100 karma · joined September 8, 2012
1. Does it spit out a css file or multiple css file I can use immediately? Can i actually amend a local document with it, or do I have to copy paste?
2. Does it give any critique on poor selector methods? Definitely have a few foolish ways of doing things that could be improved with a little bit of "hey...stop that" feedback, in my work
3. ??? PROFIIT
4. Can it give me a few stats on the css to benchmark it? You're already showing me the unused ccs selectors, can you present other data that you could present to your boss and say hey...look at this, this is why it's worth doing this stuff
5. Known browser issues highlighted. "Hey! In IE8...that div ACTUALLY does this". Also, heres how to fix it. Insta–contextual documentation. As I say that I realise I'm asking for Clippy back in a way so I shall bow out. Responsive design? worth thinking about...anyway!
Really interesting project! I'm going it use it this weekend and see how it goes :)
Video: https://vimeo.com/100505617
Design in Detail: Changing the Time Between Shots for the Sniper Rifle from 0.5 to 0.7 Seconds for Halo 3
PDF: http://twvideo01.ubm-us.net/o1/vault/gdc10/slides/Griesemer_...
Talk & SlideDeck: http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1012211/Design-in-Detail-Changi...
Here's some typefaces that are for the most part, only numbers, that I think might look rather nice for just tabbed numerical data: http://www.typography.com/fonts/numbers/inside/claimcheck http://www.typography.com/fonts/numbers/inside/greenback
"Here's what the left-brainers have to think about such a well though-out and through design process..."
It's hinging on the effort that went into the process, which is by all means extensive and impressive. Its' defensive. But I think your line of questioning is extremely important and I'm a designer, so I'll give it a bash with explaining why they did this.
I don't think you could ever back up with numbers that these changes 'matter' to users. Any research that could be done would, in the words of someone better than I – be used like a drunk uses a lamp post. For support, not illumination.
At the end of the day, I'm inclined to agree that these changes are negligible for users. What this is more a case of is Facebook deciding they care about the craft and quality of the visual design in their product. Regardless of if users give a toss. The change isn't quantifiable in numbers. It will most likely not change the bottom line of the company.
But what it does do, is communicate that Facebook cares about visual design craft. This is part of branding. Deciding they care about these things, to have the image of the company they want.
These changes are on par with Apple choosing to make a glass staircase in their stores. It's like Twitter choosing the colour of their office furniture, it's like any other company implementing anything that does not directly or clearly affect returns or is quantifiable in numbers. Simply put, it's a culture thing. They've decided they care about visual design craft and so they put money into it so they can have high quality visual design craft. And they have done that here – this is high quality.
Look it, people can talk and read all the shite they want but unless they actually do and show results – they're a load of hot air. I do recognise a vibe from your post that I've encountered. Freelancers who have been freelancing for two years and write a book about it. A load of shite most times. Common sense and basic business practises are whats in the book. And they're written in this extremely irritating tone. But hey, if it helps some people out – great.
Your last sentence is revealing. The days of knowing some extra sweet photoshop tricks and that actually mattering is over. No one gives two fucks about your excellent layer effects. What does the image communicate and is it relevant for the audience? I can find out how to make anything I want – but if it doesn't affect the bottom line (money or action) why would anyone give a shit. That's just craft.
Although you reminded me of a great old wives tale of Eddie Van Halen turning his back on the audience to play the tapping parts of his solos because he was scared someone would steal his 'trick'.
Also lurk moar is usually applied to noobs who have not been in the community long enough and are asking beginner questions.
* The image for Éva looks like something they'd take at border control for a refugee. Not a fitting profile image for a professional interpreter in the slightest. Also it's placement on the homepage hero image is bizarre. Her face is...reassuring though. Reminds me of a kind aunt. Probably a good vibe for your audience. Take a better photo that isn't a passport scan.
* The navigation font size is quiet small and does not have enough contrast to stand out against the background image. Most of the important text is small actually.
* The background image is actually quite nice I think – from what I can make out it isn't Hungarian though – very well might be wrong. I do think it's Roman mosaic feel lends credibility to her practise though.
* "...with a subversive sense of humour" — not sure this is applicable
* "...drug importation, human trafficking, rape and murder." — Human rights issues might be more suited here. Rape and Murder pull you out of focusing on her expertise.
Thats all for now. Good start. Keep working.
Agree with you on accessibility and responsiveness. Think visual design for the most part should stay the same.
Design thinking was the big one years ago in trying to get alternative, yet profitable viewpoints in the boardroom. UX has done much better with this as it's much closer tied to the business lingo with things like conversion rate, A/B, etc.