HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jameshart

22,635 karma · joined March 31, 2011

submissionscomments
jameshart··on Pre-Modern Armies for Worldbuilders, Part I: Why They Fight
I guess it’s so long-winded you never made it to the four paragraph section, about 20 paragraphs and two subheadings in, about economic motivations for recruitment?

> The first place most modern folks’ mind goes, of course, is to pattern this task off of their own jobs and so to assume that these fellows are under arms because they are paid to be, which I am going to term the employment principle.

jameshart··on Pre-Modern Armies for Worldbuilders, Part I: Why They Fight
This is a blog post (not a paper) written for a general audience by an academic summarizing content he has gone into greater detail on in his other blog posts which generally have more links to further reading - and this one also opens with suggestions of three or four books that provide a deeper overview of the topics it goes into.

It also doesn’t pretend to be anything other than the author’s opinion about how fantasy world builders might better incorporate real world historical analogues into their stories for greater verisimilitude – and, yes, to further Bret Devereux’s explicit agenda which is to counteract what he sees as historical misinformation perpetuated by fantasy authors adopting a sheen of ‘based in realistic history’ while actually doing a disservice to ancient and modern people and their histories.

jameshart··on Lockdown Mode
Related: simonw is Simon Willison
jameshart··on I Found Ultra-Pure Quantum Crystals in an Abandoned Mine in the Atacama Desert
They were in fact discovered 54 years ago. The quantum properties weren’t recognized until 2012.
jameshart··on AI subscriptions are a ticking time bomb for enterprise
I hate it. This article starts off well! There is data and it seems well argued, but then halfway through, there it is: example of trend. Another example. Third example. It’s not just X – it’s Y.

It’s as jarring as getting halfway into a well written article, clicking a link to a source, and getting rickrolled.

It’s all you can do to not let it distract you from the fact that in 1998, The Undertaker threw Mankind off Hell In A Cell, and plummeted 16 ft through an announcer's table.

jameshart··on I believe there are entire companies right now under AI psychosis
I mean, the stories about how stuff was getting built in the late 90s/early 2000s aren’t much worse.
jameshart··on Steve Jobs in Exile – New book on Steve Jobs’s years at NeXT Computer
I’m so confused. Your complaint is that Apple don’t make a mouse that you like?

Are you in some situation where you are being forced to use a Magic Mouse?

Other manufacturers make mice in every form factor you can imagine. I don’t believe any apple product comes with a Magic Mouse bundled - you’re not forced in any way to buy one.

Apple don’t make any headphones that I like. I don’t feel like this is a failing on Apple’s part?

jameshart··on How to make your text look futuristic (2016)
I think the author is aware: https://typesetinthefuture.com/2014/11/29/fontspots-eurostil...
jameshart··on Learning Software Architecture
I’m not sure what part of the article this is attempting to critique.

But I would say that just because your preferred mental model is an abstract algebraic one where you build an abstract model that can apply to multiple situations doesn’t mean that such an architecture is best for every situation.

The article talks very clearly about the system and social constraints that it is optimizing for architecturally and ‘turning everything into a fold’ doesn’t immediately strike me as helping to meet the fast-build-feedback needs of the deep contributors and easy-and-safe-to-hack-in-modules needs of the weekend warrriors, which is what are described as the goals of the architecture.

But it also doesn’t strike me as very clearly not the case that the architecture has some of the features you’re describing.

It feels rather like you have a pet mental model which you think all architecture should subscribe to, and… I’m sorry but that seems naive.

jameshart··on Guitar tuner that uses phone accelerometer
Pack it up folks, nubinetwork has exposed the scam that is the guitar tuner industry. You don’t need a guitar tuner if you have ears; all the guitar techs and musicians who use them have bought into a lie. And obviously since guitar tuners are a waste of time, a tech demo showing that you can use the accelerometer in a commodity handheld device to pick up minute vibrations with sufficient accuracy to detect guitar tuning from a web page is just feeding into the hands of Big Tuner.

Seriously, this is the very definition of a shallow dismissal.

jameshart··on Using Claude Code: The unreasonable effectiveness of HTML
HTML was invented for physicists to be able to write papers. It's not something that's beyond anyone without frontend dev experience.

CSS, on the other hand...

jameshart··on The ROKR wooden typewriter: a closer look
If you’re interested in how the inner mechanics of an Underwood typewriter work, Animagraff’s cutaway 3D animations are an excellent exploration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yKpIwi1UUIk

All of Jacob O’Neal’s videos in the series are excellent, like the pages from a Popular Mechanics cutaway brought to life.

jameshart··on I’ve banned query strings
Crafting outbound links with your own additions and handing them out to visitors to your site is similar to the practice of writing someone’s phone number on the door of a bathroom cubicle with ‘for a good time call:’ written above it.

You’re handing out someone elses’s contact details, but giving the person you hand them to a completely fabricated expectation for how the interaction will go.

jameshart··on I’ve banned query strings
Use #fragment identifiers then
jameshart··on Distributing Mac software is increasing my cortisol levels
Publishing a tip jar link is going to be possible no matter how you distribute. The desire to use itch is about wanting to sell.
jameshart··on I’ve banned query strings
There’s nothing ruder in hypertext etiquette than giving someone a link to navigate to someone else’s HTTP server, where you have manipulated that URL in some way unsanctioned by the server you are sending them to.

You can’t just send arbitrary query string parameters to a server and assume they will just ignore them. Just like you can’t just remove query string parameters and assume the URL will work.

jameshart··on Distributing Mac software is increasing my cortisol levels
Making it take some pain for developers is precisely what makes it valuable. If you could automate signing up for a developer account and didn’t have to put up some cash it would lose all value as a trust signal.
jameshart··on Distributing Mac software is increasing my cortisol levels
Maybe the PDFs were malware?
jameshart··on Distributing Mac software is increasing my cortisol levels
Okay, but then the argument that Apple is charging them to certify their software and that is excluding hobbyists falls away doesn’t it? Now you’re not a hobbyist.
jameshart··on Let’s Encrypt: Stopping Issuance for Potential Incident – Resolved
Useful context: https://letsencrypt.org/2026/01/15/6day-and-ip-general-avail...
jameshart··on A web page that shows you everything the browser told it without asking
> Your device carries these typefaces, of the seventeen commonly probed by fingerprinting checks. The specific combination of fonts on your device is nearly unique

The set of fonts available in stock iOS is hardly going to be unique now is it?

That it is even possible to install fonts onto iOS would be news to most users.

jameshart··on Canvas is down as ShinyHunters threatens to leak schools’ data
Some liability, sure. Civil, not criminal, though, right?

But the post I was responding to said it should be a crime to have unsecured systems.

That is equivalent to saying it should be a crime to leave your door unlocked.

jameshart··on Canvas online again as ShinyHunters threatens to leak schools’ data
Sorry, I wasn’t trying to defend Canvas, so much as give general advice that ‘I could build this in a weekend’ is rarely a wise claim. The specific ways in which Canvas could not be built in a weekend do not need to be the ones I identified.
jameshart··on Canvas is down as ShinyHunters threatens to leak schools’ data
I think states should be able to do better than a ‘great firewall’ to defend their domestic net infrastructure from malicious foreign actors.

But I do think it should be much more states’ responsibility to make their domestic network safe for citizens and businesses and institutions to operate.

jameshart··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
No no, this quarter we’re trying to shift from capex to opex. Try to keep up.
jameshart··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
Genuine kubernetes scaling strategy: add a do-nothing container that runs with a lower priority than your real workloads, that requests half a machine’s worth of mcpu.

When you deploy a new container, and all your nodes are fully allocated, that low priority container will get evicted, and your container will immediately get scheduled in its place. Then k8s will try to find somewhere to put that half-machine container. If it finds somewhere it fits, it’ll schedule it. If not, it’ll trigger your cluster auto scale to add a new node where that task can run, making sure the next container you want to deploy has some readily available capacity to drop on to.

Basically the same sysadmin strategy, automated.

jameshart··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
There are two kinds of tech company.

Companies which have done a layoff

And companies which haven’t done a layoff yet.

jameshart··on Canvas online again as ShinyHunters threatens to leak schools’ data
On the contrary.

My analogy would be: of course buildings have to be built to withstand gravity. That’s a natural part of the world that cannot be eliminated.

Buildings are built to stand up to natural forces. But not to, for example, the threat of a malicious actor crashing a plane into them. That isn’t typically considered a reasonable thing to architect civilian infrastructure for.

When you built IT infrastructure likewise you should build it to handle the natural forces it will be exposed to. But are you as accountable for securing it against the acts of malicious parties as a structural engineer is for securing a building against gravity, or as accountable for securing against those acts as the structural engineer is for securing that building against terrorists?

jameshart··on Canvas is down as ShinyHunters threatens to leak schools’ data
We do not generally hold victims of crimes accountable for failing to defend themselves adequately.

If someone threatens you with a knife and gets you to hand over your wallet, your bank doesn’t get to say ‘you should have hired better security’ when the mugger uses your credit card.

The problem here is the mugger, and that’s who the state goes after. Even if the victim walked into a bad area. Even if the victim could have defended themselves.

Same with ransomware attackers. They are the problem. We might encourage potential victims to behave in ways that make it less likely for them to be targeted. But if they are targeted, we should still focus our societal disdain on the criminal not the victim.

jameshart··on Canvas online again as ShinyHunters threatens to leak schools’ data
It is a very common error to look at a specialist piece of software, superficially consider the basic data structure it appears to have and think ‘seems simple enough. Basic CRUD app.’

But it’s rarely the case in practice.

In a sibling comment right here for example someone bemoaned the difficulty in Canvas of having two TAs simultaneously grade separate parts of the same assignment. That sounds like something that goes beyond CRUD.

But more importantly any workflow system, which an LMS will be full of, has to handle the always tricky problem of how changes to workflows affect the things that are currently in the workflow. Assignments posted in course X need to be approved by person Y; some assignments are submitted for approval; person Y goes on leave and now the approval needs to be person Z. Not a simple CRUD problem.

These are things that occur to me with only a moment’s consideration of what an LMS system might need to deal with. The actual domain probably has considerable more complexity that I can’t even imagine.

← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →