HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ivan_gammel

5,676 karma · joined February 28, 2011

Scaler CTO, Berlin, DE
submissionscomments
ivan_gammel··on Iran threatens 'complete and utter annihilation' of OpenAI's $30B Stargate
Nobody except Israel is setting civilian homes as targets for their rockets. Not all energy infrastructure is even remotely „dual use“ (and this label is itself propaganda used to justify strikes on non-military targets).
ivan_gammel··on Iran threatens 'complete and utter annihilation' of OpenAI's $30B Stargate
He may care in the end, because TACO. Looks like this is a pattern of modern war where both sides are testing the escalation levels by attacking the infrastructure. It‘s like MAD, but going up in smaller increments rather than hitting with everything after one or two limited strikes like nuclear. Basically, you hit my power plant, I‘ll hit yours. It‘s the same path Ukraine went on: they initially showed restraint in responses, but now they are matching Russian pressure by choosing the same civilian targets.
ivan_gammel··on Spring Boot Done Right: Lessons from a 400-Module Codebase
You can drop cloud spending by 10x factor and still use Spring Boot comfortably. In startup world exist infra costs benchmarks and they are very generous. That fat does not come from frameworks, it comes from not spending an extra hour on solution design.
ivan_gammel··on Spring Boot Done Right: Lessons from a 400-Module Codebase
I bet this is happening because in many enterprise applications you do not need high performance. Requirements to a service doing 1000 transactions a day are very different from requirements to a service doing HFT. Service per bounded context may be reasonable choice and Spring Boot/Spring Cloud may be adequate solution for it.
ivan_gammel··on Spring Boot Done Right: Lessons from a 400-Module Codebase
Exactly. It allows to build boring stuff at a fraction of what a SV startup would burn using some fancier tech. And most problems in the world are boring stuff.
ivan_gammel··on Spring Boot Done Right: Lessons from a 400-Module Codebase
Spring may be a bad choice for microservices (context required, because it is not true in general), but it is strange to compare it (DI framework/mvc/orm abstraction etc) with Go (programming language). Java exists in many flavors, you do not have to use Spring to build a performant microservice.
ivan_gammel··on Spring Boot Done Right: Lessons from a 400-Module Codebase
Spring framework may look complicated only at start, until you get it, but then it becomes quite easy to reason about.

OTOH, Spring Boot is a huge pile of various loosely coupled framework connectors, web, queues, security, databases etc. Some of them are of good quality, some are not so good. It is that uneven mix giving the perception that Spring is a mess.

ivan_gammel··on Should QA Exist
In development of medical devices existing quality controls are already working well, right?
ivan_gammel··on Should QA exist?
More like certified products. New ISO standard may require professional liability for software products, which will be adopted as requirement by big consumers and will pull the industry into certification loop, because insurers will ask for it. This will obviously put a high entry barrier to many product categories, slowing down innovation.
ivan_gammel··on Should QA exist?
Automated tests are no longer expensive to write and nowadays less expensive to execute.
ivan_gammel··on Should QA exist?
> because anything a QA engineer can do manually can be automated.

Looks like you never worked with a decent QA team and do not understand the full scope of quality management. They have plenty of creative tasks not aligned with other roles.

ivan_gammel··on Should QA exist?
There are two very important ideas in this article, which I fully agree with: QA are not the only people responsible for quality - entire team is. QA act as experts and drivers of quality management process, but they should not and are not acting alone. They should have adversarial approach which is helpful on every stage of SDLC. Thus, few more items from my list why QA is useful in every engineering organization and why every team I hire has at least one QA starting from 4-5 people:

1. Quality management is a continuous process that starts with product discovery and business requirements. Developers often assume that requirements are clear and move on to building the happy path. QA often explore requirements in depth and ask a lot of good questions.

2. QA usually have the best knowledge of the product and help product managers to understand its current behavior, when new requirements suggest to change it.

3. The same applies to product design. Good designer never leaves the team with a few annotated screens, supporting developers until the product is shipped. Design QA - the verification of conformance of implementation to design specs - can be done with QA team, which can assist with automation of design-specific tests.

4. Customer support - QA people are natural partners of customer support organization, with their knowledge of the product, existing bugs and workarounds.

And just a story: on one of my previous jobs recently hired QA engineer spotted number error in an All Hands presentation. That was an immediate buy-in from founders. :)

ivan_gammel··on Miscellanea: The War in Iran
>On the other hand isn't this how the russian revolution happened?

It happened because Russian empire (and German empire) lacked state security apparatus adequate to the threat. It was fixed by most authoritarian states after that, so e.g. Soviet Union survived for 70 years despite many popular uprisings, which happened almost the whole time of its existence. It went down only when elites in Moscow destroyed it from within.

ivan_gammel··on Atlassian says it had right to fire engineer for suggesting CEO is 'rich jerk'
I fully agree with you, it doesn’t. However I wasn’t saying that, so I have to conclude that you are speaking to someone else here, making up arguments from an imaginary opponent, and I’m not needed here. Good luck.
ivan_gammel··on Atlassian says it had right to fire engineer for suggesting CEO is 'rich jerk'
This conversation is not about „employees thinking/not thinking about shareholders“. You are cherry-picking that topic and taking it out of context, for what reason exactly?

I have explained already a few times why and what context matters here. Are you struggling to understand it or just avoiding it?

ivan_gammel··on Atlassian says it had right to fire engineer for suggesting CEO is 'rich jerk'
> They get money for their labor.

Yes, and what is the essence of that labor? It is to create profits for shareholders. You are not getting paid to contribute to toxic culture or to seize the means of production. CEO could have been in the wrong, but the moment when the “us vs them” idea starts dominating in corporate culture is the moment company dies and those jobs that everyone is so afraid to loose are ceasing to exist.

>This is ignoring that the concept of companies having to care about shareholders above everything else is a lie spread to justify evil behavior.

Nobody is claiming the “above everything else” here

ivan_gammel··on Atlassian says it had right to fire engineer for suggesting CEO is 'rich jerk'
> no employment contract I've ever signed requires

The sole reason for existence of for-profit corporations does not have to be explicitly stated in the contract. It’s implied and better be understood.

> does not mean blind allegiance to management…

Yes, it doesn’t. Nobody said it does.

> The employee's statement here was fact.

Sure. It it wasn’t the fact, it would be even worse.

> The CEO shouldn't be attacking and alienating their labor force.

It’s irrelevant. One person’s bad judgement does not justify another’s.

ivan_gammel··on Atlassian says it had right to fire engineer for suggesting CEO is 'rich jerk'
> That's not clear at all. Why do you say so?

Do you see any, even little sign of constructive criticism in what she said? Anything that could improve corporate culture or help her peers or management to understand the problem? Any hint on how it could be fixed? I don’t.

> Read the article.

I did read the article and came to the same conclusion as Atlassian.

> I refuse to believe anyone, including Oracle employees, likes Larry Ellison.

When you sign the working contract, your job is to act in the interests of shareholders. If you despise them or disagree with what they do, you can still work there and use your position to align their interests and the interests of the public. You can try to change it from within. But the moment when you decide to burn the bridges is the moment when you should leave. To me this is pretty obvious, and I’m really surprised to see here some sort of entitlement.

ivan_gammel··on How Invisalign became the biggest user of 3D printers
This sounds like AI-written comment, at least in the first part. What I do not get is why are you dismissing the argument about number of visits. 3D printed braces are still braces. They require manual adjustment for each treatment stage. Aligners do not need that - they may need a check-up in the middle of the treatment, maybe one or two mid-course corrections, maybe an appointment for installation of attachments, but that's it. You change aligners at home without visiting doctor.

>Many younger patients forget and lose their plastic aligners.

They can get a new one easily by post.

ivan_gammel··on Atlassian says it had right to fire engineer for suggesting CEO is 'rich jerk'
The “people who are critical of you” are very broad category that includes both toxic behavior and constructive disagreement. The former must not be tolerated, the latter can be encouraged as long as it’s not a blocker. In this case it is clearly the former and it requires suppression, but disciplinary action may have been too harsh or perfectly adequate depending on prior history with this employee. It was not said like “it was insensitive to appear in front of the team this way”. It was indeed said like he is a rich jerk. Zero added value, rage bait, polarization of the team.
ivan_gammel··on How Invisalign became the biggest user of 3D printers
LightForce still requires a lot of visits to the doctor. Nice source of revenue for orthos. Aligners may become more accessible to patients, because that tech is more scalable by design.
ivan_gammel··on How Invisalign became the biggest user of 3D printers
1. There‘s always a reason or two for the treatment. The problems with bite may affect your health in various ways. There’s aesthetic component in it, sometimes even cultural preferences for how your teeth should look like. But let’s say patient cannot afford to care about final position when signing up for the treatment. They just trust the doctor saying they need it. Failure mode: patient is unhappy with outcome and will ruin your business from marketing perspective.

2. Let‘s say the practice does it in old way, with impressions - no intraoral scanner. The scanner of impressions still needed, but it can be cheaper. Someone needs to build it and achieve required accuracy (let’s say, 50 μm). Who? Why? Failure mode: bad scan leads to aligners not fitting your teeth from day 1. Oops.

3. Let‘s say someone builds a good OSS alternative to OrthoCAD (Who? Why?), so that orthodontist on site could build a treatment plan and export it into series of 3D models for printers. Failure mode: good treatment plans are rarely possible or output is garbage (aligners do not fit, cause pain etc)

4. Maybe some company develops good plastic or patent expires, so that it is possible to produce it in India, China or other inexpensive location with strong industrial base. That would be cool, otherwise: non-compliant plastic breaks in patient’s mouth, decomposes with patient ingesting some toxic chemicals or is simply not strong enough to move teeth in desired position, so you have problem with 2nd aligner.

5. Maybe you get to this point, but you still need a printer that can maintain the same precision in printing. And you need a good cutting and finishing process. Someone needs to build such device. Failure modes are similar to the mentioned above.

6. The ortho supervision sounds easy, but how many patients in developing countries do even have a possibility to see orthodontist? They are definitely not in position to treat themselves.

So, in this process, what is good enough exactly? Who and why would drive the costs down while building an on-site solution?

ivan_gammel··on How Invisalign became the biggest user of 3D printers
IIRC, yes. It’s been some time ago, I don’t know how manufacturing looks now. It’s different process compared to 3D printing at home. It doesn’t mean it should be different, it just has to maintain certain properties. I’m not chemical or bioengineer to go into detail of it :)
ivan_gammel··on How Invisalign became the biggest user of 3D printers
It is definitely not that simple for a number of reasons. Yes, aligners and retainers in theory may be printed on some commercially available hardware. At your own risk, because you will be printing a medical device and you will need:

1. A treatment plan: simulated movement of teeth at every step, taking into account all forces. That’s specialized software or external lab service.

2. Precision. You put too much pressure at the wrong angle and you will need a surgery to fix the damage, because the tooth root moved in wrong direction.

3. Plastic. You cannot use ordinary 3D printer ink. You need a plastic that can survive the chemical environment in your mouth, maintain the pressure, and you probably want it to look good (no discoloration etc).

4. Finish: Align Tech, Straumann etc do not stop after 3D printing, there are few other steps involved to make sure there’s no sharp edges etc.

5. Maybe you will need attachments (to focus pressure in the right direction on certain teeth) or wires.

Align Tech is Apple of clear aligners, but now competition exists, producing aligners at scale is commercially more efficient, considering all the risks and required qualifications, and of course the best materials for aligners are patented and not sold OTC to everyone.

Disclosure: I worked at Align 10 years ago and later was CTO of European DTC competitor.

ivan_gammel··on Java is fast, code might not be
> What percentage of your inputs are invalid numbers and why ?

This is a wrong question to ask in this context. The right question to ask is when actually exceptional flow becomes a performance bottleneck. Because, obviously, in a desktop or even in a server app validating single user input even 99% of wrong inputs won’t cause any trouble. It may become a problem with bulk processing, but then, and I have to repeat myself here, it is no longer a number parsing problem, it’s a problem of not understanding what your input is.

ivan_gammel··on Java is fast, code might not be
It does not. If you need to parse a number, you use standard library and you will be fine. The described case with huge impact on hot path is the demonstration why using brains is important. The developer that will get into this mess is the one who will find the way to suffocate his code with performance bottlenecks in thousand other ways. It’s not a language or library problem.
ivan_gammel··on Java is fast, code might not be
Normally in 100% cases, with parseInt/parseDouble etc. Getting NumberFormatException so frequently on a hot path that it impacts performance means, that you aren’t solving the parsing number problem, you are solving a guessing type problem, which is out of scope for standard library and requires custom parser.
ivan_gammel··on Java is fast, code might not be
God, please make me unsee it. That‘s a cool trick that turns into an anti-pattern itself if abused.
ivan_gammel··on Java is fast, code might not be
TBH, I do not see how Java as a language steers anyone to use one those shotguns. E.g. the knowledge about algorithmic complexity is foundational, the StringBuilder is junior-level basic knowledge.
ivan_gammel··on Java is fast, code might not be
The answer is simple: model optimized for storage and model designed for processing are two different things. The languages used to describe and query them have to be different.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →