HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

imbokodo

-13 karma · joined April 14, 2018

submissionscomments
imbokodo··on Why Asian-Americans feel powerless in New York’s elite high schools
There is a class if people who do not work, whose parents did not work, who themselves have parents who do not work. The type seen in the documentary "Born Rich". They get into the best universities as legacies.

You never hear talk of this idle class ensconced in inherited privilege and luxury. However, a few decades after Americans were lynching those of African descent, blowing up their little girls while they're going to church, executing them for voter registration drives etc. - a few decades after that if an attempt is made to push blacks at Stuyvesant above the 1 in 45 mark, in a city where 1 in 4 are black - then, only then do we hear about the need for meritocracy and so on. From the mouth of a man who got a "small loan of a million dollars" from his father, with his son-in-law who, according to Daniel Golden, bought his way into Harvard.

When am I going to see the articles about legacy admissions to the top colleges? I won't hold my breath.

Luxury for the idle class at the top, the rat race (with some national oppression of Africans, Lakota etc. thrown in) for everyone else. No thanks, I'll keep my sickle sharpened for a higher target.

imbokodo··on The Opium of the Intellectuals (2005)
> communism as the best system

Marx said capitalism due to its nature would lead to a cycle of wealth inequality, overproduction, debt bubbles and financial crises, and that these would get worse over time. Capitalism would collapse due to this and be replaced not by communism but socialism.

Communism would be the system that comes after socialism.

imbokodo··on The Opium of the Intellectuals (2005)
> Hasn’t Marxism had its chance?

Marx said "I will not write recipes for the kitchen of the future". As Marx refused to create a "Marxism" for someone to implement, how can Marxism have been tried? It's a question asked by someone who knows little to nothing of him. It's like someone new to computers asking which programming language to learn. There is no answer as it is a naive question. The answer is any or all languages, and they should be studying algorithms and data structures and programming language principles, not the specific mechanism for counting how many characters are in a string in a particular language.

> how many precedents are there for a complete upheaval of the economic system

The upheaval around the time of behavioral modernity. The transition from hunter-gatherer to agriculture. From imperial Rome latifundias to feudalism. From feudalism to capitalism. Then the stirrings of post-capitalist systems from the Paris Commune top now. So that's quite a few changes over the past millennia.

Also Marx said these systems are not overthrown, they self-destruct. Kind of like the Great Depression - due to the internal logic of capitalism, companies will shut, evictions will rise, unemployment will skyrocket, and no internal mechanism of capitalism will have a solution to this.

imbokodo··on The Opium of the Intellectuals (2005)
> This is a distillation of Roger Kimball’s (and many others’) accusations that Marx was an intellectual’s intellectual

I don't even see why it matters. I myself am not an expert on gravitational waves. If Neil Degrasse Tyson or Michio Kazu read a scientific paper by Rainer Weiss on gravitational waves and then break it down for me in layman's language, I don't see why that takes any shine off Weiss's Nobel prize.

As it is, Marx wrote some work for the public like the Communist Manifesto (although 170 years later where the names Metternich and Guizot are less familiar than Merkel and Macron, it may seem more obscure), as well as more dense works like Capital.

It's an silly argument - if Marx went over things lightly, his ideas would be more easily attacked and he would be called lightweight. If he writes densely and goes over each argument thoroughly to make it airtight he can be accused of being difficult for the layman to understand with light reading. I guess Marx preferred making his arguments more airtight than worrying about accusations of being a chore to read.

imbokodo··on The Opium of the Intellectuals (2005)
> AT&T and Walmart all very centralized. It doesn't seem to hurt their performance. They don't compete on price - they define markets and platforms, and dictate terms. They're able to change rapidly compared to monopolies of the past

I don't disagree that AT&Ts monopoly control over the local loop in California, the Midwest and the South, or its oligopolistic control of cell signals have hurt their performance. It has hurt consumers, it has hurt US productivity. One just need to look at some of the other industrialized countries to see how their network access and cell signals can function unfettered by such monopolies.

A decade after the taxpayer TARP bailout of the major "too big to fail" banks, it's stunning to see someone claim that corporate America has finally itself licked centralization and monopoly.

imbokodo··on The controversy over child killing among Amazon tribes in Brazil
Brazil was under a military dictatorship until 1985 where those wanting democracy were imprisoned, tortured and killed. Over the past four years we have seen what started as a minor investigation into corruption turn into a judicial coup, overturning governments the people are voting for - the judges ousted Lula, then their process led to the ousting of Rousseff, who herself was tortured during the dictatorship. You also now have major voices hinting or calling for a return to dictatorship.

You also have well-funded extrajudicial efforts by mining interests massacring Indians, organizers, rural workers or anyone who gets in the way of mining interests. Many uncontacted Indians are being killed, yes - by well-funded mining interests.

In the midst of this, we hear nonsense about the legal system which just overturned Brazilian democracy and which won't provide adequate funding for protecting Indians from mining company slaughter, wading into the Amazon to, in its benevolence, sort out what are probably seen as mercy killings of children who can't survive in that environment and will be leading a life of suffering. Often due to the circumstances caused by the mining companies trying to kill them. It's the height of hubris and hypocrisy that Foreign Policy, which itself has justified more bloodshed than any magazine, sees fit to try to bestow this mantle into itself.

imbokodo··on The Ratio of Workers to Retirees Is Plunging Across Developed Economies
And the ratio of workers to worker productivity increases every year, so it all balances out.

In the US I pay inordinate taxes and do not get the health, education etc. that I would in Europe. Instead I am paying for hundreds of US military bases all over the world, the $1.5 trillion F35 piece of junk etc. The one thing I will get, money in retirement, they are trying to take away from me.

imbokodo··on A Japanese cyber-security expert who defended basic decency was stabbed to death
> societal abundance

These might be times of abundance, but not societal abundance. Trump did not win speaking about there being societal abundance. It does not exist in the US, and certainly not in the third world. Just walk down to the Tenderloin in San Francisco or take an extended walk around Oakland, and you can see this for yourself.

imbokodo··on ‘A Powerful Signal of Recessions’ Has Wall Street’s Attention
> Or capital's other options for returns (real estate, emerging markets, etc) will look bad-ish for the next 10 years and continue to prop up the stock market because its the only good outlet for extra cash for a decade or three.

And if capital flows into the stock market, not to keep pace with growth or to expropriate the standard rate of profit, but simply because it has nowhere else to go, then the natural outcome of this is overproduction. Which leads to a falling rate of profit. Which eventually means falling stock prices, as earnings and market cap are always linked over the long term (even for Amazon.com, which will have to start showing a profit when it moves from #8 to #2 on the Fortune 500 list).

imbokodo··on Successfully Countering Russian Electoral Interference
Actually the last time the French government was toppled was in 1958. The communists had become the largest party, and French officers, unhappy with decolonization, especially in Algeria, seized Corsica and planned to invade Metropolitan France in Operation Resurrection.
imbokodo··on Things I Learned in the Gulag
A good book on prison lessons is Soledad Brother by George Jackson, a black man who was imprisoned in Soledad Prison, California, USA. He was killed by a guard at San Quentin in 1971.
imbokodo··on AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner
Lenin wrote about the inevitability of monopoly in 1916. He would not have been surprised that the 1911 break up of Standard Oil would be undone in 1999 with the ExxonMobil, nor the slow reconsolidation of the Baby Bells, nor the other monopolies bringing us back to the gilded age.

http://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/ch0...

imbokodo··on AI at Google: our principles
This was basically the same argument the Zentrumspartei made for voting for the Enabling Act in 1933.
imbokodo··on Social Security says system's costs will exceed income this year
Congress repealed the creation of the Independent Payment Advisory Board, that would cut the cost of Medicare without cutting service much. Thus Medicare costs are higher, thus spending exceeds income. Reinstate this board, as well as some other measures, and it will be back on target.

It is a manufactured problem. Anything benefiting the taxpayer like Social Security or schools is always being cut, while the funds to move the US embassy to Jerusalem or send the Navy to the South China Sea seems to be bottomless.

imbokodo··on The New Yorker has formed a union
> forced

You are working at a place where you are as forced to take orders from bosses employed by the Newhouse heirs. People work all day to get their wages and refurbish ongoing capital expenses, then at night they work for free to kick up expropriated surplus time profits to SI Newhouse IV.

Conde Nast, without consulting you, as they do for most decisions, has theoretically come to the agreement with a union that they represent you as a bargaining unit. This , of all the things you are forced to do seems to be the only one you have a problem with, the one giving you more autonomy and money.

It's a bizarrely convoluted logic where you have almost no say in Conde Nast's decision about your own management, revenue disbursement etc., but in solely this decision that they made, you are being "forced".

imbokodo··on Seymour Hersh on spies, state secrets, and the stories he doesn’t tell
That link reminds me of when Bush said "This crusade - this war on terrorism - is going to take a while". If Bush described the war on terror as a crusade, I don't see how out there Hersh is when he says some officers see the war on terror as a crusade.

Also General Boykin is listed as the Grand Chancellor of the Knights of Malta on their web page ( http://www.theknightshospitallers.org/grand-chancellor.html ). The old crusader order. Boykin gave a speech in a church in October 2003 that seemed to cast the war as a holy war between Christianity and Islam.

This sentiment exists for some in the military and Hersh mentions it in speeches and interviews.

imbokodo··on Seymour Hersh on spies, state secrets, and the stories he doesn’t tell
You and tptacek are putting words like "cabal" in his mouth.

The mainstream press beyond Hersh has reported on Christian fundamentalism at leadership levels at the USAFA during Bush's presidency. Also former undersecretary of Defense for Intelligence General Boykin's actions and statements.

There are also stories Bush told Chirac about Gig and Magog, and biblical prophecy during the war in Iraq. How true that is I do not know.

I see this type of talk on cable TV late at night where I live. I can imagine what radio and TV in Oklahoma or Mississippi is playing. I am not surprised this has gotten into the water. Nor do I find it odd Hersh would mention this in an interview or speech, it must seem strange to a rational secular person like himself.

The military fundamentalist news was not Hersh specific and was reported more widely.

imbokodo··on Seymour Hersh on spies, state secrets, and the stories he doesn’t tell
> an elaborate ruse

News started to leak out that bin Laden had been killed in Abbotabad not long after it happened. As no one disputes, one of the helicopters crashed.

The disputed premise is either the Pakistani high command ok'd the raid (Hersh) or they did not (you - official line). That is the premise. The "elaborate ruse to cover up a quid pro quo conspiracy" is a no-brainer after that. If the high command did OK the raid and there was no ruse, it would basically be saying the Pakistani military does not protect Pakistanis from the invasion of foreign armies, that it is more or less a US puppet. Something a sizable portion of Pakistan, not unsympathetic to bin Laden, thought already.

And why wouldn't they support bin Laden - the US stood along side them supporting bin Laden's jihad to oust the secular government of Afghanistan in the 1980s. They have just remained the same, it's the US that shifted its policies (putting Army bases in Saudi Arabia, getting into conflict with bin Laden and other Arabian elements).

Either the high command ok'd the raid or they did not. It is natural for the ruse and conspiracy to follow. I am sure it was one of the "ransom" demands made so that the raid could happen.

imbokodo··on Seymour Hersh on spies, state secrets, and the stories he doesn’t tell
> He was pummeled for publishing, in the LRB, an all-but-refuted story claiming that the entire story about the assassination of Osama Bin Laden was a lie (he relied on the secondhand story of a retired, anonymous defense department employee for his sourcing; his home publication, The New Yorker, refused to run it).

The New Yorker refused to run his bin Laden story? The My Lai story was published in the St. Louis Dispatch, only 30 papers picked it up initially. Only the Washington Post published about Watergate for months (with a few exceptions). Abu Ghraib was barely reported until the pictures came out. That the commissar at the New Yorker would not affix his signature means little to me.

The official story was, and in your mind presumably still is (though it seems to be in tatters now) that Osama bin Laden sat in a compound in Abbotabad, to the complete ignorance of all high Pakistani officials, including those living less than a mile away at the Pakistan Military Academy. Tariq Ali called this risible in the days after the raid, as did some of the Pakistani press. It's a completely ludicrous story. Later investigation by Pakistani journalists, Hersh and others uncovered even more. The official story was known to be ridiculous when it was announced. You are correct that he was pummeled for publishing the story and about the New Yorker though. I am not sure what has been refuted, other than the US government sticking by its original story. I guess it all comes down to whether one believes IF Stone's old journalistic maxim "Governments lie". People seem more interested in ad hominem attacks on Hersh, appeals to authority etc. as opposed to looking into whether the bin Laden raid story was true. Because the idea that no one in high position with connections to the Pakistani Military Academy had no notion bin Laden was there is laughable.

imbokodo··on China has turned Xinjiang into a police state like no other
The Marxist/Maoist idea of the Chinese would be that the government is just part of the superstructure on top of the base. The base being the current state of the forces of production in their continual self-evolution and reinvention, and the relations of production flowing from that.

In other words, the economic system determines the political system. When hunter-gatherers became farmers, the political system changed. When farming as the center made way for manufacturing and industry, the political system changed (as did culture).

I don't see this as much different than Americans driving Lakota onto the Standing Rock Indian Reservation. Just two years ago the US federal government arrested and injured many on that reservation. Or Americans driving Vietnamese onto strategic hamlets. Or locking Japanese up in the 1940s. I don't see what innovation the Chinese have made.

imbokodo··on Google Won't Renew Contract for Project Maven, Pentagon Drone AI Imaging Program
You're correct that a corporation's biggest enemies are the workers who do all the work and create all the wealth of that corporation.

You're also correct that this is a victory for those workers and a defeat for the corporation.

imbokodo··on China’s SenseTime, the world’s highest-valued AI startup, closes $620M round
> Not only that, but the US government is neither as aggressive nor as forward-looking about such partnerships, preferring to let market forces have their way

I have not seen this in practice. Wall Street had Glass-Steagall repealed in 1999 which led to the TARP $420 billion bailout in 2008, and Trump just rolled back almost all of Dodd-Frank, so the next taxpayer bank bailout is probably not far off (US taxpayers bailed out S&Ls in the 1980s too). I have not seen much of market forces having their way in the US other than lip service.

Also, look at the 1970s history of Lockheed to see a "never let fail - heed the diktats" company. From the 1971 billion dollar government bailout to the 1976 bribery scandal. Probably one of the most government blessed companies in a country full of such-blessed companies.

imbokodo··on The 9.9 Percent Is the New American Aristocracy
The top is predicated on the existence of the bottom. I watched some of the royal wedding the other day, that family has not worked in living memory, or perhaps even historical memory.

Heirs live in luxury without need of work because what used to be called the reserve army of labor is used as a bulwark against those working, which in cause generates those profits. Wealth created by those who work, expropriated by heirs who do not work. So, as I said, the top is predicated on the existence of the bottom.

imbokodo··on The 9.9 Percent Is the New American Aristocracy
As all wealth that can be created comes from work, and as the heirs who mostly make up the 0.1% do not work, it follows that the wealth comes from those below.

Actually the article has a fairly conservative vantage. As the pie is not what is significant. The wealth and money and pie have little significance. What matters is the expropriation of surplus labor time, by the heir, from the one who works. It is a social relationship, expropriating the worker's time. The pie, the wealth, the product is not what has significance here.

imbokodo··on Ask HN: When is federation a better solution than decentralization?
The US Treasury department says trading in Petro cryptocoins would violate US sanctions against Venezuela. So Bitfinex will not trade in it. Coinmarketcap.com lists over 1500 cryptocoins, but not the Petro.

This sort of things shows up the myth of decentralization. Only one cryptocoin with elements of decentralization has been truly challenged, and has basically collapsed under US government pressure. It shows "decentralization" only exists until one powerful country challenges it. Which effectively means all cryptocoins may as well be directed by the US Federal Reserve. Which means you might as well buy dollars if that is the case.

While this is all the case, it can not be proved, so can be dismissed. What it does portend - the complete collapse of Bitcoin at some point - can not be dismissed though.

imbokodo··on In a Warming West, the Rio Grande Is Drying Up
Texas's governor, Greg Abbott sued the federal government to stop climate change regulations.

Then when Hurricane Harvey hit, he said the federal government needed to give him over $100 billion for the cleanup.

imbokodo··on Mandaeism
> They do marry other Jews

Other Jews can marry in, but even this is limited. The majority of self-identifying Jews in the US would not have the qualifications to marry in. Any how, they are an insular community.

imbokodo··on Mandaeism
The Syrian Jews in Brooklyn, New York are near-impossible to convert into. I don't see it as inconceivable some other sect banned it altogether.
imbokodo··on Chinese mass-indoctrination camps evoke Cultural Revolution
And here we see it...the British intern people like Michael Farrell without a trial, and he is said to be a "captured IRA member" and so forth. He's still alive actually, acting as a lawyer for refugees. You people still have to invent lies for why you interned people like him, shot unarmed people in the street that protested the internment etc.

But the Chinese are the real bad guys. It's why the British had to burn his winter palace at the end of the Opium wars.

imbokodo··on Chinese mass-indoctrination camps evoke Cultural Revolution
In 1971, England began interning thousands of Irish who opposed the English army in the six counties of north Ireland. The New York Times wrote editorials calling the interned without trial "diehards" and "uncompromising bigots". A few months later, a march for their civil rights through Derry was met by gunfire as 14 unarmed men were shot by the British.

It's strange (well, not really) how easily we see sympathy or shrugging when the English speaking West interns without trial, or incarcerates Muslim radicals under torture, or mass incarcerates its former slave population etc., then dabs a handkerchief for Muslim radicals in China. It reminds me of the tears shed in Washington DC for the Muslim terrorists blowing up Chechnya in 1999, and 2000. That kind of slowed down in 2001.

I suppose this is "whataboutism", which is amazement at Western professionals who pontificate about far-off lands of competitors, when the westerners have done or are doing worse.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →