HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jacoblyles

8,837 karma · joined January 29, 2009

bitcoin address: 1EMrE4tP9rs83R2TekkMudJK2MmTuiyer2

http://www.jacoblyles.com/

email me: jacob.lyles@gmail.com

twitter me: @jacoblyles

blog me: http://jacobexmachina.blogspot.com

submissionscomments
jacoblyles··on What happened to innovation?
It seems unnecessary to belabor a common point while trying to make a counter-intuitive one.
jacoblyles··on What happened to innovation?
Capitalism tends to monopolies? This is not true at all in the common case. Have you read "The Innovator's Dilemma"?

Highly regulated industries, industries with network effects, or industries that require very rare natural resources (diamond mines) are exceptions. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly

jacoblyles··on What happened to innovation?
It's weird that a few people are challenging short-term thinking, and they're all friends with each other (Thiel, Musk).

Also, it's weird how short-term thinking has infected the government. Nobody's forcing them to meet a quarterly P&L, you'd figure that would give them more freedom.

jacoblyles··on Edward Snowden: Saving Us from the United Stasi of America
It was actually a very close ruling (5-4) that hinged on whether "regulating interstate commerce" gave the power to the government to compel people to participate in commerce.

Personally, I disagree with the Wickard v. Filburn ruling that gave the power to the government to control what a farmer grows on his own land to feed to his own cattle under the "interstate commerce" power. The Constitution was distorted beyond any reasonable reading of the English language during the FDR administration and we never recovered.

The Republic is dead, FDR killed it. It's just taken us awhile to get used to living in a totalitarian state. Well, here we are.

jacoblyles··on Edward Snowden: Saving Us from the United Stasi of America
Part of the NSA's surveillance program was already found to be illegal and the executive branch classified the court's ruling:

http://blog.rongarret.info/2013/06/court-finds-nsa-surveilla...

How screwed up is that?

jacoblyles··on Former NSA Employees Praise Edward Snowden, Corroborate Key Claims
It's time for a "Tea Party" of the left to take down pro-surveillance Democrats in the primaries.
jacoblyles··on Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment
I don't see how freedom can last in a country for long with secret laws.
jacoblyles··on Brazil protests spread in Sao Paulo, Brasilia and Rio
Is there any good example of a modern country transitioning from a high-corruption country to a low-corruption country?

Call me cynical, but I haven't seen a mass protest movement do a whole lot of good lately. The arab spring seems to have provided an opening for a lot of radical Islamic movements and hasn't improved the quality of life for anybody. Egyptians are suffering economically.

The Brave New Day never comes

jacoblyles··on The Snowden Principle
Because people in history were different from us, we can learn nothing from them? This is one of the most anti-intellectual non-sequiturs I regularly see, and it makes me sad and fearful for our democracy.
jacoblyles··on How Cults Seduce and What Marketing Can Learn From Them [pdf]
As an ex-Jehovah's Witness, I agree this article gets a lot of things wrong. But they also are a crazy cult. I suggest the book "Crisis of Conscience" from an ex-governing body member if you're interested in JW's seedy history[1]. They started as a numerology-obsessed doomsday cult and evolved from there - the last time JWs sold off their possessions in anticipation of the end of the world was 1974, but it wasn't the first time. Today things aren't quite as bad, but they're still bad:

1) I wasn't allowed to have non-Jehovah's Witness friends or participate in after-school activities

2) Higher education was discouraged (I understood that it had been prohibited in earlier years, but they liberalized with the times). The idea is that you should spend your life serving the lord and not seeking material gain.

3) Reading non-Jehovah's Witness books on religious topics is prohibited. Some of the Church Services ("meetings") consist of reading verbatim word-for-word material handed down from the central organization ("the society"). Sermons ("talks") are written by cobbling together recent material put out by the society.

4) They practice shunning of ex-members (JWs will not talk to an ex-JW. I have no friends from childhood that will speak to me)

5) They do require a huge time commitment - door-to-door ("field service") at least once a week and three meetings per week.

6) They believe all other religions are products of the devil, sent to deceive mankind. Theirs is the only correct one.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/CRISIS-OF-CONSCIENCE-Raymond-Edition/d...

jacoblyles··on NSA admits listening to U.S. phone calls without warrants
I hated most literature when I was 18, then magically fell in love with the same novels I hated when I was 24. Still, there is more nuance I can pick up now at 30 with more study of history. If you haven't read the Iliad and a majority of the Bible, then you simply can't understand most of Western literature and those things take time.

It's interesting to see that this is a universal experience. School gave me literature before I was able to appreciate it, and it nearly turned me off to the taste.

jacoblyles··on Civil Liberties Groups Are Suing the NSA
I'll just leave this here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5862676

jacoblyles··on Live on C-SPAN now: NSA Chief Testifies at Cybersecurity Hearing
I think what Snowden did is a great thing, but it probably isn't great from the NSA's perspective. The NSA probably wants smart people who can do what they're told and keep their mouths shut.
jacoblyles··on Live on C-SPAN now: NSA Chief Testifies at Cybersecurity Hearing
It may be true that people without traditional education credentials are likely to be less conformist/more likely to cause trouble.
jacoblyles··on Before Prosecuting, Investigate the Government
You live in a Democratic country. Is it any surprise that the majority of educated people are committed true-believers in the Democratic process, despite all evidence that it may be broken?
jacoblyles··on Before Prosecuting, Investigate the Government
The American people would never stand for a dictator in name. But they would stand for powerful permanent bureaucrats that no elected official had the ability to push around.

6 of one, half-dozen of the other.

jacoblyles··on Before Prosecuting, Investigate the Government
Are you going to get the President's party to support the impeachment of his elected officials?

USGov is broken.

jacoblyles··on Civil Liberties Groups Are Suing the NSA
If we were writing a Constitution nowadays, I would certainly support explicit protections for the right to privacy in all forms of communication and the right to use encryption technology. The principles of the Constitution are very good but the language is too outdated to withstand the concerted effort of cynical men seeking to expand their power.

Of course, I also support the right to bear arms. We need new protections from our government. Now is not the time to be wolves, not little lost sheep in search of a protector.

jacoblyles··on Civil Liberties Groups Are Suing the NSA
Now what will you do when the Supreme Court finds the NSA's programs to be unconstitutional and they keep doing it anyway?
jacoblyles··on Court found NSA surveillance unconstitutional in 2011
Enough people can stomach them in their districts to elect them.

Progressives would turn a lot of stomachs off the blue coastal areas. This site has an overrepresentation from California and Europe, which skews our perception.

jacoblyles··on Senator Biden On NSA Database (2006) [video]
You must not know a lot of Tea Partiers. Though to be fair, they are more "right-wing revolutionaries" than "conservatives" by any reasonable sense of the word.
jacoblyles··on Russia may deem civil servants’ use of Gmail, Facebook ‘high treason’
peer to peer DNS is possible (see: namecoin)
jacoblyles··on Russia may deem civil servants’ use of Gmail, Facebook ‘high treason’
To be fair, most of Eastern Europe was under the Soviet boot in my lifetime, and I'm only 30. I'm sure Eastern European residents are happy that their American allies are not letting their guard down re:Russia.

Just because one side of a conflict starts to do something bad does not make the other side the good guys!

jacoblyles··on Senator Biden On NSA Database (2006) [video]
Isn't partisan politics a wondrous thing?
jacoblyles··on Court found NSA surveillance unconstitutional in 2011
The Pauls, and other reps supported by Campaign for Liberty (Justin Amash).
jacoblyles··on Court found NSA surveillance unconstitutional in 2011
If the Supreme Court makes a ruling and nobody follows it, does it really have any power?

If the legislature makes 10% as many rules as the executive, who really legislates?

If branches of the executive insist on their "independence" from elected officials, is the US really a Democratic Republic?

What kind of country do we live in, really?

http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2013-05-24/opinions/39495...

jacoblyles··on Rand Paul: Big Brother Really Is Watching Us
Progressive California did a great job with its two PIPA-cosponsoring Senators. I don't know how the software industry gets rolled so badly in state politics.
jacoblyles··on Obama: No warrantless wiretaps if you elect me (2008)
The present reality of our government's structure is certainly nothing like it claims in its charters and bylaws. America is best described as a post-democratic state. The permanent bureaucracy is the largest and most powerful branch of government and it is never subject to elections. From the Washington Post editorial desk[1]:

"Our carefully constructed system of checks and balances is being negated by the rise of a fourth branch, an administrative state of sprawling departments and agencies that govern with increasing autonomy and decreasing transparency.

For much of our nation’s history, the federal government was quite small. In 1790, it had just 1,000 nonmilitary workers. In 1962, there were 2,515,000 federal employees. Today, we have 2,840,000 federal workers in 15 departments, 69 agencies and 383 nonmilitary sub-agencies.

This exponential growth has led to increasing power and independence for agencies. The shift of authority has been staggering. The fourth branch now has a larger practical impact on the lives of citizens than all the other branches combined.

The rise of the fourth branch has been at the expense of Congress’s lawmaking authority. In fact, the vast majority of “laws” governing the United States are not passed by Congress but are issued as regulations, crafted largely by thousands of unnamed, unreachable bureaucrats. One study found that in 2007, Congress enacted 138 public laws, while federal agencies finalized 2,926 rules, including 61 major regulations.

The judiciary, too, has seen its authority diminished by the rise of the fourth branch. Under Article III of the Constitution, citizens facing charges and fines are entitled to due process in our court system. As the number of federal regulations increased, however, Congress decided to relieve the judiciary of most regulatory cases and create administrative courts tied to individual agencies. The result is that a citizen is 10 times more likely to be tried by an agency than by an actual court. In a given year, federal judges conduct roughly 95,000 adjudicatory proceedings, including trials, while federal agencies complete more than 939,000.

These agency proceedings are often mockeries of due process, with one-sided presumptions and procedural rules favoring the agency. And agencies increasingly seem to chafe at being denied their judicial authority.

Of course, federal agencies officially report to the White House under the umbrella of the executive branch. But in practice, the agencies have evolved into largely independent entities over which the president has very limited control. Only 1 percent of federal positions are filled by political appointees, as opposed to career officials, and on average appointees serve only two years. At an individual level, career officials are insulated from political pressure by civil service rules. There are also entire agencies — including the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal Trade Commission and the Federal Communications Commission — that are protected from White House interference."

And some reflections from a government worker[2]:

"The most fascinating thing about working for the government for the last 6 or 7 years has been learning how government really works. Almost no one has any idea how government actually functions.

We spend inordinate amounts of time and money determining who will occupy short-term elected positions in government. Once there, people make a living thinking about what these politicians should be doing. On the other hand, we spend almost no time thinking about who will permanently occupy the bureaucratic positions that are actually responsible for implementing governance.

The vast majority of the employees of the government, like me, are unelected and – for all intents and purposes – cannot be fired. Focusing on the 0.0001% of government employees that get elected (obviously!) misses the remaining 99.9999%. Virtually everyone thinks that its possible to "change" government while maintaining 99.9999% of its employees. This belief is obviously retarded.

I should also note that people are not used to thinking about working environments in which employees cannot be fired. This situation changes the employment dynamic in many ways. Outside of the government, a "boss" is in charge. However, once the power to fire employees is removed, how is it possible for a boss to really be in charge? In a sense, this creates a situation in which the employees are – in reality – in charge.

When we are taught how laws are made, we’re told something like: someone writes a bill, both houses of Congress vote on the bill, if it passes it’s signed by the President and then it’s law at which point it might be interpreted by the courts.

This is correct as far as it goes. However, have you ever asked yourself who that "someone" is who’s writing the bills? Seems like a powerful position, no? That someone is generally unelected and cannot be fired.

The common story also doesn’t go far enough. Regulations are now, by any serious metric, more important than laws. Regulations are written and implemented by agencies, often with little or no judicial oversight. Modern laws aren’t even really laws anymore, they’re just lists of regulations that Congress hopes agencies will implement.

In ancient Rome, the Senate governed until Julius Caesar took power. However, emperors kept the Senate around for a few hundred more years (at least until Diocletian). Are you so sure that the system of government that you believe in hasn’t already been overthrown? Are you like a Roman in the 200s AD who believes in the power of the Senate to appoint an emperor?"

[1]http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2013-05-24/opinions/39495...

[2]http://foseti.wordpress.com/2011/02/02/on-government-employm...;

jacoblyles··on Palantir and Prism: A Possible Link
You don't see much American patriotism in California. If you never see your country's flag throughout the day, you don't have fascism.
jacoblyles··on Palantir and Prism: A Possible Link
It's striking how much of modern political thinking comes down to branding.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →