HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

imbokodo

-13 karma · joined April 14, 2018

submissionscomments
imbokodo··on Google employees reportedly quit over military drone AI project
> the world is full of extremists > Osama bin Laden could have been bombed

What you seem to be saying, in what we hear all the time, is spending money and doing work that increased the power and capabilities of the US military will makes us all better off.

You are also seem to be saying that Osama bin Laden is an extremist.

But in the 1970s, as Afghanistan was working towards becoming a more secular society, the US military and intelligence agencies were arming Osama bin Laden and his fellow jihadis, the proto Taliban and proto Al Qaeda. Who wanted, among other things, for the secularization of Afghanistan to stop, and for an Islamic dominated government to come in. An effort which the US succeeded in, along with their partner Osama bin Laden.

This being the case, I am not exactly sure when bin Laden and people like him became extremists. I suppose it was after the US began it's military occupation of Saudi Arabia. Osama bin Laden opposed the US military occupation of his country.

This may sound equivocal about bin Laden, but the US is more equivocal about bin Laden. I think he never should have been armed by the US. People of a like mind said as much then. Others disagreed.

In other words, if the US is making political errors (or is not making errors and is pursuing negative goals), more power and capability to carry out those erroneous policies will not help matters.

For example, Trump just escalated the conflict in the Middle East this week, which only satisfies religious fundamentalists. Handing him more power to do so will not help things, it will just mean more 9/11s in response to the blow he just landed against Arabs/Muslims.

imbokodo··on H. G. Wells' 1934 interview with Stalin (2014)
"Stone Age Economics" by Marshall Sahlins
imbokodo··on H. G. Wells' 1934 interview with Stalin (2014)
These events are determined by things like the reproduction of labor, not Earth's solar orbits, which is why a generational timeline is more apropos. Also we have data from a variety of sources, but do not know the exact day when the first person was enslaved in the Fertile Crescent.

That aside, I mean right before 10000 years ago, before concepts like slavery, class, surplus etc. began their rise.

All human society then were in traveling hunter-gatherer bands.

imbokodo··on H. G. Wells' 1934 interview with Stalin (2014)
It is strange reading this - 330 generations ago, the entire world was communist. This began fading away, whereas nowadays only a few people live like this, deep in the Amazon and in other out of the way places. So it was a very natural state of human history from now back to the beginning, and the only way from 330 generations to the beginning.

Whereas the seeds of a capitalist society are at most 20 generations old. The news is full of talk of the royal wedding in the UK - officially ruled by the monarch. The United Kingdom is de jure a feudal kingdom still, if not de facto (I do not mean the UK still is de facto feudal, but that it is a sign of how recent this all is that, de jure, the UK is de jure feudal).

It's strange that such a recent phenomenon, with all its crises and such can be seen as the only way aligned with human nature, whereas one existing from the beginning is described as utopian.

imbokodo··on I am leaving llvm
> Damore and Eich...THAT's why they're EXCLUDING people for their political views

The actual exclusion can be seen by walking around the engineering departments of FAANG companies (or Market Street startups) and seeing virtually all male, white or Asian faces. One in eight Americans are black - where are they? That is the real exclusion. Damore was fired for effectively boasting about this exclusion.

It's illustrative that you ignore the massive exclusion of blacks and others from non-sweeping, non-cafeteria server jobs, and get ALL CAPS semi-hysterical that those who are dumb enough to align themselves with these exclusions and subjugations are the victims and excluded ones.

imbokodo··on A new book on Renaissance mathematics makes a bold case
Copernicus was employed by the Catholic Church, but did not publish until March of 1543 - and he died in May 1543. So yes, he was employed by the church and openly promoted heliocentrism for less than two months and then died.
imbokodo··on Two Koreas Agree to End War This Year, Pursue Denuclearization
You mean like the massacre of No Gun Ri and the general policy of shooting civilians in the Korean war? The Gwangju massacre?

Oh you don't mean the atrocities of the dictatorships in the south under the US military occupation, you mean the north.

imbokodo··on Two Decades of War Have Eroded the Morale of America’s Troops
> tried to keep North Vietnam from conquering South Vietnam

That is not what US internal diplomatic notes said at the time, not in modern interviews if McNamara, Clark Clifford etc.

The Vichy French colonialists, then the non-Vichy French, then the Americans fought to retain the Vietnamese colony in the south. The fight was against the National Liberation Front in the south - Buddhist monks, Paris educated professionals, peasants etc. The north had little involvement until mid-1968. Also French Indochina was one country until 1954, and the ceasefire lines were supposed to be temporary barring national elections, which the US opposed. There never was a "South Vietnam".

> The South's people would have the same horrific history

US policy during the Korean War was to fire on civilians, as happened at No Gun Ri. South Korea was under a series of dictatorships with a more horrific history than anything happening up north until the late 1970s up until the Gwangju massacre in 1980 in South Korea. The northern economy eclipsed the southern one as well. Things began changing in both countries in the 1980s and 1990s for a variety of internal and external reasons.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3