HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

isamuel

1,186 karma · joined August 15, 2009

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/isamuel; my proof: https://keybase.io/isamuel/sigs/IsCZ2z7ULN4qhgFL7w1wfZ2gtl6qz3Ehtp22SvdXyzc ]
submissionscomments
isamuel··on This Is Water (2005)
Let’s go ahead and caption this comment “On The Cusp of a Revelation (2021)”
isamuel··on MP Maria Miller wants AI 'nudifying' tool banned
In America, the federal child pornography law applies only to depictions of an actual child (and you have to know it, for possession offenses, though that’s another matter). But the Justice Department has long taken the position that an image of a clothed child that’s altered to then make the child look nude—-they used to call these “morphed” images—-counts. I don’t think it’s ever been definitively resolved by the Supreme Court, and I don’t know what the courts of appeals have said, but tools like DeepSukebe have made that argument way more appealing. I’d bet that this is where regulation will begin: images of children. That has always been a domain where American courts have been extremely reluctant to intervene; for example, any visual depiction of a seventeen year old engaged in sex is proscribable without resort to the ordinary inquiry into whether the work as a whole is “obscene,” etc.

But under reigning American First Amendment law, it gets a lot harder to explain why a law like the one being proposed here would be acceptable. The Supreme Court has, for example, held that the distribution of animal-cruelty videos cannot be forbidden. And it’s not clear to me how one could proscribe the distribution of an imaginary visual depiction of an adult who was nude. You could call it defamatory, I suppose, but if it’s concededly fictional… I don’t know.

isamuel··on Apple is now an antifragile company
The article argues that Apple is "antifragile"

> thanks to a diverse mix of strong products.

That is not quite correct. That is robustness: it means the company can endure stressors in a variety of ways. (Other commenters have pointed this out, and I agree with them.)

But the article does hint at a real argument for antifragility: cash.

Apple's cash position, plus their diverse mix of revenue categories, means that in bad times they will be relatively advantaged over competitors. For example, the company spends $40 billion per quarter or so on advance purchases from chip suppliers---meaning that, when supply shocks happen, they will be better off, because they will continue to have what they need but competitors suddenly will not. What allows them to do that? Money. A giant pile of money. That money contributes to robustness, yes, but when sector- or global-scale stressors occur, it will mean that they can actually improve their competitive position.

I can think of counterarguments, but I think that's the strongest case.

isamuel··on Java Is Underhyped
As a bookmark I can point to later, I want this on record:

This kid's going to the moon.

isamuel··on Why are so many successful founding CEOs software engineers?
You can do both. Usually, nails go along the outside and screws in the "field," but I'll confess that it's been 30 years since I helped my dad do it (I was a big help, I'm sure) so perhaps the state of the art has changed.
isamuel··on Why are so many successful founding CEOs software engineers?
This is a better way of putting the point I was inelegantly grasping at. The neighbor kid is just an industrious kid---they happen to be nailing up drywall, but it's not that nailing up the drywall is why they end up running Berkshire Hathaway (or whatever) later. It's that they're industrious, and have various other traits that---in some other context---would result in them doing whatever else.

Maybe they turn into the engineer who can extract water, if only for reasons of path-dependency. And in a world where water-extraction is a valuable industry, that path-dependent contingency will result in them maybe starting a valuable water-extraction engineering firm. But it's not that nailing up drywall as a kid made them uniquely qualified. It's that they were industrious and smart and had sufficient fortune and whatever else. Which is good, all that stuff is good.

isamuel··on Why are so many successful founding CEOs software engineers?
All of the people on this list are "software engineers" in the sense that they have some rudimentary education in the field. Almost none of them could get a job as a software engineer at their own company, if they had to, because they would be completely unqualified. And I'm not looking down my nose at anyone: I have an undergraduate degree in CS, but I got it 16 years ago and then went to law school, and there is not a serious place on earth that would let me touch their codebase. But if I started a really valuable company tomorrow (maybe I should), I would code as a software engineer on this list.

I mean, come at it from the other direction: Why are there so many software engineers who are not successful CEOs? My God, they have the secrets of for loops, S-expressions, they know about vim---and yet they aren't running Pfizer? Why not?

isamuel··on Write Simply
There is no empirical evidence that can "validate" a normative claim, except to the extent that such claims rely on empirical priors. You can't squeeze an "ought" from an "is," literally by definition.

The response "this normative opinion is not falsifiable" is just confused—it's like saying "this empirical observation is not good."

isamuel··on Banned Seuss
Seuss had a lot of weird ideas. Any literary executor worth his salt would find a way to preserve the value of the literary estate by limiting distribution of the weird shit. Imagine that: a great guy had some bad books, which ought to probably be forgotten. Who’d have bethunk’d it.
isamuel··on Trading Time for Money
The only correct points in here are 3 and 4 but they’re said in a really roundabout way.

You don’t sell “time” for money. You sell labor. To do that you need a buyer. Most buyers purchase in bulk, and in many fields, want “requirements agreements”—you’ll produce as much as we need. Selling a little bit of labor power is often like trying to sell one bean. Doesn’t work that way.

That’s all you need.

isamuel··on Dasung just released a 25 inch eInk monitor
Any firm with a truly valuable product could buy the patent (or at minimum, a license). This is basically Coase Theorem 101. At this scale, transaction costs are not significant and so the property right will end up allocated to the most efficient holder.

Even if you don’t like that pure theory point, litigation is expensive and takes a long time. If some small little patent holder is really being stubborn and you’ve got something valuable, it’s not that hard to grind them into dust while you get big. Litigation financing makes this a little harder than it used to be but still.

isamuel··on LambdaMOO takes a new direction (1992)
This sounds entirely right. Because I also have a recollection of that party room in the clouds. Actually, it's further refreshing my recollection---I think the main area was called "the Sprawl" or something like that? Maybe it WAS just a mirror, and the reason I haven't ever been able to find anyone else talk about it is that I was under a teenage misimpression about the name.

EDIT: AHA. Sensemedia apparently had a virtual community consisting of MANY themed MOOs, termed "The Sprawl," of which Snow was one; ChibaMOO was I guess the famous one, and was based on Neuromancer. This is more progress than I have made on this in years, so thanks!

isamuel··on LambdaMOO takes a new direction (1992)
I spent an enormous amount of time on "Snow Crash", a MOO that I think was similar and was popular around the same time. This was in the middle or late 90s. The world was incredibly rich---everything in it was an object that was programmable if you had the right ownership permissions. I don't remember the language it used, or if it even was a standard one, but looking back it was unbelievably robust. I was able to make a "video recorder" that could be turned on, record all the events in a given place, and replay them later to make it all seem like it was happening again; a couple then used this to record their in-world wedding, which I only learned about months later.

I have DESPERATELY searched for years for any commentary on this community slash game, with no luck. I can even remember the telnet address: sapporo.sensemedia.net. Port 8888, maybe? Ah, alas.

isamuel··on What is the best length for short stories? (2016)
Personally? I think the best length is "short."

More seriously, this study is selecting on the dependent variable. No good.

isamuel··on My Heroic and Lazy Stand Against IFTTT
https://xkcd.com/927/
isamuel··on FBI argues it can force Apple to turn over iPhone source code
The Lavabit case was decided on entirely procedural grounds—the Fourth Circuit never said that it was OK to compel the disclosure of the SSL keys, only that Lavabit had waived its objections in the district court (at which stage Lavabit was acting without counsel).

Source: I briefed and argued the Lavabit case in the Fourth Circuit.

isamuel··on Jonathan Ive and the Future of Apple
It's not even criminal to possess material, non-public information and trade on it. It's only illegal (at least in the United States) if the insider gives you the information in exchange for some tangible benefit, and then you trade on it.
isamuel··on Why New Yorkers will be sipping bone broth in coffee cups this winter
Bone broth is really good, and it's also very easy to make if you aren't a New Yorker or don't want to pay $4 for a small cup. Put a bunch of bones in the slow cooker; add some water and vinegar; let 'er rip. That's it. It leaches out all of the minerals and stuff from the bones.
isamuel··on Mayday.us
I've found Safari's credit card auto-fill to be remarkably good. To a first approximation, I never type my credit card information anymore—and when I do, I'm willing to blame the website designer for doing some goofy thing to prevent recognition.
isamuel··on CurrentC Has Been Hacked, Testers’ Email Addresses Stolen
The iPhone 6 has both a secure enclave, for Touch ID, and a secure element.

"Every time you hand over your credit or debit card to pay, your card number and identity are visible. With Apple Pay, instead of using your actual credit and debit card numbers when you add your card to Passbook, a unique Device Account Number is assigned, encrypted, and securely stored in the Secure Element, a dedicated chip in iPhone."

https://www.apple.com/iphone-6/apple-pay/

isamuel··on NYU Eats World: An alumna laments the rise of an imperial university
NYU's law school has been an elite institution for some time. The same is true of the philosophy and Italian studies departments.
isamuel··on Airlines crack down on ‘mileage runs’
It's a reasonable question, and it's one of the things about airline status that I actually value a lot, so here's an attempt to answer it.

First, if you have carry-on luggage and the flight is full, this guarantees you access to overhead space. That can be a big deal. Having to gate-check your bag can be irritating if you've got things in there that you need, and the longer the flight, the more important this is.

Second, at least on Delta, the people who board priority have a separate line. That line continues to exist even after general boarding starts. The upshot is that, even if you board with everyone else, you can cut the line and not have to stand around waiting. If you prefer sitting down to standing in a line, then this is valuable and good.

Third, and related to #2, boarding early means you're likely boarding with other frequent travelers. Those people are better to board with because they are quicker and more efficient, on average, about things like clearing out of the aisle, getting settled, etc. This means less waiting around and being jostled in the aisle.

All of this adds up to a much more pleasant experience.

isamuel··on How Many People See Your Tweets? Twitter Opens Its Analytics Dashboard
I wonder how this counts third-party clients; does a download by Tweetbot count as an "impression?"
isamuel··on Overcast – A powerful yet simple iPhone podcast player
I've been looking forward to this and was planning on a day one purchase, so I'm pleasantly surprised to learn that there's even more here than I expected. Things like Smart Speed and Voice Boost are features I haven't seen anywhere else, and if they work as advertised, are major innovations.

They're also bred of listening to a lot of podcasts. Marco seems like he's scratching his own itch with these features, which is always great.

isamuel··on Apple Confirms Its $3 Billion Deal for Beats Electronics
What in the world makes you think Time Warner would sell HBO to Apple?
isamuel··on FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet
The actual notice of proposed rulemaking (or "NPRM," as ad-law nerds call it): http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-14-61A...

I haven't read it in full yet, but I've read the introduction, and the press coverage (surprise!) does not seem quite right to me.

isamuel··on Airbnb closes $500M round of funding at a $10B valuation, led By TPG
I think you're stating their point accurately. But what I mean is that in the usual case, the value of 1,000,000 shares is actually greater than 1,000,000 x (price of one share), because you're getting something more with those million shares: control. That said, there may be countervailing forces at work in tightly-held startups that don't apply to liquid capital markets.
isamuel··on Airbnb closes $500M round of funding at a $10B valuation, led By TPG
Usually, you pay a premium for large equity stakes, because they come with more practical control. (Witness every tender offer takeover ever.) The other two points are more convincing, however.
isamuel··on What You Can't Say (2004)
Good on you. I think you're on the right side of history.
isamuel··on Dropbox 2048
This is a great demonstration of a feature I didn't know existed—using Dropbox to save application-level data. I'm sure I'm just behind the curve, but there are probably a lot of us back here. Nice move, DB.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →