HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

iluxonchik

173 karma · joined February 22, 2014

My name is Illya. I'm entrepreneur and engineer. I develop products that disrupt how we think and interact with money and empower our digital privacy. I use this platform to articulate my thoughts on blockchain, DeFi, Zero-Knowledge cryptography, AI and finance. I aim to merge deep technical concepts with practical applications.

Illya's Threads: https://illya.sh/threads/ Illya's Thoughts: https://illya.sh/thoughts/

Website: https://illya.sh/ Blog: https://illya.sh/blog/

I am the founder of zkLocus - a protocol for private geolocation sharing off & on-chain. zkLocus turns geolocation into a Real World Asset (RWA).

zkLocus homepage: https://zklocus.dev/ zkLocus GitHub: https://github.com/iluxonchik/zkLocus

submissionscomments
iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
I understand that you are expressing your political views, however you still fail to explain how exactly the BRICS digital currency as a cryptocurrency on a public blockchain supports the claims that you've made.

My goal is not to argue. I'm genuinely interested in the feedback. We are building the next era of finance, one that is more transparent, decentralized, trustless and inclusive. By employing mutual cooperation and iteration, we can move towards a better future more swiftly and efficiently.

How about we start with decentralization? Pick your FIAT currency of choice, and tell how many entities have the absolute control over that currency's supply. Now let's compare it to the BRICS digital currency, as presented in the article. Big difference, right? :)

iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
What do you mean?
iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
Hello and thank you for getting back on this,

I feel that there may be a misunderstanding on how you understand the BRICS digital currency to be implemented. I'll address your comment point-by-point:

0. The statement that commercial banks create more money that private banks is misleading. Since 2000, The U.S. government debt grew by about $25+ trillion from 2000 to 2023. Commercial bank loans increased by about $7+ trillion in the same period. Governments resort to the central banking entity directly for the issuance of debt through securities. I am citing the USD data, as it's available in detail and clarity directly from the government sources, like FRED.

1. You are describing a part of to the process by which the money supply increases, which indeed can be done by commercial banks. This is what happens when one gets a loan for a property or kickstart your business. While this is true, I don't understand how it goes against anything in the article. You appear to downplay the fact that the *commercial banks have to strictly abide by the rules set in place by the central bank*, namely on topics like overnight exchange rates, the minimum reserve factor to kept at the central bank, and the eventual premium on those reserves. For example, in the EU we've had negative central bank interest rates for a long time, until recently. This meant that commercial banks were incentivized to loan the money out instead of keeping it stored. In the US, commercial banks were incentivized to purchase government debt securities, like bonds, by not having to take a "haircut" on their value. As such, the commercial banks can be seen as a direct extension of a central bank.

2. It is incorrect to say that the Central Bank "does NOT have direct control or the money supply", and you appear to contradict this assertion when in the next sentence when say that "the central bank attempts to influence the money supply through interest rates". Central bank is the entity that influences the money supply the most, as I've described in the previous point. If you disagree, please explain the correlation between the money supply (e.g. M2), and the central bank interest rates. FRED has this data accessible in an easy to understand manner: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/

3. I'm not sure how far along you've got in the article, or how familiar you are with Automated Market Makers (AMM), but the dynamic supply can be implemented without having a central bank in a traditional sense, as it can all be controlled by a smart contract. In the formula `M = ForT + FDI + PI + ForEx + G&EX + InterSec + Der + ForDeposit + EuroCurrency + MTransfer + Etc`, every argument is a financial derivative, and a smart-contract blockchain + ZKP is the perfect way to concretize them.

4. If by "the issuer has direct control over the money supply" you are refer to the smart contract issuing the currency, then you are correct! A point that you may be missing is that *nobody can influence this process, beyond what is encoded in the code of the smart contract*. If the smart contract has a rule where some "magic entity" can create supply at will, then of course that entity will have full and direct influence on the supply. But this is neither what the article proposes, nor how the BRICS currency is being designed.

Let me know if some parts were unclear. Looking forward to continue this discussion.

iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
If designed & implemented correctly - absolutely. In fact, as I outline in the article, this is one of its most exciting value propositions. I'm not sure how far along you've got, but your question is answered in the following sections:

- Supply, Demand, Value & Oranges

- BRICS Supply During Economic Boom

- BRICS Suppply During Economic Downturn

iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
Hello economist and thank you for your feedback,

You've made claims questioning my knowledge level and suggested that my opinions should not be disregarded, yet you haven't presented any arguments on where exctly my economic understanding is ill.

Could you please expand on those arguments?

iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
Yes, indeed! I would also expand on how the implementation of this on a public blockchain, expands the "trust free" feature to the general public, as derivatives can be easily created on a smart contract based blockchain.
iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
Based on the discussion that we've had I'll assume that you don't have any actual criticisms regarding the value-propositions of the BRICS digital currency as a cryptocurrency on a public blockchain.

Arguments in the form of "I dislike X, therefore everything associated with X is bad" are not very useful. I'll refrain from answering to any follow-ups, unless they pertain to the topic of the article.

I will however, be glad to re-engage on queries related to the BRICS digital currency as a cryptocurrency on a public blockchain.

iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
Of how it's used as a weapon?
iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
I will refer you to my comment above. The BRICS currency does not have a "reserve" currency, and as such the Ruble is not a reserve currency. A more correct way of thinking is of economic health of the Russian Federation and other member countries is used a "collateral" for the BRICS currency. The "economic health" is defined by algorithmically through a formula. You can find the formula in my comment above and of course in the article.
iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
The BRICS currency does not have a "reserve currency". You are thinking in terms of existing currency structures, where a single currency is treated with more importance that other currencies. The BRICS currency itself, is a derivative of the currencies and economies of the member countries.

In the article, I present the formula for the calculation of the supply of the BRICS currency:

`M = ForT + FDI + PI + ForEx + G&EX + InterSec + Der + ForDeposit + EuroCurrency + MTransfer + Etc.`

Each component in this formula represents a key economic indicator:

- `ForT`: Foreign Trade, encompassing the total value of exports and imports between the BRICS nations and the rest of the world.

- `FDI`: Foreign Direct Investment, capturing the inflow and outflow of investment capital.

- `PI`: Portfolio Investment, including investments in stocks, bonds, and other financial instruments.

- `ForEx`: Foreign Exchange Transactions, representing the volume of currency exchanges.

- `G&EX`: Gold and Foreign Exchange Reserves, a crucial component that partially backs the value of the BRICS currency with an asset holding intrinsic value - gold.

- `InterSec`: International Securities, such as bonds issued by BRICS nations in international markets.

- `Der`: Derivatives, financial contracts deriving their value from underlying assets or benchmarks.

- `ForDeposit`: Foreign Deposits, the total value of BRICS currency held in foreign accounts.

- `EuroCurrency`: Eurocurrency Market Operations, capturing the BRICS nations' activities in other currency markets.

- `MTransfer`: International Money Transfers, the flow of funds between the BRICS and other nations.

- `Etc.`: Other relevant economic indicators as needed. The article doesn't develop on the specifics, but you can imagine one of those factors as being the country's Bitcoin reserves.

As such, the supply is algorithmic (akin to UniswapV2's approach of`x*y=k`) and the formul aims to create a BRICS currency supply that dynamically responds to the collective economic state of the member nations

iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
I'm not sure how far along you got in the article, but have you ever heard about zkML?
iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
While I appreciate your reply, it feels that you expressing your subjective view on geopolitics, rather than expanding on the shortcomings of the BRICS digital currency, when implemented as a cryptocurrency on a public blockchain as described in the article.

Perhaps you could elaborate on how precisely you see proposed architecture as a misfit, and explain how existing solutions are better?

Thanks!

iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
Hello and thank you for your comment.

I'm not sure how far along you got in the article, but I cover all of these points in the "BRICS Digital Currency as a Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain" section. Blockchain is utilized as an authenticated, integrity assured, and trustless state machine and storage layer controlled by a programmable execution layer.

The issuance the currency is performed on a public blockchain through a smart contract. In the article I also cover how the proposed solution would not require any infrastructure management at all. The infrastructure is the blockchain, and the blockchain is run publicly via a consensus protocol. If you are curious about how this is possible in more detail, check out our whitepaper on zkSafeZones - a solution aiming to reduce civilian casualties in conflict areas, by leveraging zkLocus, Zero-Knowlegde protocols and the blockchain: https://zklocus.dev/zkSafeZones/

Still regarding the issuance of the asset, one can leverage zkSNARKs or zkSTARKs to trivially bridge data onto the blockchain from any source, such as your typical HTTPS endpoint. And thanks to their verifiable computation model properties, the correctness of this process can be verified by any third-party, including you and me.

Looking forward to your reply.

iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
Could you please expand on your concerns, namely in the context of the proposed implementation of BRICS currency as a cryptocurrency?
iluxonchik··on BRICS Digital Currency: Cryptocurrency on a Public Blockchain
This articles covers how the proposed BRICS digital currency can be realized as a cryptocurrency, thus challenging the claims made in the 'Digital Money Options for the BRICS' paper. The article explores how a public blockchain with smart contracts, combined with Zero-Knowledge Proof protocols like zkSNARKs and zkSTARKs, provides a natural fit for implementing the BRICS currency. It covers how the dynamic supply mechanism, legal compliance on-chain, and the integration with DeFi and zkLocus for authenticated private geolocation can be materialized. It also explans how the BRICS nations can leverage these technologies for a more decentralized, interoperable, and efficient financial system aligned with Web3 principles.

I’m curious to hear the community's feedback on this. Is there something you disagree on?

iluxonchik··on Collateralized ERC-20 Token
This repository presents a set of smart contracts for creating Collateralized ERC-20 tokens. Such tokens are backed by other ERC-20 tokens, providing a lower bound for their value and stability. Collateralized ERC-20 tokens can be used in various applications, such as loyalty tokens, stablecoins, asset-backed tokens, and tokenized commodities. Such tokens are immune to inflation, as their value is tied to an underlying asset. The concept is similar to "Wrapped Tokens", but the ones presented here are tailored towards the use case of project-specific tokens emitted to its users or investors.
iluxonchik··on Analyzing the performance of Tensorflow training on M1 Mac Mini and Nvidia V100
do you happen to have a draft version available somewhere? i'm diving into ML with Swift soon
iluxonchik··on Starting a Podcast: Anyone Interested in Being a Co-Host?
thank you :)
iluxonchik··on Starting a Podcast: Anyone Interested in Being a Co-Host?
that actually sounds like a good idea for a blog post :)
iluxonchik··on Weak Security and Vulnerabilities in the Portuguese Government's Auth System
Thank you :)

Regarding the XSS attack, I have the answer here: https://iluxonchik.github.io/chave-movel-digital-xss/#commen...

I did not, thank you for suggesting, I will do it now.

iluxonchik··on TLS 1.3 approved
This is not true. The client can simply skip the certificate verification, making the connection unauthenticated. Raw Public Keys (which are basically simplified X.509 certificates), can also lead to unauthenticated connections.

In fact, Appendix C5[1] reads:

   Previous versions of TLS offered explicitly unauthenticated cipher
   suites based on anonymous Diffie-Hellman.  These modes have been
   deprecated in TLS 1.3.  However, it is still possible to negotiate
   parameters that do not provide verifiable server authentication by
   several methods, including:

   -  Raw public keys [RFC7250].

   -  Using a public key contained in a certificate but without
      validation of the certificate chain or any of its contents.
[1] https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tls-tls13-28#appendix...
iluxonchik··on Plagiarized news sites are using Cyrillic characters to avoid detection
I doubt websites hosted in Eastern Europe care about copyright legal threats. Even if they contact the hosting provider directly I doubt any action will be taken. Eastern Europe has plenty of cheap, shady hosting providers where you can host pretty much anything that you want. Unless the website is making a lot of money, nobody is going to spend significant resources to take those websites down.

Let me speculate of why they might be doing it. Google will de-rank pages that have content that's identical to others (e.g. identical paragraphs of text). Maybe Facebook is doing something similar?

Let's say one of your friends shares an article from BuzzFeed.com, then another friend shares an exact clone of this article from FakeBuzzFeed.com. Now, Facebook might not want to show two articles with the same title from two different websites on your timeline. And considering that BuzzFeed.com is a website with a higher ranking that FakeBuzzFeed.com, it will probably choose to display only the fist one. If you do the Cyrillic trick to the article in FakeBuzzFeed.com, Facebook will think it's something completely different and present it to you, thus getting you a higher reach.

The same applies to the advertising part: if you're constantly submitting page ads with exactly the same titles as the one's that real users are sharing, it might get you banned.

iluxonchik··on Regular Expression That Checks If A Number Is Prime
Well, we read from left to right, naturally that is the order of the letters, so the one on the right is "in front" of the left one.
iluxonchik··on Regular Expression That Checks If A Number Is Prime
Yep, you are correct :)
iluxonchik··on Regular Expression That Checks If A Number Is Prime
Oh, that was probably it. That would be true if we were talking about FIFO queues :)
iluxonchik··on Regular Expression That Checks If A Number Is Prime
Okay, technically it's regex, but I didn't want to get into this distinction, since "regex" and "regular expression" are used pretty much interchangeably (unless you're in the academia :) ).
iluxonchik··on Regular Expression That Checks If A Number Is Prime
What do you mean? Could you please clarify that? What did your understand by "in front"?
iluxonchik··on Regular Expression That Checks If A Number Is Prime
Thank you :)

You are probably right, but this function was my first head-to-head encounter with Perl, I researched just a little bit what I needed to know in order to write it.

iluxonchik··on Why People Should Learn Python
Hey there! I've answered a similar observation in the comment section of the blog :)

> Of course it can be done all with command-line tools, but the point was not to show you how you can count and sort word occurrences. I just wanted to show that it's possible to include Python scripts in your "command line workflow". I wanted to give a simple example that would give you a taste of the idea :)

iluxonchik··on Why You Should Learn Python
Yes, I've been doing some Django dev lately and the experience has been very pleasant, specially when it comes down to APIs :)
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →