HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

itistoday2

628 karma · joined June 18, 2011

I upset the powers that be through my support of Bradley Manning, and now have this new account.

    Previous Karma  : 2231
    Previous Avg    : 7.47
    Previous account: http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=itistoday
I've got https://lobste.rs invites! (HN "like the good ol' days".) Happy to invite folks I feel will contribute positively to the community.

On Lobsters: moderation is public info, and so is who invited who. Downvotes require reasons, and they are undoable.

Send me an email (itistoday at gmail) with your HN profile and temporarily place your email info in your HN profile so that I can verify you.

submissionscomments
itistoday2··on Group Currency
> Where does this $33 million magically come from (and reliably appear every single year)?

Let's be serious here. There's no magic about it.

Red Hat has 7300 employees (as of 2015) [1] and made $0.024 million per employee in 2014. Multiply by 1000 and you get $24.4 million. Maybe these scientists have a patent that does well and it covers the extra $9 million to get $30k per year. (Sidenote: that seems low for Red Hat. Wiki says Google does $0.25 million/employee, an order of magnitude higher.)

Edit: Actually, those figures are based on profit, not revenue... Revenue/employee at Google is ~$1.2 million.

Don't confuse basic income with not working.

When people don't have to think about survival they are free to think about the flying car. If anything, there should be a net increase in the rate of value creation.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Hat

itistoday2··on Group Currency
> If the act of issuing tokens is disconnected from the process of bringing value into the given ecosystem, then the act of issuing tokens is merely inflationary. If the act of issuing tokens is directly connected to bringing value ("Bob brought X units of value in, Bob gets X tokens"), then it's not really a basic income.

True, the process of issuing tokens disconnected from new value is inflationary. But that doesn't imply that the currency as a whole is inflationary.

Some members might not be doing anything for some period of time and simply inflating the currency while others are deflating it through value creation. But sooner or later those folks will produce something of new value that deflates the currency while others take a break.

It's certainly possible. Universities do this for their tenured professors today and it seems to work out fairly well.

See also this reply: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9501494

itistoday2··on Group Currency
> Your FAQ and reply still have not addressed where __REAL VALUE__ comes from.

Here's an excerpt:

In the future, the AcademicCoin is very valuable. It represents 1000+ respected researchers who accept it as payment for their time, early access to research results, papers, etc.

Some examples of value are clearly listed there, so I'm not sure what the confusion is.

I also wrote a followup reply to another comment that might clear things up:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9501494

itistoday2··on Group Currency
Let me try again. The underlying concern seems to be (correct me if I'm mistaken): "How can a group currency provide a basic income?"

By definition. For a cryptocurrency to qualify as a group currency, it must provide its members with a basic income. This basic income is backed by the value that the group creates (whatever it may be).

In other words, profits go to paying back members for their existence. To be accepted into a group it's assumed that you will be providing some kind of value, but the group understands you might face hard times and so it provides you with a basic income.

The wider community in turn, has faith in the group's future, and that results in an appropriate price for the group's currency, which is being minted by group members.

It's certainly possible that a group could fail to provide a basic income to its members, but the point is that it tries. Otherwise it doesn't fit the definition.

itistoday2··on Group Currency
> Using a cryptocurrency to provide basic income would manifest simply as the creation of currency, with no actual value being created to correspond to the new currency, so it's just going to be inflationary.

CryptoUBIs/group currencies can be deflationary. Have a look at the first item in the FAQ [1]. If the value represented by AcademicCoin is increasing faster than the issuance of tokens, AcademicCoin becomes deflationary.

[1] http://groupcurrency.org/#FAQ

Disclaimer: I am a co-author of the document.

itistoday2··on Cops: We Need Rights More Than You, Citizen
> Everything he said is true, now what are we going to do about it?

For those of us who are illiterate when it comes to legal matters, the best we can do about it is to first fix our ignorance.

When computers break, folks look for their local computer geek to fix it. When laws break, computer geeks should seek the counsel of their local law geek (or become one themselves).

Now, if the law geeks say their system is so broken that there's nothing they can do to reasonably fix it, that's when the wider community can take alternative steps.

itistoday2··on Oracle latest to be sued for wage-fixing
There's no reason for barbarism. If the situation needs to be fixed then a change needs to happen one way or another (someone else pointed out a settlement amount hasn't been decided yet).

For this context a financial punishment is appropriate ("punishment should fit the crime"). And the existence of the formula above is actually helpful. It makes it simple to figure out exactly what the punishment amount should be, whereas flogging as a deterrent is a tad harder to measure, and as you point out, is barbaric.

itistoday2··on Meeting Snowden in Princeton
> Secret laws are pure poison; government lawyers claim authority and act on it, and we don’t know about it.

"Secret laws" are not laws. It is the equivalent of "because I said so", and that is simply a fascist edict.

@CombiHack points out:

> If “ignorance of the law is no excuse”, then the law MUST be publicly available. [..] Alternatively (less preferable): If “secret laws are laws”, then ignorance of the law MUST be a complete defense. End of story.

itistoday2··on Compiling Objective-C Using Visual Studio 2015 [video]
I've been a Mac user since OS 7. Don't reinvent history.

Since 10.0, OS X got progressively better with every release up to 10.4. After that things got progressively worse.

Your are only proving our point.

itistoday2··on Compiling Objective-C Using Visual Studio 2015 [video]
Microsoft would be stupid to not offer to port Cocoa apps.

How else are they supposed to convince developers such as myself to even consider buying a PC? With Apple dropping the ball with Yosemite, the opportunity is ripe for Microsoft to compete for quality devs and quality apps.

itistoday2··on Show HN: Feature voting for GitHub
> If you want other people to use what you made, you may have to do what they want. :)

Exactly. First thing I did when visiting the comments here was see if someone had brought up this issue. Just some more feedback (to indicate a consensus): I won't consider using this tool unless it provides easy access back to GitHub.

An example of a successful project that does bi-directional linking is BountySource.

itistoday2··on A note on the argument about the 'morality' of adblockers
> I hope there's a place in the future for both indie work and expensive "blockbuster" content.

Certainly. You'll note that as individual expenses go down, group expenses should go down as well since employers will no longer have to cover their employees cost of living. Prices of everything will continue to plummet (as they have been). If anything, they should be able to do more on the same budget.

EDIT: You might think "Well who's paying for all those basics? Surely that will imply higher taxes."

Compare the cost of a 1GHz CPU today to the cost 10 years ago. The price went down and yet taxes did not play a significant role in that. The basics could be covered by taxes, but they need not be. The price of basics goes down over time naturally as technology advances and builds off of the knowledge and efficiencies of the technology before it. Taxes can be used to accelerate this process, but they are not necessary for it to happen in the first place. Free, clean drinking water was not even a thing a few centuries ago. Now it is everywhere in first world countries. The same should happen with other necessities.

itistoday2··on A note on the argument about the 'morality' of adblockers
> I think the problem is life standards that emphasized to us by ads.

Heh, if that's true, that's another reason for folks to use adblockers. ;)

> So, I don't believe giving more to people solves anything.

When it comes to solving problems, the evidence is rather strong. Giving people more food, shelter, medicine, health care, education (even plain old money), results in striking benefits to individuals and communities.

This should not be surprising, but if you need studies, there are plenty:

https://www.reddit.com/r/BasicIncome/wiki/studies

itistoday2··on A note on the argument about the 'morality' of adblockers
I'd be interested to know what the Internet is like for folks in countries like Sweden where welfare systems are far more capable.

For example, do Swedish websites also rely heavily on advertising? How does the economy of Swedish content (in Swedish markets) compare to American content in America?

BTW: I should be clear that I am not advocating any particular type of welfare system. It does not even have to be government managed. The important thing is that a system exist to free people's minds from the mundane details of basic survival.

itistoday2··on A note on the argument about the 'morality' of adblockers
> In fact, our reluctance to pay for any type of content has led to the state we are in today.

People's reluctance to pay and their aversion to advertising is, I think, understandable and reasonable.

It is just a quirk of the time period that we find ourselves in that there is any "moral" dilemma attached to this situation.

The reason people perceive it as a moral situation is because we've established a society in which one must extract money out of others in order to survive.

Our welfare system is not yet currently capable of providing people with the basic necessities: food, shelter, clothing, clean water, healthcare, education, and equal access to opportunities.

If it were, you would find that the cost of content really would approach $0. If, for example, artists did not have to worry about any of the previously mentioned necessities (if it was just given to them), then most of them would probably be perfectly happy to continue to produce content for free and without advertising.

I know, as a software developer and entrepreneur, that I personally would be happy to not charge anything for any software that I create (or charge very little), if these basics were taken care of.

As more people continue to lose their jobs to robots and automation, we will (if we can avoid destroying ourselves), move in that direction.

itistoday2··on Pin-pointing China's attack against GitHub
Here ya go: https://github.com/robertdavidgraham/masscan

    @collinrm I just took masscan, changed the HTTP request,
    then tweeked the code to generate a small TTL.
Source: https://twitter.com/ErrataRob/status/583433175302479872
itistoday2··on Why Baidu Has Been Hijacked to Attack GitHub
Well said. It's your nuance that I like, and it's the lack of nuance in the original assertion that I find wanting.
itistoday2··on Why Baidu Has Been Hijacked to Attack GitHub
As much as I love MLK and Gandhi, this assertion never made sense to me.

An eye for an eye would leave two people blind: the person who blinded the other, and the one that was blinded.

Once people start seeing the severe consequence of blinding someone (getting blinded back), they and everyone else would most likely stop, not continue blinding more people.

itistoday2··on Maintaining Digital Certificate Security
> No, it doesn't. It describes the format of multi-SCT on page 16, and it explains the rationale for this (basically all of the points you brought up) on page 32.

I see the wording wasn't very clear, so I removed the word "only" to make the meaning clearer. It now reads:

"The CT spec allows one SCT to accompany a certificate, making this attack feasible"

Good catch. :)

itistoday2··on Maintaining Digital Certificate Security
We wrote a blog post to answer this question: https://blog.okturtles.com/2015/03/certificate-transparency-...
itistoday2··on Google warns of unauthorized TLS certificates trusted by almost all OSes
So, I'm realizing that this whole conversation is somewhat silly because blockchains already provide CT and they do a better job of CT than Google's CT.

If you'd be interested in reading a draft of a blog post on this topic, please shoot me an email (see my profile).

itistoday2··on Maintaining Digital Certificate Security
> I don't think DNSChain is a feasible project.

If you want to prevent MITM attacks, it's one of the only options available to you (probably the only realistic option):

https://github.com/okTurtles/dnschain/blob/master/docs/Compa...

> However, we can reduce the scope of the problem, and just focus on forcing certificates to be public. [1]

DNSChain/Blockchains already provide certificate transparency (publicly auditable log of certs issued), and they do a far better job of it than Certificate Transparency.

itistoday2··on Fear of Apple
I've been much happier with lobste.rs' voting system than HN's. On Lobsters:

1. All moderation is public information.

2. Who invited who is public information.

3. You need to pick a reason for downvoting something.

4. You can undo a downvote or an upvote.

Perhaps because of these properties (or something else), I also enjoy the conversations and community there better.

Frankly, I am annoyed that I can't read what your post said without copy/pasting it into a text document. WTH HN? Don't treat us like children.

It's obvious his post was downvoted for no good reason (as many posts on HN are). By making them difficult to read you're just making it difficult for others to evaluate even what reason it might have been downvoted for was.

(P.S. If you want a Lobsters invite, see my profile.)

itistoday2··on Maintaining Digital Certificate Security
So, as mentioned in the first link, client audits via the browser would do absolutely nothing during an attack:

"None of CT’s proofs (audit or consistency proofs) will detect mis-issuance of a certificate by a rogue CA, not even if gossip of STHs (signed-tree-heads) successfully occurs [1]"

And that's for today's attacks. In the section before that paragraph, another attack is demonstrated that also cannot be prevented by CT's audit proofs.

[1] https://moderncrypto.org/mail-archive/messaging/2014/000873....

itistoday2··on Maintaining Digital Certificate Security
> Part of the trick with blockchain is validation. Everyone is not going to keep a full node, not even close, and just delegating trust is not the answer. You want to trust but verify.

Right, so hence the two techniques I mentioned in my reply: query more than one server, and/or use Dionysis' "proof of transition" (for lack of a better name).

itistoday2··on Maintaining Digital Certificate Security
> If Google stored their domain info in a blockchain how would anyone know what identifier actually belonged to Google?

The same way they know that Google chose google.com and Twitter chose twitter.com instead of twitter.io or something else.

> The last time I brought this up you admitted there was no good solution yet, has that changed?

This is referring to something else I think, how to transfer .com's into a blockchain while preserving ownership, is that right? That could be done (if needed) with a centralized registrar whose job it was to vet the ownership of the names upon first registration in some namespace. After the initial registration, control would be transferred to the owner of the domain. This is again, however, specific to the case of migrating ICANN domains (if someone wants to do that).

itistoday2··on Google warns of unauthorized TLS certificates trusted by almost all OSes
> Therefore it's important to me that you not get downvoted. So I'm trying to help you get listened to, by telling you why I find myself wanting to reach for the downvote button—but the things you say are important enough that they deserve being engaged with, even if the manner in which you say it is frustrating.

Well, I appreciate that, thanks. I also appreciate that you decided to engage in actual honest discussion.

itistoday2··on Google warns of unauthorized TLS certificates trusted by almost all OSes
> I don't see why the CA wouldn't immediately query logs for all certificates that chain off of their intermediates, to verify that intermediates are only used in the way that people said they'd be used.

That's unlikely to happen (I suspect) because the amount of data that would need to be processed would be significant. Each CA would have to effectively mirror all of the logs out there, and the logs impose rate limits on queries. It would be interesting also to see what happens when a log gets DDoS'ed (we know OCSP servers aren't useful because of that problem).

> Is it possible to configure the browser to fail closed if it hasn't reached its update server within some period of time?

Sure.

> Is this something that CT can/should do? Can we standardize something like Chrome's CRLsets, and make the browsers require they be able to reach CRLsets somehow, either through the vendor or through a CT log?

Can? Yes. Should? Well, I suspect this would be yet another user experience nightmare that would therefore lead to little support for the idea.

> What's DNSChain's solution here? Can a MITM pretend that the blockchain hasn't moved in a few weeks?

Are you referring to the connection between clients and DNSChain or a blockchain and its network?

If the former, then a MITM's only option is to block connection to DNSChain, which would be treated as a MITM attack (appropriately).

If the latter, yes, a MITM could do that, and if PoW is being used by the blockchain this attack would be detectable instantly due to an immediate and significant drop in block difficulty. Even if it somehow wasn't detected, it still wouldn't allow the MITM to issue fraudulent certificates.

itistoday2··on Google warns of unauthorized TLS certificates trusted by almost all OSes
Legitimate SCTs can be used in attacks just as well (this will probably be the common case), as explained here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9254713

itistoday2··on Google warns of unauthorized TLS certificates trusted by almost all OSes
When you run out of legitimate arguments resort to personal attacks, got it.

The number of people on Earth who've spent the time studying Certificate Transparency in depth could probably be counted on two hands. You and I are two of them. That leaves ~8 other people (who are probably not reading these threads) to comment.

I'm grateful to everyone who's taken the time to support DNSChain, Namecoin, and related projects by writing about them, podcasting, tweeting, blogging, contributing code, etc.

https://github.com/okTurtles/dnschain#community

This certainly requires community support.

← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →