HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ivancdg

750 karma · joined August 31, 2010

http://ivancdg.com
submissionscomments
ivancdg··on Goldman Sachs and the $580 Million Black Hole
Funny, when I read your 3rd paragraph, that made me think of the danger of putting too much faith in doctors.

Doctors get really peeved at people who research online and self-diagnose. On the other hand no-one cares about your health as much as you do, and no-one has access to as much information about what the root causes of malady could be.

Although Christopher Hitchens hated the expression 'X is battling with cancer', the phrase implies a personal engagement (as opposed to delegating) which can indeed make all the difference in the world.

ivancdg··on There's no speed limit (2009)
It seems to me that one of the reasons CDBaby was/is so successful is because its primary customers are musicians, rather than consumers of music.

Strictly speaking CDBaby sells to both categories (it sells a service to musicians, and CDs to customers).

But to me, as a professional musician, it seems that people buy less music in product form now. Therefore the real customers for music-based products are...the musicians themselves.

There are more musicians than ever before. All are competing against one another. As a result, they are willing to spend their disposable income on promotions, marketing.

Providing a service like CDBaby's was a brilliant way of tapping into that emerging market.

What made it disruptive was: the price-point, the musician-friendly ethos, the dependability and speed of the customer service.

As a musician/entrepreneur, it seems to me that very few startups realize that they may be more successful asking musicians to pay for something than finding 'customers' for their 'products' in the old fashioned (read: recording industry) mold.

Of course spinning the story to sound musician friendly is delicate...and essential.

Do you see other opportunities for charging the growing contingent of musicians for a service that is worthwhile?

ivancdg··on EMI music is sold to Universal. We're down to three major labels.
The way I understand it, 'Muck Work' was meant to be a go-to place for people specialized in all the things musicians would like to outsource. To my knowledge, it never launched (Hey Derek: am I wrong?)

Regarding trust issues, that is an excellent point. It is ironic that you would like to help, but can't for lack of trust.

The easiest way to overcome that is to make small promises, then keep them/over-deliver.

Most people who try to help musicians have good intentions, but are not actually effective. They make promises, then fail to deliver, leading to disappontment for all.

My two cents: a person who would like to help should just identify an area in which they have real experience, and focus on that, insted of 'dabbling'.

For example, I have professional photographers, sound engineers, designers who essentially donate their time, or work at a huge discount, as a way of supporting my work. I find that VERY helpful.

As a counter-example, I've had people offer to help cold-call potential clients, but these people have no experience cold-calling, so it has been a big waste of time.

oDesk has been infinitely more helpful in a matter of months than any of the 4-5 people in 1st world countries that I've had try to help over the years (which led, in turn, to me being extremely cautious about help).

ivancdg··on EMI music is sold to Universal. We're down to three major labels.
One of the conclusions one could draw from your comment is that the wrong kind of people (professionals) have been the ones involved in developing musicians' careers. ie, lawyers, corporate marketing-type people, etc.

As a professional musician I think this is correct.

The biggest challenge that I face is in my career (besides the creative challenges of creating compelling music) is this: there are very few smart, talented people who have an initiative to help me develop my career AND the skills to do so.

My current annual income is X, derived primarily from concerts.

If I had the right people helping me this could easily become 6X, and I would gladly pay my team of part-time helpers a substantial percentage of equity to make it happen (rather do more than less, bigger pie to split).

But chances are the people with the talent to make that happen would rather do other things that will:

- make more money - will be more fulfilling than, say, cold calling venues or other less-than-edifying things that, ultimately, make or break a career.

When I read about the idea Derek Sivers had to get people to specialize in 'Muck-Work' I got really excited.

If someone created an oDesk for musician's specialized helpers that were good at a myriad of very limited, but important tasks, they could make a pile of money.

It's easier said than done. I think Derek realized this and that's why we're still waiting for Muck Work to launch...

ivancdg··on Release day economics
No question that this is true.

And there are a lot of people making a lot of money on selling 'self-marketing opportunities' to independent musicians.

But to compare that industry ('huge'?), in terms of revenue, to what the majors did in their hey-day is an exaggeration.

The model of selling services to indie musicians has not yet surpassed the model of selling music to customers.

But perhaps that's where we're headed? That's a depressing thought.

ivancdg··on Release day economics
It's a fantastic time to be an entrepreneurial, forward-thinking, business-oriented musician.

But that is a fairly small subset of people with the talent set necessary to stand out musically.

The security of the previous set-up is gone but the opportunities are endless.

Does this sound familiar yet?

A generation ago many of the people reading this would be lifers for HP, IBM...now look what you're doing instead?

OK, so you're lifers for Google and Facebook.

You get the point, though.

ivancdg··on Release day economics
All of this is true.

However, the implication that an outsider might draw from your comment is that, say, the band that wrote the original post might hope to make those kinds of royalties since they (presumably?) wrote the melody and lyrics to the original song.

If they sign to a major label and have a hit that continues to rake in those royalties, that is wonderful. If one of their songs is used in a big Hollywood film, and for covers, etc, great.

But that's a lot of ifs. Even non musicians know the truth now, they've all read "Courtney Love Does the Math" on Salon.

The reality of most musicians, even those signed to major labels, is far from a rosy economic picture. It seems to me that to imply otherwise is disingenuous.

Didn't mean for that last part to sound like an attack, it's just that reading your (very well written) comment does not solve the problem of the musicians who wrote the original post.

ivancdg··on Release day economics
The Earbits guys (frighteningly prolific bloggers) wrote about Spotify recently:

http://blog.earbits.com/online_radio/spotify-replaces-piracy...

"The service may do a good job fighting illegal file sharing but it also does a great job of eliminating any motivation to buy an album that you can listen to through the service."

In Europe Spotify's been available for a while. I was in on the beta when their catalog was a lot more restricted, and it was already impressive. With the majors on board, it's hard to see the freight train stopping.

How can one reconcile how wonderful it is for consumers with the payment statements that make us musicians cringe? I think of it as all-you-can-eat iTunes for very little per month; the recent competitors/alternatives pale in comparison.

They deserve a lot of credit for building a workable model that makes iTunes look like a rip off (I hate that software).

But they further dilute the value of recorded music, which is a huge paradigm change for the music industry that will ruin the viability of many musicians.

Perhaps we can re-educate the public to value music again by taking a pledge to pay for it, à la pg-patents? Something tells me this new, 'recorded music ~ free' paradigm is here to stay.

ivancdg··on Release day economics
He probably did it in France; it is much more expensive here to do stuff like that than in, say, the UK or Germany.

They're way behind the US in terms of competitive pricing for factory-produced goods.

I ordered promo CDs pressed in California in 2009.

They were pressed in Taiwan with Japanese machines.

I received them 6 days later in Mountain View...at half the price of France, great quality. Incredible.

ivancdg··on Release day economics
Spotify is such a rip-off for musicians; I love the way these guys highlighted that in a light-hearted way. But the economics of the alternatives are not going to make anyone rich, either.

For future reference: if you sign-up via CDBaby, there is a one-time fee of $35 (or $55 if they create your bar-code) and you are set-up with iTunes, Amazon, etc, without a yearly fee. Even though Derek's gone it's still a good deal.

Also, you should seriously consider contacting Magnatune. If they like your music you can be on all of those platforms for free. And John Buckman is a very nice guy. Et en plus il parle le français comme toi et moi.

ivancdg··on How to sell: tips from a marketing guy who can actually sell something
This was a witty comment (the end made me chuckle)...but flippant.

Ultimately it is not very helpful: it does not address the content of the original article, which is excellent.

It is easy to fall into the trap of being so skeptical of sales writing as to automatically discount it. We see a lot of that here on HN which I find to be an unfortunate knee-jerk reaction.

Sales is a skill. During a layover I bought a book on the 'business' shelf of a UK airport. The book had tons of the warning signs of #2 above. I was extremely skeptical. It was called 'Selling to Win' by Richard Denny. It had the cheesiest cover you can imagine (think citrus green with pink).

But the things I learned in that book allowed me to get to 'ramen profitability' in my field. I was ahead of the crowd 6 months later, largely thanks to the techniques in that book.

Had I dismissed the book, I'd still be making fun of the cover and complaining about not having enough work.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2