HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

isaacfrond

21,228 karma · joined July 8, 2021

submissionscomments
isaacfrond··on A Theoretical "Case Against Education"
In my own time as a high school student, I would come up with alternative solutions all the time. I'd always get full marks, though sometimes I'd have to explain it to the teacher afterwards.

Recently, I did the same test as my daughter did, who is now in high school. It was a bet kind of thing. So anyway, after doing the exam, I figured I'd have 9 out of 10 marks. I though t I'd lose some marks for some clumsy arithmetic, but it went pretty well (I thought).

So my daughter then grades my test and carefully explains that maybe I might just have a passing grade (6 out of 10). Ok. whatever. That can't be right. So she takes my test to the teacher to have her grade it as well. The teacher's verdict: clearly, easily, a failing grade. Maybe 4 out of 10 marks.

Turns out getting the right answer in a clever way counts for nothing. What you are being tested on is: can you reproduce the algorithm we are teaching you in school. As I solved most of the problems in a different manner, I consequently got almost none of the marks. I suppose, that if you know and accept this, then you can accept the result as well.

It's disappointing I guess, but certainly it makes math more accessible. I suppose there are pros and cons.

Your son wasn't tested on cleverly getting the right answer. The test was: can you reproduce this algorithm. He couldn't.

isaacfrond··on A Theoretical "Case Against Education"
tl;dr

The facts you learn at school are surprisingly ill remembered. But stuff learned by cultural osmosis is remembered very well. So why go to school?

isaacfrond··on The OpenAI board was right
On this one, it is OpenAI who are terrible and acting like spoiled kids.

They approached Ms. Johansson, she said no, and they went ahead and did it anyways.

isaacfrond··on Archie, the Internet's first search engine, is rescued and running
I remember installing a text only browser to visit a 'website' at CERN on this new thing the 'world wide web'. I browsed their website for like 30 seconds, and deleted the browser. That will never amount to anything. I was sure of it.

My children delight in this story. Though they don't really believe the text-only part. That's got to be a fabrication on my part.

isaacfrond··on When AI helps you code, who owns the finished product?
When you use a spellchecker to check a text who own the text?

When you use a style guide, citation book, encyclopedia, to write a text who owns the text?

I'm sorry but obviously if you produce something whether with help from a tool or not, you are responsible.

isaacfrond··on How to fix bugs in 24 hours or less
Reminds me of my stint in software. We could easily to these numbers as well.

Until we outsourced code production to a country halfway round the globe. Completely changed the dynamics from solving interesting problems in nicely written code, to chasing people around you've never met and never will to fix bugs in 1000+ lines functions, while you know it's an exercise in futility as no doubt there will be lots and lots more where that came from.

isaacfrond··on AT&T Goes Up Against T-Mobile, Starlink with AST SpaceMobile Satellite Deal
Yes. High time that Musk's Starlink get some competition.
isaacfrond··on Google and Harvard unveil most detailed ever map of human brain
Those pictures are stunning
isaacfrond··on Hot take on OpenAI’s new GPT-4o
Interesting. The spelling error seems to help the model!?

Anyway, tried the corrected prompt again on both 4 and 4o, but they failed them both. Reintroducing the spelling error didn't help either.

You can substitute 'elephant' for a whole range of animals, and for most, but not all, it will make something up.

isaacfrond··on Hot take on OpenAI’s new GPT-4o
GPT-4o has no problem on my computer. Here is the output. (read past the first line)

The first elephant to "swim" (not swing) across the English Channel was Jumbo the elephant. Jumbo, an African elephant, gained fame in the 19th century as a star attraction in the London Zoo and later with P.T. Barnum's circus in the United States. However, it is essential to clarify that Jumbo did not swim across the English Channel in the literal sense. Instead, he traveled by boat from England to the United States in 1882, marking a significant journey in his life and adding to his fame.

The idea of an elephant physically swimming across the English Channel is a myth or a playful exaggeration rather than a historical fact.

isaacfrond··on Elon Musk's X can't invent its own copyright law, judge says
It seems so, yes
isaacfrond··on Mice with Hybrid Brains Can Perceive the World Using a Rat's Sense of Smell
tl;dr

Researchers have grown mice with brains made partly of rat cells, allowing them to smell the world through another animal's neurological hardware.

isaacfrond··on Whistleblower who raised concerns about Boeing jets dies at 45
Just so that I can fill in my Bayesian formula. Do you have any idea how many whistle blowers didn't die?
isaacfrond··on Mystery 'Gpt2-Chatbot' Fuels Speculation over OpenAI's Next Gen ChatGPT
Chatbot Arena has banned Gpt2-Chatbot by now. It's not entirely clear, the notice says:

gpt2-chatbot is currently unavailable. See our model evaluation policy here.

It's not clear to me though, which part of the policy they violated though.

isaacfrond··on Hotel WiFi JavaScript Injection (2012)
Only on HN will you be modded down, receive a rant from two people, only to in the end get the admission: yes, you're right.
isaacfrond··on Plato's final hours recounted in scroll found in Vesuvius ash
Is this the same group as the million dollar challenge we had here earlier?
isaacfrond··on The Myth of the Second Chance
Life has no way. It can't remind you of anything.
isaacfrond··on The Myth of the Second Chance
Close enough. It's "Don't try"
isaacfrond··on Hotel WiFi JavaScript Injection (2012)
Problem is solved with using a VPN, no?
isaacfrond··on Teacher's 'Clever' Hack for Catching Students Using ChatGPT on Essay
tl;dr

She begins by splitting her essay prompt—the title of the essay given to her students—into two paragraphs before adding a sentence in-between in white using the smallest size possible. The idea is that if the essay prompt is copied and pasted into ChatGPT, the teacher can then search for the sentence hidden in the small white font when the assignment is submitted.

There is a problem though. "If a student happens to notice that there is hidden text in their assignment prompt, then there are some possible outcomes: they can either remove the text or mistake it as a part of the instructions," she said.

isaacfrond··on New Foundations is consistent – a difficult mathematical proof proved using Lean
You could start with the Natural numbers game.

https://adam.math.hhu.de/#/g/leanprover-community/NNG4

isaacfrond··on New Foundations is consistent – a difficult mathematical proof proved using Lean
Next up the abc-conjecture!

Claimed to be proven in 2012, and to 400+ page paper is online. But I don't many accept the proof.

isaacfrond··on Single atoms captured morphing into quantum waves in startling image
https://archive.is/20240423025205/https://www.newscientist.c...
isaacfrond··on EURISKO Lives
Excellent question. I have no clue either.
isaacfrond··on Cryptography Tricks Make a Hard Problem a Little Easier
I like the quanta articles. But I'd really appreciate if'd throw in a link to the actual paper.
isaacfrond··on [dead]
Imagine a Russian billionare bashing a US supreme judge, while his image is carried through the streets. You couldn’t, could you?
isaacfrond··on Block Innovation by Supporting the Generative AI Copyright Disclosure Act
tl;dr

Claiming to protect creators, or perhaps that should be 'identifiable copyright holders', the Generative AI Copyright Disclosure Act of 2024 has been introduced at the U.S. House of Representatives. At its core, the Bill requires those responsible for training or modifying a dataset, used to build a generative AI system, to notify the Copyright Office of any copyrighted works used in that process.

isaacfrond··on OpenAI op X: ChatGPT responses will be more direct and less verbose
That would be very helpful actually
isaacfrond··on Elon Musk denies knowing who's suing him to dodge defamation suit
Sure you have freedom of speech Mr. Musk. Nobody is denying you. But if you falsely accuse people of being a Nazi, that speech could have consequences.

Freedom of speech is not the same thing is freedom of consequences.

isaacfrond··on Texas will use AI to grade this year's STAAR tests
In my country the solution to this problem has always been to make these types of test multiple choice. It's not an ideal solution, because you can only ask questions which have clearly only one correct answer.

Using AI for the same task, I dunno. You more the responsibility of grading in essence to the end user who will have to check the grading. No doubt upper class parents will not know how to do it, and be motivated to get a higher score in this manner. So the result will be many more appeals and a bigger divide between the haves and haves-not.

I'm all in favor of using AI where it helps (programming e.g.). But seems not one of them.

← PreviousPage 6 of 30Next →