HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ivoflipse

4,335 karma · joined December 7, 2010

submissionscomments
ivoflipse··on Project Andiamo
I have been involved with a similar project focused on making orthotics and ankle-foot orthosis (http://www.afootprint.eu/) and I think the idea is definitely feasible.

However, there are some problems that need to be solved for this to go mainstream: - Either affordable 3D scanners with sufficient accuracy or better algorithms can make this happen with something like LeapMotion/Kinect in order to get the required 3D scan - Open source modeling software, which I believe is already available. But you'd still need some finite element modeling to determine the shape of the brace. - Affordable 3D printers with a sufficiently large work envelope to fit a brace that fits a human torso. A major downside is that the torso is so voluminous, which means it might not be able to fit multiple braces at the same time, which kills productivity. Making it modular would obviously help solve this problem, but then you require assembly afterwards and a new design that allows this. - Affordable printing material, because you're not going to make this thing out of ABS. Some of the 3D printed material also has the property of being brittle, which you wouldn't want in a brace. But I'm by no means a material expert. - Convincing orthopedic professionals to give up their old way of working and embracing your technique. This might be the hardest of all, if only because there are so many factors involved. Is your method affordable enough, is it fast enough, is it reliable, how much re-schooling is required to able to use this technique?

Regardless of all these points I still think it should be done, because prices will go down, we'll get cheaper and better materials and eventually it'll be nonsensical to do all this work by hand. So we better get started and be ready when all the pieces fall into place.

ivoflipse··on Amateurs beat specialists in data-prediction competitions
My bad, I used the Hacker News submit bookmarklet, which probably picked out a quote, rather than the title of the article. I probably should have paid more attention. But now its been too long for me to edit it
ivoflipse··on Double amputee cleared to race in the Olympics
How convenient for Oscar then that his both calf muscles are made out of carbon and don't fatigue. On top of that his low leg is significantly lighter than non-amputees, though whether this is a curse or a blessing is arguable.

Oscars main 'advantage' over fellow amputees that he grew up wearing prosthetics and had the funds to get ones that are good enough to train on. I can't imagine a Jamaican bilateral amputee being in the same situation.

The problem is that at the moment he's a one of a kind, which makes comparisons pretty much useless. Regardless of it all, his achievements are impressive and he's an example for a lot amputees.

Edit: Here's a link to a literature review I wrote about him 4 years ago. Note that it may be a draft version! https://docs.google.com/open?id=0B1W3cjBV_DpNajQyUWVJdEtwYkk

ivoflipse··on Google & Stanford create a digital brain that learns to identify a human face
Nope, but who knows if they'll do a follow up on ML-class.

But Yann LeCun posted this [1] as a response to Andrew Ng linking to his article on Google+. Basically its a summer school about Deep Learning taught by Andrew Ng, Yann LeCun and Geoff Hinton (and others). The video's should end up online.

[1]: https://plus.google.com/104362980539466846301/posts/hhMJsPQy...

ivoflipse··on Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation?
Its the same on most sites, my rep has stalled mostly after becoming a moderator on Super User and its the same for most of the others there.

However, it doesn't mean that the sites stop being useful, I read a lot of questions, but rarely feel the need to ask a new one.

ivoflipse··on The Greatest Running Shoe Never Sold
Sure there's a market for more expensive shoes. Just look at orthopedic shoes, they easily cost 1000$ dollars and in some cases are just slightly modified retail shoes (albeit not very trendy).

If you want to be all 37Signals and sell only 50 pairs of shoes per year and make a decent living: fine. But scaling that process up to anything of significance will cost you a lot more money and (typically) isn't done in your garage.

But still, I do hope he can find a partner who will help him get his product to market. It wouldn't be the first time that a good functional shoe got cancelled, because it wasn't trendy enough for a mass market appeal.

Let's just hope that within 10 years from now, we'll be able to 3D print most of the parts for his shoe at an affordable price. Which would go along way of making the process more accessible.

ivoflipse··on The Greatest Running Shoe Never Sold
Unless you have a (Chinese) factory with EVA molds and some women who stitch the shoe together in your garage, I don't see anyone 'just doing it'.

Even if you start producing your own shoes in China, wait until the first two containers come back with your initial 1000 pair of shoes all having some error that renders them useless.

Sure, you can get quality assurances in place, but you can't go and sell running shoes for twice the price of Nike or Adidas.

It takes some amount of scale to simply make this happen. So he's waiting for an investor to cover the large sums of money required to get a shoe to the market (let alone market the shoe itself).

ivoflipse··on New Stanford course - Anatomy
To apply anatomy to a human body, you must first know what to look for and how to describe it. So I imagine they'll be spending some time on getting the Latin terms down, which help reduce the ambiguity.

Example: how do you describe the direction your thumb is pointing in? In anatomy they base it on the bones in your forearm, rather than saying 'outwards', because if you rotate your hand its no longer valid.

As for the testing: there are so many bones, muscles, nerves and organs in the body that it will take more than 10 weeks to cover them all in detail. Besides, knowing the name is one thing, knowing the function another.

A sample question I got in college: What are the effects of a unilateral paralysis of the femoral nerve? Ten points of karma if you get it right.

ivoflipse··on Google.com detecting malware and notifying search users
Google's Help page lets their users Google for 'antivirus', because they don't want to endorse any product. Now they have to warn users which AV not to install as well, because their own results might show up harmful programs...

Then they assume their users, who managed to get infected in the first place, are computer literate enough to know how to install it and know what a systemscan is.

I admire that Google is trying to help their users help themselves, but I seriously doubt a lot of users will be able to solve the problem based on these steps...

ivoflipse··on Warren Buffett: I could end the deficit in 5 minutes.
Ironically the congress 'takes one for the team', while the companies that supply the army gain profit over the backs of everyone's tax money.

If everyone truly took one for the team, wars wouldn't have to be as expensive, because everyone would be fighting for their survival.

While its important to win a war, should it be won at any cost and who should pay the price?

ivoflipse··on Netflix Is Killing BitTorrent in The US
Perhaps the studios should consider letting it expand to Europe as well...
ivoflipse··on How was the capacity of the 'magical Chinese harddisk' faked?
I guess the answer on Super User is a nice summary of the whole discussion here on Hacker News ;-)

Does your head start to hurt even more after seeing me comment here as well? ;-)

ivoflipse··on Don't tell StackOverflow I'm a hacker (they think I'm a bot)
It's bi-monthly nowadays. Even so, you can use the API instead, its there for a reason.

Its too bad for this guy that he simply can't access SO the normal way, but that's not SO's fault

ivoflipse··on Wozniak: Innovative projects, not tests, should determine a student's grade
This fits in somewhat with the earlier discussion about Scott Adams on How to get real education (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2426459).

Instead of learning students "to remember what art looked like just in case anyone asked", they should learn skills that requires them to acquire knowledge.

Sure a lot of education 'fakes' this by focusing on projects, but what useful skills can you honestly acquire in 10 weeks when your attention has to be divided over just as many courses?

ivoflipse··on Larry Page's first blunder
Actually his suggestion at the end of grouping all the different features together on one cohesive page would be an improvement over being spread out over all the separate products.

But whether the decision is a blunder remains to be seen... We'll see in a couple of months if its for better or worse.

ivoflipse··on How will 3D printing affect the chinese economy?
They will always be able to do things cheaper. Because their manpower is cheaper, they will buy and sell stuff in larger quantities and produce it with their own materials (which is at the moment the costly part).

For now, unless you have a Makerbot and want ABS lego, consumers simply can't afford 3D printing their toys with commercial 3D printers. It's just like with regular printers: the ink is more expensive than the printer itself!

However, that's not to say that it will always remain that way and I can't wait for that day to come!

ivoflipse··on The State of Version Control: an Infographic
You also forget that Kiln has it's own dedicated Stack Exchange site. http://kiln.stackexchange.com/

This one has 1300+ questions!

ivoflipse··on Quora vs. StackExchange: Why, Joel, Why?
So you base that Stack Exchange has failed on one out of the two failed sites, out of over forty proposals that are still there?

As has already been mentioned elsewhere, if the site lacks genuine expertise of the topic, the blind will simply follow the other blind. Putting a site that doesn't work out of it's misery is doing the users a favor in the long run

ivoflipse··on A Stack Overflow user's reply to Experts Exchange blogpost
That's where we have Meta.SO for @Tyrannosaurs:

http://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/79435/130099

ivoflipse··on Python - How to sort my paws?
Actually, it's normally used for humans, to analyze their gait so you can prescribe things like insoles or shoes.

However, I don't think you want to go buy an expensive measuring device just for your dog ;-)

← PreviousPage 3 of 3