 9:41 AM is always the time displayed on iPhones and iPads
Sorry to dissapoint you again, my watch is set to 24 hours ;)
iliis··on SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atlantic
The seas are huge and empty. Keep in mind that this was just an experiment which could easily have gone wrong. You probably don't want to have to explain why you made a rocket-shaped hole in somebody's roof ;)

Also: Chances are higher that you're able to recover useful wreckage (like data loggers) when you crash into water.

iliis··on Why 9:41 AM is always the time displayed on iPhones and iPads
At least the Casio watch I'm wearing at the moment doesn't dispaly a leading zero.
iliis··on Bret Victor's favourite books
Tha reasoning backward trick sounds very interesting. Certainly a cool idea I have to try!

Also, it sounds you might be interested in LessWrong.com - if you haven't stumbled upon it yourself already.

iliis··on Navy tests rail gun
I haven't been in that many banks but I've never been at one that tells you to turn off cellphones , neither in Europe nor here in Africa...
iliis··on Navy tests rail gun
Can somebody please add a warning that there's an autoplaying video? It's a bit awkward if your phone suddenly starts talking about guns when your standing in line in a bank :/

Edit: A video tag would be nice in general for mobile users.

iliis··on Radiation-hardened quine
A friend of mine writes firmware for embedded devices like automatic door controls. Besides having very well designed and redundant hardware (multiple PSUs etc.) the software does a lot of things to keep itself running robustly. For example, the microcontroller regularly tests its own memory for bad blocks and compensates accordingly - similiar to what flash memory controllers do.

So yeah, even if you don't go into space or inside a nuclear reactor software can be written to tolerate a lot of harware failures.

iliis··on Torus-Earth
It would have to be a very small sun tough in order to fit trough the hole and not burn the planet to a crisp. So we arrived at the Discworld, where the elephants carrying the world sometimes have to lift their legs to let the sun pass.

Such a small star would probably have to be kept burning artificially, as the smallest mass still allowing nuclear fusion is around 80 times the mass of Jupiter.

iliis··on I never finish anyth
Thanks! It is nice to know I'm not the only one going trough this. Let me know if you find the/an/your answer!

Some things I've noticed: Being physically fit helps and doing sport is a bit easier than overthrowing the world. Maybe ask a friend to go with you.

Sleep is also easily modified: Try out the effects of light, temperature, noise, sleep duration etc. Maybe use Melatonine or a sleep cycle alarm.

It's also a lot easier to do things when I don't have to do them. If I tell myself, I _have_ to run today in order to get fit I probably won't do it. But just going outside quickly for some fresh air? Sure, let's check the mailbox ... and now that I'm outside, why not run for a bit?

It's a bit like jumping out of the bed before the brain realizes what you're doing and has no time to scream "I don't want to wake up!" :)

iliis··on Dijkstra on Haskell and Java (2001)
Yes. Yes, I do. And it makes a tremendous difference.

Abstractions are an absolute necessity without which we could never have built a computer. And may be fine to stay at one level of abstraction for day to day stuff. Knowing the levels below and above however makes it possible to not only use the current one better but to also to navigate the hierarchy and use the best abstraction for a specific task. And design new ones if necessary.

Our CS courses provided exactly this: We looked at single transistors, programmed microchips, implemented a CPU on a FPGA, toyed with kernels and drivers, walked trough the OSI-layers, wrote a compiler, a static code analyzer, used monads and the lambda calculus, learned about turing machines and different computing architecures, abstractions, models and beyond.

It really helps to have the 'whole' picture.

iliis··on The Next Ten Billion Years
Well, you may never have read Asimov's "Last Question": http://filer.case.edu/dts8/thelastq.htm
iliis··on Gzip + poetry = awesome
If you're talking about Kolmogorov Complexity here, you can't really "circumvent" it. Kolmogorov Complexitiy of a string is basically defined as the size of the shortest possible representation of said string. If you manage to"bypass" the Kolmogorov Limit you actually just "lowered" it (well, it alwayws was by definition this low).

Your main point is totally valid however. You cannot compress infinitely. A simple proof: For any given N bits you can encode [at most] 2^N different strings. As there exist more than N strings there must be one which cannot be represented by N bits. As N can be arbitrarily large you'll always find strings which cannot be compressed lower than some chosen size. QED.

iliis··on I got hired at a Bangladesh sweatshop. Meet my 9-year-old boss [video]
> Because it will marginally increase the cost of the goods

And this is not even a given. Even in blue-collar industries it can be quite profitable to improve working conditions and thereby raising employee productivity.

iliis··on Swiss to vote on 2,500 franc basic income for every adult
Yes, the economic argument looks solid. Good old supply and demand.

Problem is, we may not be able to automate these jobs so easily.

iliis··on Swiss to vote on 2,500 franc basic income for every adult
As a swiss I'm quite excited about this. Even if I'm pessimistic about a successful vote.

I want to mention a side-point which I haven't encountered so far: In the 'problem of lazyness' (i.e. "who will do the boring work if you are paid anyway?") one answer that often comes up is automation. Menial/low-skill jobs will be done by robots.

It's a common image that in the future robots will clean our toilets and grill our burgers while the humans have ample time to enjoy life, build rockets and do fulfilling work.[1] However, if AI research has told us one thing it's that this view is quite wrong - the opposite is true. Things humans think of as 'easy' like walking around or doing laundry are actually very difficult engineering problems and 'hard' stuff like playing chess or doing rocket science are easier in an absolut sense.

The reason behind is simple: Evolution had millions of years to perfect walking on legs and interacting with the environment. Our bodies almost literally have an walkTo(Place) API, so the only thing 'we' (our conscious self) have to do is to call it. Abstract thinking is something new and our brains have to do it manually. It takes you less time to run over debris than to multiply large numbers and so we have a distorted picture of what is hard in an absolute sense.

The picture is true for humans but it falls apart when we want to automate it. We are still decades away of beating humans in soccer but Jeopardy is a solved problem.

I'm not convinced that 'low'-skill jobs are the first to fall into the hands of machines. [2]

---

[1] Ignore for the moment the fact that unclogging toilets can also be fulfilling.

[2] This is of course a broad argument. We still have no clue what Intelligence or Creativity actually is - It may still turn out to be very complicated. But I nevertheless think there's a good chance that we will figure out hard AI before you can buy a robot which washes your socks, mows the lawn and fixes your plumbing.

iliis··on Go Pro on a soaring eagle [video]
Ah, this is just beautiful.

There's a whole community flying model airplanes trough a camera and video goggles: http://vimeo.com/16604842

iliis··on Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
Good point. We let them shoot and kill each other however.
iliis··on Athletics cost colleges, students millions
This seems to be the norm here in Europe. Our university does have a very diverse offer of sports activities (everything from running, dancing, boxing or paragliding to jazz and waterboarding), but it is more a hobby-thingie and doesn't touch normal study-life at all.
iliis··on Digital physics
Nice to know there's a name for this concept!

You can take the idea further and abandon any notion of time or even discreteness altogether: If the universe is essentially information, this information can be _completely_ described by some (mathemtical) language. Note, this description doesn't have to be finite.

For the finite and discrete case this description may simply be a very long bitstring/vector which contains every detail of our universe. If time is discrete as well we can write a whole timeline as a matrix, a set of bitstrings each representing one slice of 'now'. Notice how we now have one static thing being a perfect representation of the universe. No need for a computer or interpreter. Just a big table of ones and zeroes representing everything from the big bang to your mother.

However, our universe might be continuous. You might still be able to describe it with finite amount of information tough. A function like x -> x*x is continuous and defined for infinitiely many values but can still be written down just fine. Even infinite complex things like fractals can have a very short descriptions. Or take pi. An infinite sequence of numbers describable in a few sentences.

Point is, a universe need not to be discrete in order to be written down on a sheet of paper. It just needs to be finite in an information theoretical sense. And you may need a lot of paper.

I strongly suspect the universe is bounded. But what if it isn't? Can we still se it as a mathematical entitiy? I think so, but I'd like some comments on that. We have the well-defined set of real numbers and it contains _every_ real number, even those who are completely random up until the last of their infinite digit. There are numbers in R which have an infinite Kolmogorov complexity [1]. And yet, we can put them all in one set. We can even draw a picture of all these numbers (it's just a line, but that's more than our analysis professor would draw to illustrate something).

In conclusion: I think (and didn't proof) that even if the universe contains infinite information and cannot be the result of some turing machine it can still be tought of as a mathematical object. A thing like sqrt(2) or a triangle.

----

A second and orthogonal tought is about the 'reality' of all this. This is a bit metaphysical and philosophical. If you are still reading please tell me I went crazy. The idea is, if you have a perfect description of our universe (be it a turing machine, a big matrix or some other complicated mathematical thingumabob) is there a difference between the description and the real thing? Obviously not, one is just words on a paper or bits in a computer and the other a world full of loving and caring people and other stuff. How can I even ask such a question? (Hint: I'm on the Internet and can write what I want.) Well, imagine doing this whole computer simulation of our universe. Would you feel any different when being run on some sort of computer? If you and everything around you would be perfectly simulated would you notice it? Would you even be able to? For the ones running the simulation the difference would be obvious. But being part of the simulation you may have no way of knowing that you are a piece of software. It would all seem and feel real. It would BE real. And yet you are just bits. You could stop the computer, dump it's memory and write it all down. Doesn't seem like such a difference between words on paper and reality after all.

What I'm trying to explain is that a perfect description of something is actually, in some sense, the _same_ thing as the object being described. It's a bit like uploading the whole universe instead of just a brain. In the end all you have is information. Doesn't matter if this information flows trough transistors, is written in ink or just an element of the set of real numbers.

And if you say the number '4' 'exists' and so does 'pi' then why not 'the universe' as well? If you say this then you just answered the question 'why do we exist?' Because _everything_ exists. In the same sense as every possible triangle 'exists' so does every universe. We just happen to observe one specific instance.

The sad thing is: This doesn't really explain anything. If you say absolutely everything exists you haven't made any predictable or verifiable claim. So it may give you a philosophical answer to why are we here but it isn't much more than '42'...

----

[1] Some formal proof would be nice here. I didn't think it trough down to the simplest axiom. Maybe it's enough to argue that there are only countable many turing machines but uncountable many real numbers and therefore some real numbers cannot have a finite description.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →