803 karma · joined September 25, 2011
I write a script. It doesn't work. I don't know why. I look at the error message, and then google for 30 minutes to understand what it really means - which parts of the code broke, why, how to fix them. Because none of the 3 things (which, why, how) is easy to get to.
OK, I fix it, having learned something new (like that there are infinite special cases with almost any functions).
I commit it to repo, go for coffee. In the afternoon, a colleague asks how to run that code. Well, it was a simple script, half a page, what's the problem?
I take a look, and on their machine it doesn't run. We don't know why. An hour later we discover she has some R profile file with a setting that changes behavior of some standard library... and she also has different encoding set as default, and so on, and so forth... whatever. I don't know why runtime environment encoding changes behavior of code that only deals with numbers, but hey! It's interesting at least. We fix it, we are happy.
A few days later I run the script again. It works. The result doesn't look right though. It's mostly zeroes. Hmm.
I run it a few more times, playing around with input, trying to figure out what's up.
OK, after a few minutes I realize there's lots of red color that flashes on running the script on my screen - just so fast I barely see it.
It turns out half the code isn't really running, the script just ignores it though (errors do NOT stop the code from running), and keeps going. It produces partial output happily announcing it finished.
That is the most serious mindfuck. Everything is OK, says the prompt, here's your 1 megabyte result of the calculation, oh, just don't look at the numbers, because I havent' really run any of the code... I couldn't find one of the functions.
I sit there wondering. Which is worse: the fact that every time I try launching the script something else is happening, or the fact that the runtime environment by default will return garbage with NO warning at the end (which is the only thing you see on screen) but with a million warnings in between (which you won't see unless you have really good reflexes...).
Which is worse?
I decided at some point, that I want a language to fail, and to always give me the same result. An error, an exception, this should kill the program and shout as loud as possible "Won't give you anything". Also I want code that ran yesterday to run today, and to run on my colleague's machine, and on a newer version of R. This was never our experience.
A comment here said that Valve was open to disabling buying in the app and they are still banned. Hmm.
I can see how Apple's position to get some cut is reasonable, but we are talking multiplatform here. Was Valve unwilling to give Apple any cut at all? Was Apple insisting on too big a cut? What's going on?
If Apple lets Amazon do this (presumably because Amazon is too big to ignore) and won't let Steam do it (because Steam isn't big enough), then this feels more like a cartel than monopoly.
What a cool possibility overall!
"Today we're launching some changes on Google Images to help connect users and useful websites."
"Ultimately, Google Images is a way for people to discover information in cases where browsing images is a better experience than text."
Do you believe any of these statements? I am still surprised how easily corporations will hide their true motives, resolve any cognitive dissonance internally, and how easily others will forgive them.
I wonder how people within Google are feeling when this happens. And I don't mean "when a feature gets removed", there may be valid reasons to do that. But when the official communication about them contains manipulative statements such as above, how do employees who aren't allowed to speak up feel?
The difficulty in riding a bike in a city doesn't come from having to control the vehicle. Danger doesn't come from the ability to maim someone with a bike. It comes from hugely complex set of rules, dynamic nature of traffic, high speed high pressure decision making necessary, sensory overload and fatigue, self control, competition on the road etc.
That's what you need to take into account to navigate safely.
Just like humans are generally all alike (with few exceptions, such as size, food preferences or favorite pop song - we really are extremely similar to one another in almost every aspect of our life), so are animals much more like humans than many people think, and for me the default hypothesis is that they are indeed similar.
Then we try to disprove it. How can I prove that animals do not feel pain? Well I can try a few things: - Maybe they don't run from harm? - Maybe they don't fight when attacked? - Maybe they don't dodge hits? - Maybe they don't care about predators? - Maybe they don't have nervous system at all which we believe to be the basis for pain? (also based on an observation of people whose damaged nervous system made them not feel pain)
Turns out, all those things are broadly true about animals, so it's hard to prove they don't feel pain. So maybe they do?
If you try with thoughts, consciousness, abstraction, planning, communication, emotion, detecting emotion of others of the same species or other species, etc. you will quickly find that: - for some animals it seems quite certain they do all that - for some it's unclear how much they can do - for some it's almost certain they don't do any of that not just because they don't have the type of brain area which in humans is responsible for this, but also because there is nothing in their behavior, senses etc. that even resembles that kind of function.
I don't need to prove that my dog feels pain. Assuming he doesn't, why does he bark, bite, squeal etc. when something hurts it?
It's similar to frequently repeated claims that only humans are conscious, but dogs, cats, cows, horses, etc. (let alone non-mammals) are not. That only humans have true and advanced emotions, thoughts, imagination, planning, abstraction, etc. I think apes and monkeys have convinced some already that it's not the case, but it really doesn't take much more than observing a dog over a few weeks to see how incredibly smart, emotionally subtle, plan-based, communication-based (between species!) etc. they are.
I wonder if there's anything better.