HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

incision

4,766 karma · joined June 6, 2012

hn.incision@gmail.com
submissionscomments
incision··on Show HN: Professional sound effects for UI projects
Very slick.

I would definitely use this if I had a need for it beyond changing the default notifications on my phone/desktop.

One suggestion, I think the those little 'devices' are the perfect way to demonstrate why I would want this, but it wasn't immediately obvious to me that they were interactive at all.

A unique color or subtle animation for the play buttons to make them eye-catching might be worthwhile since clicking was definitely a revelation.

incision··on Amazon just told me to log into someone else's account – and delete it
>"The practice of checking the validity of email addresses seems to be lost on many (most?) businesses."

Yes, including some that should really know better.

I see this issue with more than one major bank.

>"Whenever I could find the relevant information, I contacted the various people that send me the original email to correct the information."

That's brave. I've had nothing but grief with this - some combination of "Who are you?", "Leave me alone." and "You stole my email address!" in every case.

Contacting the sender isn't much better.

In the case of medical / financial information it seems to me there should be an easy way to report this to some sort of regulatory authority.

incision··on The Predictions of Robert A. Heinlein
While I get that Heinlein may have intended to make genuine predictions...

"Heinlein carefully points out that all good science fiction writers tell a story first and prophesy second, using arguably the greatest of them all, H.G. Wells, as an example."

There's something I really dislike about evaluating science fiction as prediction in general.

A work of fiction can't be right or wrong, just more or less similar. Flying cars and geopolitics in the year 2000 are no more right or wrong than the color of imagined character's eyes.

incision··on Fire TV Stick
Ordered one with the benefit of the Prime discount, don't think I would have done it for $39. At the higher price I'd be inclined to spend twice as much and get another Roku 3.

I'll hook it up to the one display that doesn't currently have a Roku attached. The discount price of $19 seems worth never using the horrible built-in apps on that display again.

That said, my expectations are low - even at $19. Amazon impresses me as uneven and lazy when it comes to everything but their core business.

It's stuff like the original Kindle Fire launching with the awful combination of no parental controls + one-click ordering or the Android Kindle app lacking basic display settings for ages and still lacking a consistent store experience.

Given that, plugging this stick in to find that it too lacks parental controls or runs some outdated or incomplete version of popular app like Netflix or YouTube would not surprise me in the slightest.

incision··on Alan Eustace Jumps from Stratosphere, Breaking Felix Baumgartner’s World Record
Fantastic.

I've long thought that if I ever acquire the means I'd want to take a U2 ride like James May [1]. I'm thinking I'd definitely prefer this.

Also, no wonder his name felt so familiar [2].

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJoMDq4AyLc

2: http://pando.com/2014/03/27/how-steve-jobs-forced-google-to-...

incision··on Assange: Google Is Not What It Seems
The piece is 5800+ words, exactly one of which is DARPA.

It's entirely possible that Assange is a nut, but nothing he says presents quite as nutty as extrapolating that single mention into a tale of innocent students being seeded with delusions of CIA double agents and elite shadow cabals by a scheming madman.

incision··on Assange: Google Is Not What It Seems
That was interesting.

I've always been a bit curious about Schmidt and what sort of measure someone who is neither in awe nor seeking to impress might make of him.

I think the whole piece is probably best summed up with this line towards then end.

>"What Lockheed Martin was to the twentieth century, technology and cyber-security companies will be to the twenty-first."

That certainly makes sense.

incision··on How Crowdsourcing Turned on Me
Fascinating stuff, not at all what I was expecting. Two things come to mind reading this.

1.) The crowdsourced and algorithmic solutions seem to be framed in contrast if not exclusive to each other here. I wonder if combining the two couldn't have helped avoid this:

>'However, the crowd was hopeless against a determined attacker. Before the first attack, our progress on the fourth puzzle had combined 39,299 moves by 342 users over more than 38 hours. Destroying all this progress required just 416 moves by one attacker in about an hour.'

I'm wondering if it's easier to create a 'bouncer' algorithm that detects and blocks/reverts aberrant behavior than to solve the core puzzle itself. If that problem is in fact easier - identifying 'hurtful' or unusual moves, could addressing it help the core solution by helping avoid non-malicious 'back sliding' too?

(I have no clue about these things.)

2.) The sort self-importance expressed by the attacker is just awful.

Unlike the author, I don't see it as a concern about "how crowdsourcing puts the collective potential of humans above technology". That almost sounds noble.

This impresses me as plain old envy and entitlement, an overgrown cousin to every "Why is this on HN?" or "Why is this on the front page? I submitted this before and no one voted for it." comment on HN. The whole thing is one big "should" of personal gratification.

incision··on Fabric – Mobile developer platform by Twitter
I find this choice of name particularly egregious. It's not just the existence of current projects [1] and common use in technology prior [2], but the source.

Twitter, being Twitter could call this whatever they wanted.

"Yolk" or whatever would make just as many front pages.

I don't see how "Fabric" can do anything but serve someone inside Twitter who likes the name while being inconvenient / irrelevant to everyone else.

1: http://www.fabfile.org/

2: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switched_fabric

incision··on The Percy Jackson Problem
I feel like both 'sides' are talking around each other here. Both have points, both are overstated.

Personally, I'd worry less about the headiness of these books than what seem to be common themes of characters whose defining characteristics are innate - birth as a demigod, half-wizard or having a high midichlorian count.

Does anyone still write about 'normal' people doing great things?

incision··on Maglev Train Seen Making Washington-to-Baltimore Trip at 311 MPH
>"The Silver Line is pretty expensive for what it is, but I think you're overstating it. If I understand the Wikipedia page correctly, the $6.8 billion figure is for the full 23 mile extension, not just the 11.6 miles built so far."

You're right, I did mistate the length.

In general though, I think you're misunderstanding my thrust here. You're talking about value, I don't think this project is a good value at all, quite the opposite [1].

I'm just thinking about engineering and construction...

The Silver Line is a demonstration that building 23 miles of 45 mph commuter rail line costs at least $6.8B despite the benefit the benefit of 40 years, 100+ miles and 90 stations worth of experience doing the same.

Given that, actually building a first of it's kind 40 mile 300 mph rail line through the same sort of aerial and tunnel requiring [2] suburban counties around DC for 'only' $10B seems completely implausible.

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8492525

2: http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/bal-maglev-train-i...

incision··on Maglev Train Seen Making Washington-to-Baltimore Trip at 311 MPH
>'$10B seems exhorbitant for a 40 mile stretch of track + trains etc.'

Perhaps, but it's right on par with the cost of the recent Metro extension which cost $6.8B for an 11.6 mile extension running on existing tech.

Successfully building an entirely new Maglev line for 'only' $10B would be a steal relatively speaking, but I don't see that happening.

More likely, I'd expect the planners want Government buy-in because they recognize how susceptible the Government is to chasing sunk costs and covering all the difference when the project predictably balloons to 5x what was proposed.

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_Line_(Washington_Metro)

incision··on Maglev Train Seen Making Washington-to-Baltimore Trip at 311 MPH
This impresses me as someone chasing Federal funds and trying to PoC maglev in the US, not a solution to any real problem.

>'A maglev train may help ease traffic that has made roads in Maryland’s Montgomery County, which lies between Washington and Baltimore, the fourth-most-congested in the country, according to digital-mapping company TomTom NV. (TOM2) Washington ranks seventh.'

Not really.

Prince Georges, Anne Arundel and Howard lie between Baltimore and DC, hence the existing MARC lines running through them [1]. Any new lines would undoubtedly follow those paths.

It's not DC <-> Baltimore that's miserable it's Northern VA <-> North / East DC suburbs. Transit in the DC area is built around bringing people in and out of DC, not from suburb to suburb.

People who don't take MARC for the DC <-> Baltimore now aren't doing it for time, they're doing it because they don't want to ride the MARC, deal with the bottleneck of Union Station then ride two Metro trains and a bus to get to work in VA. Swapping MARC for Maglev won't change that, but it will cost a lot of money.

Improving the existing infrastructure and/or figuring out how to draw more business into DC proper would be a better use of any funds.

1: http://mta.maryland.gov/sites/default/files/MARCsystemmap.JP...

incision··on The Introverted Face
I've recently come to realize that I'm consistently terrible at recognizing faces.

Anecdotal of course, but at this point I've noticed and heard / seen it demonstrated by other people enough to give me pause.

When I think about describing someone, it's almost always in terms of what they've said - specific choices of words, tone or body language, certainly never about the face.

If true, I wonder if this would be any sort of advantage / disadvantage?

incision··on My Day Interviewing for the Service Economy Startup from Hell
>"I think all these companies that put a pretty UI over a bunch of low-skill 1099 workers are exploitative."

While I totally agree with this I wonder about whether / why people working this jobs would be re-classified?

Many if not most people I know in work in technology on 1099 and are applied in ways which would seem to be more clearly misclassified than these workers.

incision··on My Day Interviewing for the Service Economy Startup from Hell
I must be old...

I feel like I read stories about horrible jobs and tough times finding work from young college grads regularly and the news would seem to corroborate them [1].

Apparently, these people end up serving coffee or answering phones for clown shop start-ups.

Meanwhile, I know people trying to hire for what I'd consider traditional entry level jobs (clerks, reception, no-risk security, no-experience necessary apprenticeships) offering full benefits plus 35-45k+ salaries who would be overjoyed to see a single college-educated applicant.

What's going on here? Do people believe in this Amway-esque pitch for a "world of opportunities"? Do traditional jobs feel like giving up? Are they too restricting?

1: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/she-the-people/wp/2014/0...

incision··on Why firms don't want you to be brilliant at your job
Exactly.

It's easy enough to understand this applied to fast food, but I get the impression other industries would rather not believe it to be true.

Thing is, I think it's clearly evidenced in tech by every "I went through two days of interviewing on algorithms and distributed systems to hack on PHP boilerplate?" story. Tech might go to the trouble to select for brilliance, but they aren't necessarily using or paying for it.

Further it's readily admitted by folks like a16z [1].

"Thus software itself becomes the driving force of leveling the ability to write software to solve problems. This is a good thing: As software becomes a high-impact, low-skill trade, we decouple the technical ability and experience needed to write tricky software from the ability to solve problems for people."

1: http://a16z.com/2014/07/30/the-happy-demise-of-the-10x-engin...

incision··on Volvo Bets Its Future on Small, Turbocharged Engines
It seems an odd choice to say three turbochargers in an article that references superchargers when it reads as an electric supercharger plus sequential turbos.

Personally, I'd much rather see advancement / acceptance of self-drivers even if limited to highways than incremental improvements to traditional cars.

The main, perhaps only reason I really care about response and acceleration is the generally selfish, adversarial behavior of human drivers.

The contrast between the same daily drive in a 4-cyl compact and torquey V8 is stark. In the former, every lane change has to come with permission - that drivers are often unwilling to give. In the latter, I'm in complete control.

I'd much rather the third possibility - to know we're all on autopilot gliding along at a safe, predictable rate to our destinations.

incision··on An Author Confronts Her Number One Online Critic
That this started on Goodreads doesn't surprise me at all.

I use the site regularly, but I put it in the same category as most single topic 'communities' - something I'll use (reference), but know better than to engage with.

Basically, I find that such places tend to end up heavily steeped in their own customs and hierarchy which are dominated by the sort of super users and relationship-driven mobs that the author ran into.

At least Amazon finally acknowledged the toxic elements of the Goodreads community [1]. It's surely a tough problem.

What I really wonder is what exactly causes a community to end up that way? Every successful community has a struggle with growth and groupthink, but some get particularly bad. Is it a failure in moderation or are some topics and demographics just more susceptible?

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodreads#Criticism_and_controv...

incision··on Google Material Design Icons
">How many years have to elapse before that icon is rethought? When was the last time you personally held an actual floppy disk? How would you even fit a floppy disk into a phone (or website)?"

I don't think any of that matters.

How many smartphones run on AA batteries [1]? How many people have ever configured anything involving gearing [2]?

Rethinking an icon feels like a contradiction. It doesn't matter what it's 'supposed' to be.

It's not a floppy disk, it's the save icon.

1: https://www.iconfinder.com/search/?q=battery

2: https://www.iconfinder.com/search/?q=settings

incision··on Rental America: Why the poor pay $4,150 for a $1,500 sofa
Funny thing about being broke, it seems to come with an intense even overwhelming desire to feel/signal otherwise in what are usually counterproductive ways.

Where I grew up, everybody was pretty damn poor. Still, probably half my neighborhood or more was beholden to Rent-A-Center for a dining room set or couch. Most were ashamed to shop at K-Mart or even buy generic cereal.

That said, I think IKEA could do tidy business by targeting a slimmed down catalog to the areas where rent to own thrives.

incision··on Kicking the Bukkit: Anatomy of an open source meltdown
Are there any particularly good comparisons of OSS licenses in terms of facts as well as perception?

I regularly see comments on one project or another pointing to a XYZ license as the reason a project failed / has few contributors as if the 'problem' with that particular license is entirely self-evident.

It's awfully confusing as I'm sure I've seen polar opposite opinions on every major license under the sun, each entirely bereft of context.

incision··on How to Reapply to YC
Neat.

As others have noted, the product could benefit from promoting the "camera + smarts = faster, easier and better than visiting a tailor" aspect more.

I'd use this if it could do pants as well.

incision··on What will it take to run a 2-hour marathon?
>'...the content itself is worth reading.'

It sure looks that way and I'm normally pretty tolerant of design flourishes, but I find this simply unbearable.

Still, I really wanted to read this, but neither Pocket, Readability nor Instapaper are able to pull more than a few paragraphs of usable text out of it.

The design isn't just bad or annoying it's hostile.

incision··on Box acquires MedXT
Is it?

I have no solid idea, but my impression from glancing at solutions for healthcare years ago wasn't that Hospitals are choosing Big Co so much as they have little choice.

As I understand it, smaller companies don't try / give up on keeping up wit the costs of required certifications (possibly the wrong term) and the like.

This also seemed to help explain the slow pace of advances and updates to such systems as patches and changes have their own onerous process.

incision··on The Kitchen Network: America’s Underground Chinese Restaurant Workers
>'If anything, this article just shows how lazy Americans can be, when Americans can't be bothered to eat meat or fish with bones, but of course that's just an anecdote.'

Labeling Americans as a group and particularly certain subsets within as lazy is just as credible and, I'd wager, often done for many of the same reasons as labeling immigrants freeloaders.

incision··on The Kitchen Network: America’s Underground Chinese Restaurant Workers
I was actually surprised that the workers in question are themselves Chinese. In and around DC (Indian Head extends perhaps 15 miles out) restaurants that 10 or 15 years ago would have been staffed entirely by Asians are overwhelmingly staffed by Hispanics under Asian management.

I often wonder what sort of path the people who used to work those jobs have taken since.

incision··on A Warning to the Tech Community on Abusive Journalists
I wouldn't limit this to Journalists.

It's solid advice for dealing with most anyone, particularly people with any sort of 'power' over your work and decisions.

With slight modification, these are the same sort of red flags to note precautions to take when dealing with a manager, executive or customer.

I think managing the expectations of non/semi-technical people and taking care in the way we evaluate and represent each other's work to those people is an important, but often overlooked part of this business.

incision··on In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above its weight
>'The real issue is after exporting them they probably don't send all that much money back home.'

It's my understanding that this is not the case. That remittance from the US is a pretty significant part of many developing economies [1][2].

I've yet to a met an immigrant professional in the US who didn't send huge amounts back home along with itent or at least hope of retiring there.

1: http://www.havanatimes.org/?p=94444 2: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-12-17/global-immigrants-s...

incision··on Gaspard, the anti-assault accessory: never be alone again
>'Anti-assault accessory...Strangers that rescue you are rewarded.'

This is begging for disaster.

I've personally witnessed the ugly mess of an overzealous rescue, a rescuer labeled assailant when the victim changes their mind or late responders are simply confused and of course violent wisdom of gathering mobs.

Digitally amplifying a scream this way is serious business. Assault and attacker, words the site uses freely, are dead serious yet being applied to an easily activated 'bunny' pin with implied 'rewards'.

I hope these folks think heavily about the potential implications - not just intent of what they're doing here.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →