HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jamesdelaneyie

100 karma · joined September 8, 2012

jamesdelaney.ie
submissionscomments
jamesdelaneyie··on The Rapidly Disappearing Business of Design
Design studios are not coming to an end anytime soon, no matter how well domain knowledge is packaged up and sold off as competency. We've given people better tools and guidelines to improve their day to day presentational communication skills, not "made them designers" – it's like saying that buying a new plug-and-play faucet for your shower and installing it yourself has made you a plumber, to use a cliche'd comparison. Years of study, work and research has made this a relatively simple thing to do, so let the layman handle it. Let them pick a style, it's a small job, who cares?

This production work is coming to an end, the value of a design agency in their years of experience working in the field in practises too many mention here is not being given the shoulder in favour of inexperienced word processors, unless it's Ralph from accounting making a so-so boilerplate christmas card for a law firm. When you want to reposition your firm as a leader in immigration rights cases and communicate that effectively, who you gonna call?

Classically trained designers and alums from design masters courses offer a skill set outside of basic production. Take a look the design maturity scale [0] to see what I'm taking about. Valued designers have moved on to (like the OP article mentioned) applying design principles and design viewpoints to affect structural, organisational, long-term change across a wide number of industries and social endeavours. Choosing a nice grotesque for your h1 is not on the same level as designing a conceptual poster to rouse the heartfelt concern for audiences you're trying to make take action on a social issue.

I'm sorry David, but for you to come here and ply you're wares of "Top 20 Typefaces To Use" and herald it as the downfall of the independent design industry is shortsighted, ignorant and quiet frankly insulting. You're marketing here, so by all means work away – but I'll not have that spiel stand un-countered, where design skills are the equivalent to a new swish suit some wall-street head is showing off to his friends, pointing out the finer details of his cuffs. Jesus wept. /rant

[0] http://www.sjef.nu/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/design_maturit...

jamesdelaneyie··on The drug revolution that no one can stop
More than fair point. Craft beers usually do have a higher alcohol percentage though, so they would actually get you drunk 'better'. Taste would be subjective however. Personally I'd be 50/50 on getting drunk, having a nice drink, no reason you can't have both :)

The point being, if all substances were legalised, I think we all could easily see there being a wide range of branded drugs that might offer the same base experience with different subtleties to it. Longer and harder or short and sweet etc. You don't think so?

jamesdelaneyie··on The drug revolution that no one can stop
I don't think so. It's like saying we have Heineken, so why would anyone want a craft beer?
jamesdelaneyie··on Skeleton 2.0 CSS Framework
Hey man, super cool to see you come back to the project after so long. Skeleton was the only understandable framework that was on the go when I started developing, and it really helped me get to grips with RWD. Every time I'd start new projects I'd come back to Skeleton for reference and now have my own extended version thats always being refined, ExoSkeleton ;)

Thanks a mil the work you put in man, Cheers!

jamesdelaneyie··on What We Learned From 40 Female YC Founders
I think the point is that a healthy work/life balance would allow you to give 100% of yourself to the child at the particular moment you're with them. Not having to check an email when you're reading them a bedtime story. Being able to take a week off and not have an excess work-related ruminations badgering the gullet in the background of a family-holiday that detract from you're daughter saying "DAD! WATCH THIS!"

unobserved pool splashes

jamesdelaneyie··on How Would You Redo the Google Interface? (2004)
Jenny Holzer's piece is by far the most interesting and opinionated, and still relevant to current discussions on security, leaks et al. Love her take on this.

Sherpard and Davis' are trite in both concept and execution. IDEO's is prophetic, but they're a pretty good forecasting company. Truly disappointed with Sherpard and Davis' though, walkover commercial designers.

jamesdelaneyie··on Rules for Creating Gorgeous UI, Part 2
User orientation and regularity or commonality of action should define the most prominent and accessible navigation and actionable clicks/taps. Where are you, what are you most likely doing, then give them the items needed for those scenarios while holding back the rest somewhat.
jamesdelaneyie··on Rules for Creating Gorgeous UI, Part 2
Medium's hallmark is an 'enjoyable reading experience'. Care to give some opinion on what makes it poor? Not being funny here, I'm not their biggest fan but such an dousing comment provokes debate.
jamesdelaneyie··on The Design Details Podcast
16px seems to be somewhat of an industry average [0]. Depends on the communication needs of the item. Personally I find smaller text and longer line lengths set the tone for how I should be consuming the article. Smaller and longer, more thoughtful reading. Big and short, bit sized scanning of text.

[0] http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2011/10/07/16-pixels-body-co...

jamesdelaneyie··on The Design Details Podcast
A design that consciously chooses to go outside these guidelines can still be good design, same with your fine-dining and hobbit architecture examples. Context and the goals of the brief are key.
jamesdelaneyie··on The Design Details Podcast
Design includes aesthetics, I think you need to recalibrate your definition.
jamesdelaneyie··on Why Did Google Decide to Split Inbox from Gmail?
Completely agree I have the web bias, it's what I grew up making, yet I think the further comparisons you mention (autocad + c++ (tbh, no knowledge there)) separate the implementation from the final artifact much too abstractly for it to be a viable recommendation for career designers. Want to design a stool? Learn joints. Want to make an app? Learn flows. I wanted to make cool shit happen on a screen when you clicked, so I'm learning javascript.

You're right in saying that design schools can't offer the specialisation of a particular production mode to all students, it's not feasible. Yet what is feasible, is that the interest is there, and it can be built upon by one lecturer or third party resource (on recommendation) to a particular student. There are people who I graduated with that gained an incredible amount of print production knowledge in their final year that stands to them completely, while I focused on "hey why can't i make stuff on this website move and interact in a more delightful[0] way.

The main point here is that there is a investment in learning any production technique, and anyone who has that knowledge will always be more valuable than someone who does not. The choice for designers is to work it out for themselves if it's worth learning it for what they want to do.

Now I've gotten ranty :( sidebar: That's a fierce irish name you have, are you from Eire? :P

[0] Kill me

jamesdelaneyie··on Why Did Google Decide to Split Inbox from Gmail?
I have always felt that learning code as a designer is no different to learning to take the production of print work into your own hands. Foil-blocking? Better talk to the printer. Six spot colours on a 64 page handbook? Best check with the printer. Half fold gate sleeve design with laser cut matte finish front over a high-gloss neon backing? Jesus, I better check with the printer.

With digital design, the turn around is so short that it can be incredibly beneficial to learn similar digital techniques yourself instead of waiting for the reply that tells you "can't do it".

You specifically mentioned interaction design as the first discipline (and i would URGE companies to hire classically trained designers), and ffs, of all the disciplines, it's the most tied to coding. It is integral to learn of the production processes to be worth your salt. In college, we made books by hand. We made websites without frameworks, exhibition designs in foamcore real-life mockups. Any course worthwhile will continually stress the understanding and competency in the production methods. I'd like my architect to know the theory and have some practise in building a basic wall, wouldn't you?

jamesdelaneyie··on Why Did Google Decide to Split Inbox from Gmail?
This is ranty, but also quite insightful into how a mistreated developer would feel and should give pause to other designers listening in. For what it's worth, the digital design crusaders have been pushing for tighter integration with developer style tools to make the hand-off more carefree. That being said, I do love to let my mind run wild with ideas and then pass it along to tomorrow me that is tasked with making that happen. It's a shame I have so few people to review code for security, scalability, known conventions and best practises. If it works, I'm happy out.
jamesdelaneyie··on Isaac Asimov Mulls “How Do People Get New Ideas?” (1959)
The idea of a non-accessible user interface leading to greater quality in content posted is very interesting and something that's played on my mind for years and have noticed in some communities. Would love if there was any research on the topic.
jamesdelaneyie··on The Limits of Friendship
I would dismiss any and all notifications with a curt 'oh piss off!' unless they were impeccably timed and had something sentimental like a large photo of me with that friend.
jamesdelaneyie··on Which Shellshock logo should be used?
Threw my hat in the ring also: https://d324imu86q1bqn.cloudfront.net/uploads/asset/attachme...
jamesdelaneyie··on Request HN: Designers – Shellshock vulnerability needs a logo
Here's something: http://i.imgur.com/NCrA3TK.png

Use away, not claiming any rights on this.

jamesdelaneyie··on Depression and feeling like an outsider
How can you help people who don't realize this and would refuse any suggestion to seek advice? I fear my mother might be struggling with this since she was laid off last year but actively refuses to have conversations about how she might feel. 1/4 of my blame lies in Irish culture however :/
jamesdelaneyie··on I Had a Stroke at 33
That really irked me as well, which is an absolute shame because the rest of the article was very well written.
jamesdelaneyie··on Ads work by cultural imprinting, not emotional inception
Well there is an element of cultural signaling going on. Washing up liquid like 'Fairy' in the UK usually feature an attractive mother in a middle class white household dealing with the state of their children's (usually boys) clothes after they've come home from soccer practise or school or what have you. The ad isn't saying Beyonce endorses the product, but it is saying that yes! you too can be like this supermom and effortlessly and jovially clean your kid's clothes for school tomorrow, so you look like a neglectful parent thanks to Fairy. Trust Fairy. Live Fairy. Fairy is love. Fairy is life.
jamesdelaneyie··on Ask HN: Are you a drinker or a teetotaler?
Daily drinker as well. Although it varies. Sometimes I'd have a week without taking a sip without realising and other weeks I'd get through a bottle of wine over the course of a night after work.
jamesdelaneyie··on Ask HN: Are you a drinker or a teetotaler?
I'm Irish and I'm still not a fan. It tastes of boring, Irish guilt and dread. Most of my designer friends are very partial to it, but it's more a case of having the one Guinness and then moving onto other beers.
jamesdelaneyie··on Designed to Annoy: A theoretical look at designing inefficient packaging
It is Behance after all. The designer's site is similar in it's presentation however. ID students tend not to be great with typography or web design, despite having user centric design as a main tenant of their craft.

Not gone on the concept either. It's boring for a student project. He has both eyes firmly placed in the industry. Sad to see.

jamesdelaneyie··on The Unexotic Underclass
If they can't afford it, then it's not really a solution to their problem is it?
jamesdelaneyie··on Dystopian sci-fi is making us fear all new technology
Ah cunt! CLOG: Sci-Fi is out of print! :( I would kill for that. Is there any way I could offer something for a share of that?
jamesdelaneyie··on Dystopian sci-fi is making us fear all new technology
The author calls for creators to present a new future world that is optimistic and to me, that feels a little shallow and half baked. It is certainly not subversive, it is naive.

We are out of the pure postmodern cynicism, but the rebuttal isn't a swing back to modernism as the author seems to vaguely hint at. Personally I subscribe to the idea that we have moved into a new cultural period that many call Meta-modernism. There are many other theories alongside this, Digimodernism and 'New Sincerity' being the ones I've heard the most about. Point being is that this new approach blends the cynical with the optimistic to have a more holistic view. Objectivity and subjectively co-exist.

In this frame, there has been a movement in the design world for the past ten years called Design Fiction that works in this space I think. Dunne and Raby at the RCA London pioneered it and sci-fi author Bruce Sterling is an adamant supporter. From MIT Media Lab, Design Fiction is:

"How to provoke discussion about the social, cultural, and ethical implications of new technologies through design and storytelling."

In short, it creates objects that imply worlds of the future. It is not completely dystopian, nor is it completely optimistic. Those views are left up to the viewer to decide on. I definitely feel this approach is much more valuable than the authors' knee-jerk out-of-date push to happy-up sci-fi.

jamesdelaneyie··on Dystopian sci-fi is making us fear all new technology
Caught that as well. Wouldn't say disingenuous though, as it felt more rushed than actually thought about. Also a really really shit title.
jamesdelaneyie··on Ask HN: How would you improve this app description to increase sales?
To be honest the copy looks fine. What swings the decision to download an app for me are the images showing the interface (generally a walkthrough) and the app icon. That and the reviews.

Possibly tie the random title generator to the 'pieces' idea? It is essentially writing prompts yes?

jamesdelaneyie··on MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Email Platform
I would be inclined to share this naive outlook. But it's email.
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →