HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

isaiahg

426 karma · joined February 13, 2015

submissionscomments
isaiahg··on Rust for Embedded C Programmers
Is there really any mystery to why someone would prefer a language they know and are comfortable with. I'm more concerned why that seemed provocative enough to require inquiry. Rust is a very interesting language for sure, but there's an extremely robust c ecosystem that one would lose by transitioning at this point. And for library creators, there's much more to lose.
isaiahg··on A simple defer feature for C
> Defer() statements would be executed at scope-exit, in last-in first-out order. Standard block scoping would apply for anything declared inside of the defer().

But this still doesn't address the problem the change is used to contain. Should defer free a variable's value as it is when defer is used or the value at the end of the scope.

And is it really such huge change. I don't find it too far removed that it becomes confusing and I appreciate the additional control over what should be freed and where. You can imagine a scenario where a variable is being reused multiple times where this kind of additional control might be useful.

isaiahg··on Humble subscription service is dumping Mac, Linux access in 18 days
Humble died around 2017 when ign bought them. Ever since then they've been unable to figure out their identity. Their bundles have been pretty bad lately too. Mostly just old titles and assets.

They stuck when they launched. If they had only kept their business model and improved they're service they would still be doing great.

isaiahg··on Exploring System76's New Rust Based Desktop Environment
I know it's early but I was really hoping for something that looks different from the regular gnome desktop. Let me preface that by saying that I like gnome fine. And I've used it many times. But it's always felt like the design is less focused on desktop users and more an attempt to make a mobile friendly layout fit to desktop.

What system76 is doing could be a great opportunity to rethink a desktop for desktop users. And I understand that after so many years, users have come to expect certain things from a desktop and there's less room to innovate without alienating a huge segment of the userbase that doesn't want to relearn how to use their computer. But still it would be great to get a new idea in the space. And I would love to get an alternative to gnome and kde that isn't just a remix of the past desktops.

isaiahg··on Analysis of the overhead of a minimal Zig program
Thankfully much of the controversy around V has escaped me. The clashes between proponents and detractors has mostly occurred on my periphery and it comes across rather silly to me. And I realize that will make me unpopular with both sides. It reminds me more of highschoolers arguing rather than than engineers actually trying to solve something, in that no one is fully wrong and everyone is a little bit right.

One side should realize they're deriding a project that's still in its infancy and it's bound to be unfinished, buggy, off-kilter, and missing features that are still more or less just rough ideas in the heads of the creators. The same can be said for any early project.

And one side needs to accept the creators were a bit overzealous and advertised features that we're really just rough ideas in their heads. And that fighting criticism with anger just makes those criticizing double down in their energy and aggressiveness.

I'm sure V will be a fine language some day. I actually like the simple style of Go's syntax. It's a breath of fresh air when you're up to your neck in "Value<double, SIUnits::m> distance;" Though I question if it actually brings anything new more than some nicer syntax. I might wait until it's closer to a v1 and make something in it for my blog.

isaiahg··on Analysis of the overhead of a minimal Zig program
The people who like zig really like zig so they upvote it to the top while the people who don't like zig are at worst indifferent to it. So no one really complains.

But we're starting to reach the point where zig is becoming popular and people will hate it for that alone very soon. Because we're all really just cavemen typing on keyboards and we can't even discuss how to encode text strings without descending into tribal war.

isaiahg··on Emfy: Emacs for You – Quickly set up vanilla Emacs for editing
Pick whichever, it wouldn't be emacs if there wasn't at least 3 ways to do something.

read this for a complete answer https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/manual/html_node/emacs/In...

isaiahg··on Ubisoft deleted account with hundreds of dollars’ worth of games for inactivity
And probably the most complicated solution
isaiahg··on A Review of the Zig Programming Language (Using Advent of Code 2021)
That's the one part in which I really disagreed and the author does a bad job of explaining why they think that.
isaiahg··on Open 3D Foundation announces first major release of Open 3D Engine
Just downloaded the deb and installed it. Not going to lie it's a little janky but it also seems closer to the metal. It's just a cmake project and the code seems easy to understand. Once you get a project running in the editor it's very similar to unreal. The ui looks right out of UE5.

The discord also seems nice and populated by people from SIGGRAPH. It's run by the Linux Foundation and seems to be an effort to create a game engine equivalent of Blender.

Overall it looks pretty decent for a first release. You can kind of see the possibility of what it could be in the future.

isaiahg··on Firefox is the alternative to a Chrome hegemony
Those reasons might have applied half a decade ago. I was one of the early adopters of chrome and I've since switched back to Firefox for a better experience
isaiahg··on Firefox is the alternative to a Chrome hegemony
I use Firefox as my daily driver and I couldn't disagree more. But it's hard to reply adequately because you don't actually tell us what your problems with it is. In what ways is Firefox not an acceptable alternative?
isaiahg··on Flatpak Is Not the Future
I usually steer clear of these types of discussions because I find the arguments ultimately pointless in the end. The users pick the winner based on their experience regardless of the merits of the systems available. Also I'm certain I'll come out of this worse for wear, as is the experience whenever one crashes a heated debate among engineers arguing over which is the better standard. So I'm going to hastily step into this den of wolves and jump out again.

The fundamental issue I find with all these distribution systems is that they always seem more designed to justify a computer science degree rather than solving the problem in a user friendly way. And that applies to debs and rpms as well. All the solutions seem so over-engineered to the point that only engineers have a hope to get any kind of consistent usable experience out of it. Certainly you can try to hide all that complexity behind a nice GUI with icons and layouts, but that only works so well until something goes wrong. And then the user is stuck juggling a broken system and waiting for a reply on a support forum that may never come. That also mirrors my views on why Linux has yet to break into the mainstream desktop market.

But lets go even further, another fundamental issue. Sometimes it feels like these systems are working to justify a basic design choice of Linux that's overstayed its welcome. The idea to separate libraries and binaries was a fabulously beautiful engineering idea to fix a problem that stopped being an issue a decade ago. When your system has 32mb of storage, it makes sense, but less so when you can buy a 2tb solid state drive for $120 on Amazon. Counter to the argument in the article, storage is cheap and becoming cheaper at such a rate that continuing this philosophy will appear more odd by the day. And now we've officially come full circle and engineered it away with flatpak and appimage.

In an ideal world, these perfect systems should work beautifully. But users aren't perfect and neither are developers. That's why I now value software not by the novelty of how it solves a problem but in how few parts it can do it. For all Elon Musk's personal issues, he was letter perfect about one thing. The best system is no system. The best process is no process. For every additional step of complexity you add when solving a problem, you gain three additional problems. 1. You have to maintain it across the half-lifes of developer interests. 2. You have to teach users and developers how to use it the right way, a nearly impossible task. 3. All the systems that rely on it become more complex, duplicating problems 1 and 2 ad nauseam.

For me part of the answer was missed 12 years ago with AppImage. It works so well that I find myself breathing a sigh of relief whenever I find an application I want that uses it. That's because I know it'll just work. It's a testament to the usability of AppImages that it's still in use years later even without support from major distros. I think the linux community at large is at risk of missing something very good there. At least for user facing programs, it works wonderfully.

isaiahg··on Pangea Aerospace successfully hot fire tests the first MethaLox aerospike engine
The article hints that this design may be less complex.

> The engine is extremely low cost to produce, as it is completely additively manufactured (metallic 3D printing) in only two pieces.

isaiahg··on Show HN: Mako – a full Bitcoin implementation in C
As someone who's teaching themselves C could you elaborate?
isaiahg··on Ask HN: Creating a consumer humanoid robot – suggestions for apps?
When studying a foreign language unless you live near where the language is spoken, it's extremely hard to practice. Even online it's hard to find someone who doesn't disappear after the first chat and you almost certainly live in different timezones. It occurred to me how useful it'd be to have a little robot to practice with. Something I could sit on my desk, with a language model, that I could try out conversations with. It'd also be convenient if you're not super confident in the language yet since a robot can't judge. I imagine it would end up as a killer app paired with a robotic bear that children can use. You might even be able to sell to the education sector.

Btw, like others have said, it's a bit creepy looking. I didn't realize someone could make a teddy bear and somehow make it look cold and murderous but bravo. If you're going to make a teddy bear, at least make it look soft and cuddly. And give the eyes some life to them please

isaiahg··on SDL gets an Epic MegaGrant to work on next-gen Vulkan API
Hope that includes better documentation. I've tried SDL2 a few times but I always have trouble after getting a window appear. Api docs are great but only go so far.
isaiahg··on Scientists say they may have detected dark energy
In the present it seems like we've discovered so much but modern science is still such a young concept in the timeline of humanity. I'd wager we still have many wrong answers and much of how the universe works is still undiscovered
isaiahg··on I Miss the Old Internet (2019)
Maybe things felt better because the internet originally reflected a subset of our population. Before the advent of cheap smartphones and 24/7 connections with a cellular plan, being part of the early internet usually meant you had a well paid job and were educated.

The internet of today hasn't changed much and is still a reflection of it's population. And if we don't like what we see it's because it highlights the worst parts of society as well as the best.

I've been doing a lot of thinking on how the internet has changed humanity since it's inception and watching our gradual change into a more connected and collectivist mentality. I think right now we're all being confronted with the imperfect creatures we are and ultimately I think it's a good thing for how we'll progress from here.

isaiahg··on Morning diurnal preference is associated with reduced risk of depression: study
Isn't it more likely that people who aren't depressed wake up earlier
isaiahg··on Zig Makes Rust Cross-Compilation Just Work
Same here and I've been counting the days until my current project is finished so I can start one in zig
isaiahg··on Building virtual worlds: video games and autobiographical architecture
“A person who thinks all the time has nothing to think about except thoughts. So, he loses touch with reality and lives in a world of illusions."
isaiahg··on Grain: WebAssembly-First Programming Language
from their website :

>No runtime type errors, ever. Every bit of Grain you write is thoroughly sifted for type errors, with no need for type annotations.

isaiahg··on Mozilla Firefox update is making me abandon Chrome – Here's why
I remember being one of the first adopters of chrome back when it launched and how great it was. A few years ago I moved back to Firefox. Mozilla has done a great job since then to close the gap and Firefox is better than ever
isaiahg··on Signal Tries to Run the Most Honest Facebook Ad Campaign Ever, Gets Banned
It's irresponsible unless they were waiting for the ban and purposely orchestrated it for publicity
isaiahg··on No one will read your book (and other truths about publishing)
I feel that too. It doesn't just work in the short run it works in the long run many times too. Was it always like this or did a switch happen at some point? or are we just remembering the past with rise colored glasses
isaiahg··on Why you should NOT use NativeScript
The message I'm getting from Google is that flutter is the future and will get more support eventually. You can also see it in their fuchsia os which is heavily focused on the ecosystem.
isaiahg··on Handles are the better pointers (2018)
I haven't read the whole article yet but it says pretty early on that they're indexes to an array
isaiahg··on Go is a great programming language
That's not what's called a thinking error, it's a personal opinion. Just like yours
isaiahg··on Go is a great programming language
I've been seeing this too all over the place. Why do we have to continue break out in this tribal behavior with our identities tied to what language we use. It matters less what language you use than what kind of algorithms and data structures you know, not to mention problem solving skills. And those things can translate to any language.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →