HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

imoverclocked

2,901 karma · joined December 12, 2015

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/imoverclocked; my proof: https://keybase.io/imoverclocked/sigs/Z0Q0aI_Vlw_3St1jfvfagZrFc1voOffbSR7m2kfGkFI ]

All opinions posted here are my own.

submissionscomments
imoverclocked··on Several vulnerabilities have been discovered in the Linux kernel
Is there a way to know if a particular vanilla kernel has a particular CVE addressed? Unhelpfully, the ChangeLog-* only seems to contain sporadic references to CVEs.
imoverclocked··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
I don’t think it’s that unique. Social learning is documented in a wide range of species.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_learning_in_animals

imoverclocked··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
If you have enough friends, you can learn the lesson.
imoverclocked··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
Canal sized pipes?
imoverclocked··on What Sun got wrong
We used it all to great success ... along with our Linux hosts. We had a stack of T1's and eventually a few thumpers (x4500's) which we ended up running a variant of OpenSolaris on. There was also some bigger iron that was humming along on Solaris 8 which provided a very stable environment (until I fat-fingered a command one day.)

Later on, we even ran an ipfilter based router from a T1 on OpenSolaris for decent IPv6 connectivity with link-aggregation+vlans when our Cisco 6509 setup was found to be inadequate for the task.

imoverclocked··on What Sun got wrong
I mean, flashback to 2010 ... zones, dtrace, smf, iscsi and zfs were very well integrated together and lightyears beyond what was available in the Linux space at the time.

Zones were lightweight, more akin to the Linux vserver project or lxc. You could make a zone on its own zfs filesystem, clone the zone (which creates a zfs clone), launch the clone, run a throw-away task, tear the zone down which also discards the zfs snapshot+clone. It was quick and cheap but also half a decade before Docker was released or popularized.

zfs integrated into other parts of the system just as well. eg: iSCSI volumes backed by a zpool and export properties configured in zfs. All of these technologies were built with the idea of being "self-healing." Meanwhile, Linux has a disparate iSCSI daemon, lvm+ext4/reiserfs, initd, and probably 20 different tools to learn if you want to grab metrics across the stack like dtrace on Solaris was capable of.

The out of band management was amazing too. Yes, some x86 hardware had ilom but like everything else in the space, it's bolted on and not truly integrated.

Sun made really nice stuff that outpaced Linux in a lot of ways. The ecosystem came from a time of competing BSDs and looked for paying customers for the engineering marvel they had created. They were used to customers figuring out how to use Unix, and the Linux crowd at the time still fit that rubric. The OS was not optimized for low-latency terminal interaction and thus "felt slow" (aka: Slowaris) but a well tuned DB on Sparc really cooked.

Finally, I went to a few Sun events and had Sun reps come and look at what we were doing. They were definitely happy to help with any kind of outreach/onboarding we needed. The issue was none of "onboarding" but was a lot of "Linux is a movement." In early times, Linux was an anti-corporate movement and some of that energy carried through to the 2010s. It's sadly ironic because Sun itself has roots in open standards and an anti-establishment mentality.

imoverclocked··on Nobody pays for FOSS, we can force them to
The reason I dislike this is because of the game it creates. Let's say we have someone who developed a small, well-used dependency (say: xz) but there is now incentive to be "in the dependency chain." xz is open, LLMs are really good at stealing/recreating; what stops someone from publishing rxz (maybe a rust port, maybe a gnu-r port, maybe it's "Really fast" xz, maybe it's just hoping for a typo in a registry.) This new dependency adds very little over the original xz and xz could have just used a simple PR.

On the other side of things, does accepting a PR from someone grant the author the ability to collect royalties for that software project? If so, how would you quantify that? LOC seems like a quick but really bad answer for what it is incentivizing.

For many, the entire point of "F" in "FOSS" is not getting tangled up in this kind of mess. I personally would never want to add "am I opening myself up to a lawsuit if I don't pay someone for their PR" to enter my calculus of accepting a PR. Especially if this is because I reject payment at all on a project.

Finally, if a company/employee submits code to FOSS under this model, do they now expect a return?

imoverclocked··on NATS publishes preliminary report on technical incident of 8 September
2026 … but the code is running from what decade and has to interact with systems from what other decades?
imoverclocked··on Let's make quality the norm again
Being “a dick” and having a high quality product are often orthogonal to each other. Reputation also requires brand recognition which often lends itself to enshittification as companies get established.
imoverclocked··on Let's make quality the norm again
So, given reality, how would you suggest this gets done?
imoverclocked··on LG denies TV spying claims, says tracking and snooping concerns 'not true'
Then what about all the cloud enabled spyware? How would that work? (/sarcasm)

Truly though, smart-home stuff runs the whole gamut of privacy and device manufacturer relationships. eg: I have used three different smart/room AC units:

- one requires its own cloud-enabled app for any remote connectivity, no HomeKit integration - one integrates with HomeKit but then leaves an upgrade hint that can only be done through an app with a login - one integrates with HomeKit and pretty much just works

HomeKit then allows me to remotely control via HomePod/AppleTV acting as a router ... of course this is just a different cloud connectivity but with on-premises devices controlling other on-premises devices.

For each manufacturer of smart devices, there is potentially a separate cloud where data is being funneled through. Some devices support multiple upstreams.

I get that Matter should be a way to fix it but the reality feels more like https://xkcd.com/927/

Part of me just wants dumb devices back. Get rid of buttons on a microwave (just give me a knob for time and maybe another knob for power setting.) Remove touchscreens from cars (mine glares at me with certain sun-angles.) Bring back the desktop/computer hutch and phones that don't live in your pocket. However, having the ability to start cooling my bedroom 45 minutes before I arrive home is ... pretty compelling too.

imoverclocked··on Record-High 89% in U.S. Say Government Corruption Widespread
> You all literally saw what he did in his first term!

False, unfortunately. Disparate news outlets covered events very differently and folks watching pro-Trump outlets (or only listening to friends who do) through the first term were under the impression that he did an excellent job. They may even still believe that the 2020 election was actually stolen. Heck, there are depositions this year while vetting appointees who refuse to admit (despite all available evidence) that the 2020 election was valid.

imoverclocked··on deSEC – Free Secure DNS
I had this issue with cloudns and a single record with an IPv4 and IPv6 address. They only allowed one free ddns record which covered exactly one protocol. On top of that, they added records to resolve unknown names for advertising purposes.

I get that it costs money to run a DNS service but it seems like it should be a lot cheaper at scale than a lot of companies are providing.

imoverclocked··on The largest electric aircraft just flew [video]
Aircraft design is very intricate. Change the CG, break the whole system.

Fuel is often placed in wings because adding/burning fuel from your center of lift means your CG doesn't significantly change through a flight and you spend less on pumping fuel within the aircraft. With batteries, you are looking at a constant mass from the beginning of the flight to the end... so you can place it anywhere. Electric motors are orders of magnitude lighter than jet engines. Also, you don't need to pump electrons against gravity so placing all of that weight lower has handling/performance advantages.

By using an airframe shape that is well known, they are reducing risk and appealing to existing pilots. By building it from the ground-up, they are taking advantage of differences between the tech.

eg: all of that weight in the fuselage instead of the wings means that rolling is going to be much more nimble. Yaw might be affected as well, depending on the placement/moment of the batteries.

imoverclocked··on Why HPSC Is a Big Deal for Space Exploration
> The PIC64-HPSC series has a built-in 240 Gbps, 16-port TSN Ethernet switch with Remote Direct Memory Access (RDMA) that uses the RDMA over Converged Ethernet (RoCE) version 2 standard

It seems like this is what the article is referencing. However, the ethernet embedded CPUs have "GigE" or even 10/100 capability. Why the need for 240 Gbps with 16 GigE ports? Are the ports 10G fiber capable and they are just future-proofing or is there something I missed with the time-slicing and RDMA?

imoverclocked··on Protobuf has LSP support
There is a lot of ambiguity in this thread.

Yes, breaking changes need to be staged carefully/compatibly across versions.

Simple renaming/reordering is not a breaking change between code versions. The wire format knows numeric ids, not names. It breaks code compilation until the renames are put into effect. There is a subtle breakage where someone renames a field (think: field -> old_field) and then later adds "field" to mean something else; software that isn't recompiled in this window might not recognize that "field" is potentially different. Uncompiled languages may suffer this even more subtly. -- All of this to say, breaking compilation is not the end of the world but there are more dragons as the scope grows.

Stop-the-world is usually only needed when someone has made an unplanned/incompatible change with versions that are still running. If your infrastructure+development is done right (hah) this should never happen.

imoverclocked··on Apple's App Tracking Transparency treated its own apps better than rivals
> In addition, app publishers and content providers, such as media publishers, will be given more scope to explain to users what significance personalised advertising has for their offering and their business model.

Great, sounds like a new channel for marketing where I really just want to opt-out. Also, does this added scope include the mechanism to maliciously comply like so many websites do with cookies? (eg: You want our cookies? Here is a list of things you can de-select... with toggles that aren't clearly on or off)

imoverclocked··on Protobuf has LSP support. You're welcome
Despite interesting legal definitions, companies are just groups of people.

I also read the title as having an air of self-importance or maybe passive-aggression. If you read it a little more dispassionately then it's just an awkward way of stating that this is a gift.

Why is this a gift? The company does not need to give it to you, though it arguably benefits from doing so. It did so with some definition of "free."

imoverclocked··on Protobuf has LSP support. You're welcome
> a useless one

If you have a (long) list of fields and you want to keep them lexicographically sorted, being able to reorder is quite useful if you rename a field.

imoverclocked··on I close SSH port 22 (and what I use instead)
I’m confused; Your entire response seems like reasons to not do this.
imoverclocked··on I close SSH port 22 (and what I use instead)
This is an interesting piece that is often overlooked by folks in the "but NAT is security" camp; Having a sparse address space that is 64-bits makes it impossible to iteratively scan over a range. If you don't reverse resolve or you disallow zone transfers then you also have no real discoverability for that /64.
imoverclocked··on I close SSH port 22 (and what I use instead)
> Whoever wrote that does not know WTF they are talking about

... or they know something you don't.

imoverclocked··on The main way I've seen people turn ideologically crazy (2025)
I think knowing about the branches of your government is a prerequisite to having an opinion or good argument about it. It’s not sufficient to just know that but it’s a good filter in the USA where a surprising number of people have “opinions” but lack the most basic knowledge.
imoverclocked··on “Code was never the hard part” is an insult to all programmers
Code still is the hard part. Or at least one of them.

Code, is written in a language. Language is opinionated. Things written in that language are also opinionated. LLMs often have horrible opinions.

imoverclocked··on Parsers don't have to be complicated
Is the good reason that parsers are doing this in the first place? To me, it sounds like a practice/implementation that necessitates a second layer of parsing. If so, then maybe JSON is not the optimal medium to be using for the data being distributed.
imoverclocked··on Parsers don't have to be complicated
The hardest thing about writing a parser is cognitively accepting what is going to be considered valid input. You can make the best parser that is fast and well specified but invariably someone will (ab)use it in an unexpected way.

Famous examples: despite so many initial good intentions, html tags don’t need to be closed, JSON numbers are too often encoded as strings, YAML can look like what most people expect or it can look progressively more like JSON… and on and on.

imoverclocked··on Show HN: Kakehashi – Experimental userspace to run macOS binaries on Linux ARM
Do you plan on supporting different target versions and implementing similar restrictions to those targets?

eg: older macOS had a writable /usr/ while newer does not without manual effort.

Also, do you plan on having similar cli tools available with similar features ported (maybe from the available Darwin sources?)

eg: can I run a /bin/bash script that expects a macOS environment? Will it get "Darwin" from "uname -o"

imoverclocked··on NetBSD 11.0
> That saves me $ and helps the environment a little bit :)

Seems like a tradeoff with power though. Even emulating hardware from that era is more power efficient than actually running it. Of course, if you have custom ISA cards or something then you are likely stuck :)

imoverclocked··on NetBSD 11.0
> If you are using flash-based media (e.g. a USB drive), please use the .img files rather than the .iso images.

I have done that in the past but there are already .img files specifically for USB. Seems redundant.

imoverclocked··on NetBSD 11.0
> CD-ROM media

Wow, I just learned that I can still buy a pack of new CD-RW discs. This is an almost 30 year old format that is still published for!

Long live ATAPI!

Seriously though, why still publish CD formats when a usb-stick is far more ubiquitous and much easier to actually write. Are there systems that can boot CD-ROM interfaces that don't have USB boot capability still?

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →