HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

iscoelho

684 karma · joined January 18, 2017

submissionscomments
iscoelho··on Microsoft BitLocker – YellowKey zero-day exploit
1) Except that the entire premise behind BitLocker TPM's security relies on the login screen as a hard security boundary, and thus any attack on the login screen is an attack on BitLocker. It is semantics to dispute this and certainly fits "downplaying."

2) I'm sure many organizations are thankful that the researcher has decided not to release that exploit chain at this time. I am hopeful that Microsoft will not be as dismissive and will resolve it before it is publicly released.

3) It distracts from the point. The point is that Microsoft's security record is so bad that many of the vulnerabilities appear deliberate and obvious enough to be backdoors.

4) Yes, this also fits the definition of downplaying.

iscoelho··on Mystery Microsoft bug leaker keeps the zero-days coming
Considering the researcher had already reported these to Microsoft, and delayed releasing them publicly until Microsoft "pulled every childish game possible" (quote) instead of patching them, it's not unreasonable for the researcher to be withholding another exploit from the public to limit harm.

I also disagree that the PIN bypass would be "10 times more impressive," but that's just my professional opinion.

iscoelho··on Microsoft BitLocker – YellowKey zero-day exploit
What's with all the replies on these threads downplaying this? Why is it mainly brand new accounts? What's going on here?

I've seen every variant of:

1) "this is an authentication/privilege escalation bug, not a bitlocker exploit" (? what are you even trying to say)

2) "even though the attacker explicitly warns that this is capable of bypassing TPM+PIN, that isn't actually true or what he meant"

3) "we shouldn't jump to conclusions that this is a backdoor"

4) "we already knew BitLocker with just TPM isn't secure" (? except many organizations depend on it to be)

iscoelho··on Mystery Microsoft bug leaker keeps the zero-days coming
That’s quite a stretch, to say the least.
iscoelho··on Despite doubts, federal cyber experts approved Microsoft cloud service
But it doesn't. Full authentication bypass exploits are extremely rare and unheard of among tech giants. Maybe account takeover/recovery, sure, but full bypass? It just never happens.

Microsoft goes beyond that: they've managed to have a critical vulnerability in almost every authentication product they have ever created. It's exceptional.

iscoelho··on Despite doubts, federal cyber experts approved Microsoft cloud service
I knew there was another incident that I was forgetting, insanity... I don't understand how Microsoft keeps getting away with this and everyone just forgets.
iscoelho··on Despite doubts, federal cyber experts approved Microsoft cloud service
Microsoft has never been good at security, and that is why their centralization to cloud is absolutely terrifying.

I'm reminded of Storm-0558 [1] where a stolen signing key was able to forge authentication tokens for any MSA / Azure AD / Government AD user. They downplayed the severity. Just imagine if that level of access was used to pull a Stryker on a nation-wide scale. That is an economic disaster waiting to happen.

[1] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/blog/2023/07/14/ana...

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
I'd use WireGuard in that case. The main reason WireGuard is popular at all is because it is approachable. IPsec is much more complicated and is designed for network engineers, not users.
iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
That's a large packet benchmark, not mixed packet size, and it just barely hits it. If you need consistent 10Gbps for a business use case, I would not consider that sufficient.

> "To me, the bulk of Tailscale's overhead comes from the fact that the dataplane is running between user and kernel space."

Yes and no, it's more complicated. DPDK is the industry standard library for fast packet processing, and it is in entirely user space. The Linux kernel netstack is just not very fast.

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
Mikrotik can be popular for CE (Customer Edge) devices, that is correct. Those are not ISPs however, those are customers.
iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
CE (Customer Edge) is what you are referring to. ISPs would be the PE (Provider Edge). I am aware it can be popular for SMB CE devices, however that is simply not the case for PE devices.

Service Provider ISPs cannot use Mikrotik - It is impossible. RouterOS supports none of the features required for a service provider. VRFs are even still unsupported in HW [1]. I am confused why this is even a discussion as anyone with experience working at an ISP/SP would come to the same conclusion.

[1] https://help.mikrotik.com/docs/spaces/ROS/pages/62390319/L3+...

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
AWS/GCE/Azure's network implementations pre-date EVPN and are proprietary to their cloud. EVPN is for on-premise. You don't exactly have the opportunity to use their implementation unless you are on their cloud, so I am not sure comparing the merits of either is productive.
iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
I'm curious what you classify as a business ISP?

Take a look at AMS-IX, one of the largest internet exchanges: https://bgp.tools/ixp/AMS-IX

21/1020 (2%) of all peers are Mikrotik. 15 (1.4%) of those are >=1000mbps. 7 (0.6%) of those are 10gbps. None are larger than 10gbps.

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
wireguard-go is indeed very slow. For example, the official WireGuard Mac client uses it, and performance on my M1 Max is CPU capped at 200Mbps. The kernel WireGuard implementation available for Linux is certainly faster, but I would not consider it fast.

Tailscale however, although it derives from WireGuard libraries and the protocol, is really not WireGuard at all- so comparing it is a bit apples to oranges. With that said, it is still entirely userspace and its performance is less than stellar.

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
I have not seen a case where I could not source a Juniper switch (for example) for lower $/port than Mikrotik, even at 400GE. It is unheard of to pay MSRP. YMMV.
iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
VXLAN is used in cloud/virtualization networks commonly. VM HA/migration becomes trivial with VXLAN. It also replaces L3VPN/VRFs for private networks.
iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
I don't disagree (:

Though there are definitely use cases where it is needed, and it is way easier to implement earlier than later.

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
If I can source an enterprise Cisco/Juniper/Arista ASIC switch that is 1) rock-solid 2) full featured 3) cheaper - which I can - there is unfortunately no rationale where Mikrotik would be applicable in any professional project of mine.

With that said, I love Mikrotik for what it is: it is very approachable and it fills a niche. I believe it has added a lot of value to the industry and I'm excited to see their products mature.

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
There are also solutions like Arista TunnelSec [1] that can achieve IPsec and VXLANsec at line-rate performance (21.6Tbps per chassis)! This is fairly new and fancy though.

[1] https://www.arista.com/assets/data/pdf/Whitepapers/EVPN-Data...

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
Exactly this. I would love to see a commercial product with a hardware implementation for WireGuard, but it does not yet exist. IPsec, however, is well supported.
iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
At this time, there is no commercial offering for hardware/ASIC WireGuard implementations. The standard WireGuard implementation cannot reach 10G.

The fastest I am aware of is VPP (open-source) & Intel QAT [1], which while it is achieves impressive numbers for large packets (70Gbps @ 512 / 200Gbps @ 1420 on a $20k+ MSRP server), is still not comparable with commercial IPsec offerings [2][3][4] that can achieve 800Gbps+ on a single gateway (and come with the added benefit of relying on a commercial product with support).

[1] https://builders.intel.com/docs/networkbuilders/intel-qat-ac...

[2] https://www.juniper.net/content/dam/www/assets/datasheets/us...

[3] https://www.paloaltonetworks.com/apps/pan/public/downloadRes...

[4] https://www.fortinet.com/content/dam/fortinet/assets/data-sh...

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
Any ASIC switch released in the last decade from Cisco/Juniper/Arista supports EVPN/VXLAN in hardware. EVPN is built on BGP. This has become the industry standard for new enterprise and cloud deployments.

The lack of support for hardware EVPN is one of the many reasons that Mikrotik is not considered for professional deployments.

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
EVPN/VXLAN fabrics are becoming industry standard for new deployments. MACSEC/IPsec is industry standard for site-to-site.

You'd be surprised to know that this is especially popular in cloud! It's just abstracted away (:

iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
VXLAN is for L2 between campuses. It is commonly used in enterprise and cloud networks.
iscoelho··on Ask HN: Vxlan over WireGuard or WireGuard over Vxlan?
VXLAN over WireGuard is acceptable if you require a shared L2 boundary.

IPSec over VXLAN is what I recommend if you are doing 10G or above. There is a much higher performance ceiling than WireGuard with IPSec via hardware firewalls. WireGuard is comparatively quite slow performance-wise. Noting Tailscale, since it has been mentioned, has comparatively extremely slow performance.

edit: I'm noticing that a lot of the other replies in this thread are not from network engineers. Among network engineers WireGuard is not very popular due to performance & absence of vendor support. Among software engineers, it is very popular due to ease of use.

iscoelho··on Green card interviews end in handcuffs for spouses of U.S. citizens
> I'd much prefer they enforce the laws evenly and then fix them where they're broken rather than disadvantaging everyone going through the legal process while those that cheat get to jump ahead.

That is incredibly optimistic to believe that any legislation reforming immigration will be passed in the next decade.

There is a reason ICE was neutralized until now. Life is short. We don't have time for congress to play politics while Americans and their spouses suffer. Let people live their lives.

iscoelho··on Green card interviews end in handcuffs for spouses of U.S. citizens
Your immigration attorney will advise that you overstay. If you do not, your application will be abandoned.
iscoelho··on Gov. Abbott's office redacts pages of emails about Elon Musk
Negotiating is difficult if you show your hand. It is arguably beneficial to both the state and Elon that the e-mails stay redacted. I agree it is unfortunate though.
iscoelho··on Gov. Abbott's office redacts pages of emails about Elon Musk
If the result of the negotiations are in good faith and beneficial for his constituents, then it is not corruption. Of course, that's open to interpretation.

Corruption is usually when there is personal benefit to the politician themselves.

iscoelho··on FFmpeg to Google: Fund us or stop sending bugs
It appears we are not reading the same thread.
← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →