HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

irjustin

7,091 karma · joined May 6, 2019

irjustin.com
submissionscomments
irjustin··on A competitor crippled a $23.5M bootcamp by becoming a Reddit moderator
With the phrase "the most reliable" which is a phrase to mean the subject you're describing is inherently reliable. Meaning you can read the reviews on reddit differently than amazon, yelp, and the rest. If reddit reviews can't be read differently vs others, why "most reliable"?

You're trying to walk a line that says reddit not authoritative and yet reliable. In this specific context authoritative also comes to mean reliable. So we're at reddit is not reliable yet reliable?

I'm saying it can't be. The well has been poisoned and it's not safe to pray it didn't mix. That you need to treat reddit with the same skepticism lest you be taken for your money. Perhaps you don't agree, which is fair then we agree-disagree.

irjustin··on A competitor crippled a $23.5M bootcamp by becoming a Reddit moderator
Argh, there isn't one - is the message we're trying to get you to accept.

Just because reddit is reliable vs its peers != absolutely reliable.

Like Amazon, Yelp, Google any review system will become gamified for money. So just like those platforms every review you read you need to ask "who is the reviewer? do they review other things? how 'realistic' does it read? Are they pushing anything? Is the thing i'm reading affected by money? Were they given a product? were they given a discount/kickback for a review?" etc etc.

You cannot simply look at a review and say oh yeah that's a good review of someone who just wants to help others.

The whole reason this thread exists is exactly because of above. Someone weaponized the trust, your trust, of reddit to bring down a startup - and it worked.

irjustin··on A competitor crippled a $23.5M bootcamp by becoming a Reddit moderator
Beyond my pay grade but I'll take a stab (meaning I'm talking out of my ass).

Some in fact have but the majority? Probably laziness, but laziness is just misaligned incentive-goals.

Communities have very little incentive to de-reddit. It's actually a huge amount of work and they gain almost nothing directly.

Separately, I was thinking you know HNews is pretty immune to this problem because we don't have a central theme or something, right?

But no, that just means I can't see how I'm being monetized is all. Blind leading the blind.

irjustin··on A competitor crippled a $23.5M bootcamp by becoming a Reddit moderator
> Reddit was knowingly ruined by google. Once google pushed reddit to the top of search results

Ehhhhh I agree and yet also disagree (it's fun though).

Yes they were ruined by being promoted by algo changes, but do I blame google directly? For me, no.

It's exactly as we stated before, it's because it was so trustworthy. Individual people's personal experience with X or Y many times with good details. That earned a lot of strong backlinks, blogs, etc. The domain became authoritative especially on esoteric searches. Then algo changes came (remember pandas?) and pushed them even further. I mean that's the point of search systems right? Get you to trustworthy information that you're looking for.

Then the money grabbers showed up.

So it's just like Harvey Dent said - either you die a trusted niche community or live long enough to see yourself become weaponized for money. He was so smart, that Harvey Dent.

irjustin··on A competitor crippled a $23.5M bootcamp by becoming a Reddit moderator
> it's also the most reliable place to get a general crowd-sourced opinion on the internet. There are specialist forums for specialist subjects, sure, but nowhere else delivers like Reddit does on a diverse set of topics.

That's some impressive blindness. That's exactly why the OP is stating it's unreliable. It _was_ reliable. Now it's a minefield, because trust->money.

Just like Amazon 5 star reviews. They used to be good probably until about 2012-2015 (if you stretch it). Then it became weaponized because the trust was so high. Anything with strong 5 star reviews sold.

Of course, you can "figure out" if what you're reading is trustworthy, but to blanket state "the most reliable place" - days gone to yesteryear.

irjustin··on TiVo exiting legacy DVR business
> Maybe if they went with there own premium streaming service

If you don't own the content, you get squeezed. Hulu, Spotify all of these guys get nickle-dimed into oblivion.

Netflix understood this deeply creating one of the biggest, successful pivots in startup-dom

irjustin··on Ask HN: HNews constantly logged out mobile?
This is iOS so no extensions.
irjustin··on Toyota runs a car-hacking event to boost security (2024)
It's weird right? I get that Nokia honestly couldn't see it coming, it was basically the first in recent history. Too much too fast, RIM included.

But all the bigwigs currently in Toyota are the age to have seen and lived that transition. It's not like they're new to battery tech.

And they say - wow look at that... nah, let's build hydrogen.

irjustin··on Jeff Bezos says AI is in a bubble but society will get 'gigantic' benefits
This is why revolts happen.

If you scratch under the hood of UBI, it's a mechanism to keep revolutions at bay. The balance of tax the ultra wealthy vs giving people enough to "live comfortably" is always the job of governance.

irjustin··on Jeff Bezos says AI is in a bubble but society will get 'gigantic' benefits
Thought experiment - Startrek replicators are real.

This basically means almost everything can be built without human involvement. The guy who owns the replicators is the richest.

The wealth gap is so massive you get revolts (because we're educated, not serfs, right?) So then government needs to step in. Either tax->ubi?, socialize it, or make it a state asset?

Regardless, that's the goal of AGI/robotics/etc.

irjustin··on Building the heap: racking 30 petabytes of hard drives for pretraining
> This market is ripe for disruption. here should not be a need to shovel hundreds of billions per year into AWS revenue for the industry. The same business operating at 20% margins would be a game changer.

Honestly, I don't understand this line of thinking. You're not alone in it either, but it always reads so naive.

Like you can magically hand wave or it'd be so easy and get a competitor who can do it just as well and/or cheaper than AWS. But somehow these statements seem to ignore that you can't. Otherwise Digital Ocean would've, or cloudflare or <name-your-linnode-rackspace-startup>.

The industry funnels billions to become vendor locked in because AWS is simply that good - bar none.

irjustin··on AI is not killing jobs, US study finds
Wish I could read the article. Is this true across all sectors?

[Edit]

https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/evaluating-impact-ai-lab...

Underlying study.

irjustin··on Founder sentenced to seven years in prison for fraudulent sale to JPMorgan
Jeez that place looks better than so many schools even vacation homes. Something's really wrong with this picture.
irjustin··on iRobot Founder: Don't Believe the AI and Robotics Hype
Having been through the VC system, I don't believe his face value statement, and I 100% believe you're right.

They want to invest, but not at his terms that he's demanding.

The thought experiment is - he wants to raise 1m @ 2m val. 50%. There's not a VC/angel/seed who wouldn't take that deal given who he is. So he's pricing himself at a level he "is willing to do this startup thing again" and it's simply too expensive.

irjustin··on Man still alive six months after pig kidney transplant
> Has no real democracy and the govt is able to plan decades ahead.

I get the sentiment but accuracy is important here. It's a real democracy vs counties where voting is a sham.

But yes, it is widely managed by a single party that was setup by a benevolent dictatorship and the current administration generally does a good job and is voted in with strong support.

So agreed, they can do really interesting things because of their time horizons of control combined with willingness to work for the better of the people.

irjustin··on Man still alive six months after pig kidney transplant
At a system level - in Singapore it is. HDB (public) for affordable, private for everything else. 75+% of housing is part of the HDB system.
irjustin··on What happens when coding agents stop feeling like dialup?
You still make mistakes. Just because you did it yourself doesn't mean it's error free. The more complex the question the more error prone.

Thankfully the more complex the question almost always there's more than one way to derive the answer and you use that to check.

irjustin··on What happens when coding agents stop feeling like dialup?
> The issue with your analogy is that calculators do not hallucinate. They do not make mistakes. An accountant is able to fully offload the mental overhead of arithmetic because the calculator is reliable.

If you've ever done any modeling/serious accounting, you'll find that you feel more like a DBA than a "person punching on a calculator". You ask questions and then you figure out how to get the answers you want by "querying" excel cells. Many times querying isn't in quotes.

To me, the analogy of the parent is quite apt.

irjustin··on David Lynch LA House
Thanks it was a nice read.
irjustin··on Want to piss off your IT department? Are the links not malicious looking enough?
I haven't clicked on either, which one's gonna do it to me? Is it 50/50 or 100%.... here we go
irjustin··on YouTube addresses lower view counts which seem to be caused by ad blockers
To be fair it's mental effort that you now have to expend when you didn't before.

I stopped reading the news because it just became too tiring.

Not saying it's right or wrong. It's just - I understand.

irjustin··on ERP Therapy Sucks
We were on another thread where the study was saying LLMs being used as psychiatrists is bad.

Then another hnuser chimed that he ran a support forum for people. Said, these aren't the real problem. The real problem are the "AI girlfriends". They go off the rails completely and tell people to unhinged things. Apparently his forum already lost a few members to who knows what because of these things.

That surprised me a lot.

irjustin··on Immunotherapy drug clinical trial results: half of tumors shrink or disappear
Downvoted.

The mental leaps to connect the two are very very large. If you distrust western medicine's process then let's discuss, but trying say we collectively shouldn't because "look at Russia!" isn't it.

irjustin··on Microsoft doubles down on small modular reactors and fusion energy
oh wow that's cool. I do understand why they moved away from it. Battery is waaaayyyyy easier to understand for the layman and lay-kid (me).
irjustin··on Microsoft doubles down on small modular reactors and fusion energy
I'm really sad the core argument for the Matrix's existence doesn't hold up (it never did, just for me as a kid is all).
irjustin··on I bought the cheapest EV, a used Nissan Leaf
Are you proud of yours? I'm US and I'm not proud of how our taxes are earned and I'm definitely not proud how they're spent.
irjustin··on Taiwan Submarine Cable Map Showing Current Outage
This whole page is an exercise in confusing UX.

Left has "Active" in red because it's "Active Incident" not the cable is "Active" but at first glance "Active" makes it seem like the cable is operational.

irjustin··on Pentagon Docs: US Wants to "Suppress Dissenting Arguments" Using AI Propaganda
Flip side is we just use AI to promote dissenting arguments.

This feels like the war on drugs and it won't end well in that nobody wins.

irjustin··on The “Wow!” signal was likely from extraterrestrial source, and more powerful
It's not, but interference is a big problem.

You need to rule out that you accidentally picked up some radio broadcast and state that otherwise anyone worth their salt will first ask, "Are you sure it didn't come from the local radio station?"

irjustin··on Code review can be better
mmmm this is up to each repo/maintainer's settings.

To be fair you don't know if one line change is going to absolutely compromise a flow. OSS needs to maintain a level of disconnect to be safe vs fast.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →