HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ironman1478

1,250 karma · joined July 23, 2015

I write FW for camera systems.
submissionscomments
ironman1478··on Ask HN: Are most of us developers lying about how much work we do?
For me personally, I am going through this for the past month, however its because for the 5 months before I was working basically 50-60 hour weeks with tons of active debugging, coding, and triaging (HW bringup type work). But next month we start ramping up to start new projects.

It could just be what you are doing isn't fundamentally that difficult and doesn't require a 40 hour work week and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. If people think you're worth the money you are getting paid, then you are worth that money. They pay you to get things done, not to sit in a desk for 40 hours a week or be stressed for performance reasons.

ironman1478··on Ask HN: What are the best-designed things you've ever used?
This mechanical pencil https://uniballco.com/products/kuru-toga-elite-mechanical-pe... It just feels so good to write with and it just doesn't break. I've used so many mechanical pencils and some feel better, but they have quality issues. This pencil just works.
ironman1478··on California moves to recommend delaying algebra to 9th grade statewide
They would in my opinion. I was a tutor in high school and college for algebra. I worked with people some people who struggled. They all eventually got it if they wanted to get it, which they generally did to not get held back :p. You just have to work with them and truly understand what they are not understanding. The big issue is concepts are not learnable in isolation. You said vectors are basic, but are they? They were initially just abstractions to model sets of physics problems. Without the context, its pretty difficult to understand them IMO, especially things like dot products. "oh, i multiply two vectors and I get a number? what? Oh and that number can be described as the multiplication of magnitudes of the vectors multiplied by the cosine of their angle? Oh how do I get the magnitude? What's cosine again? etc." It goes forever and generally you'll find that people will struggle with basic things because they never had an opportunity to sit down and genuinely internalize those ideas.

Everything builds on other concepts and people's misunderstandings generally came from not truly understanding the basics. Its hard to personalize education at scale though.

ironman1478··on California moves to recommend delaying algebra to 9th grade statewide
Sorry, I didn't mean to imply that fighting poverty would solve all issues by itself. However, its unclear to me how reducing poverty wouldn't help? I know its not related to the specific topic, but for example many people of color drop out of college because they cannot afford to stay in or feel obligated to help their families in time of need.

https://www.apa.org/pi/ses/resources/indicator/2014/06/child... It seems like alleviating poverty will help? It also just feels... obvious?

ironman1478··on California moves to recommend delaying algebra to 9th grade statewide
These efforts feel misguided. Black and Latino people aren't bad at math because of the language used in math education (most of the language seems neutral from what I remembered), it's because they are largely poor, due to structural racism or they are first generation immigrants who didn't come to work in tech or something. They're just poor and unfortunately it's hard to really do anything when you're poor in America.

My parents immigrated from Romania and were part of the Florida Romanian community. Many were poor, didn't really have a great support system, and didnt really get America. Many of the kids in that community just dropped out or didn't do well in school and that's largely because of a poor home life and just not having access to anything. All the countries that have great education systems also have great support systems for families.

Algebra isn't hard (though it is time consuming imo), you can pass all the tests with memorization since it's applying a few patterns over and over again. Delaying it isn't going to make people better at it.

ironman1478··on How learned helplessness happens in engineering teams
This is definitely happening. A engineer can't really work on anything truly complicated if they hop around every 2-3 years. These types of engineers gain cursory knowledge of topics but never become experts.
ironman1478··on Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
You need a car in SF depending on the area you live in. On the west side, SF has very poor public transit
ironman1478··on Is going to the office a broken way of working?
There is a book on this topic called "bowling alone" if you are interested. These observations are ones people were making pre-covid.
ironman1478··on It is easier to educate a Do-er than to motivate the educated
John Carmack works on cutting edge technology, so he embarks on things that are already difficult and the answer is not known ahead of time. Now if you are talking about deadlines, then sure. It can be intuited if the deadline is unreasonable. There are problems out there where the answer isn't known or even close to being known without significant effort. A "Do-er" in the case is valuable because they are willing to go the distance to try things. Though I will say, its unclear why an educated person cannot also be a Do-er. Those are two independent variables IMO. I would say I'm a Do-er and I got educated so I could "do" more.
ironman1478··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
Technology doesn't exist in a vacuum. It exists to address societal, political, existential (climate change), or financial problems. For example, let's talk about self driving cars (my field). The only reason they are necessary are fundamentally societal (people die from cars) and political (America doesn't want to invest in public transit for many societal reasons that aren't logical). It's a technology that doesn't have to exist. These societal issues are the reason why it's worth investing in the tech and they affect the design of the car and what problems it needs to solve.

I get the appeal of trying to look at technology solely in isolation, but society influences whether technology needs to exist and how it's designed.

ironman1478··on JSON Schema bundling formalised
I started using jsonschema at work and can't go back. We have an extremely large configuration file to configure our system and there are lots of 'optional' blocks that can be configured. Jsonschema really cleanly allows you to express that logic without having to write a line of code. It's been great.

Protip: if you are using jsonschema in python, it takes in a dict() not a file, so you can use yaml (or something else) as your configuration file and still validate it with jsonschema.

ironman1478··on JSON Schema bundling formalised
So you don't sanitize JSON input to your system? That's what this tool is for. The alternative is writing custom code to validate it, which is just as messy and worse, bespoke.
ironman1478··on It's Time for Operating Systems to Rediscover Hardware
So, it's funny. It's not uncommon to run RTOSs and Linux on the same CPU, where the rtos coordinates tasks between the components that have real time requirements and the Linux side does stuff like stream data from a buffer that the rtos writes to. We had this architecture on some systems and the amount of cludging to get this all working was annoying to say the least. We specifically had issues are figuring out how to partition the memory regions for each OS and it wasn't trivial to validate.

I wasn't around when the decisions at my employer when the decisions made around OS options, but this would've been a viable one if it was mature enough at that time. Thanks for the info!

ironman1478··on It's Time for Operating Systems to Rediscover Hardware
I've worked on firmware for a few SoC's that my company has designed or purchased and we use embedded linux on some. I think his observation about how Linux doesn't abstract the hardware accurately is totally right. The system isn't that complicated, but implementing everything within the world of Linux has been painful imo, so for future implementations we're evaluating RTOS's. The main reason people use Linux on these custom SoCs because of driver availability of key components (ethernet phys and persistent storage), large library of tools, and probably $ (who wants to pay for QNX). Those are good reasons, but if you have to write a large volume of code, it doesn't really feel like it's providing too much. It definitely felt like we were just using a hammer and seeing everything as a nail. Those are my 2 cents.
ironman1478··on China has forbidden under-18s from playing games for more than three hours/week
This is really difficult for me to have an unbiased opinion on, but I think this is an OK decision (3 hours seems a bit too little >.>). I've pumped WAY too many hours into online games. I played fighting games, dota, starcraft, you name it, I played it and I played it before I was 18. I really think that it stunted my social growth (though not too much) because I got really hooked on the competitive aspect of those games. Those games still get their hooks in my once in a while (splitgate I'm looking at you). However, another reason I played so many games is because I lived in the middle of nowhere in florida and didn't have a car. There wasn't much I could do other than go to school, exercise, and play games. Everything was 30+ miles away by car. I think if China is going to do this, they have to provide other outlets for people to interact with each other. Games are a way of doing that for many because there simply isn't another option for them when they are young and don't have a car and don't live in a major city like new york or SF.
ironman1478··on Bigger vehicles are directly resulting in more deaths of people walking
I am not going to refute those EV claims! To be clear, you are talking to a person who is in a brand new sector of the transportation industry. I have somewhat of an interest in seeing people not drive in major metropolitan areas anymore. I am coming from a biased position where I believe people should not be driving as a first choice, unless they live in an area where its not economically viable to provide large scale public transit or bike lanes, like rural & suburban areas.

You are saying, why not ban cars? But not all SUVs are created equal. They aren't all RAV4s or CRVs. If you look at the new land rover defender, its unclear how people can even see out of that monstrosity. Its enormous and has insanely bad visibility and is HEAVY. That thing would destroy other SUVs, let alone cars. A ford explorer from the early 2000s is flimsy compared to these new SUVs.

ironman1478··on Bigger vehicles are directly resulting in more deaths of people walking
https://www.google.com/amp/s/fordauthority.com/2020/10/execu...

Not everybody needs to do those things. I have lived 28 years without owning a truck and will never need one. My father knows how to drive many sized trucks for work, but he never needed to own one. Trucks provide utility and to be clear, I singled out SUVs because they have basically no value for people buying them, except that it makes them feel safe because they aren't the smallest vehicle on the road anymore. Most are terrible off-roaders and if people need to carry more people they can buy wagons and vans.

Also, the EV remark. The issue is that SUVs are correlated with more deaths, including hitting peds at higher rates. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_sport_utility_v...

If an EV car was correlated with higher deaths than other vehicles, that should be examined and we need to consider it.

ironman1478··on Bigger vehicles are directly resulting in more deaths of people walking
Yeah, it's the saddest thing. I think what sucks, is that people don't really know how much better our lives would be if we were less car dependent. There are 6 million accidents a year. That means that like at least 18 million people ar affected (gotta get that car fixed in the best case right?) each year, at a minimum (let's assume a family of one child and two parents and one of these people gets into an accident and let's assume they were crashing into just walls or something). Accidents aren't just bad for the people in the accident, but they cause financial stress and mental stress to the families affected.

If we just discouraged driving by even a small percent (and thus a small fraction of accidents) so many people's lives would be better, simply due to the magnitudes as play.

ironman1478··on Bigger vehicles are directly resulting in more deaths of people walking
Car makers are making this the default. Ford is (or has?) eliminated cars from their American offerings. The problem is that even within the class of SUVs and trucks, those vehicles have gotten larger and faster over time.

The analogy of the hot and cold person assumes the hot person is wearing a t-shirt and sweater, when in reality when you compare it to vehicles, it's more like they are wearing that gortex jacket from Seinfeld + 3 layers of sweaters. People don't need to cater to somebody unreasonable. People don't need SUVs. They provide like no advantage compared to a wagon to most people and endanger everybody else.

ironman1478··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
I think a set of metrics would be if people's stressors have been reduced. Like Do people spend less time worrying about paying bills, job security, etc. I agree that a "happiness" metric is not great.
ironman1478··on The rise of never-ending job interviews
That's true. I want to say that that's Google's fault right? Because not everybody is on the team you're interviewing for (I might be wrong)? At Apple you are interviewed by the team, who presumably needs another person to assist them.

Also, regardless of whether or not they want to be there, it's a bad look for the company. Somebody took a day off to talk to you, it's only fair that an interviewer reciprocates

ironman1478··on The rise of never-ending job interviews
I don't mind going through a single day with many rounds, but when it's spread out it's super frustrating. It feels really disrespectful of my time. I interviewed at Apple and had like 3 onsites with different teams all in one week and got the results quite quickly. It was such a good experience compared to some companies where it's such a chore.

I also think the attitude of companies during interviews really sucks. Many feel like they're doing you a favor or you're wasting their time. That was a distinct feeling I got when interviewing at Google, but not at Apple and I really think it's why I passed those and not google. They were collaborative and fun at Apple. I put a lot of effort into making candidates at my company feel welcomed and like they are already part of the team and IMO it really helps them succeed.

ironman1478··on JPG vs. RAW: Get it right the first time (2009)
Raw isn't really a format unless you are referring to CSI packets or something. It's just the values coming off the sensor. Those values are heavily dependent on the design of the sensor. There are significant non linear characteristics in those values and each camera has hw/sw to account for that sensors characteristics. It is very difficult to make two different sensor models that will provide the same exact value for a scene because they way they capture the scene is electrically and physically different.

All those algorithms the parent is talking about are custom made per sensor generally. The ideas are the same, but they have to be tuned for each sensor and as the parent said, it's incredibly subjective and every company / vendor approaches the problem differently depending on use case.

ironman1478··on JPG vs. RAW: Get it right the first time (2009)
I don't know if it's generalizable. Processing raw sensor data requires a knowledge about the dynamic range and knowledge about non linear characteristics of the sensor. Bitdepth isn't the only differentiating factor between raw sensor data. 0x100 doesn't mean the same for 2 different sensors. Also, there is an assumption in the article that the data is linear, but that's not true of all sensors. Some compand their data and there is hardware in the camera to relinearize the sensor output.
ironman1478··on In defense of hard counters in real time strategy games
I made a comment about trees, but the other issue is that the map is super asymmetric. The bottom half (radiant) has a generally safer jungle and a very difficult to contest small pull (always been this way. Camp has just changed over time). The top team (dire) has a worse jungle, but it is closer to Roshan. The problem is people don't know how to use Roshan well (either capturing it or using the aegis), so that advantage isn't realized unless the team is at the top levels of the game.

I think the perspective issue is there. But its not the entire 5%

ironman1478··on In defense of hard counters in real time strategy games
I really don't think the MOBA comment works for Dota 2. Its not really about the characters, its about the map, position, and timing (itemization + push timing). The characters are important, but frequently people pick meta characters and get bopped. This wouldn't be an issue if dota had new people playing the game, but I want to say that dota is at this point filled with people who have been playing for a long time. So, you'll see people who at low levels just destroy people with characters that are supposed to be bad because they just know where to stand and abuse the map or creep aggro. Its wild.

Just as a specific example. If you take two teams of equal MMR and one had all the character counters so they "should" win. If the team with the better characters doesn't know how to pull the safelane, they will just straight up lose. Full stop. They will get gold starved and unless the other team throws (which is very common lol) they should lose.

Also, losing like this in dota is anti-fun. Its really not a good time for like anybody, the winner of the loser. Its just one team dumpstering another and it happens at all levels.

ironman1478··on In defense of hard counters in real time strategy games
Its really difficult. The exact placement of individual trees in the game matters a lot and it affects line of sight, which is a key component to Dota. If you flipped the view, not only would it just be weird, but what is visible can change I think based on the camera position. A tree that blocks a path in one camera position doesn't block it in another. A single tree's position sounds trivial, but navigating them is crucial at mid and high levels of play.
ironman1478··on In defense of hard counters in real time strategy games
I think its cool seeing what factors are considered in RTS balancing. I guess an equivalent for fighting games would be invincible vs non-invincible DPs or weird things like movement options.

In RTS games balancing seems a bit more quantifiable. In fighting games there is a lot of guessing at what actually counters what unless its extremely obvious. Its hard to tell if a matchup or strat is good/bad due to the character/move properties or if its because one player is way better.

ironman1478··on Return to Office Hits a Snag: Young Resisters
So, I'll preface this that maybe this only applies to my workplace and IMO what I'm going to write might be rude.

I also work in a technically hard space and remote work isn't perfect, specifically because there is a hardware component to my job. However, I really think its not a huge deal because I think people are overestimating how good communication was pre covid. I have generally observed that people who I didn't really understand or who were simply bad communicators in person, are bad in a WFH environment. If people are bad at giving clear & concise answers, the problem isn't WFH, its that their writing and communication skills aren't actually that good. I feel though that in person, people get to lean on being funny, nice, etc. but in a remote environment clear & concise communication is required or else people get ignored or they waste a bunch of time. Their lack of communication skills and potentially technical skills are more obvious in a remote environment due to this. The people who could get things done didn't stop once WFH started, it was the people who were already pretty "meh" who's issues got amplified during covid.

ironman1478··on Kubernetes is our generation's Multics
IMO the problem with this is when you go from startup -> not a startup you go from creating an MVP to something that works with a certain amount of uptime, has performance requirements, etc. Frameworks will still help you with those things, but if you need to solve a performance issue its gonna be hard to debug if a you don't know how the primitives work.

Lets say you have a network performance issue because the framework you were using was misusing epoll, set some funky options with setsockopt, or turned on Nagle's algorithm. A person can figure it out, but its gonna be a slog whereas if they had experience working with the lowest level tools the person could have an intuition about how to debug the issue.

An engineer doesn't have to write everything with the lowest level primitives all the time, but if they have NEVER done it than IMO that's an issue.

← PreviousPage 7 of 11Next →