HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

james_s_tayler

2,220 karma · joined October 30, 2018

submissionscomments
james_s_tayler··on Clear is better than clever
> [1] Oh, and of course, neither your compiler, nor your DI framework is mathematically capable of telling you that half of the dependencies you're providing for Parent are no longer used for anything. Go get your coal miner's hard-hat, finish up your will, sign the waiver about black lung, and go delving through your dependencies.

Yes they are?

If it's not referenced it, it's not needed. That's pretty straight forward?

james_s_tayler··on Clear is better than clever
I'm a big fan of SOLID too. It actually makes a great deal of sense.

Re: your comment about "And of course I have seen adverse effects from it (eg. your linked article complains of innumerable, non-sensical interfaces) but that is mostly due to inexperienced developers that don't get it"

While this is true, there is a deeper implication here. Assume programming talent is normally distributed. Now, ask yourself above what percentile do you have to be in that distribution to truly grasp the how/why of SOLID and to be able to wield it to solve problems. Now, ask yourself what percentile do you have to be below where you just go crazy with creating non-sensical interfaces and thousands of awfully named classes with single responsibilities such as "CustomerCommandMapEmbelisherConverter"?

The real problem is that code bases tend to be horrible (also normally distributed!) because a lot of talent doesn't meet the bar and can't actually produce programs that aren't rubbish. In any org you'll find the quality of the code base is somewhere on a normal distribution. And you will find all the engineers somewhere on a normal distribution. You'll have a couple of brilliant people, a couple of horrible people, a lot of average people.

The only time you truly see exceptional code bases that everyone stops and goes "wow, this is nice!" are the rare times the stars aligned.

james_s_tayler··on Clear is better than clever
We have this discussion on HN every month.

So far the answer I've worked out is:

Because its optimal solution to let talent flow through BigCo in SV. There is no domain or tech-stack specific stuff. So studying for the interview process allows the applicant to apply for multiple companies. At the same time it's a pretty hardcore process, so the company knows they are getting engineering talent that is a) smart and b) obedient.

For the rest of the world it absolutely doesn't make sense and that's why where I live, you don't see that style of interviews at all.

james_s_tayler··on It’s Never Going to Be Perfect, So Just Get It Done
The problem is people want a simple, one-size-fits-all mental model of what an MVP is.

Different industries, different problems, different solutions = different definitions of what an MVP will and can be.

Most of this entire discussion is useless.

james_s_tayler··on It’s Never Going to Be Perfect, So Just Get It Done
It makes perfect sense Agile works a lot better for Government projects. Also probably for agencies too.

I'm not 100% on SaaS. Need something more fine-tuned. Call it SaaSGile.

james_s_tayler··on Fighting Complexity in Software Development
This. All day long.

On the current code base I work on I swear every single one of my pull requests contains large amounts of variable and method renaming to make it easier for the next person because if it takes me half a day to compute an understanding of what "var result = apiTotal - total" is actually doing then it isn't named nearly clearly enough.

james_s_tayler··on Fighting Complexity in Software Development
It's not even about programming languages at this point. It's Peopleware. People are the number 1 cause of all problems in software.
james_s_tayler··on Ask HN: Have you ever had an existential crisis?
I used to think from a nihilistic perspective a lot because it seems like the most logical position to take. I'm not depressed or anything and nihilism doesn't at all get me down. I just sort of think it is what it is. Though I do remember I went to see Jordan Peterson live when he came to my city and he said something that made me rethink nihilism as a valid perspective. And it wasn't a religious comment either.

He was saying people tend to fall into the trap of thinking that in a million years none of this is going to matter and that they're just one of seven billion people, so they don't really matter etc. Then he said now imagine your 6 year old daughter gets cancer... what do you tell her? That in a million years it isn't going to matter? That she's only 1 of seven billion people, so who cares? And if it's not the answer at a time like that then it's probably not the answer.

I dunno... but it struck a chord with me and I've not been able to entertain the nihilistic perspective ever since. Now whenever I find those thoughts coming on and think why on earth do I push so hard or why do I bother with what I do etc... I take on a more cosmic perspective. That through our actions and experiences the universe is able to observe, enjoy and comprehend itself. The point is to be the matter and the energy. The point is to be the experience.

Like why do you sit down and watch a movie when you know it's going to end?

james_s_tayler··on Ask HN: Recommend one book I need to read this summer?
Didn't realise it was a novel, but I second not watching the movie.
james_s_tayler··on Dear Agile, I’m Tired of Pretending (2018)
Please don't assume decent project managers. That's how you get in trouble.
james_s_tayler··on I’ve Picked My Job over My Kids
The justice system is less justice, more system.
james_s_tayler··on I’ve Picked My Job over My Kids
I never resent my co-workers for child-related late starts or early finishes. I respect them. I prioritize work/career and I always admire the ones who don't.
james_s_tayler··on Avoid Indirection in Code
You know how many times I've seen that exact scenario in code bases? Plenty. Some developers just do really pointless shit and then name is terribly to add insult to injury.
james_s_tayler··on Avoid Indirection in Code
TL;DR - don't pointlessly wrap functions from the standard library in methods with non-standard names.

Yes. Please. Stop. Doing. That.

james_s_tayler··on Japanese Company Charges Its Staff $100 an Hour to Use Conference Rooms
But Japanese people never make mistakes. They always pay their bills. They are always on time. They are robot gods.

Turns out they actually do do all of the things you suggest, but that's not how they perceive themselves to be, so 'they don't do that'.

True story - I worked on implementing a billing system for a Japanese utility company and when our team asked for the requirements around how to handling dunning when people don't pay their bills the response we got back was "Japanese people always pay their bills."

I shit you not.

james_s_tayler··on I’m not really a good web developer, I'm just good at Googling things
On the contrary, do. Having things in working memory is the core of creative problem solving.
james_s_tayler··on I’m not really a good web developer, I'm just good at Googling things
I do.
james_s_tayler··on World’s top bicycle maker is moving U.S. orders to Taiwan factory
I know "blockchain all the certification marks!" we can call it "ChainOfCustodyChain" $$$$$$$$$
james_s_tayler··on In Defence of the Technical Interview
Amazing.
james_s_tayler··on In Defence of the Technical Interview
Yup. Just means the normal distribution applies to software engineers too, which makes perfect sense. A handful will be so god awful you'll wonder how it is they even have a 10 year career in the first place. A handful will be in the first couple of years in their career and you'd think they have been doing it for 10 years. Most are average.

But here's the kicker... in software engineering average means bad. Because average code is not good code, because only amazing code is good code. So all these questions and tests trying to figure out who's a good engineer are kind of rubbish. Mostly they will be average engineers. But companies seem to think "we only hire the best" all the meanwhile the trash-fire slowly burns.

james_s_tayler··on Ask HN: What to read after “Thinking in Systems”?
The Model Thinker is excellent.
james_s_tayler··on I got asked LeetCode questions for a dev-ops systems engineering job today
10/10 I would go for randomize the array and check if it's sorted. Repeat if it's not.

I like the people I work with to have a good sense of humor.

james_s_tayler··on Micro Frontends
how do you make an interface monoidal?
james_s_tayler··on AWS costs every programmer should know
Yeah, great for an internal facing app on your company intranet that only needs infrequent access but requires a relational database.
james_s_tayler··on Absolute truths I unlearned as junior developer
> "Not everyone will become senior during their career"

This. So much this. I didn't realise that until a little while ago but when I did it made me realise I need to understand actually what make someone a senior. It's not just an automatic progression.

james_s_tayler··on Absolute truths I unlearned as junior developer
Have experienced this too. Haha.
james_s_tayler··on Why GitHub used Haskell for Semantic
damn... I missed "what's the problem?" haha.
james_s_tayler··on Why GitHub used Haskell for Semantic
>Similarly, the difficulty to explain Monad is Monad itself is pretty abstract and general.

A Monad is just a Monoid in the Category of Endofunctors.

james_s_tayler··on SEC Charges Kik With Conducting $100M Unregistered ICO
we ran that experiment in 2017 and everyone got rekt
james_s_tayler··on An outlining app similar to Workflowy
Some of the UX isn't quite as smooth as Workflowy... but it does have some features workflowy is missing like images/attachments etc. It's definitely very pretty. I find the loading of some nodes to be unbearably slow though. The cross-linking is a great feature, though again the markdown processing takes a while to happen so the UX feels choppy and lets it down slightly.

I don't really get the need for the files panel on the left hand side. In theory the first page just acts as an ad-hoc version of that. Seems unnecessary to me. I could look past that though as if you just hide it and pretend it's not there then it doesn't really matter.

Also... no mobile app :/

I use workflowy every day and there are definitely areas for it to improve on that I feel like dynalist is trying to address. Will keep an eye on this one. Not ready to switch at this time but hopeful for the future.

← PreviousPage 25 of 34Next →