HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

irremediable

835 karma · joined March 31, 2013

Interdisciplinary researcher
submissionscomments
irremediable··on Request For Research: Basic Income
> So basically as a middle class person, I don't benefit at all, I may even lose money, but some kid who has no income and wants to live in his parents basement gets $10k/yr for contributing nothing to society? Am I understanding this correctly?

The benefit for you is that you'd be living in a better society. Hopefully, you'd see reductions in crime, improvements in various service jobs, etc.

That kid gets $10k/year, sure, but then again lots of people already have the means to live in their parents' basements. Most of them prefer not to do so.

However, there'll be other people getting that $10k/year. Single mothers could spend more time with their children. More people would become educated. The job market would become more liquid for employees, hopefully improving working conditions.

irremediable··on What is Something You Recommend (and why)?
Kettlebells. They're a good, time-efficient way to get a bit of aerobic and a bit of anaerobic exercise. Especially useful if you have problems that stop you running, e.g. foot problems or knee joint issues. Just make sure to get the technique right before you push yourself with them.
irremediable··on The Story Behind F.lux
Fair point; more of us should imitate your attitude to these things.
irremediable··on Is e Normal?
Yeah, great counterexample. I was thinking, "but continued fractions... that rings a bell..." -- couldn't figure out what seemed off about it, though.
irremediable··on The Story Behind F.lux
I use it, and I like it, and I think it works. But I also think they should really try to publish a paper on it, proving it works to improve e.g. people's sleep quality.
irremediable··on Can a $9 Computer Spark a New Wave of Tinkering and Innovation?
> Where is it now? I'm not sure (and I would love to know) how kids these days are building things that are able to compete for valuable attention span.

I'd say it's videogames. I got into programming through glitching games, then scripting games, then programming games. I know a lot of other people my age (mid-20s) who had similar experiences.

Look at kids making various contraptions in Minecraft -- and look at how many of them go into the modding scene.

I don't think that tinkering experience has been lost; people just forget what a small fraction of the population was interested in this stuff in the first place.

irremediable··on The Future of Real-Time SLAM and “Deep Learning vs. SLAM”
There's going to be a growing overlap between the two. I studied a bit[1] with one of the big SLAM research groups in the UK, and even several years ago, they were trying to combine SLAM and neural nets in various ways. A lot of their PhD students went on to ride the crest of the "deep learning" wave, and made a lot of money.

[1] Only an undergrad project a few years ago; I didn't do anything especially cool there.

irremediable··on All Hollowed Out: The lonely poverty of America’s white working class
I... don't know.

I think visitation rights are genuinely an area where men have it worse. That said, I know plenty of women who didn't do well out of divorce. My mother was divorced for much of my childhood, and so were many of her friends. Several of the ex-husbands fiddled their income such that they paid minimal support while having enough money to go gallivanting around the world.

Thanks for sharing, in any case. It's all food for thought -- and clearly, something needs to be done about visitation rights.

irremediable··on ‘Locked-in’ people show signs of awareness when faced with sums
I'm sceptical, because some people in (what was presumed to be) a vegetative state also showed those "signs of awareness". Not read the paper yet, though.
irremediable··on All Hollowed Out: The lonely poverty of America’s white working class
I really like your point about pubs. Your point about mass immigration is good too, though I think it omits the impact that automation and outsourcing have already had on employment.

Not so sure about your view on marriage, though. Are you saying your son shouldn't marry because, if he finds a girlfriend and has children, marriage would disadvantage him should they ever divorce?

irremediable··on Top Books on Amazon Based on Links in Hacker News Comments
> it's pretty clear that a list like this is going to underrepresent books where an amazon link is less likely

But the list was explicitly generated from Amazon links... wasn't that always going to be the case?

irremediable··on The Tennis Racket
It's sad to hear about your disenchantment. I hope I'm not being presumptuous, but... why don't you do some sport that's more independent? I enjoy kettlebell training, running and playing tennis. For the first two sports, it's entirely on me: I don't need anyone else, and it's all about the joy of the movement. In tennis you need an opponent, but that can just be one other person whom you regularly play with.

I guess there must be a feeling of sunk costs, in that you reached a high level in your martial art(s) of choice. But surely it would be better to do any kind of exercise, just for health and happiness, than to be thwarted by your ego? (When I say your ego is thwarting you, I mean to say that you control your reaction. The groups you mentioned are contemptible, but it is your choice whether you stop exercise entirely because of their malfeasance.)

irremediable··on The Unreasonable Reputation of Neural Networks
I think you've misrepresented their views. They doubtless know roughly what level the technology's at, even if it's not their speciality. They're worried about what level AI might go to in the next few decades/centuries. And you say they worry about an "impending AI disaster", but I don't think either of them has said they believe such a catastrophe to be imminent.

There are good reasons to be at least a little worried about AI in the long-term future. (Not to mention the imminent social effects of replacing various categories of worker with AI -- many examples of this have already happened, or are happening right now.)

Also, a minor nitpick, but you've misspelled Stephen Hawking's name. There's no "s" on the end.

irremediable··on Entry Level Positions – 3 Years Experience
Well first, have you actually applied to any of the places that asked for that experience? A lot of places will settle for far less than their advert asks. Second, have you emphasised your side-projects sufficiently? If you sell them properly, those count as professional experience.
irremediable··on French drug trial leaves six hospitalized, one brain-dead
> Treating lives as some fungible resource where the ends justify the means and whatever process results in the most living people at the end shouldn't be correct.

This is a fundamental problem in ethics -- and like many such problems, there is no "right" answer. There is no reason it shouldn't be that way, and no reason it should.

irremediable··on When to join a startup
This was a good example for finance noobs like myself -- what does the last sentence mean, though?
irremediable··on Reagan’s Impossible Dream: The X-30 National Aerospace Plane
How much of a future do you think the Skylon project has? A couple of friends in the aerospace industry have told me they think SpaceX will effectively "win" now that they can land the Falcon. Are they too optimistic about SpaceX?
irremediable··on Let artificial intelligence guess your attractiveness and age
I don't know how much better this thing is than doing: IF detect_face THEN random_guess()

That said, I think I'd agree with its ordering of those photos. shrug

irremediable··on Academics, we need to talk
Fair. This happens less in my field, but a lot of that could be because, for medical applications, people are far less willing to certify without published validation.
irremediable··on Academics, we need to talk
I agree with some of this, but I wonder...

> It drives me insane to see papers that claim that some problem is "unsolved" when most of the industry players have already solved it, but they didn't happen to write an NSDI or SIGCOMM paper about it.

I've seen many examples of industry "solutions" that aren't documented, aren't published, and aren't even validated. There's a place for papers like these. I'm not quite your typical CS researcher (I do applied math and software for medical imaging), so YMMV, but I think this criticism is too harsh.

irremediable··on Neal Stephenson: Why I Am a Sociomediapath (2015)
No disagreement here -- I know it's intentional. Thanks for the resources though.
irremediable··on Twitter Considering 10,000-Character Limit for Tweets
Yeah, this isn't even that new -- currently people get the same effect by posting images of text. Allowing them to attach text is a logical improvement.
irremediable··on Neal Stephenson: Why I Am a Sociomediapath (2015)
It's interesting. I thought I didn't lose much time to social media because I only used them in "dead" time, e.g. waiting for a train. But I've come to believe this was a mistake in two respects. Firstly, no time is truly "dead", and there's almost always something better I could be doing. Secondly, almost any use of social media trains me to crave more -- it genuinely is addictive, and the unreliability of the novelty ("refreshing in the hope of seeing something new") makes this all the worse.
irremediable··on Let artificial intelligence guess your attractiveness and age
Any chance of seeing a photo of you in guymode that it recognises as being in guymode?

In its defence, you do look very different in those photos. I wouldn't recognise you as the same person. That said, I'm surprised that it ranked you so poorly in the first photo.

irremediable··on Should scientific papers be anonymous?
I don't think anonymity is achievable if the paper's to be any good. Papers build on previous work, and are reviewed by people working in a relevant field. In most fields, most of the time, you have a good idea who wrote a given paper based on what they're doing, whom they cite, and what software/methods they use.
irremediable··on Steam Sales 2015
I've always liked double y-axis charts. I do wish they'd colour-code the axis labels to match their associated lines.
irremediable··on Up for Grabs: Projects which have curated tasks for new contributors
I like the idea of that, but will many places offer rewards for bugs that are on the easy end like the ones this site catalogues?
irremediable··on Lenovo Launches ThinkPad X1 Yoga at CES with OLED Display
What do people use in place of the ThinkPad now? Are there any especially good and rugged current laptop models?

I'm not looking to buy, but I had to advise relatives lately, and it made me realise that I don't know what the ThinkPad's successor is.

irremediable··on To Fall in Love with Anyone, Do This
Romantic story. :)

I've always been surprised by people falling in love online, but maybe that's part of how it happens -- a situation that encourages eye contact and questioning.

irremediable··on The Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test
I've used the KS test (and several other nonparametric stats) in research a bit. It's a cool thing to learn about, though it's worth noting that a lot of applied research can make do with parametric approaches. Thank you, Central Limit Theorem.
← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →