HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ivraatiems

8,956 karma · joined March 13, 2013

submissionscomments
ivraatiems··on Ask HN: How is AI-assisted coding going for you professionally?
> Research. It has been extraordinarily helpful in giving me insight into how to design some larger systems when I have extremely specific requirements but don't necessarily have the complete experience to architect them myself - I know enough to understand if the system is going to correctly accomplish the requirements, but not to have necessarily come up with architecture as a whole.

I agree, this is where coding agents really shine for me. Even if they get the details wrong, they often pinpoint where things happen and how quite well.

They're also great for rapid debugging, or assisted bug fixing. Often, I will manually debug a problem, then tell the AI, "This exception occurs in place Y because thing X is happening, here's a stack trace, propose a fix", and then it will do the work of figuring out where to put the fix for me. I already usually know WHAT to do, it's just a matter of WHERE in context. Saves a lot of time.

Likewise, if I have something where I want thing X to do Y, and X already does Z, then I'll say, "Implement a Y that works like Z but for A B C", and it'll usually get it really close on the first try.

ivraatiems··on Coding after coders: The end of computer programming as we know it?
I always find these "death of the X" articles frustrating.

Books didn't stop existing when the radio came out. Radio didn't stop existing when television was invented. If you go back in time a thousand years, people were complaining that an increase in literacy would damaging peoples' memorization skills.

People will still write code for consumption by other humans by hand. Some companies, though probably not most, will still prefer it. AI will change the industry - IS changing the industry - but things don't "end". They just look different, or are less popular.

There is enough for us to worry about and try to figure out how to respond to without the histrionics.

Also, on a related note, "Idiots are vibecoding bad stuff" is not the same as "engineers are using AI tools to do good work more quickly," and we should stop conflating it.

ivraatiems··on Our Experience with I-Ready
I remember that when I was in school, teachers hated my ever-present netbook laptop and the disinterest I had in their classes. Which were already repetitious and not very exciting to me.

To see it half reversed now - every student must have a laptop and use it, not listen to the teacher - and yet somehow be so much worse is really sad.

For me, the computer was a portal to worlds and experiences and time spent doing things school had no way of offering me. For a kid to grow up hating their laptop because this is what it offers them, when we have so many incredible things sitting just out of their reach, is infuriating.

I'd really like to know how and why the school hasn't responded to the parents' complaints, if they're so frequent and unanimous. Maybe they're locked into a contract?

On the other hand, a while ago I was picking up takeout at a restaurant and a little girl, the daughter of one of the owners, was doing homework and it turned out to be a simple JavaScript-like programming assignment. I helped her learn how to write a for loop to make a fox jump over some obstacles. It was fun! It's not all bad.

ivraatiems··on Science Fiction Is Dying. Long Live Post Sci-Fi?
> If it's not dark and edgy, it's not profound.

I think this is exactly it, and it's frustrating, because some of the most profound works of science fiction are things like Star Trek, which are idealistic and hopeful. They still raise questions about humanity and morality and philosophy that are deeply interesting and worth engaging with.

ivraatiems··on Science Fiction Is Dying. Long Live Post Sci-Fi?
I'd really enjoy a return to classic space opera. I think a world where technologies like AI actually work out okay to some extent is a) closer to fiction than the alternative, and b) more interesting than another dystopia.

I'd enjoy a swashbuckling noblebright adventures-in-space thing way more than yet another treatise on Technology Bad right about now.

That said, I don't know that I think sci-fi as a genre is dying per se. There are a lot of really prominent and popular science fiction pieces coming out today. Shows/books like Black Mirror and The Expanse, for example.

ivraatiems··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_strikes_on_Irani...
ivraatiems··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
> In this situation it is a fair request by the US to sign a nuclear deal that heavily restricts Iran's ability to enrich, and as Iran due to ideological reasons refused, and IMO miscalculated this will be a win-win, as losing will quell the protests, the only thing really left is the metaphorical stick

Didn't we have one of those a few years ago? I wonder what happened to it /s

Seriously, though: how can Iran both be so powerful we must avoid it becoming a blackmail state, and so weak and feckless it's not a threat to anyone?

And didn't we already attack them to stop them from getting nuclear capabilities?

ivraatiems··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
If we attacked every country in the world killing thousands of its own people we'd be at war with half the world right now.
ivraatiems··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
I was discussing this with a friend today. It just feels like there's no point to these actions.

Not in the sense of "I don't ideologically agree with our decision to do this," but in the sense of, "I do not see how this accomplishes any ideological or practical goal."

What are they trying for? Regime change in Iran? No more Iranian nuclear program? There barely was one before. Keeping Israel safe? It's been an open secret for years that Iran is not a real threat to Israel, because any action it took against Israel would be existential for Iran and its leadership.

A US president who vocally and repeatedly promised he would not start new conflicts keeps starting them, and there's not even a reason. It's infuriating. I have my partisan opinions, but that should not be a partisan statement! It's just disturbing!

ivraatiems··on An AI agent coding skeptic tries AI agent coding, in excessive detail
This investigation aligns with my experience in a lot of ways. I'm con-the influence and behavior big AI companies, but lukewarm-to-pro the actual use of the technology itself.

I use Claude and other models frequently (mostly via Cursor, with a smattering of other tools) in my work now. It is not at the "I never write code myself" point, but the AI tools are absolutely capable of generating highly effective and usable code, usually nearly as good or as good as what I'd do myself, with guidance.

It hasn't eliminated the need for my existence as an engineer, but it has changed it drastically. It is much more like "tell the computer what I want and mostly get it" than it was a year ago.

And yet, I have friends and colleagues who reject it out of hand as useless, and are so skeptical of it that they suggest it must only be good because my skills are poor, or our codebase is bad, or I'm getting lucky.

I just can't totally credit any of those explanations anymore.

ivraatiems··on Red Robin Died by Spreadsheet. Don't Make the Same Mistake
This article has literally nothing to do with "The AI Age" but keeps saying it over and over, why? For marketing purposes? It's weird.

Human CEO made bad decision. Human CEO at another company made good decision. Neither decision had anything whatsoever to do with AI.

Perhaps the author is worried nothing he has to say is interesting without buzzwords.

ivraatiems··on Privilege is bad grammar
Informality and bad grammar but otherwise sound decision making is fine, I think everyone's arguments for it here make sense.

But let's not pretend that, at least in the US, that's what it's limited to. Our current and immediate past president are both elderly men with potentially compromised mental states who regularly say crazy nonsense stuff.

Try watching this (https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=455169079910588) or this (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ZsdlULgqvA) and then watch the literal crowds of people who are saying "you just don't understand! You're not parsing it right! You're not paying enough attention to their genius!"

It's wild that we make excuses like this for people. One has to ask where the line is.

This almost certainly happens in business, too - it's just not as obvious because those folks don't have to constantly do it in public.

ivraatiems··on 221 Cannon is Not For Sale
First of all, like you say, those registries can have an LLC's name or the name of a trust, etc. It may not be my name. But some rando showing up doesn't know me, they want to occupy my house.

Second, those registries are much harder to find me in than a random Facebook Marketplace ad.

Third, those registries do not advertise that I am trying to sell my property or rent it out; there is no invitation to come to my home and approach me. I have literally had people show up at my door asking why I'm there if my house is for rent. Imagine if one of those people - as is common on Facebook Marketplace - was unhinged or dangerous, or got mad when I told them the truth.

It is a direct threat to my safety in a way that the mere record of my ownership of the property wouldn't be (if it had my name on it).

ivraatiems··on 221 Cannon is Not For Sale
This is good advice and probably an avenue I need to explore, thank you.
ivraatiems··on 221 Cannon is Not For Sale
I have had people show up at my house to ask if it was for rent, based on a fake post on Facebook using photos from Zillow from before my home was sold.

My realtor helped me get the photos taken down, but the Facebook ads for it are up to this day. Facebook completely ignores any and all attempts by me to report this malfeasance -- even though these ads literally have my personal home address on them!

It's a huge safety risk to me and not due to anything I did whatsoever; all I did was buy a house that was on the market and then move into it. It's a nightmare.

ivraatiems··on Xfce is great
XFCE and LXDE are saviors for old machines. I frequently install Xubuntu and Lubuntu on old Chromebooks (e. g. HP Chromebook 14 from around 10 years ago, 2GB RAM, Celeron processor), and you can quickly get a fully functional, usable system. I'm not writing code on them, but you can easily use them for all the things the average person needs on a daily basis from their computer.

It's great that these projects have not given into "the times" or tried to become things they're not. They're great at what they do and I hope they remain that way.

ivraatiems··on Employee commits suicide after MongoDB fired her during mental health leave
(For anyone looking now, the case has been removed to federal court for the moment. Caption "Surman, by and through the Administrators of her Estate, Gregory Surman and Karen Connolly et al v. MONGODB, INC.", 2026cv00166 in SDNY.)
ivraatiems··on LLVM AI tool policy: human in the loop
For what it's worth, this is essentially the policy my current and most recent previous workplace followed. (My employers before that were pre-LLMs.)

If you are the one with your name on the PR, it's your code and you have to understand it. If you don't understand it at least well enough to speak intelligently about it, you aren't ready to submit it for review. If you ask Copilot, Cursor, or whatever to generate a PR for you, it still must be reviewed and approved by you and another engineer who acts as your reviewer.

I haven't heard a lot of pushback on this; it feels like common sense to me. It's effectively the same rules we'd use if somebody who wasn't an engineer wanted to submit code; they'd need to go through an engineer to do it.

LLM usage has increased our throughput and the quality of our code thus far, but without these rules (and people following the spirit of them, being bought in to their importance), I really don't think it would.

I encourage you to raise this policy with your management, if you think you can get them to listen, and demonstrate how it might help. I would be very frustrated if my colleagues were submitting AI-generated code without thinking it through.

ivraatiems··on Employee commits suicide after MongoDB fired her during mental health leave
Thank you for finding this, really helpful. I checked PACER and didn't realize it was filed in state court instead.

The complaint is speaking and it is aggressively written and, to my non-lawyer mind, pretty well drafted. If I were Mongo, I would be trying aggressively to settle this and make it go away.

If I were the parents, I would be trying very hard to force any other outcome, preferably one where Mongo pays the biggest public relations price possible for what they've done, assuming the allegations are true.

The way Mongo answers the complaint will be really instructive in figuring out how they intend to play this, and in whether they think there is some explanation that will make this seem less dire.

ivraatiems··on North Korean infiltrator caught at Amazon due to 110ms keystroke lag
The Arizona woman the article refers to was sentenced to 102 months in prison for her role in this scheme: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/arizona-woman-sentenced-17m-i...

Pretty fascinating stuff.

ivraatiems··on Executive order to reclassify marijuana as soon as Monday
I support this, but I am not sure if it can be done via executive order? (Not that that has stopped any recent president from doing whatever they like via EO.)

It looks like, maybe yes? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Removal_of_cannabis_from_Sched...

but it could and probably will be challenged.

Still, it would be a good move and has been needed for a while now.

ivraatiems··on The realities of being a pop star
There is a weird assumption people make that somebody as successful as Charli XCX isn't smart because her persona is "I like cocaine and partying," and then are surprised when she can express herself like this. Like she says: "Another thing about being a pop star is that you cannot avoid the fact that some people are simply determined to prove that you are stupid."

Making music at any professional level is extremely hard work. Touring and dancing and hosting shows is even harder. It requires a substantial intellectual capacity and stamina to achieve. You either have these things yourself, or you are propped up entirely by others who have them and are invested in you for money's sake. Given Charli XCX's background, it's not actually surprising that she, in fact, has all the talent, skill, and intellect required to do this stuff herself.

Editing to add: Another place to look to learn that people with this skillset often have very very deep inner lives is Dua Lipa's book club podcast (https://www.service95.com/tag/book-club). As someone who used to run these kinds of in-depth interviews, I can say, she is damn good at it.

ivraatiems··on Show HN: My hobby OS that runs Minecraft
Excellent work.

Now all we need to do is run your OS on a redstone virtual machine inside of Minecraft, then run Minecraft on it. That way you'll have Minecraft inside your Minecraft.

ivraatiems··on How long can it take to become a US citizen?
You ignored the things I was actually trying to ask you about and instead focused on a point where I specifically called out that we wouldn't agree - a point I specifically conceded for the purpose of this discussion because I didn't think arguing it was productive.

When you say:

> You'd never accept the immigration system we had back when Fazlur Kahn came here, because you believe in magic soil. If we implemented such a system, immigration proponents would immediately shift their focus to eliminating any bargained-for restrictions, which is exactly what they've been doing since 1965.

I am not talking about what I'd accept. I'm asking why you aren't advocating for it as something you would accept. The critical point is:

> the people in control of policy on this issue, frankly, are people who are so bald-facedly hypernationalist that they see "Bangladeshi" and think "not American," and stop there. They do not care to implement a system that would work better. They don't want a system at all.

> If you think societies aren't a monolith, whether they can change or not, then allowing movement between societies to help people find ones they fit into better is a good thing. If you think the US is better off with you in it, then "just reject everyone from country/culture X" is not the right approach. That is not the position current immigration policy espouses. My original point was that the US immigration system is designed to make it impossible to immigrate legally. Not just difficult or subject to scrutiny - effectively impossible.

> Is that what you want, given your beliefs?

You may say that you don't actually think "people from culture X are not worth bringing to the US," but given the above, that is what you are functionally advocating for. You are advocating that the ladder be pulled up behind you, and me, and everyone else in this country who is successful as the child of immigrants.

If you think that an immigration system that isn't just "disallow all foreign immigrants" is worth fighting for, even if the system you want at the end isn't the one I want, you should be fighting for it instead of arguing it's OK we don't have it.

ivraatiems··on Show HN: A game where you invest into startups from history
This is a genuinely great use of LLMs/related technology. Dynamic characters you can have conversations with to make game choices more informed is a really cool idea, actually feels original and clever. I really enjoyed playing it.
ivraatiems··on Larry Summers resigns from OpenAI board
I think you missed the sarcasm in the original post ;)
ivraatiems··on How long can it take to become a US citizen?
Not to pile on, but I think part of the issue is that the GP's argument has cause and effect reversed. He believes Bangladesh is poor and unpleasant in various ways because of their culture, while in fact it runs the other way. Culture is in many ways downstream of economics, not upstream.

Of course it's more complex than that in total, and it can go both ways, but that's my view.

ivraatiems··on How long can it take to become a US citizen?
> Correct, but so what? I think it's important to be objective and detached. It would be intellectually dishonest of me to color my thinking by trying to come to conclusions that would validate my own presence in the country.

But you and your family are by your own metrics evidence that your line of thinking - "people from culture X are not worth bringing to the US" - is false.

> Societies aren't monoliths. Even Bangladesh has people like my dad, who arrive everywhere early, are horrified by corruption, and love waiting in line. But immigration isn't about individuals, it's about populations in the aggregate. And the evidence shows that populations have identifiable cultural averages that are durable over generations.

If you believe the first sentence, the second sentence doesn't follow. Isn't the whole point of immigration laws to construct systems by which people whose traits are desirable are allowed to immigrate?

If your dad exists in Bangladesh, surely he's not the only one. If Bangladesh, with ~170 million people, has 500,000 of your dad (or whatever), surely it's to our benefit as a society to get as many of them as possible here?

But the people in control of policy on this issue, frankly, are people who are so bald-facedly hypernationalist that they see "Bangladeshi" and think "not American," and stop there. They do not care to implement a system that would work better. They don't want a system at all.

If you think societies aren't a monolith, whether they can change or not, then allowing movement between societies to help people find ones they fit into better is a good thing. If you think the US is better off with you in it, then "just reject everyone from country/culture X" is not the right approach. That is not the position current immigration policy espouses. My original point was that the US immigration system is designed to make it impossible to immigrate legally. Not just difficult or subject to scrutiny - effectively impossible.

Is that what you want, given your beliefs?

(To be clear, I still hold to my original point which is that I think your fundamental view of peoples and cultures is misguided and wrong, but we're not going to agree on that, so I don't see a point in arguing it. If it were up to me the system would be very very different, but as others have pointed out, it isn't currently up to me.)

ivraatiems··on How long can it take to become a US citizen?
This is exactly the kind of logic that makes massive abuses of power possible. "Criminals" in this case is an arbitrarily defined category used capriciously by an uncaring and authoritarian government.

You could be a "criminal" tomorrow, if you look at the administration wrong.

ivraatiems··on How long can it take to become a US citizen?
I ended up replying a little further up in the thread to a related point you made, but to sort of restate:

Have you considered that under your own rubric, you're "bad for america" because you're from a "bad" culture? It sounds like by your rules you shouldn't have been allowed to come.

You say you don't view yourself as an exception, but clearly you are, so why are you special? If people like you and your dad can come from cultures like the one you left, how is it that culture is stagnant and unchanging as you say?

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →